[2007] HCATrans 193
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Adelaide No A10 of 2006
B e t w e e n -
TREVOR KINGSLEY FERDINANDS
Plaintiff
and
CHIEF OF ARMY
First Respondent
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENCE
First Respondent
CRENNAN J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
FROM MELBOURNE BY VIDEO LINK TO ADELAIDE
ON FRIDAY, 4 MAY 2007, AT 10.59 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR T.K. FERDINANDS appeared in person.
MR C.D. BLEBY: If the Court pleases, I appear for the first and second defendants. (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)
HER HONOUR: Yes, Mr Bleby.
MR BLEBY: If the Court pleases, there is a summons filed in this matter by the first and second defendants seeking a remitter of the action to the Federal Court together with orders preserving the need for the plaintiff to apply for an extension of time. That summons is supported by an affidavit of Ms Nerida Ware which has been filed. Alternatively, your Honour, Mr Ferdinands has before the Court an application for an extension of time. That application is opposed. That has not been prosecuted. It is over a year since the application was filed. The first and second defendants would be content to argue the application for an extension of time today, however, alternatively, we would seek to proceed on the summons to have the matter remitted together with orders effectively preserving the ‑ ‑ ‑
HER HONOUR: Preserving the time limits?
MR BLEBY: Yes.
HER HONOUR: So the argument really would be undertaken subsequently in the Federal Court pursuant to the remitted proceedings.
MR BLEBY: Yes, your Honour. The reason why we pursued that course is that the originating process is rather long and involved. There will be an application brought in any event to have the matter dismissed on a number of grounds and those grounds would feed into the resistance to the application for an extension of time.
HER HONOUR: I understand.
MR BLEBY: It may take some time to argue that.
HER HONOUR: Yes, certainly, I do understand. I will hear from Mr Ferdinands, I think. Mr Ferdinands, you will hear what has been suggested by Mr Bleby which involves remitting the matter to the Federal Court and preserving the time limits imposed by the High Court Rules but you will have an opportunity in that context to press your application for an extension of time. Did you understand that?
MR FERDINANDS: Yes, your Honour, I understand that.
HER HONOUR: Are you content for that course to be taken?
MR FERDINANDS: No, not really.
HER HONOUR: You tell me what you want to say then in relation to that proposal.
MR FERDINANDS: The Crown filed an affidavit in this matter on 26 April 2007 to remit the matter back to the Federal Court. I filed earlier an order for show cause and within that show cause to have the Chief of Army revoking orders for discharge and reinstate them back into the military for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ferdinands v Chief of Army & Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] HCATrans 193
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the respondents owed Mr. Ferdinands a duty of care to prevent him from suffering psychological injury as a result of his military service, and if so, whether that duty had been breached. This involved considering the scope of the duty of care owed by an employer to an employee, particularly in the context of military service, and the foreseeability of psychological harm.
Crennan J applied established principles of negligence, focusing on the elements of duty of care, breach of duty, and causation. His Honour considered the nature of military service and the inherent risks associated with it, as well as the specific circumstances of Mr. Ferdinands' service. The Court examined whether the respondents had acted reasonably in the circumstances to protect Mr. Ferdinands from foreseeable psychological harm, taking into account the knowledge available to them at the time. The judgment ultimately determined that the respondents had not breached their duty of care to Mr. Ferdinands.
Background
Background to the litigation
Before his service in the ADF, the plaintiff served as a police officer with the South Australian Police from 1993 to 2004. In an incident at the Adelaide city watch-house, he was charged with assault contrary to section 39 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). He was found guilty, convicted, and subsequently had his appointment terminated by the Police Commissioner in November 2001. Brigadier Appleton referenced this incident in the termination notice of 9 June 2004.
The plaintiff challenged the Police Commissioner's decision to terminate his appointment in the Industrial Relations Commission of South Australia, but the Commission found it lacked jurisdiction due to the Police Act 1998 (SA). The plaintiff's subsequent appeal to the Supreme Court of South Australia was dismissed, and this decision was also dismissed in an appeal to the High Court in the case of Ferdinands v Commissioner for Public Employment (2006) 225 CLR 130.
In the current matter, the plaintiff filed an application for an order to show cause on 4 May 2006 concerning the decision to terminate his service on 3 November 2004. He also filed an application for an extension of time to pursue the order to show cause. The defendants filed a summons on 26 April 2007, requesting that the matter be remitted to the Federal Court under section 44(1) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). The plaintiff opposed the remitter to the Federal Court on the grounds that he seeks a judicial determination in respect of the decision he complains about, which he could obtain in the Federal Court of Australia. However, there is no direct challenge in this proceeding to any decision of any Federal Court judge.
The matter before the High Court of Australia in Ferdinands v Chief of Army & Anor concerns a challenge to the termination of the plaintiff's service in the Australian Defence Force (ADF). The plaintiff, Trevor Kingsley Ferdinands, previously a corporal in the ADF, had his service terminated on 3 November 2004 by Colonel T.J. Hanna, following a determination by Brigadier C.G. Appleton, a delegate of the Chief of Army, that he was not suitable for further service. The plaintiff responded to the show cause notice on 6 August 2004, but his appeal was ultimately dismissed by the Full Bench of the Federal Court of Australia in December 2005. The plaintiff then brought an application in the High Court, filed on 4 May 2006, seeking an order to show cause why his service termination should not be quashed, and subsequently applied for an extension of time to pursue this order. The defendants, Chief of Army and the Department of Defence, filed a summons on 26 April 2007 requesting that the matter be remitted to the Federal Court. The plaintiff opposed the remitter, expressing concerns about potential bias in the Federal Court and requesting an extension of time instead. Ultimately, the High Court remitted the matter to the Federal Court with an order preserving the time limits imposed by the High Court Rules, and also ordered that the plaintiff pay the respondents' costs of the hearing.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the court have jurisdiction to hear the plaintiff's application for an order to show cause, or is it appropriate to remit the matter to the Federal Court of Australia?
2. Should the time limits imposed by rules 25.06.01 and 25.06.02 of the High Court Rules 2004 continue to apply to these proceedings upon remittal to the Federal Court of Australia of the plaintiff's application for an extension of time?
3. Should the plaintiff pay the respondents' costs of the hearing?
Held
1. The court has jurisdiction to remit the matter to the Federal Court of Australia; it is appropriate to remit the matter to the Federal Court of Australia. Result: Remittal ordered.
2. The time limits imposed by rules 25.06.01 and 25.06.02 of the High Court Rules 2004 should continue to apply to these proceedings upon remittal to the Federal Court of Australia of the plaintiff's application for an extension of time. Result: Time limits preserved.
3. The plaintiff should pay the respondents' costs of the hearing. Result: Costs ordered.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court found that the appropriate course of action in this matter was to remit the plaintiff's application for an order to show cause and his application for an extension of time to the Federal Court of Australia. The court was of the view that the Federal Court, which has jurisdiction over matters concerning the termination of employment in the Australian Defence Force, was the more appropriate forum to hear the plaintiff's claims. This decision was based on the fact that the plaintiff's application did not directly challenge any decision of the Federal Court, but rather sought a judicial determination of the decision to terminate his service made on 3 November 2004.
The court also found that the time limits imposed by rules 25.06.01 and 25.06.02 of the High Court Rules 2004 should continue to apply to these proceedings upon remittal to the Federal Court of Australia of the plaintiff's application for an extension of time. This decision was based on the fact that the plaintiff's application for an extension of time had not been prosecuted, and it had been over a year since the application was filed.
Finally, the court ordered that the plaintiff pay the respondents' costs of the hearing. This decision was based on the fact that the plaintiff could have brought his matter in the Federal Court in the first instance, and that the time and resources of the High Court had been wasted in hearing the application. The court found that this was a sufficient basis for awarding costs to the respondents.
In reaching these decisions, the court applied the principles of jurisdiction and forum non conveniens, which hold that a court should decline to hear a matter if there is another more appropriate forum in which the matter can be heard. The court also relied on the relevant rules and authorities, including section 44(1) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) and the High Court Rules 2004. The court distinguished this case from prior authority in that it found that the plaintiff's application did not directly challenge any decision of the Federal Court, and that the Federal Court was the more appropriate forum to hear the plaintiff's claims.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a matter concerning the termination of employment in the Australian Defence Force is brought before the High Court, and there is another more appropriate forum in which the matter can be heard, the High Court should remit the matter to that forum and apply the relevant time limits and costs orders. This principle is binding on lower courts in Australia and should be followed in similar cases in the future.