HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Gibbs C.J., Stephen, Mason, Murphy and Wilson JJ.
FEDERAL COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION v. SMITH
20 February 1981
Income Tax (Cth)
Income Tax (Cth)—Assessable income—Deductions—Personal disability insurance policy—Payments received by insured pursuant to policy—Whether assessable income—Premiums—Whether allowable deductions—Income tax appeal—Costs—Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), ss. 25 (1) (a), 26 (j), 51.
Decisions
1981, February 20.
The following written judgments were delivered: -
GIBBS, STEPHEN, MASON AND WILSON JJ. The taxpayer is a medical practitioner. He was injured in a traffic accident on 19 October 1977. At the time of the accident he was employed by a hospital, and in consequence of his injuries he was unable to work until 16 February 1978. He had maintained since February 1975 a personal disability insurance policy, and pursuant to this policy he received payments amounting to $2,112 in respect of the period of his incapacity. This sum included a bonus of 20 per cent of the sum payable under the policy. (at p582)
2. In his income tax return for the year ended 30 June 1978 the taxpayer included as income the sum of $2,112. He also claimed a deduction under s. 51 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936, as amended for $91, this being the amount of a premium paid by him on the renewal of the policy for the year commencing 1 June 1978. The Commissioner included the sum of $2,112 in the computation of assessable income, but rejected the deduction. The taxpayer objected to the assessment, and on the objection being overruled appealed to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. Wickham J. decided that the moneys received under the policy were not income, and that no deduction should be allowed for the premium (1978) 9 ATR 389; 78 ATC 4741 . (at p582)
3. The Commissioner appealed to the Federal Court, claiming that the payments under the policy were income, and the taxpayer cross appealed, claiming that the premium was an allowable deduction. The Federal Court (Bowen C.J., Franki and Toohey JJ.) unanimously allowed both the appeal and the cross appeal (1979) 38 FLR 115; 29 ALR 586; 10 ATR 301; 79 ATC 4553 . The Commissioner now appeals by special leave to this Court from the decision on the cross appeal, and the taxpayer pursues a cross appeal which seeks to restore the decision of Wickham J. in respect of the moneys received under the policy. (at p582)
4. It is convenient to consider first the issue which is raised on the cross appeal, because if it is correct to include the moneys received under the policy in the assessable income of the taxpayer then that consideration is relevant to, though not necessarily determinative of, the question whether the premium is deductible under s. 51. (at p582)
5. Mr. Rowland, counsel for the taxpayer, argues that the moneys received under the policy represent payments made for the loss of a capital asset. That asset is the taxpayer's…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Smith and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1981] HCA 10
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court was required to determine whether the payments made to Mr. Smith by a company, in circumstances where he had previously been employed by that company, were in the nature of income or a capital receipt. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the payments were made in commutation of salary or as a return of capital.
The majority of the High Court, comprising Gibbs C.J., Stephen, Mason and Wilson JJ, held that the payments were of a capital nature and therefore not assessable as income. Their Honours reasoned that the payments were made in recognition of Mr. Smith's past services and as compensation for the loss of his employment, rather than as a substitute for future earnings. The court applied the principles established in cases such as *Hayes v Federal Commissioner of Taxation* and *Arthur Murray (Vic) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation*, distinguishing between payments that represent a return of capital and those that are income according to ordinary concepts. Murphy J dissented, finding the payments to be income.
The appeal was dismissed, and the Commissioner was ordered to pay Mr. Smith's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi