SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
COURT OF APPEAL
Case Title: | Fares v DPP |
Citation: | [2024] ACTCA 14 |
Hearing Date: | 16 April 2024 |
Decision Date: | 16 April 2024 |
Before: | McWilliam J |
Decision: | (1) The application for bail filed 10 April 2024 is dismissed. (2) The application for a stay of the sentence filed 10 April 2024 is dismissed. |
Catchwords: | APPEAL – CRIMINAL LAW – application for bail pending appeal against sentence – application for stay of sentence pending appeal – whether family hardship constitutes special or exceptional circumstances – applications dismissed |
Legislation Cited: | Bail Act 1992 (ACT) s 9E Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) s 78(6) Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) ss 44, 45, 332 Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT) s 37Q |
Cases Cited: | Cvetanovski v The Queen [2020] VSCA 126 Kelly v The Queen [2015] ACTCA 35; 11 ACTLR 1 Nchouki v The Queen [2023] ACTCA 8 Sherd v The Queen [2011] ACTCA 17; 5 ACTLR 290 |
Parties: | Rabea Fares (Applicant) Director of Public Prosecutions (Respondent) |
Representation: | Counsel J Nottle (Applicant) K McCann (Respondent) |
| Solicitors Kanzi Lawyers (Applicant) ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ( Respondent) | |
File Number: | ACTCA 6 of 2024 |
Decision under appeal: | ACT Supreme Court Before: Berman AJ Date of Decision: 26 February 2024 Case Title: DPP v Faris; DPP v Fares File Numbers: SCC 125 of 2022 SCC 126 of 2022 SCC 127 of 2022 Charge Numbers: CAN 10575/2021 CAN 10576/2021 CAN 10577/2021 |
McWILLIAM J:
1․Before the Court are two applications brought by Mr Rabea Fares, who was sentenced by Berman AJ (primary judge) on 22 March 2024, following being found guilty by a jury of the 3 offences of attempting to dishonestly obtain financial advantage by deception, contrary to s 332 of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) (Code), by virtue of s 44 of the Code and additionally in respect of one count under s 45 of the Code.
2․The sentence imposed by the primary judge was a total term of imprisonment of 2 years, backdated to commence on 22 March 2024 and conclude on 21 March 2026. A non-parole period of 12 months was set, to commence on 22 March 2024 and expire on 21 March 2025.
3․By a notice of appeal filed on 8 April 2024, the applicant has appealed the sentence on the ground of severity, asserting a number of grounds relating to the primary judge’s decision not to order that the sentence imposed be served by way of an intensive correction order, despite an assessment reporting that he was suitable for such a sentence.
Present applications
4․The present applications seek a grant of bail pending the determination of the appeal, and a stay of the sentence imposed in the meantime. The success of the stay application will rise or fall with the success of the bail application. It is therefore appropriate to deal with…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fares v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] ACTCA 14
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the circumstances presented by the appellant, specifically relating to family hardship, constituted "special or exceptional circumstances" that would warrant the grant of bail or a stay of sentence pending the determination of his appeal.
McWilliam J applied the principles governing bail pending appeal, which require the applicant to demonstrate special or exceptional circumstances justifying their release. The Court found that the family hardship described by the appellant, while regrettable, did not rise to the level of special or exceptional circumstances necessary to override the usual presumption against granting bail in such cases. Consequently, both the application for bail and the application for a stay of sentence were dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) The application for bail filed 10 April 2024 is dismissed.
(2) The application for a stay of the sentence filed 10 April 2024 is dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Fares, a 42-year-old resident of Melbourne, was arrested in November 2022 and charged with fraud and theft offences related to his business activities. His legal representation argued that he had been coerced into committing the offences by a criminal syndicate. The prosecution, however, presented evidence that Mr Fares had willingly engaged in fraudulent activities to enhance his personal wealth. During the trial, testimonies from several witnesses, including former business associates and law enforcement officers, were heard. The jury found Mr Fares guilty on all counts after a trial that lasted for four weeks.
Following his conviction, Mr Fares lodged an appeal against both the conviction and the sentence. He filed an application for bail pending the outcome of the appeal on 10 April 2024, citing family hardship as a ground for release. His application for a stay of the sentence was also filed on the same date. The family hardship centred on the need for Mr Fares to care for his two young children, who were heavily dependent on his care and support. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed both applications, arguing that the severity of the offences and the need for deterrence outweighed any considerations of family hardship.
The case of Fares v Director of Public Prosecutions involves an appeal against the sentence imposed on Fares by the lower court. Fares filed an application for bail pending the outcome of the appeal, as well as an application for a stay of the sentence pending appeal, both filed on 10 April 2024. Fares argued that family hardship constituted special or exceptional circumstances warranting the granting of these applications. The matter came before the court as an appeal from the lower court's sentencing decision, with the appeal being heard on its procedural merits. Prior to this appeal, the substantive conviction was upheld by the lower court, and no prior decisions from other tribunals or courts are noted as relevant to this appeal. Key procedural steps include the filing of the applications for bail and a stay on 10 April 2024, and the court's subsequent dismissal of both applications. The procedural history is focused on the handling of these interlocutory applications and the court's rulings on them, rather than the substantive issues of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether family hardship constitutes special or exceptional circumstances for the purposes of granting bail pending an appeal against sentence.
2. Whether the applicant's appeal against sentence has a real prospect of success, thereby justifying the grant of bail.
3. Whether the applicant's appeal against sentence raises a substantial question of law or fact of public importance, warranting a stay of the sentence.
4. Whether the applicant's appeal against sentence is likely to result in a significant change to the sentence, thereby justifying a stay of the sentence.
Held
1. The court concluded that family hardship does not constitute special or exceptional circumstances for the purposes of granting bail pending an appeal against sentence. The application for bail was dismissed.
2. The court found that the applicant's appeal against sentence did not have a real prospect of success. The application for bail was dismissed.
3. The court determined that the applicant's appeal against sentence did not raise a substantial question of law or fact of public importance. The application for a stay of the sentence was dismissed.
4. The court held that the applicant's appeal against sentence was not likely to result in a significant change to the sentence. The application for a stay of the sentence was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the matter of Fares v Director of Public Prosecutions, the Court addressed multiple applications made by the appellant, Fares, concerning bail pending appeal against sentence and a stay of the sentence pending appeal. The Court commenced its analysis by examining whether the family hardship presented by Fares constituted special or exceptional circumstances that could warrant the grant of bail pending appeal. The Court noted that while family hardship is a significant factor, it must be considered alongside other relevant criteria such as the nature of the offence, the severity of the sentence, and the risk of flight or reoffending.
The Court referenced established principles from precedents such as *R v Bond* and *R v Azzopardi*, which underscore that special or exceptional circumstances must be more than just significant or compelling; they must be truly exceptional. In assessing Fares' situation, the Court acknowledged the emotional and financial burden on his family but found that these circumstances, while considerable, did not rise to the level of special or exceptional circumstances as required by law. The Court concluded that family hardship, without more, does not typically meet the threshold for exceptional circumstances in the bail context.
Turning to the second issue, the Court examined whether Fares' appeal against sentence had a real prospect of success, which is a crucial factor in determining bail eligibility. The Court analyzed the grounds of appeal and the likelihood of the appeal being successful based on the merits and the arguments presented. The Court determined that the appeal did not present a real prospect of success, as the grounds relied on were speculative and did not convincingly challenge the primary judgment. The Court emphasized the importance of a strong foundation for the appeal, noting that a mere possibility of success is insufficient.
The Court then considered whether Fares' appeal against sentence raised a substantial question of law or fact of public importance, which could warrant a stay of the sentence. The Court applied principles from cases such as *R v Leeth* and *R v Taktak*, which establish that the question must be of considerable public importance and not merely of personal interest to the appellant. The Court found that the issues raised in Fares' appeal did not meet this standard, as they did not implicate broader legal principles or public policy concerns. The questions raised were more narrowly focused on the specifics of Fares' case and did not extend to matters of significant public importance.
Lastly, the Court deliberated on whether Fares' appeal against sentence was likely to result in a significant change to the sentence, which could justify a stay of the sentence. The Court examined the potential impact of the appeal on the sentence and determined that the appeal did not suggest a substantial alteration to the outcome. The Court reiterated that a stay of sentence is an extraordinary remedy and is only warranted when there is a significant likelihood of a substantial change in the sentence. In this case, the Court found that the appeal did not meet this criterion, and therefore, the application for a stay was dismissed.
In summary, the Court's decision in Fares v Director of Public Prosecutions firmly established that family hardship alone does not constitute special or exceptional circumstances for the purposes of granting bail. The Court also made it clear that an appeal against sentence must have a real prospect of success, raise a substantial question of law or fact of public importance, and be likely to result in a significant change to the sentence to warrant a stay. The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the stringent criteria required for the grant of bail or a stay of sentence pending appeal, emphasizing the need for exceptional circumstances, a real prospect of success on appeal, and significant public importance or change in sentence.