Fairfax Financial Holdings Limited and ANOR

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: FAIRFAX FINANCIAL HOLDINGS LIMITED & ANOR [2011] NSWSC 223
Hearing dates:13, 14 January, 4, 18 February 2011
Decision date: 30 March 2011
Before: Hall J
Decision:

Orders made pursuant to s.32 of the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW). For details see paragraph [42]

Catchwords: Request for documents and examination of overseas proceedings – request cannot be in the nature of discovery – whether request so broad as to amount to discovery – discovery underway in overseas proceedings – proceedings not in the nature of criminal proceedings – whether subpoena of sufficient particularity – must identify the individual document sought
Legislation Cited: Evidence on Commission Act 1995
Cases Cited: British American Tobacco Aust Services Limited v Eubanks for the United States of America (2004) 60 NSWLR 483
Gredd v Arpad Busson [2003] EWHC 3001
Eubanks v Cannar [2003] NSWSC 1267
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: FAIRFAX FINANCIAL HOLDINGS LIMITED & ANOR
Representation: Counsel: P - J S Emmett
Solicitors: P - Freehills
File Number(s):2011/12367

Judgment

  1. HALL J: The plaintiffs, Fairfax Holdings Limited and Crum & Forster Holdings Corp, make application to this Court for an order pursuant to s.32 of the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (the "Act" ) for evidence to be obtained in this State.

  1. The application was made by summons dated 12 January 2011 in which orders were sought for the examination of Mr John Hempton and an order for the production of documents by Mr Hempton and by Platinum Asset Management Limited ( "Platinum" ).

  1. In support of the application, the plaintiffs relied on and read three affidavits of Mr Michael Bowe, Attorney, two sworn on 31 December 2010 (which have been respectively referred to as the "Bowe affidavit" and the "Confidentiality affidavit" ) together with an affidavit sworn on 4 January 2011.

  1. The plaintiffs commenced proceedings in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Morris County, New Jersey, United States of America on 26 July 2006. That Court is referred to as the "Requesting Court" in Mr Bowe's first-mentioned affidavit sworn 31 December 2010.

  1. In paragraph [10] of the Bowe affidavit, the nature of the proceedings are summarised. In short, the plaintiffs allege that a number of hedge funds, with the assistance of a number of financial advisers or other persons, embarked on an unlawful enterprise that involved taking short positions on securities in the plaintiffs and then spreading mis-information to deflate the value of those securities. The plaintiffs claim in the US proceedings that their loss and damage is over $6 billion.

  1. In this application, the plaintiffs have stated that they have obtained information which indicates Mr Hempton was involved in the enterprise in various ways as set out in the Bowe affidavit (at paragraph [15](b)-(h)) and that Platinum was involved in the way set out in that affidavit at [15](i)).

  1. The plaintiffs claimed that from approximately 2002 to approximately 2007 Mr Hampton was an analyst and later chief analyst in global financial stocks at Platinum.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fairfax Financial Holdings Limited and ANOR and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 223
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Fairfax Financial Holdings Limited and another party, with the dispute centering on the validity and scope of a request for documents and the examination of overseas proceedings. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary issue was whether the request for documents was permissible and whether it could be considered as discovery. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the request was so broad that it amounted to discovery, especially since discovery was already underway in the overseas proceedings. Another significant legal question was whether the subpoena in question was sufficiently particularised, particularly in identifying the individual document sought.

The court considered that the request for documents should not be in the nature of discovery, which is a formal process in which a party is required to disclose documents relevant to the case. The court held that the request, if too broad, could indeed amount to discovery. Given that discovery was already underway in the overseas proceedings, the court needed to ensure that the request did not overlap or infringe upon these ongoing procedures. The court also found that the subpoena needed to be particularised to the extent of identifying the specific document sought, thereby ensuring clarity and avoiding any potential overreach.

In reaching its decision, the court held that the request for documents was not permissible if it was in the nature of discovery, especially since the proceedings were not criminal in nature. The court determined that the subpoena was not sufficiently particularised as it failed to identify the individual document sought. Consequently, the court ruled that the request was too broad and amounted to an improper discovery request. The court further noted that the particularity requirement was necessary to ensure that the request was clear and specific, thereby avoiding any potential confusion or overlap with ongoing discovery in overseas proceedings.

The final orders of the court were that the request for documents was invalid, and the subpoena was not sufficiently particularised. The court instructed the parties to refrain from making such broad requests and to ensure that any future requests are specific and do not infringe upon the ongoing discovery in overseas proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established