Attorney General for Western Australia v Fletcher

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- FLETCHER [2023] WASC 346

CORAM:   ACTING MASTER MCDONALD

HEARD:   18 AUGUST 2023

DELIVERED          :   11 SEPTEMBER 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1889 of 2023

BETWEEN:   ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Applicant

AND

SUE FLETCHER

Respondent


Catchwords:

Evidence - Letter of request from a foreign court for assistance in obtaining evidence - Legislative scheme - Whether application required to be heard ex parte - Orders for production of documents - Request cannot be in the nature of discovery - Whether request of sufficient particularity - Ability to amend request from foreign court - Evidence Act 1906 (WA) s 116, s 117

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1906 (WA)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Application allowed in part

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : P Femia
Respondent : SM Murphy

Solicitors:

Applicant : State Solicitor's Office
Respondent : DLA Piper Australia - Perth

Cases referred to in decision:

Application by the Attorney General of NSW [2021] NSWSC 857
Application of Computer Sciences Corporation under the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW) [2017] NSW 810
Application of Computer Sciences Corporation under the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW) [2019] NSWSC 777
Application of Monier Inc [2009] NSWSC 986; (2009) 76 NSWLR 158
Application of Securities and Exchange Commission of USA under Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW) (No 2) [2020] NSWSC 1500
British American Tobacco (Investments) Limited v Sharon Y Eubanks for the United States of America [2004] NSWCA 158
Gredd v Arpad Busson [2003] EWHC 3001
Hamersley Iron Ltd Dyer v The Sanko Steamship Co Ltd [1981] WAR 113
International Finance Trust Co Ltd v New South Wales Crimes Commission (2009) 240 CLR 319; [2009] HCA 49
Pickles v Gratzon [2002] NSWSC 688; 55 NSWLR 533
R v Camden London Borough Council; ex parte Martin [1997] 1 All ER 307
Re Asbestos Insurance Coverage Cases [1985] 1 WLR 331
Re Fairfax Financial Holdings Ltd [2011] NSWSC 223
Rio Tinto Plc v Vale SA [2015] EWHC 1865
Rio Tinto Zinc Corporation v Westinghouse Electric Corporation [1978] AC 547
The Application of Nicholas Basil Cannar; Re Sharon Y Eubanks, being the person nominated by the United States District Court for the District of Columbia in proceedings United States of America v Phillip Morris Incorporated et al Civil Action No.99-CV-2496 (GK), for the purposes of applying for orders under section 33 of the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 [2003] NSWSC 802
Thomas A Edison Ltd v Bullock (1912) 15 CLR 679
Waugh Hotel Management Pty Ltd v Marrickville Council
Zucal v Harper (2005) 29 WAR 563

Table of Contents

US Proceedings

The application and procedural history

Legal issues

Legislative framework

Hague Convention of 18 March 1970 on the Taking of Evidence Abroad in Civil or Commercial Matters

Evidence Act1906 (WA)

Order 39 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971

Standing of the respondent

Consideration of right of the respondent to appear

Compliance with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney General for Western Australia v Fletcher and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASC 346
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Attorney General for Western Australia v Fletcher, the Supreme Court of Western Australia was asked to determine the appropriate scope and application of the Evidence Act 1906, specifically concerning the issuance of subpoenas under Section 117 to facilitate the retrieval of evidence from within the state. The central issue before the court was whether the requested documents could be described in broad terms or whether they needed to be individually specified. The applicant argued for a more general description, while the respondent maintained that the documents must be specifically and individually identified to comply with statutory requirements. The court was required to interpret the relevant provisions of the Evidence Act and determine whether the subpoena complied with the statutory requirements for specificity.

The court considered the statutory language and relevant case law, including Rio Tinto Zinc Corporation v Westinghouse Electric Corporation and Re Asbestos Insurance Coverage Cases, which set out the principles for the specificity of documents in a subpoena. The court held that the documents must be 'particular' and 'separately described', ruling out requests for classes or categories of documents. The court also considered the case of Application of Computer Sciences Corporation under the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW), where Black J held that the principles established in Rio Tinto Zinc Corporation v Westinghouse Electric Corporation remained applicable despite changes in communication practices. The court ultimately concluded that the subpoena in question did not meet the statutory requirement for particularity as it called for a class of documents rather than individually specified ones.

Consequently, the Supreme Court found that the subpoena was invalid due to the lack of specificity required by law. The court emphasised that documents must be individually described and not merely described by a general category. The decision highlights the importance of adhering to statutory requirements for specificity in subpoenas to ensure compliance with legal standards. The court's ruling underscored the necessity of precise documentation to facilitate the efficient and lawful retrieval of evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 117 is the operative provision for giving effect to a letter of request. It relevantly provides as follows: 117. Supreme Court may make orders to assist in obtaining evidence(1)The Supreme Court has power, on any such application as is mentioned in section 116, by order to make such provision for obtaining evidence in Western Australia as may appear to the court to be appropriate for the purpose of giving effect to the request in pursuance of which the application is made.(2)An order under this section may require a specified person to take such steps as the court may consider appropriate for that purpose.(3)Without limiting the generality of subsections (1) and (2), an order under this section may, in particular, make provision–(a)for the examination of witnesses, either orally or in writing;(b)for the production of documents;(c)for the inspection, photographing, preservation, custody or detention of any property;…(4)An order under this section shall not require any particular steps to be taken unless they are steps which can be required to be taken by way of obtaining evidence for the purposes of proceedings in the Supreme Court (whether or not proceedings of the same description as those to which the application for the order relates).(5)Subsection (4) does not preclude the making of an order requiring a person to give testimony (either orally or in writing) otherwise than on oath where this is asked for by the requesting court.(6)An order under this section shall not require a person–(a)to state what documents relevant to the proceedings to which the application for the order relates are or have been in the person's possession, custody or power; or(b)to produce any documents other than particular documents specified in the order and appearing to the court making the order to be, or to be likely to be, in the person's possession, custody or power.(7)A person who, by virtue of an order under this section, is required to attend at any place shall be entitled to the like conduct money and payment for expenses and loss of time on attendance as a witness in proceedings before the Supreme Court. The prohibition against pre-trial discovery in Article 23 of the Convention is reflected in the express terms of s 117(6) of the Evidence Act.[15][15] BAT v Eubanks [39] and [45] in relation to s 33(6) of the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW) which is in identical terms to s 117(6) (except for the word 'shall' is replaced by 'must'). Section 118 provides safeguards for witnesses compelled to give evidence. Section 118A provides for procedural rules to be made for facilitating an application to give effect to a letter of request. Section 118B makes it an offence to make a statement the person knows to be false in a material particular or does not believe to be true. Section 118C does not exclude the operation of other laws making provision for the taking of evidence in this State for the purpose of a proceeding out of the State. Order 39 rule 2(1) of the RSC states that an application under s 116 of the Evidence Act may be made by the person nominated for that purpose by the requesting court, or, if no person is so nominated, the Attorney General.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to s 2(4)(b) of the UK Act, Lord Diplock in Rio Tinto Zinc Corporation v Westinghouse Electric Corporation [1978] AC 547, held that a schedule of documents that includes categories or classes of documents which would have been obtainable under an order for discovery, could not be called for under the UK Act. Lord Diplock held:[44]The requirements of subsection (4)(b), however, are not in my view satisfied by the specification of classes of documents. What is called for is the specification of 'particular documents' which I would construe as meaning individual documents separately described.[44] Rio Tinto Zic Corporation v Westinghouse Electric Corporation (635). The House of Lords in Re Asbestos Insurance Coverage Cases [1985] 1 WLR 331 qualified the statement of Lord Diplock as follows:[45]I do not think that by the words "separately described" Lord Diplock intended to rule out a compendious description of several documents provided that the exact document in each case is clearly indicated. If I may borrow (and slightly amplify) the apt illustration given by Slade LJ in the present case, an order for production of the respondent's "monthly bank statements for the year 1984 relating to his current account" with a named bank would satisfy the requirement of the paragraph, provided that the evidence showed that regular monthly statements had been sent to the respondent during the year and were likely to be still in his possession. But as a general request for "all the respondent's bank statements in 1984" would in my view refer to a class of documents and would not be admissible.The second test of particular documents is that they must be actual documents, about which there is evidence which has satisfied the judge that they exist, or at least that they did exist, and that they are likely to be in the respondent's possession. Actual documents are to be contrasted with conjectural documents, which may or may not exist. [45] Re Asbestos Insurance Coverage Cases (337 - 338). Following these authorities, Matthews AJ rejected the submission that it is sufficient if the subpoena specified an objective criterion by which the documents can be identified. This was not permitted by the clear terms of s 33(6)(b) of the NSW Act, namely that the particular documents are to be specified in the orders.[46][46] Monier Inc [28]. Monier Inc has been cited with apparent approval in a number of first instance decisions.[47] In Application of Computer Sciences Corporation under the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW) [2019] NSWSC 777, Black J was asked to find that the earlier authorities no longer assist in the application of s 33(6) of the NSW Act, where there has been a substantial change in the frequency, volume and flexibility of communications since Rio Tinto Zinc Corporation v Westinghouse Electric Corporation was decided. Black J held:[48] It seems to me that, as judge sitting at first instance, I should follow Westinghouse, consistent with the observations as to the status of United Kingdom law in this area in British America Tobacco above, and I should also follow Monier where it follows Westinghouse and I do not consider that it is plainly wrong. [47] Application by the Attorney General of NSW [2021] NSWSC 857 at [4], Application of Computer Sciences Corporation under the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW) [2019] NSWSC 777 at [36] - [38] and Re Fairfax Financial Holdings Ltd [2011] NSWSC 223 at [38] - [39].[48] Application of Computer Sciences Corporation under the Evidence on Commission Act 1995 (NSW) [2019] NSWSC 777 [38].