Fair Work Ombudsman v Zenobia Trading Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v Zenobia Trading Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 453  

File number(s): SYG 231 of 2022
Judgment of: JUDGE CAMERON
Date of judgment: 27 April 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – breaches of civil remedy provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – imposition of penalties – relevant considerations.
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 14, 539, 545, 546, 547, 550, 687, 700, 701, 716, 793

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4AA

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson (2022) 96 ALJR 426

Kelly v Fitzpatrick (2007) 166 IR 14

Fair Work Ombudsman v Grouped Property Services Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 557

Division: Fair Work Division
Number of paragraphs: 26
Date of hearing: 27 April 2023
Place: Sydney
Solicitor for the Applicant: Fair Work Ombudsman
For the Respondents: No appearance by or for the respondents

ORDERS

SYG 231 of 2022

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

ZENOBIA TRADING PTY LTD (ACN 125 465 590)

First Respondent

JORGE BALLAS

Second Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE CAMERON

DATE OF ORDER:

27 April 2023

THE COURT DECLARES BY CONSENT THAT:

1.The first respondent contravened s.716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to comply with the compliance notice served on it on 13 June 2021.

2.The second respondent was involved, within the meaning of s.550(2)(c) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), in the first respondent’s contravention.

THE COURT ORDERS BY CONSENT THAT:

1.Within 28 days the first respondent:

(a)pay to the applicant the outstanding entitlements the first respondent was required to pay Khem Poudel under the compliance notice served on it on 13 June 2021, being $6,034.71; and

(b)pay $546.26 into Khem Poudel’s nominated superannuation fund and provide proof of such payment to the applicant;

2.Within 28 days the first respondent pay to the applicant interest on the amount required to be paid in accordance with order 1(a), calculated in accordance with paragraph 2.2 of the Federal Court of Australia practice note “Interest on Judgments Practice Note (GPN-INT)”.

3.The applicant distribute to Khem Poudel the amounts paid to the applicant pursuant to orders 1(a) and 2 above within 90 days of the payments being made by the first respondent.

THE COURT FURTHER ORDERS THAT:

4.The first respondent pay a pecuniary penalty of $15,000.

5.The second respondent pay a pecuniary penalty of $3,000.

6.The penalties be paid within 28 days.

7.The pecuniary penalties be paid to the Commonwealth.

8.The applicant have liberty to apply on 7 days’ notice in the event that the orders have not been complied with.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Zenobia Trading Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 453
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Ombudsman brought this proceeding against Zenobia Trading Pty Ltd and its director, Mr Ballas, for contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The respondents did not file any evidence or submissions, nor did they appear at the hearing. The second respondent, who appeared for the first respondent at earlier court dates, continued to represent them and was notified of the hearing date. The Court proceeded to judgment, satisfied that the matter was properly before it and that the respondents had submitted to its jurisdiction.

The legal issues before the Court involved whether Zenobia and Mr Ballas contravened sections of the Fair Work Act by failing to comply with a Fair Work Inspector's notice requiring them to remedy underpayments to a casual employee, Mr Poudel. The Court had to consider the agreed facts, which detailed that Zenobia had not paid Mr Poudel the correct wages and penalty rates, and had failed to provide evidence of compliance with the notice by the required deadlines. The Court also had to determine the appropriate penalties for the contraventions.

The Court found that the respondents had failed to comply with the notice and did not provide a reasonable excuse for their non-compliance. The Court considered various factors in determining the penalties, including the nature and extent of the conduct, the loss caused, the size and financial resources of the respondents, and the need for deterrence. The Court concluded that the respondents' conduct demonstrated a disregard for their obligations and the authority of the Ombudsman. The penalties were set with regard to the value of a penalty unit at the end of the contravention period.

The Court ordered Zenobia and Mr Ballas to pay penalties to the Commonwealth and Zenobia to pay Mr Poudel the outstanding entitlements and unpaid superannuation contributions, with interest. The Court also made declarations and orders as appropriate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents have not filed any evidence or submissions, nor have they appeared today. The second respondent filed a notice of address for service and appeared for the first respondent at the first court date on 11 March 2022 and subsequently. The second respondent has continued to represent the first respondent in this proceeding and he was advised of today's hearing date. I am satisfied the respondents have submitted to the jurisdiction of the Court and that they have been notified of today’s hearing. I am further satisfied that the matter should proceed to judgment notwithstanding their absence from the hearing. STATEMENT OF AGREED FACTS The terms of the statement of agreed facts are set out in attachment A to these reasons. In summary, it was agreed that: (a)Mr Poudel had been employed by Zenobia as a casual employee from 26 February 2020 to 26 November 2020; (b)Mr Poudel’s employment was covered by the 2010 Award until 29 May 2020 and then by the 2020 Award; (c)Mr Poudel was entitled to be classified as a cook (grade 1); (d)Mr Poudel was paid a flat hourly wage which did not satisfy his casual minimum hourly rate or penalty rates entitlements under the Awards; (e)following a complaint by Mr Poudel on 3 December 2020 and an investigation by Fair Work Inspector (“FWI”) Andy Lam, FWI Lam formed a reasonable belief that Zenobia had contravened the following terms of the Awards in respect of Mr Poudel’s employment: (i)clauses 13 and 20.1 of the 2010 Award and cls.18 and 11.2 of the 2020 Award regarding the casual minimum wage ($3,314.72); (ii)clause 34.2(a)(i) of the 2010 Award and cl.24.2(b) of the 2020 Award regarding the penalty rate for work between 10:00pm and midnight on Monday to Friday ($108.35); (iii)clause 34.1 of the 2010 Award and cl.24.2(b) of the 2020 Award regarding the penalty rate for work on a Saturday ($1,565.10); and (iv)clause 34.1 of the 2010 Award and cl.24.2(b) of the 2020 Award regarding the penalty rate for work on a Sunday ($1,046.54); (collectively “Outstanding Entitlements”)(f)pursuant to s.716(2) of the FW Act, on 13 June 2021 FWI Lam issued the Notice to Zenobia; (g)the Notice required Zenobia to remedy the contraventions of the Awards by: (i)calculating and paying Mr Poudel his Outstanding Entitlements and superannuation-related entitlements as required by cl.22.2 of the 2020 Award (and cl.30.2 of the 2010 Award) by 14 July 2021; and (ii)providing the Ombudsman with reasonable evidence of the steps taken to comply with the Notice, including details of the calculations and proof of full payment of the amounts, by 21 July 2021; (h)Zenobia did not comply with the Notice by the required deadlines and did not provide a reasonable excuse for not having done so; (i)Zenobia’s failure to comply with the Notice contravened s.716(5) of the FW Act; (j)Mr Ballas was responsible for ensuring Zenobia’s compliance with the Notice and had actual knowledge of the Notice, of the requirement to comply and of Zenobia’s failure to comply and, as such, was an intentional participant in Zenobia’s failure to comply with the Notice; (k)Mr Ballas was involved in Zenobia’s breach of s.716(5) of the FW Act and by virtue of s.550(2) of the Act is taken to have contravened the provision himself; and (l)Zenobia is liable to compensate Mr Poudel $6,034.71 for the Outstanding Entitlements and $546.26 for unpaid superannuation contributions.LEGISLATION AND RULES

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A penalty unit was worth:(a)$210 until 30 June 2020; and(b)$222 on and from 1 July 2020: s.4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth).APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE Correspondence regarding compliance notice FWI Thammakitpairote deposed in an affidavit affirmed on 26 October 2022 that the Ombudsman had had the following interactions with Mr Ballas regarding the Notice and the actions required to be taken by Zenobia: (a)on 16 June 2021 FWI Thammakitpairote emailed Mr Ballas referring to the Notice and stated that failure to comply was a contravention of the FW Act; (b)on 25 June 2021 Steven Tokic, a compliance notice officer employed by the Ombudsman, emailed Mr Ballas with a copy of the Notice and a reminder about the 14 July 2021 date for compliance with the obligation to pay the amounts owing to Mr Poudel; (c)on 25 June 2021 and 20 July 2021 Mr Tokic tried to reach Mr Ballas by telephone; (d)on 21 July 2021 Mr Ballas contacted Mr Tokic by telephone and advised that he was not in a financial position to be able to comply with the Notice as the restaurant had closed down and he had large debts to cover while in pandemic lockdown with no income; (e)on 29 July 2021 Mr Tokic emailed Mr Ballas a letter notifying him of Zenobia’s failure to comply with the Notice and inviting Mr Ballas to provide a reasonable excuse (if any) within 7 days; (f)on 11 August 2021 Mr Tokic emailed Mr Ballas a copy of the Notice and provided a final opportunity to rectify non-compliance by 18 August 2021. On the same day, Mr Tokic sent a text message to Mr Ballas with the same information; (g)on 23 August 2021 Mr Tokic spoke to Mr Ballas who advised that he was not in a position to comply with the Notice as he was on the verge of losing his business and home and claimed that he had lost $3 million due to COVID lockdowns. Mr Tokic confirmed that there was no possibility of Mr Ballas complying with the Notice and that Mr Ballas understood that legal action might be the next course of action; and (h)on 1 February 2022 a solicitor employed by the Ombudsman sent Mr Ballas a letter notifying him that, should he not comply with the Notice or provide any relevant information to the Ombudsman by 14 February 2022, litigation seeking penalties against Zenobia and Mr Ballas personally might commence without further notice. Industry report FWI Thammakitpairote deposed that the Ombudsman conducted research into particular industries and annexed to his affidavit a report into the café and restaurant industry. That report disclosed that cafes and restaurants accounted for 9.7% of all the disputes completed by the Ombudsman in the 2018/2019 to 2021/2022 financial years. Searches regarding the respondents FWI Thammakitpairote deposed that on 24 October 2022 a legal support officer employed by the Ombudsman conducted a search using the Equifax database and found that Zenobia remained registered as at 24 October 2022. This search further provided that Mr Ballas, as at 24 October 2022, was the director of Zenobia and a second company, Gojo Investments Pty Ltd (ACN 143 101 311) which remained registered and was associated with Atmosphere Restaurant Café (ABN 411 431 013 11) which a Google search recorded as “permanently closed”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Those penalties are to be paid to the Commonwealth within 28 days. CONCLUSION There will be declarations and orders accordingly. Zenobia will also be ordered to pay the Outstanding Entitlements and unpaid superannuation contributions, with interest, to the Ombudsman for on-payment to Mr Poudel.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The facts agreed by the parties satisfy me that it is appropriate to make the declarations sought.Considerations The purpose of a penalty under the FW Act’s civil penalty regime is primarily, if not solely, the promotion of the public interest in compliance with the provisions of that Act by the deterrence of contravention of it. The theory is that the financial disincentive involved in the imposition of a pecuniary penalty will encourage compliance with the law by ensuring that contraventions are viewed by the contravener and others as an economically irrational choice: Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson (2022) 96 ALJR 426 at 431 [9], 442 [66]. When determining the penalties appropriate to impose for contraventions, regard should be had to all of the circumstances of the case, guided by the various discretionary considerations discussed in authorities such as Kelly v Fitzpatrick (2007) 166 IR 14, in order to arrive at a single result that is an instinctive synthesis of those various factors. In circumstances such as the present, where the period during which the contraventions occurred saw the value of a penalty unit change, it would be appropriate, when setting the penalties to be imposed, to have regard to the value of a penalty unit at the end of the period of contravention, although regard may also be had to the fact that a lower amount applied for part of the period: Fair Work Ombudsman v Grouped Property Services Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 557 per Katzmann J at [396]–[401]. Nature and extent of the conduct which led to the contraventions The respondents were plainly on notice that Zenobia had failed to comply with the Notice and, prior to the commencement of this proceeding, were given numerous opportunities to rectify the non-compliance. The Ombudsman submitted that the respondents’ conduct “demonstrate[d] a disregard for their obligations under the FW Act and the authority of the [Ombudsman] as a regulator of Commonwealth workplace laws” and to an extent that has to be accepted as, knowing what they had to do, they did not do it. However, I have not overlooked what Mr Ballas is recorded as having said to the Ombudsman’s representatives, albeit he has not attended the hearing today, or filed any evidence, that might permit the Court to make a confident conclusion as to the veracity of his statements in those conversations. Nature and extent of loss The respondents’ failure to comply with the Notice led to the Ombudsman bringing this compliance proceeding at some public cost. It has also led to Mr Poudel still being out of pocket to the extent already mentioned.Size and financial resources of respondents No evidence was led by the respondents that might have shed light on the size of Zenobia’s business or how its resources were affected by the pandemic, as asserted by Mr Ballas in his conversations with the Ombudsman’s officials. However, it can be assumed that the business was not a large one or that the non-compliance was an error of a junior staff member which might have some comparatively innocent explanation. Deterrence