Fair Work Ombudsman v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fair Work Ombudsman v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2013] FCA 582

Citation: Fair Work Ombudsman v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2013] FCA 582
Parties: FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v QUEST SOUTH PERTH HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 109 989 531), CONTRACTING SOLUTIONS PTY LTD (ACN 099 388 575), ASHVIN LUCHMAYA and PAUL KONSTEK
File number: WAD 185 of 2011
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 14 June 2013
Place: Perth
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – sham contracting – accessorial liability – whether threat to dismiss in order to reengage employee as an independent contractor – whether misrepresentation of employment relationship as a contract for services
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 357, 358, 360, 361, 550, 793(2)
Cases cited: Building Workers' Industrial Union of Australia v ODCO Pty Ltd (1991) 29 FCR 104
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 2) (2010) 201 IR 234
Fair Work Ombudsman v Maclean Bay Pty Ltd (2012) 200 FCR 57
Wells v Fair Work Ombudsman [2013] FCAFC 47
Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661
Zuijs v Wirth Brothers Pty Ltd (1955) 93 CLR 561
Date of hearing: 16 - 18 October 2012 and 16 November 2012
Place: Perth
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 257
Counsel for the Applicant: IM Neil SC
Solicitor for the Applicant: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the First Respondent: The First Respondent did not appear
Counsel for the Second and Fourth Respondents: RE Lindsay
Solicitor for the Second and Fourth Respondents: Norton Rose Fulbright Australia
Counsel for the Third Respondent: The Third Respondent did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

WAD 185 of 2011

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
Applicant

AND:

QUEST SOUTH PERTH HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(ACN 109 090 531)
First Respondent

CONTRACTING SOLUTIONS PTY LTD
(ACN 099 388 575)
Second Respondent

ASHVIN LUCHMAYA
Third Respondent

PAUL KONSTEK
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 JUNE 2013

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Within 14 days the applicant file and serve submissions on final orders.

2.Thereafter within 14 days the represented respondents file and serve submissions on final orders.

3.The final orders be determined on the papers. 

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

WAD 185 of 2011

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
Applicant

AND:

QUEST SOUTH PERTH HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(ACN 109 090 531)
First Respondent

CONTRACTING SOLUTIONS PTY LTD
(ACN 099 388 575)
Second Respondent

ASHVIN LUCHMAYA
Third Respondent

PAUL KONSTEK
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE:

14 JUNE 2013

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

1.               INTRODUCTION

1.1             The allegations and response

  1. This proceeding concerns staffing arrangements at serviced apartments in South Perth Western Australia. 

  2. The applicant contends that in 2009 the respondents were involved in setting up a scheme of sham…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 582
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fair Work Ombudsman v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) involved the Fair Work Ombudsman taking action against Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd, Contracting Solutions, and others for alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009. The primary focus of the case was on the alleged unlawful dismissal of three employees and their subsequent engagement as independent contractors. The Fair Work Ombudsman contended that the alleged dismissals were unlawful under section 358 of the Fair Work Act, and that the subsequent engagement of the employees as contractors was a contravention of the Act as they remained employees in reality.

The key legal issues before the court were whether the employees were unlawfully dismissed and whether they were properly converted to independent contractors. The court had to determine if there was a contravention of section 358 of the Fair Work Act by Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd, and if so, whether Contracting Solutions could be held liable as an accessory to this contravention. The court also needed to examine the nature of the relationship between the parties, the intent behind the conversion process, and the knowledge and participation of Contracting Solutions in the alleged contraventions.

The court found that while the employees were indeed converted to independent contractors, this conversion was voluntary and not the result of any unlawful dismissal. The threat made by Mr Luchmaya to Ms Buttrum-Virco did not constitute a contravention of the Fair Work Act as it was not demonstrated that Contracting Solutions had knowledge of this threat or were involved in the arrangement. The court concluded that the contention that Contracting Solutions was an accessory to the alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act by Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd failed because there was no evidence of their knowledge or participation in the alleged contraventions.

The court held that Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd was not liable for the alleged unlawful dismissals, and that Contracting Solutions could not be held liable as an accessory. The claims against the respondents were dismissed, and no orders were made in favour of the applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Evidence in chief was adduced by affidavit, supplemented as necessary and witnesses were, of course, cross-examined. 5. THE EVIDENCE FOR THE APPLICANT5.1 Ms Buttrum-Virco Ms Buttrum-Virco was, in my view, an impressive witness. She struck me as being intelligent and truthful and was willing to make concessions where appropriate. Ms Buttrum-Virco started work as a part-time receptionist at Quest South Perth on 18 March 2009. She had an interview with Mr Haayema and his friend ‘Pako’ who was the night caretaker at the time. She was sent paperwork. She worked at Quest South Perth thereafter while she was studying accounting and finance at university. She worked 20 to 25 hours per week on average. When she commenced there was one full-time, senior receptionist who worked weekday daytime shifts from 7.00 am to 3.00 pm. There were four part-time receptionists including her who shared the morning, evening and weekend shifts. All the part-time receptionists were students who generally worked around their respective university timetables. The shifts were displayed on a fortnightly roster on a wall in reception. When Ms Buttrum-Virco started at Quest South Perth, the senior receptionist prepared the rosters. Normally they were prepared a week in advance. She normally worked one or two evening shifts, 1.00 pm or 2.00 pm to 8.00 pm during the week and then alternate weekday shifts from 8.00 am to 4.00 pm. If she needed to change her shift, she would normally arrange to swap shifts with one of the other receptionists herself and then she would let Mr Haayema know before the relevant shift. Normally for an evening shift, she would arrive around lunchtime so there was some overlap with the full day receptionist. She had her own desk off to the side and so would not sit at the front desk with her. There was a standard checklist at reception of the things that needed to be done every shift such as checking email and responding to queries, checking the pH levels in the spa and balancing the takings at the end of the shift. There was a big diary where reception staff would write things to be done later by the other receptionists. She would follow up on anything that had been written in that. Ms Buttrum-Virco wore a QSP uniform for the entire time. At the end of every week, she would fill out a timesheet detailing the hours she had worked that week and sign it. Each staff member had a clipboard for his or her own timesheet. The clipboard would be left behind the office door each week for Mr Hayeema ‘to do the pays’. She was paid fortnightly into her bank account, her normal pay rate being $15.63 per hour on weekdays and $23.45 per hour on weekends. In the second half of 2009, Mr Haayema started to be less involved in managing at Quest South Perth. He hired Mr Luchmaya to be the onsite manager in mid-2009. He lived in one of the on-site apartments. When Ms Buttrum-Virco was working evening shifts he would normally come into reception to check how she was going at least once during the shift. Similarly, he would do so on the weekend. If any problems arose, she would call him on his mobile phone and he would come back to the premises.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to Ms Buttrum-Virco, Contracting Solutions cannot be held to have been involved in QSP’s alleged contravention of s 358 of the FW Act, according to these respondents. That involvement is said to arise as a consequence of the conversion agreement between QSP and Contracting Solutions and the fact that a representative of Contracting Solutions provided Ms Buttrum-Virco with a copy of a Contractor Application. That cannot be sufficient for accessorial liability as the alleged threat made by Mr Luchmaya to Ms Buttrum-Virco was not demonstrated to have been within the knowledge of Contracting Solutions, nor was it part of the arrangement between Contracting Solutions and QSP constituted by the Hiring Agreement. In order to attract accessorial liability, it is common ground that a person must have knowledge of the essential facts constituting the contravention, be knowingly concerned in the contravention, be an intentional participant in the contravention based on actual not constructive notice of the essential facts and need not know that the matters in question constituted a contravention: Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661 and Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd (No 2) (2010) 201 IR 234 (at [198]. 10. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION The applicant contends (ASOC at [7]) that QSP, by Mr Luchmaya, on 29 November 2009 threatened to dismiss Ms Buttrum-Virco in order to engage her as an independent contractor to perform the same work as a receptionist and (ASOC at [8]) that this threat was a contravention of s 358 of the FW Act in which Mr Luchmaya was involved within the meaning of s 550 of the FW Act. Although Ms Buttrum-Virco had completed most of the Contractor Application and had been paid once by Contracting Solutions, the obvious purpose of the threat was to ensure that she was properly ‘converted’. Thus it was made at the time when she was an employee. It is unnecessary therefore to consider the further question of whether this constituted or could constitute a constructive dismissal (of a casual employee). I consider that the entire conversion process in her case was an arrangement designed, amongst other purposes, and for whatever reasons, to make it easier to dispense with the services of Ms Buttrum-Virco. To that extent only I consider that the claim succeeds against QSP and Mr Luchmaya as its voice. There was no evidence that the appearing respondents were even aware of this threat let alone participated in it. The case against them fails. In my view, the contention that QSP dismissed each of the three employees to engage them as independent contractors to perform the same work fails. The applicant also pleads various representations. By ASOC at [11], it pleads that on various occasions in November 2009 QSP, by Mr Konstek acting for and on behalf of QSP and Contracting Solutions, represented inter alia to Ms Best and Ms Roden that if they underwent the conversion, they would thereafter be engaged under a contract for services under which they would perform work for QSP as independent contractors. The representations were said to be oral at meetings conducted by Mr Konstek in November 2009 and in writing in a document ‘Quest – System Changes’ signed inter alia by Mr Konstek and by the ‘Contractor Application’ each furnished to Ms Best and Ms Best by or at the direction of Mr Konstek and executed by them and finally, in the case of Ms Roden, by a letter addressed to her under the letterhead of Contracting Solutions dated 30 November 2009. The problem with this plea is that it does not set up any contravention of the FW Act. Assuming those representations were made, they only breach the FW Act if they are misleading on the basis that the employees concerned remain in truth employees and never became independent contractors. But the applicant’s primary case was that they did become independent contractors yet by force or threat rather than voluntarily. I have found they did become independent contractors but voluntarily.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established