Fair Work Ombudsman v Lotus Farm Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v Lotus Farm Pty Ltd [2024] FedCFamC2G 369

File number: MLG 1077 of 2023
Judgment of: DEPUTY CHIEF JUDGE MERCURI
Date of judgment: 26 April 2024
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – FAIR WORK – parties by consent seek declaration of contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – contraventions of civil remedy provisions in FW Act – underpayment of two employees – where underpayment has since been rectified – parties jointly seek imposition of penalties in an agreed range – exact penalty to be imposed determined by the court – guiding penalty principles agreed – penalties at lower end of agreed range appropriate – orders stayed for three months – declarations of contraventions and penalty orders made.
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss 45, 323(1)(a), 535(1), 536(1), 546, 550, 718 and 718A(1)

Horticulture Industry Award 2010 

Cases cited:

Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate and Ors [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 258 CLR 482

Fair Work Ombudsman v Roach [2023] FCA 781

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 48
Date of last submissions: 4 March 2024
Date of hearing: 4 March 2024
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms N Campbell
Solicitor for the Applicant: Fair Work Ombudsman
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr T Joseph
Solicitor for the Respondents: Nguyen Do Lawyers

ORDERS

MLG 1077 of 2023

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

LOTUS FARM PTY LTD (ACN 167 006 135)

First Respondent

SON THAI

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

DEPUTY CHIEF JUDGE MERCURI

DATE OF ORDER:

26 APRIL 2024

THE COURT DECLARES BY CONSENT THAT:

1.The First Respondent, Lotus Farm Pty Ltd (Lotus Farm), contravened the following civil remedy provisions in the period 19 June 2017 to 3 September 2020:

(a)section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FW Act) by failing to pay Ms Trang Minh Thi Le (Ms Le) and Ms Loan Thi Kim Vu (Ms Vu) the minimum hourly rate of pay required by clauses 10.4(b) and 14.1(a) of the Horticulture Industry Award 2010 (Award);

(b)section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay Ms Le and Ms Vu the casual loading required by clause 10.4(b) of the Award;

(c)section 45 of the FW Act failing to pay Ms Le the overtime rates required by clause 24.3 of the Award;

(d)section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay Ms Le the public holiday penalty loadings required by clause 28.3 and 28.4 of the Award;

(e)section 323(1)(a) of the FW Act by failing to pay Ms Le in full by making deductions from her wages on 19 October 2019 and 1 November 2019;

(f)section 718 of the FW Act by producing false or misleading pay slips to a Fair Work Inspector on 26 October 2021 knowing, or being reckless as to whether, they were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Lotus Farm Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 369
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia is an application by the Fair Work Ombudsman against Lotus Farm Pty Ltd and its director, Ba Phuc Tran. The Ombudsman seeks declarations of contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the imposition of civil penalty orders against the company and its director for underpaying two employees and providing false documents to the Ombudsman. The legal issues before the court include whether the penalties proposed by the parties are within an appropriate range, considering the guiding principles for penalty determination and the totality principle.

The court found that the penalties proposed by the parties, while agreed upon, still needed to be assessed to ensure they were neither manifestly inadequate nor manifestly excessive. The court noted that civil penalties are primarily deterrent and compensatory, and the court must be persuaded that the agreed penalties are appropriate. The court considered the purpose of civil penalties to encourage compliance with the legislation and the need for deterrence. Additionally, the court took into account the impact of the underpayments on the employees, who were deemed vulnerable workers.

After considering the totality of the evidence and submissions, the court found that the penalties proposed by the parties were appropriate. The court noted the significant underpayment of the employees and the provision of false documents to the Ombudsman, which warranted a penalty. The court ordered that the penalties be set at the lower end of the agreed range, considering the guiding penalty principles. The court also ordered that the declarations of contraventions and penalty orders be stayed for three months.

The final orders made by the court include declarations of contraventions of the Fair Work Act by Lotus Farm Pty Ltd and Ba Phuc Tran, and civil penalty orders against them in the amounts of $130,806 and $28,987.20, respectively. The penalties are to be imposed after the three-month stay period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents rely upon:(a)the affidavit of Ba Phuc Tran affirmed 29 November 2023;(b)the affidavit of Son Thai affirmed 30 November 2023;(c)the respondents’ outline of submissions filed on 31 January 2024 and the respondents’ further submissions on penalty filed 23 February 2024.BACKGROUND The following brief summary is taken from the SOAF and is not in contention. The First Respondent is a corporation which operated a farm producing fruit and vegetables in Werribee. The Horticulture Industry Award 2010 (‘Award’) as varied from time to time, applied at all relevant times to the First Respondent in respect of Ms Vu and Ms Le. The Second Respondent was at all material times, a co-director and company secretary of the First Respondent. He was, for all intents and purposes, responsible for the management of the First Respondent’s employees. The contraventions the subject of these proceedings, occurred during the Assessment Period, namely between 19 June 2017 and 3 September 2020. During that Assessment Period, the First Respondent employed both Ms Vu and Ms Le. Ms Le was employed from 20 February 2017 to 3 September 2020. Ms Vu was employed from 27 February 2017 until 21 January 2018. It is common ground that the employees did not work continuously throughout these periods. The Award covered the First Respondent and Ms Vu and Ms Le and at all relevant times, both Ms Vu and Ms Le were classified as Level 1 employees pursuant to the Award. It is also common ground that in 2017, Ms Le was instructed to (and did) repay to the First Respondent certain amounts of her pay. In addition, it is also common ground that in 2019, the First Respondent made unauthorised deductions from Ms Le’s wages. The First Respondent admits that it failed to comply with its obligations under the Award to pay Ms Vu and Ms Le their entitlements to: (a)minimum rates of pay;(b)casual loadings;(c)overtime; and (d)public holiday penalty rates. By reason of these admitted contraventions, the First Respondent underpaid:(a)Ms Le the total sum of $22,363.52; and (b)Ms Vu the total sum of $6,167.30. The First Respondent rectified the underpayment to Ms Le on 10 August 2022 and rectified the underpayment to Ms Vu on 20 June 2023. In addition, the First Respondent has made the following superannuation rectification payments:(a)$2,566.08 in respect of Ms Le; and(b)$1,224.61 in respect of Ms Vu. The Second Respondent has conceded that he was involved in each of the underpayment contraventions outlined above. It is also not in dispute that during the applicant’s investigation, the First Respondent provided false or misleading documents to the applicant in response to a Notice to Produce. The respondents concede that the First Respondent knew or was reckless as to whether the pay slips it provided in response to the Notice to Produce were false or misleading. The First Respondent admits that it contravened section 718A(1) of the FW Act in providing the pay slips to the applicant in response to the Notice to Produce knowing or being reckless as to whether they were false or misleading.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, because of the timing of the relevant contraventions, there has been an increase to the value of the penalty unit over the relevant period. I agree with the manner in which the applicant proposes to treat the applicable penalty over the relevant period.SUBMISSIONS AND CONSIDERATION Applying the well settled principles on determining a penalty for breach of a civil remedy provision, the applicant seeks penalties in the range of $201,240 to $224,794 in respect of the First Respondent and the range of $38,649.60 to $44,956.80 in respect of the Second Respondent. The calculations which lead to these figures are set out in detail at Annexure B to the applicant’s written submissions which are found at court book pages 276 to 283. The applicant further submits that applying the totality principal to these amounts, they should be further reduced by 35% in the case of the First Respondent and 25% in the case of the Second Respondent. Applying such a reduction, the Applicant therefore seeks penalties in the range of $130,806 to $146,116.10 for the First Respondent and the range of $28,987.20 to $33,717.60 for the Second Respondent. The respondents agree to this range but submit that the penalty ought to be at the lower end of that range in both cases. Even though the parties have agreed to a penalty range for the contraventions, the amount of any penalty imposed remains a matter for the court. The court must still be persuaded that the proposed penalties are within an appropriate range in so far as they are not so manifestly inadequate or manifestly excessive. As stated by the majority in Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate and Ors [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 258 CLR 482 at paragraph [59]:It is true that there is a public interest in the imposition of civil penalties as opposed to the purely private interests which are in issue in many civil proceedings. But civil penalty proceedings are by no means the only civil proceedings in which the public interest is involved. … Once it is understood that civil penalties are not retributive, but like most other civil remedies essentially deterrent or compensatory and therefore protective, there is nothing odd or exceptionable about a court approving an agreed settlement of a civil proceeding which involves the public interest; provided of course that the court is persuaded that the settlement is appropriate. Having regard to the totality of the evidence in this matter and the submission of the parties, I am satisfied that the range proposed is appropriate in that sense. One of the main purposes of civil penalties is to encourage compliance with the legislation. Deterrence, both general and specific, is therefore a key consideration. The penalty must be set at a level where it will deter the respondents themselves and others from engaging in similar conduct. I have also had regard to the fact that these contraventions have resulted in employees, who could properly be regarded as vulnerable workers, being substantially underpaid during their employment. They have given evidence about the impact of that on their lives and I have had regard to that.