Fair Work Ombudsman v Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd (in liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fair Work Ombudsman v Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2019] FCA 1601

File number: ACD 41 of 2018
Judge: KATZMANN J
Date of judgment: 26 September 2019
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS — application for leave to proceed against company in liquidation under s 500(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in proceedings for remedies under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) for pecuniary and other forms of relief, including pecuniary penalties, arising out of alleged contraventions of Fair Work Act — where deed of company administration pleaded as a bar to some of the claims — where claim against the company has a solid foundation and gives rise to a serious question to be tried — where claim has to be proved against the company before claims of accessorial liability can be made out against the other respondents — public interest considerations — where no opposition from liquidators or company’s other major creditor
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 9, 444A(4), 444D(1), 444E(3), 491(1), 494, 500(2), 553B, 556(1)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss 61(1), 361, 682

Cases cited:

ACN 093 117 232 Pty Ltd (in liq) v Intelara Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd (in liq) [2019] FCA 1489
Atkins Freight Services Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2017] FCA 1134
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Artorios Ink Co Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 753
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Birubi Art Pt Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 1785
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Link Solutions Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1790
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Phoenix Institute of Australia Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) [2016] FCA 1246
Bartolome Durado & Delo Be Isugan v Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd [2018] FWC 4711
BE Australia WD Pty Ltd (subject to a Deed of Company Arrangement) v Sutton (2011) 82 NSWLR 336
Kowalski v Trustee, Mitsubishi Motors Australia Limited Staff Superannuation Pty Ltd [2003] FCAFC 18
Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. v City of Swan (2010) 240 CLR 509
Melhelm Pty Ltd, in the matter of Boka Beverages Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Boka Beverages Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2019] FCA 1184
Metropolitan Health Service Board v Australian Nursing Federation (2000) 99 FCR 95

Rushleigh Services Pty Ltd v Forge Group Ltd (In Liq) (Receivers and Managers Appointed); In the Matter of Forge Group Ltd (In Liq) (Receivers and Managers Appointed) [2016] FCA 1471

Tomlinson v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Limited (2015) 256 CLR 507

Vagrand Pty Ltd (In liq) v Fielding (1993) 41 FCR 550

Date of hearing: 24 September 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: Fair Work Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 48
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M Seck with Ms B Byrnes
Solicitor for the Applicant: Office of the Fair Work Ombudsman
Counsel for the Respondents: The respondents did not appear

ORDERS

ACD 41 of 2018
BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

FOOT & THAI MASSAGE PTY LTD (ACN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd (in liquid... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1601
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Fair Work Ombudsman sought leave from the Court to continue their proceeding against Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd (in liquidation), a company which has been in liquidation since August 2019. The company, previously known as FTM, was registered in November 2010, and was placed in voluntary administration in December 2015. The company's sole director, Mr Elvin, was also its secretary and sole shareholder. FTM entered into a deed of company arrangement on 11 April 2016, and Viet Ngo was appointed as sole director, secretary and shareholder of FTM. The deed of company arrangement was terminated on 17 October 2017, and FTM ceased to be under external administration. On 15 October 2018, the company was referred to Jirsch Sutherland, a firm of insolvency practitioners, by Mills Oakley. On 13 August 2019, a resolution was passed to wind up the company under s 491(1) of the Corporations Act, and Trent Andrew Devine and Andrew John Spring of Jirsch Sutherland were appointed liquidators. The winding up was a "creditors' voluntary winding up" as no declaration of solvency was made in accordance with s 494 of the Corporations Act. The Fair Work Ombudsman sought leave to continue their proceeding against FTM for alleged underpayments to employees, and this application was not opposed by any party.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Fair Work Ombudsman should be granted leave to continue their proceeding against FTM. Under s 500(2) of the Corporations Act, after the passing of a resolution for voluntary winding up, no action or other civil proceeding against a company is to be proceeded except by leave of the Court and on such terms as the Court imposes. The Fair Work Ombudsman submitted that their claim had a solid foundation and gave rise to a serious dispute, and there was good reason to depart from the course of lodging a proof of debt. The Court considered the relevant principles guiding the exercise of the discretion to grant leave, and concluded that the Fair Work Ombudsman had made out their case for relief and should have leave to continue their proceeding.

The Court found that the Fair Work Ombudsman's claim had a solid foundation and gave rise to a serious dispute, and there was good reason to depart from the course of lodging a proof of debt. The Court also found that the circumstances surrounding the voluntary liquidation suggested that Mr Elvin may have had a role in placing the company into liquidation and that the assets of the company were sold to a company owned by Mr Elvin’s partner, Khara Sanchez. Although the Fair Work Ombudsman only submitted that the evidence raised a suspicion of an "uncommercial transaction" or an "unreasonable director-related transaction", the Court found it unnecessary to deal with the relevant evidence or to decide whether it rises higher than a suspicion. The Court granted leave to the Fair Work Ombudsman to continue their proceeding against FTM.

In conclusion, the Court granted leave to the Fair Work Ombudsman to continue their proceeding against FTM for alleged underpayments to employees. The Court found that the Fair Work Ombudsman's claim had a solid foundation and gave rise to a serious dispute, and there was good reason to depart from the course of lodging a proof of debt. The Court also found that the circumstances surrounding the voluntary liquidation suggested that Mr Elvin may have had a role in placing the company into liquidation and that the assets of the company were sold to a company owned by Mr Elvin’s partner, Khara Sanchez. Although the Fair Work Ombudsman only submitted that the evidence raised a suspicion of an "uncommercial transaction" or an "unreasonable director-related transaction", the Court found it unnecessary to deal with the relevant evidence or to decide whether it rises higher than a suspicion. The Court's decision was based on the relevant principles guiding the exercise of the discretion to grant leave under s 500(2) of the Corporations Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, leave should be granted.Background facts FTM was registered on 1 November 2010. Mr Elvin was its only director as well as its secretary and sole shareholder. It was placed in voluntary administration on 15 December 2015. On 11 April 2016 FTM entered into a deed of company arrangement (DOCA). The same day Viet Ngo was appointed as sole director, secretary and shareholder of FTM, replacing Mr Elvin in those positions. The DOCA was terminated on 17 October 2017 and at that point FTM ceased to be under external administration. On 15 October 2018, Mills Oakley, who formerly represented FTM in this proceeding, referred the company to Jirsch Sutherland, a firm of insolvency practitioners. On 13 August 2019 a resolution was passed to wind up the company under s 491(1) of the Corporations Act and Trent Andrew Devine and Andrew John Spring of Jirsch Sutherland were appointed liquidators. A week later, a Form 205 was lodged with ASIC notifying it of the resolution. Evidently, no declaration of solvency was made in accordance with s 494 of the Corporations Act which means that the winding up was a “creditors’ voluntary winding up”, having regard to the definition of that term and of the term “members’ voluntary winding up” in s 9 of the Corporations Act. That much is confirmed by the terms of the Form 205. On 23 August 2019, Jirsch Sutherland lodged with ASIC the information about the company’s affairs sent to creditors (Form 5604). Three categories of creditors were identified in that form: (1)secured creditors, most of whom are customers who hold current vouchers to the FTM shop, but include employee entitlements with liabilities amounting to $83,458.15;(2)unsecured creditors whose liabilities amount to $444,495.83, 92%, of which is a liability owing to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO); and(3)contingent liabilities amounting to $668,352.58, which is the sum the Ombudsman is seeking in compensation with respect to the alleged underpayments to employees in the present proceeding.The relevant principles Subsection 500(2) of the Corporations Act does not mandate any particular considerations. The discretion to grant leave is at large. Nevertheless, the authorities have laid down a number of principles which guide the exercise of the discretion. Black J recently summarised the position taken in the authorities in In the matter of DSHE Holdings Limited (recs and mgrs apptd) (in liq) [2018] NSWSC 82 at [18]:[T]he purpose of this section is to prevent a company’s assets being dissipated by unnecessary litigation, and an applicant for leave will be required to show why it should not be left to prove its debt in the winding up: Re Gordon Grant & Grant Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 314; (1983) 7 ACLR 669; (1983) 1 ACLC 742; HFPS Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Tamaya Resources Ltd (in liq) (No 1) [2016] FCA 442 at [18]. The claimant must establish that the claim has a solid foundation and gives rise to a serious question to be tried; factors relevant to the exercise of the court’s discretion may include the degree of complexity of legal and factual issues and the prospect that a proof of debt will be rejected; and the power to grant leave is discretionary and other factors may be relevant to its exercise…See also: Rushleigh Services Pty Ltd v Forge Group Ltd (In Liq) (Receivers and Managers Appointed); In the Matter of Forge Group Ltd (In Liq) (Receivers and Managers Appointed) [2016] FCA 1471 (Foster J) at [15].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

No evidence was adduced about FTM’s financial circumstances. Ms Thirukumar’s evidence suggests, however, that FTM may not be able to pay the amounts sought by the Ombudsman. She deposed that on 29 August 2019 she was told by Darcy Barlow of Jirsch Sutherland that a valuation of the company’s assets was under way and the liquidators did not know how much it had but Mr Barlow “[did] not think there [was] much money there”. Be that as it may, the fact that a company is in liquidation and may not be able to pay penalties, at least, is irrelevant to the grant of leave: Birubi (Perry J) at [14]. Her Honour’s remarks were confined to the payment of penalties but that was a case in which compensation orders were not made or sought: see Birubi at [1]. Conclusion Consequently, not only does the Ombudsman’s claim have a solid foundation and give rise to a serious dispute, the Ombudsman has also established that there is good reason to depart from the course of lodging a proof of debt. The Ombudsman also argued that the circumstances surrounding the voluntary liquidation suggest that Mr Elvin may have had a role in placing the company into liquidation and that the assets of the company were sold to a company owned by Mr Elvin’s partner, Khara Sanchez. Some of the evidence adduced on the application went to this issue. If that were so, the Ombudsman submitted, the liquidators might be able to apply to the Court under s 588FF of the Corporations Act which may result in additional funds being available to meet the claims and/or that there has been a contravention of s 596AB of the Corporations Act, which prohibits a person from entering into an agreement or transaction with the intention of preventing the recovery of employees’ entitlements or significantly reducing the amount that can be recovered. She submitted that conduct of this kind is a powerful factor weighing in favour of the grant of leave: see, for example, ACN 093 117 232 Pty Ltd (in liq) v Intelara Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd (in liq) [2019] FCA 1489 (Derrington J). But the Ombudsman only submits that the evidence raises a suspicion of an “uncommercial transaction” (see s 588FB) or an “unreasonable director-related transaction” (see s 588FDA). Having regard to the other considerations, it is unnecessary to deal with the relevant evidence or to decide whether it rises higher than a suspicion. The Ombudsman has made out her case for relief and she should have leave under subs 500(2) of the Corporations Act to continue her proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 500(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) relevantly provides that, after the passing of a resolution for voluntary winding up, no action or other civil proceeding against a company is to be proceeded except by leave of the Court and on such terms as the Court imposes. On 4 September 2019 the Ombudsman filed an interlocutory application seeking leave to proceed against FTM. The application was supported by five affidavits, the most substantial of which was affirmed by Sharissa Thirukumar on 9 September 2019, a lawyer in the Ombudsman’s office. Each of the affidavits was read but none of the deponents was required for cross-examination. Indeed, the application was not opposed. The liquidators were notified of the application the day it was filed and indicated that they neither consented to nor opposed any orders the Court might make. On 12 September 2019 Mr Elvin advised that he neither consented to nor opposed the application. Mr Puerto remained silent. None of the respondents appeared at the hearing. For the reasons that follow, leave should be granted.Background facts FTM was registered on 1 November 2010. Mr Elvin was its only director as well as its secretary and sole shareholder. It was placed in voluntary administration on 15 December 2015. On 11 April 2016 FTM entered into a deed of company arrangement (DOCA). The same day Viet Ngo was appointed as sole director, secretary and shareholder of FTM, replacing Mr Elvin in those positions. The DOCA was terminated on 17 October 2017 and at that point FTM ceased to be under external administration. On 15 October 2018, Mills Oakley, who formerly represented FTM in this proceeding, referred the company to Jirsch Sutherland, a firm of insolvency practitioners. On 13 August 2019 a resolution was passed to wind up the company under s 491(1) of the Corporations Act and Trent Andrew Devine and Andrew John Spring of Jirsch Sutherland were appointed liquidators. A week later, a Form 205 was lodged with ASIC notifying it of the resolution. Evidently, no declaration of solvency was made in accordance with s 494 of the Corporations Act which means that the winding up was a “creditors’ voluntary winding up”, having regard to the definition of that term and of the term “members’ voluntary winding up” in s 9 of the Corporations Act. That much is confirmed by the terms of the Form 205. On 23 August 2019, Jirsch Sutherland lodged with ASIC the information about the company’s affairs sent to creditors (Form 5604). Three categories of creditors were identified in that form: (1)secured creditors, most of whom are customers who hold current vouchers to the FTM shop, but include employee entitlements with liabilities amounting to $83,458.15;(2)unsecured creditors whose liabilities amount to $444,495.83, 92%, of which is a liability owing to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO); and(3)contingent liabilities amounting to $668,352.58, which is the sum the Ombudsman is seeking in compensation with respect to the alleged underpayments to employees in the present proceeding.The relevant principles