Fair Work Ombudsman v Aisha & Umma Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v Aisha & Umma Enterprises Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 382

File number(s): MLG 2632 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE SYMONS
Date of judgment: 12 May 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work – parties by consent seek declaration of contravention of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – failure of the respondent to comply with compliance notice – whether penalty should be imposed and level of penalty to be imposed – factors relevant to penalty – where greater need for deterrence exists in the café and restaurant industry – where steps required under compliance notice still unperformed at time of penalty hearing – where respondent failed to engage in proceeding – penalty imposed.
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 545, 546, 547, 716

Restaurant Industry Award 2010 cll. 20.1, 30.2, 34.1  

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commission v Pattinson (2022) 399 ALR 599; [2022] HCA 13

Fair Work Ombudsman v Corporation Sun Pty Ltd [2020] FCCA 2849

Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1990] FCA 521

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 55
Date of last submission/s: 31 March 2023
Date of hearing: 31 March 2023
Place: Melbourne
Solicitor for the Applicant: HWL Ebsworth
The Respondent: No appearance

ORDERS

MLG 2632 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

AISHA & UMMA ENTERPRISES PTY LTD (ACN 143 329 382)

Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE SYMONS

DATE OF ORDER:

12 May 2023

THE COURT DECLARES BY CONSENT THAT:

1.The respondent contravened s 716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) by failing to comply with the compliance notice issued on 18 June 2020 (Compliance Notice).

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

2.Pursuant to s 545(1) of the FW Act the respondent take the steps that were required by the Compliance Notice within 28 days by:

(a)making the full payments to the employees listed in Column A of Annexure 1 (the Employees) in the amounts specified in Column D of Annexure 1, to rectify the underpayments in respect of the minimum rates for ordinary hours worked and penalty rates for ordinary hours worked on a Saturday, Sunday and Public Holiday (the amounts outstanding).

(b)calculating and paying any superannuation contributions required by clause 30.2 of the Restaurant Industry Award 2010 (the Award) in respect of the amounts outstanding to the Employees.

3.Pursuant to s 547(2) of the FW Act, the respondent pay to the Employees interest on the amounts outstanding pursuant to paragraph 2(a) above within 28 days of the date of this order.

4.Pursuant to s 546(1) of the FW Act, the respondent pay a pecuniary penalty of $15,125 in respect of the contravention of s 716(5) of the FW Act.

5.Pursuant to s 546(3)(a) of the FW Act, the pecuniary penalty referred to in paragraph 4 be paid to the Commonwealth within 28 days of this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Aisha & Umma Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 382
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involves the Fair Work Ombudsman acting as the applicant, and Aisha & Umma Enterprises Pty Ltd, trading as RMB Café, as the respondent. The primary dispute centres around the non-compliance with workplace laws by the respondent, specifically the failure to pay employees the applicable minimum wages and penalty rates as stipulated in the Restaurant Industry Award 2010. The case was heard and decided by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The legal issues at hand primarily revolved around determining the appropriate penalty to be imposed on the respondent for its breaches of the Award and the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act). Key considerations included the extent of the contravention, the impact on the employees, and the degree of cooperation and remorse demonstrated by the respondent. The court had to balance the need for general and specific deterrence against any mitigating factors, such as the respondent's cooperation in signing a statement of agreed facts.

The court reasoned that the failure of the respondent to comply with the Compliance Notice and rectify the underpayments, coupled with its minimal participation in the proceedings, demonstrated a lack of genuine contrition. The court emphasised that such behaviour undermines the statutory notice regime and imposes additional burdens on regulators and the judiciary. It was noted that the employees were deprived of significant wages over an extended period, and the majority of the outstanding amounts remained unpaid. Despite acknowledging the challenging operating environment during the contravention period, the court found that this did not justify the respondent's indifference towards the proceedings. Consequently, the court determined that a penalty of $15,125 was appropriate, considering the need for deterrence and the specific circumstances of the case.

The court's final orders include the imposition of a penalty of $15,125 on Aisha & Umma Enterprises Pty Ltd for its contravention of section 716(5) of the FW Act. This penalty reflects the court's assessment of the respondent's actions and the broader implications of such non-compliance on the regulatory framework and affected employees.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The outstanding issue is the size of any penalty to be imposed.BACKGROUND The respondent is the operator of a café trading as RMB Café located in Melbourne. In around November 2018, the applicant commenced an investigation into the respondent’s compliance with workplace laws as this had application to the Employees. Following the investigation, Fair Work Inspector Jaimie Adam (FWI Adam) formed a reasonable belief that from 1 May 2017 to 6 August 2019 (the contravention period), the Employees were employed by the respondent and that during the contravention period, the Restaurant Industry Award 2010 (the Award) covered and applied to the Employees. With respect to the Employees, FWI Adam formed the belief that:(a)Seven of the Employees were not paid the applicable minimum wage specified in the Award during the contravention period;(b)Nine of the Employees were not paid the full penalty rate in the Award for ordinary hours worked on a Saturday;(c)Ten of the Employees were not paid the full penalty rate in the Award for ordinary hours worked on a Sunday; and(d)Nine of the Employees were not paid the full penalty rate in the Award for ordinary hours worked on a public holiday. Following this investigation, FWI Adam formed a reasonable belief that the respondent had contravened clause 20.1 (minimum wages) and clause 34.1 (penalty rates for work on weekends and public holidays) of the Award. On the basis of this belief, FWI Adam gave the respondent the Compliance Notice. The Compliance Notice required the respondent to take steps that included payment in full to the Employees of the amounts identified in Column B (see Annexure 1), calculation and payment of any additional superannuation contributions required by clause 30.2 of the Award, and the production of reasonable evidence to the applicant of compliance with the Compliance Notice by 27 July 2020. It is common ground that the respondent failed to comply with the Compliance Notice and that as a result, the respondent contravened s 716(5) of the FW Act. The following amounts were paid by the respondent as partial rectification in response to the Compliance Notice:(a)on 10 November 2020, two payments of $467 (totalling $934) were made to Simranpreet Singh (Mr Singh);(b)on 24 January 2021, a payment of $467 was made to Mr Singh;(c)on 30 July 2021, a payment of $701.42 was made to Ankush Sharma (Mr Sharma);(d)on 18 August 2021, a payment of $2,500 was made to Mr Singh;(e)on 17 February 2022, a payment of $2,500 was made to Mr Singh; and(f)on 29 March 2022, a payment of $2,500 was made to Mr Sharma. Following the payments referred to in paragraph 11, the amounts still outstanding to each of the Employees are those specified in Column D of Annexure 1.PROCEEDINGS IN THIS COURT These proceedings were commenced by the applicant filing an originating application and statement of claim on 15 October 2021. On 2 February 2022, I made orders by consent referring the matter to mediation and on 14 July 2022 Registrar Edwards (who conducted the mediation) made orders by consent that the parties file a statement of agreed facts and that the matter otherwise progress to a penalty hearing.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, the applicant also invites the Court to be circumspect about any finding of genuine remorse or regret in circumstances where the respondent has failed to rectify its lack of compliance with the Compliance-Notice with the consequence that the Employees are still underpaid by an amount of $27,516.34. The failure of the respondent to file any material (beyond the statement of agreed facts) or to appear at the penalty hearing is said to be indicative of a corporate mind-set disinclined to facilitate the course of justice. CONCLUSION I consider that a penalty in the amount of $15,125 should be applied in this case. In fixing this amount I accept, as a general proposition, that a failure by an employer to comply with a compliance notice given under ss 716(2) and (3) of the FW Act, undermines the efficacy of the statutory notice regime and increases the administrative and cost burden of the workplace regulator and where proceedings are then issued, diverts judicial resources. This is a mischief to which general deterrence can and should appropriately be directed. I also accept that there is some evidence that supports a greater need for general deterrence when the case is one that concerns a business that operates (or operated) in the café and restaurant industry. I have also given weight to the fact that in this case the Employees (or the majority of them) have been deprived of not insubstantial amounts of money over a lengthy period that commenced in some instances back in May 2017, this being the beginning of the contravention period. It is significant that the greater proportion of the outstanding entitlements have still not been rectified and there is a dearth of information to shed light on the current financial circumstances of the respondent. The failure of the respondent to participate in the penalty hearing, beyond its signing of a statement of agreed facts, also means that the Court is left to speculate as to the level of contrition and insight it possesses and whether the respondent is used currently or will be used again in the future, as an employment vehicle. While I accept that the operating environment that pertained at and around the time of the respondent’s contravention was challenging, this does not exculpate or explain the apparent indifference of the respondent to the proceeding. I am satisfied that a penalty in the amount of $15,125 is an appropriate and proportionate response to the respondent’s single contravention of s 716(5) of the FW Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant also submits that the correspondence sent by Mr Ali’s lawyer on 26 October 2020 (refer [32] above) and which makes reference to his client now trading as “Hummsies Kitchen Williamstown” invites an inference that Mr Ali and the respondent have an interest or involvement in other hospitality businesses. This is said to reinforce the need for specific deterrence in this case.Contrition, corrective action and cooperation The applicant concedes that the respondent has cooperated by its signing of an agreed statement of facts and its consent to the making of a declaration that acknowledges a breach of s 716(5) of the FW Act. The applicant suggests that a discount of 10 per cent is an appropriate response to this cooperation. However, the applicant also invites the Court to be circumspect about any finding of genuine remorse or regret in circumstances where the respondent has failed to rectify its lack of compliance with the Compliance-Notice with the consequence that the Employees are still underpaid by an amount of $27,516.34. The failure of the respondent to file any material (beyond the statement of agreed facts) or to appear at the penalty hearing is said to be indicative of a corporate mind-set disinclined to facilitate the course of justice. CONCLUSION I consider that a penalty in the amount of $15,125 should be applied in this case. In fixing this amount I accept, as a general proposition, that a failure by an employer to comply with a compliance notice given under ss 716(2) and (3) of the FW Act, undermines the efficacy of the statutory notice regime and increases the administrative and cost burden of the workplace regulator and where proceedings are then issued, diverts judicial resources. This is a mischief to which general deterrence can and should appropriately be directed. I also accept that there is some evidence that supports a greater need for general deterrence when the case is one that concerns a business that operates (or operated) in the café and restaurant industry. I have also given weight to the fact that in this case the Employees (or the majority of them) have been deprived of not insubstantial amounts of money over a lengthy period that commenced in some instances back in May 2017, this being the beginning of the contravention period. It is significant that the greater proportion of the outstanding entitlements have still not been rectified and there is a dearth of information to shed light on the current financial circumstances of the respondent. The failure of the respondent to participate in the penalty hearing, beyond its signing of a statement of agreed facts, also means that the Court is left to speculate as to the level of contrition and insight it possesses and whether the respondent is used currently or will be used again in the future, as an employment vehicle. While I accept that the operating environment that pertained at and around the time of the respondent’s contravention was challenging, this does not exculpate or explain the apparent indifference of the respondent to the proceeding.