FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v ACN 146 435 118 PTY LTD & ANOR | [2013] FCCA 803 |
| Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Default judgment – default in compliance with requirements to file and serve response and defence. |
| Legislation: Cleaning Services Award 2010 |
| Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27 |
| Applicant: | FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN |
| First Respondent: | ACN 146 435 118 PTY LTD |
| Second Respondent: | CATHERINE PAINO-POVEY |
| File Number: | PEG 6 of 2013 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Lucev |
| Hearing date: | 12 July 2013 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 12 July 2013 |
| Delivered at: | Perth |
| Delivered on: | 12 July 2013 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Ms E Raper |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | The Office of the Fair Work Ombudsman |
| Counsel for the Respondents: | Mr D Love |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Dean Love & Associates |
DECLARATIONS AND ORDERS
THE COURT DECLARES THAT:
The First Respondent contravened:
(a)section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“FW Act”) by failing to pay:
(i)Ling Chai (Chai);
(ii)Fleur McMillan (McMillan);
(iii)Jai Vainu (Vainu);
(iv)Susan McDermott (McDermott);
(v)Yuan-Miao Wen (Wen); and
(vi)Shuk Pui Yau (Yau);
(collectively the Employees)
the minimum rates of pay for all hours worked in accordance with clause 16.1 of the Cleaning Services Award 2010 (MA000022) (the Modern Award);
(b)section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay each of the Employees at least fortnightly in accordance with clause 20 of the Modern Award;
(c)section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay each of the Employees the applicable overtime rates for overtime hours worked in accordance with clause 28.1 of the Modern Award;
(d)section 324(1) of the FW Act in that it unlawfully deducted amounts payable to Vainu, McDermott, Yau, Wen, Chai and McMillan in relation to work performed in the initial weeks of their periods of employment;
(e)section 323(1) of the FW Act in that it failed to pay Yau’s wages in full, resulting in an underpayment to Yau;
(f)section 323(1) of the FW Act by failing to pay each of the Employees in full the amounts payable to them in relation to the performance of work;
(g)sections 44(1) and 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees in respect of their accrued unpaid annual leave and annual leave loading on termination of employment, in accordance with s.90(2) of the FW Act and clauses 29.1 and 29.7 of the Modern Award;
(h)section 45 of the FW Act by failing to provide access to rosters that showed the Employees’ start and finish times in accordance with…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v ACN 146 435 118 Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FCCA 803
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the respondents had contravened the Fair Work Act and the Modern Award as alleged by the Applicant, and whether default judgment should be entered against them. Specifically, the court had to determine if the respondents' response, which consisted of a reproduction of the Statement of Claim with handwritten annotations of agreement or disagreement, constituted a valid defence. The court also considered the implications of the respondents' failure to file and serve proper documentation and their legal representation's inability to provide instructions.
The court found that the respondents, and their legal representatives, had been duly notified of the default judgment hearing. Given the lack of a proper defence and the respondents' failure to comply with court orders, the court determined that default judgment was appropriate. The court accepted the factual background as presented by the Applicant, which detailed various contraventions including failures to pay minimum rates of pay, overtime, annual leave entitlements, and to provide payslips and records, as well as unlawful deductions. The court applied Rule 13.03B(2) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) to enter judgment against the respondents.
Consequently, the court ordered judgment against the First and Second Respondents in favour of the Applicant. The First Respondent was ordered to pay compensation to six employees for underpayments totalling $21,596.48, plus interest and superannuation contributions. The liability hearing was vacated, and the matter was adjourned for further hearing concerning the Applicant's claim for penalties against the respondents, with directions for the filing and service of submissions and evidence.
Orders
Orders of the court
3.
Judgment against the First and Second Respondents be entered for the Applicant pursuant to Rule 13.03B(2) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth).
4.
Pursuant to s.545(2)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“FW Act”), the First Respondent pay compensation to the Employees for loss that they have suffered because of the above declared contraventions in the following amounts, being the total underpayments owing to the Employees:
(a) McDermott: $4,392.67;
(b) Chai: $4,489.68;
(c) Yau: $2,937.45;
(d) McMillan: $4554.65;
(e) Vainu: $4,220.79; and
(f) Wen: $1,915.38
(collectively, the Underpayment Amounts).
5.
Pursuant to s.547(2) of the FW Act the First Respondent pay interest pursuant to legislation on the Underpayment Amounts referred to in Order 4 above.
6.
Pursuant to s.545(1) of the FW Act the First Respondent make contributions on behalf of each of the Employees to the Employees’ nominated superannuation funds in respect of the ordinary time earnings component of the payments made pursuant to Order 4 above at the superannuation guarantee charge rate prescribed by applicable superannuation legislation as at the date these orders are made.
7.
The Underpayment Amounts, interest and superannuation referred to in Orders 4, 5 and 6 above be paid within 30 days.
8.
The liability hearing listed for 6, 7 and 8 August 2013 be vacated.
9.
This matter is adjourned to 10.15am on 6 August 2013 for further hearing with respect to the Applicant’s claim for penalties to be imposed on the Respondents.
10.
The Applicant is to file and serve any submissions and evidence on which it relies in relation to penalty by 26 July 2013.
11.
The Respondents are to file and serve any submissions and evidence on which they rely in relation to penalty by noon on 5 August 2013.
12.
The parties have leave to apply.
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
AT PERTH
PEG 6 of 2013
FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
Applicant
And
ACN 146 435 118 PTY LTD
First Respondent
CATHERINE PAINO-POVEY
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(Edited ex tempore reasons)
Originating Application
1.
The Originating Application sought orders as set out in the Statement of Claim filed with the Originating Application on 11 January 2013, by the Fair Work Ombudsman (“FW Ombudsman”) against the first respondent ACN 146 435 118 Pty Ltd (“the Corporation”) and the second respondent Catherine Paino-Povey (“Ms Paino-Povey”).
Application in a Case
2.
The FW Ombudsman has now made an Application in a Case, filed on 9 July 2013, for default judgment against the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey, who is a director of the Corporation.
3.
Based on the affidavits of Ann Lucey filed on 8 and 12 July 2013, and the affidavit of Phoebe Nicholas filed on 12 July 2013, the Court finds that the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey, and their lawyers, Dean Love & Associates, have been made aware of the default judgment hearing, and served with the relevant papers. Indeed, Mr Love appeared as Counsel at the hearing of the Application in a Case, but was unable to assist the Court as he had no instructions with respect to the matter.
4.
The FW Ombudsman’s Application in a Case, as filed, seeks declarations and orders in the following terms:
THE COURT DECLARES:
1 that the First Respondent contravened:
a) section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) by failing to pay:
i. Ling Chai (Chai);
ii. Fleur McMillan (McMillan);
iii. Jai Vainu (Vainu);
iv. Susan McDermott (McDermott);
v. Yuan-Miao Wen (Wen); and
vi. Shuk Pui Yau (Yau);
(collectively the Employees)
the minimum rates of pay for all hours worked in accordance with clause 16.1 of the Cleaning Services Award 2010 (MA000022) (the Modern Award);
b) section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay each of the Employees at least fortnightly in accordance with clause 20 of the Modern Award;
c) section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay each of the Employees the applicable overtime rates for overtime hours worked in accordance with clause 28.1 of the Modern Award;
d) section 324(1) of the FW Act in that it unlawfully deducted amounts payable to Vainu, McDermott, Yau, Wen, Chai and McMillan in relation to work performed in the initial weeks of their periods of employment;
e) section 324(1) of the FW Act in that it unlawfully deducted an amount from an amount payable to Yau at the time of the termination of her employment;
f) in the alternative to the declaration at 1(f) [(e)] above, section 323(1) of the FW Act in that it failed to pay Yau’s wages in full, resulting in an underpayment to Yau;
g) section 323(1) of the FW Act by failing to pay each of the Employees in full the amounts payable to them in relation to the performance of work;
h) sections 44(1) and 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees in respect of their accrued unpaid annual leave and annual leave loading on termination of employment, in accordance with section 90(2) of the FW Act and clauses 29.1 and 29.7 of the Modern Award;
i) section 45 of the FW Act by failing to provide access to rosters that showed the Employees’ start and finish times in accordance with clause 25 of the Modern Award;
j) section 45 of the FW Act by failing to provide McMillan, Vainu, McDermott and Yau with unpaid meal breaks when they worked for periods in excess of 4 hours and 30 minutes in accordance with clause 26.2 of the Modern Award;
k) section 712(3) of the FW Act by failing to comply with five Notices to Produce Records or Documents served on 3 October 2011, 1 February 2012 and 22 February 2012;
l) section 535(1) of the FW Act by failing to make and keep records in relation to employees of the kind prescribed in regulations 3.32(c), 3.32(d), 3.33(1)(a), 3.33(3)(d), 3.34(a), 3.36(1), 3.37 and 3.40 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) (FW Regulations);
m) section 536(1) and section 536(2) of the FW Act by failing to issue payslips to each of the Employees tht included the information required by the FW Regulations within one working day of paying amounts to them in relation to the performance of work;
n) regulation 3.44(1) of the FW Regulations by making pay slips which contained information which was false or misleading, in that the payslips stated that McMillan and Vainu had worked 7.6 hours per day, when they had actually worked 9 hours per day; and
o) section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees for time spent travelling from one place of work to another at the appropriate rate, in accordance with clause 17.10 of the Modern Award;
2 that the Second Respondent was involved in each of the contraventions of the First Respondent as set out in declaration (1) above and pursuant to section 550 of the FW Act is thereby taken to have contravened the provisions herself.
THE COURT ORDERS:
1 that judgment against the Respondent be entered for the Applicant pursuant to Rule 13.03B(2) of the Federal Court Rules 2011;
2 that pursuant to section 545(2)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act), the First Respondent pay compensation to the Employees for loss that they have suffered because of the above declared contraventions in the following amounts, being the total underpayments owing to the Employees:
(a) McDermott: $4,392.67;
(b) Chai: $4,489.68;
(c) Yau: $2,937.45;
(d) McMillan: $4554.65;
(e) Vainu: $4,220.79; and
(f) Wen: $1,915.38
(collectively, the Underpayment Amounts);
3 that pursuant to section 547(2) of the FW Act the Respondent pay interest pursuant to legislation on the Underpayment Amounts referred to in Order 2 above;
4 that pursuant to section 545(1) of the FW Act the First Respondent make contributions on behalf of each of the Employees to the Employees’ nominated superannuation funds in respect of the ordinary time earnings component of the payments made pursuant to Order 2 above at the superannuation guarantee charge rate prescribed by applicable superannuation legislation as at the date these orders are made;
5 that the Underpayment Amounts, interest and superannuation referred to in Orders 2, 3 and 4 above be paid within 30 days;
6 that the liability hearing listed for 6, 7 and 8 August 2013 be vacated;
7 that this matter is adjourned to [date] at [time] for further hearing with respect to the Applicant’s claim for penalties to be imposed on the Respondents;
8 the Applicant is to file and serve any submissions and evidence on which it relies in relation to penalty by [date].
9 the Respondent’s are to file and serve any submissions and evidence on which it relies in relation to penalty by [date].
10 the parties have leave to apply;
11 such further or other orders as the Court considers appropriate.
Factual background
5.
In the absence of any evidence from the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey, the Court accepts that the relevant factual background is primarily as set out in the affidavit of Keelyann Thomson affirmed 5 July 2013 and filed on behalf of the FW Ombudsman on 9 July 2013. That relevant factual background is as follows:
a) on 11 January 2013 the FW Ombudsman filed the Statement of Claim;
b) on 14 February 2013 the Court made orders requiring the respondents to file and serve a Defence by 13 March 2013;
c) on 13 March 2013 Mr Mark Povey, in his capacity as a director of the Corporation, and Ms Paino-Povey, filed and served a Response, annexing a Statement of Defence, which was a reproduction of the Statement of Claim, with handwritten annotations against each paragraph of the Statement of Claim, and the Particulars in the Statement of Claim, to the effect of “Agreed”, “Don’t Agree” or “Somewhat Agreed”;
d) on 2 April 2013 the FW Ombudsman sent a letter to Mr Povey by email noting that the Corporation was not legally represented as required by r.9.04 of the then
Background
Background to the litigation
On 2 April 2013, the FW Ombudsman sent a letter to Mr Povey, noting that the Corporation was not legally represented as required by rule 9.04 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth). Despite this, the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey, along with their lawyers, Dean Love & Associates, were made aware of the default judgment hearing and served with the relevant papers. Mr Love appeared as Counsel at the hearing of the Application in a Case but was unable to assist the Court as he had no instructions regarding the matter. The FW Ombudsman's Application in a Case, filed on 9 July 2013, sought default judgment against the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey. The Court found that the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey had defaulted in compliance with the requirements to file and serve a response and defence.
The matter before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia at Perth involves an originating application brought by the Fair Work Ombudsman against ACN 146 435 118 Pty Ltd and Catherine Paino-Povey. The proceedings commenced with the filing of a Statement of Claim on 11 January 2013, seeking various orders under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and associated awards. Pursuant to court orders made on 14 February 2013, the respondents were required to file and serve a Defence by 13 March 2013. On 13 March 2013, the respondents filed and served a Response, annexing a Statement of Defence, which was essentially a reproduction of the Statement of Claim with handwritten annotations. The Fair Work Ombudsman subsequently made an application for default judgment on 9 July 2013, supported by affidavits, which led to the current hearing. The Court found that the respondents and their legal representatives were duly served with the relevant papers, but no appearance was made on their behalf. Consequently, the Court proceeded to grant the application for default judgment against the respondents.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the First Respondent contravene the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Cleaning Services Award 2010 by failing to pay the minimum rates of pay, fortnightly payments, overtime rates, and other entitlements to the Employees?
2. Did the First Respondent unlawfully deduct amounts payable to the Employees as alleged under sections 324 and 323 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)?
3. Did the First Respondent fail to provide access to rosters and unpaid meal breaks as required under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Cleaning Services Award 2010?
4. Did the First Respondent fail to comply with the Notices to Produce Records or Documents served under section 712(3) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)?
5. Did the First Respondent fail to make and keep prescribed records and issue compliant payslips as required under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)?
6. Did the First Respondent make pay slips containing false or misleading information as alleged under regulation 3.44(1) of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)?
7. Did the First Respondent fail to pay the Employees for travel time at the appropriate rate as required under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Cleaning Services Award 2010?
8. Was the Second Respondent involved in the contraventions committed by the First Respondent, thereby contravening the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) herself?
9. Are the amounts of compensation, interest, and superannuation contributions as ordered by the Court appropriate given the underpayments identified?
10. Is the default judgment entered against the First and Second Respondents in accordance with Rule 13.03B(2) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) justified by the default in compliance with the requirements to file and serve a response and defence?
Held
1. The First Respondent contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Cleaning Services Award 2010 by failing to pay the minimum rates of pay, fortnightly payments, overtime rates, and other entitlements to the Employees. Result: Declaration made.
2. The First Respondent unlawfully deducted amounts payable to the Employees as alleged under sections 324 and 323 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Result: Declaration made.
3. The First Respondent failed to provide access to rosters and unpaid meal breaks as required under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Cleaning Services Award 2010. Result: Declaration made.
4. The First Respondent failed to comply with the Notices to Produce Records or Documents served under section 712(3) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Result: Declaration made.
5. The First Respondent failed to make and keep prescribed records and issue compliant payslips as required under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth). Result: Declaration made.
6. The First Respondent made pay slips containing false or misleading information as alleged under regulation 3.44(1) of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth). Result: Declaration made.
7. The First Respondent failed to pay the Employees for travel time at the appropriate rate as required under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Cleaning Services Award 2010. Result: Declaration made.
8. The Second Respondent was involved in the contraventions committed by the First Respondent, thereby contravening the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) herself. Result: Declaration made.
9. The amounts of compensation, interest, and superannuation contributions as ordered by the Court are appropriate given the underpayments identified. Result: Orders made.
10. The default judgment entered against the First and Second Respondents is in accordance with Rule 13.03B(2) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) and justified by the default in compliance with the requirements to file and serve a response and defence. Result: Default judgment entered.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) and that the Response and Defence did not constitute a valid defence; e) on 2 April 2013, the Court issued a Notice of Default Hearing and required the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey to file and serve a Defence within 14 days; f) on 9 July 2013, the FW Ombudsman filed the Application in a Case seeking default judgment against the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey. The Court's reasoning on the contravention of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Cleaning Services Award 2010 by the First Respondent is grounded in the absence of any response or defence from the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey. The Court accepted the affidavit evidence provided by the FW Ombudsman, which detailed numerous breaches by the Corporation of the Fair Work Act and the Cleaning Services Award. These breaches included underpayment of wages, failure to pay overtime, unlawful deductions, non-compliance with record-keeping requirements, and failure to provide employees with access to rosters and meal breaks. The Court applied statutory provisions and award clauses to the facts as presented in the affidavits and found the Corporation liable for the alleged contraventions.
In relation to the unlawful deductions made by the First Respondent, the Court relied on sections 323 and 324 of the Fair Work Act. The evidence showed that the Corporation deducted amounts from employees' wages without proper justification, which the Court found to be unlawful. The Corporation's failure to provide employees with access to rosters and unpaid meal breaks was addressed under section 45 of the Fair Work Act and clause 25 and 26.2 of the Cleaning Services Award 2010. The Court found that the Corporation did not comply with these provisions, leading to a declaration of contravention.
The Court also considered the First Respondent's failure to comply with Notices to Produce Records or Documents under section 712(3) of the Fair Work Act. The Corporation did not provide the requested records, which the Court deemed as non-compliance. The failure to make and keep prescribed records and issue compliant payslips was assessed under sections 535 and 536 of the Fair Work Act and relevant regulations. The Court found the Corporation liable for not adhering to these obligations.
The issue of the Corporation making pay slips containing false or misleading information was addressed under regulation 3.44(1) of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth). The evidence indicated discrepancies in the recorded hours worked by employees, which the Court found to be misleading and a contravention of the regulatory requirements. The failure to pay for travel time at the appropriate rate was assessed under section 45 of the Fair Work Act and clause 17.10 of the Cleaning Services Award 2010. The Court found that the Corporation did not pay employees for travel time as required, leading to a declaration of contravention.
The Court also examined whether the Second Respondent, Ms Paino-Povey, was involved in the contraventions committed by the Corporation. Under section 550 of the Fair Work Act, the Court found Ms Paino-Povey liable for the contraventions as she was a director and thus involved in the management of the Corporation. The amounts of compensation, interest, and superannuation contributions ordered by the Court were based on the total underpayments identified in the FW Ombudsman's affidavit. The Court applied sections 545 and 547 of the Fair Work Act to calculate the compensation and interest due to the employees and mandated superannuation contributions as required by the legislation.
The default judgment entered against the First and Second Respondents was justified under Rule 13.03B(2) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth). The Court found that the Corporation and Ms Paino-Povey defaulted in their compliance with the requirements to file and serve a response and defence. The Court accepted the evidence presented by the FW Ombudsman and declared the default judgment appropriate given the absence of any substantive defence from the respondents. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that failure to comply with procedural requirements, such as filing a response and defence, can result in a default judgment being entered against the respondent, which can lead to liability for the contraventions alleged.