Evans and Ramsay Health Care Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Evans and Ramsay Health Care Australia Pty Ltd [2024] AATA 4 (3 January 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2023/4070

Re:Susan Evans

APPLICANT

AndRamsay Health Care Australia Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Brigadier AG Warner, AM LVO (Retd), Member

Date:3 January 2024

Place:Perth

On 7 December 2023, the Tribunal decided:

For the reasons given orally at the conclusion of the hearing of this matter on 7 December 2023, the Tribunal refuses to grant the Applicant an extension of time to lodge an application for review of a decision dated 30 March 2021 of Ramsay Health Care Australia Pty Ltd.

Attached are written reasons distilled from an edited transcript of the oral reasons for decision delivered to the parties in person at the conclusion of the hearing of the matter.

..........................[Sgd]..............................................

Brigadier AG Warner, AM LVO (Retd), Member

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – extension of time application – substantive matter refusal of compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – length of delay – awareness of appeal rights and explanation for delay – merits of substantive application – prejudice – extension of time application refused

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – ss 29(2), 29(7)

Safety, Rehabilitation and CompensationAct 1988 – ss 14, 16, 19, 65(4)

CASES 

Brown v Commissioner of Taxation [1999] FCA 563
Coney and Comcare [2018] AATA 4600
Frugtniet v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2017] FCA 1227
Hewson and Australia Post Corporation [1998] AATA71
Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Minister for Home Affairs and Environment (1984) 3 FCR 344
Katoa v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2022] HCA 28
Kuljic v Secretary, Department of Social Services (1994) 33 ALD 121, 122
Noonan and Comcare [2019] AATA 515
Re Civic Tavern Pty Ltd and ACT Liquor Licensing Board (1993) 32 ALD 381
Re Grafton and Commonwealth (1988) 16 ALD
Re Romeo and Secretary, Department of Social Security (1992) 26 ALD 248
Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services and Roberts [2003] AATA 269
Selvidge v Director of Professional Services Review [2010] FCA 965
WZANW v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FMCA 107

Zizza v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1995] 55 ALD 451

REASONS FOR DECISION

Brigadier AG Warner, AM LVO (Retd), Member

3 January 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant’s substantive application seeks review of a reviewable decision of the Respondent dated 30 March 2021. By that decision it was determined that the Applicant had no entitlement to compensation under sections 14, 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) for tender kneecap into lateral quadriceps and tender cervical spine, claimed to have been sustained on 9 January 2021.  The Applicant has lodged an application for an order extending the time in which her application for review can be lodged.

  2. The extension of time application was heard in an interlocutory hearing on 7 December 2023. The hearing was conducted by telephone conference. Mr Patrick Mullally of Workclaims Australia represented the Applicant,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Evans and Ramsay Health Care Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered an application by an applicant, who was formerly employed as a nursing assistant, for an extension of time to seek review of a decision made by the respondent. The applicant's employment was terminated due to an inability to perform her role due to non-compensable injuries. She had previously claimed a workplace injury on 9 January 2021, which was denied by the respondent on 5 March 2021. This denial was affirmed on review on 30 March 2021, with a notice clearly outlining the applicant's right to seek further review by the AAT within 60 days. The applicant filed her application for an extension of time on 13 June 2023, acknowledging she was substantially out of time.

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant the applicant an extension of time pursuant to s 29(7) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) to lodge her application for review of the 30 March 2021 decision. The respondent opposed this application. The Tribunal was required to consider factors including the length of the delay, the applicant's awareness of her appeal rights, the explanation provided for the delay, and the merits of the substantive application.

The Tribunal reasoned that the length of the delay was a significant factor weighing heavily against granting an extension. The applicant's application was lodged approximately 742 days out of time, a delay described as "very significant" and requiring an "exceptional case" to overcome. The Tribunal noted that even shorter delays have been found fatal to such applications, and that extensions of over six months are generally considered rare. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the applicant was clearly informed of her appeal rights in the reviewable decision of 30 March 2021, which explicitly detailed how to apply to the AAT within 60 days and how to seek an extension of time if necessary. The applicant confirmed she understood these rights but chose not to pursue an appeal at that time, believing she had to choose between her workers' compensation claim and an income protection claim, and that she would recover. The Tribunal was satisfied that no representations were made to the applicant by the respondent that would have precluded her from seeking review of the AAT decision, nor did the respondent's engagement regarding her fitness for work suggest an intention to pursue the workers' compensation claim.

The Tribunal refused the applicant's application for an extension of time.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the conclusion of the interlocutory hearing, the Tribunal gave oral reasons for its decision to refuse the Applicant’s application for an extension of time. The Respondent subsequently requested a written statement of those reasons, and the written reasons which follow are distilled from the edited transcript of the oral reasons given on 7 December 2023.THE BACKGROUND TO THE APPLCIATION The background facts are laid out comprehensively in Exhibit A1 at [1] to [8], and in Exhibit R1 at [3] to [41] and were not disputed during the hearing. Significant elements are as follows:a)The Applicant was employed by the Respondent as a nursing assistant from 15 April 2015 to 6 April 2023, at which time her employment was terminated because of her inability to carry out the requirements of her role as a nursing assistant due to non-compensable injuries or conditions.b)The Applicant claimed that on 9 January 2021 she suffered a workplace injury (Exhibit A2, para 6).c)The Applicant signed a Comcare Claim Form (Exhibit R1, annex A) on 10 February 2021 seeking acceptance of liability under s 14 of the SRC Act for “tender above kneecap into the lateral quadriceps, tender cervical spine”.d)By a determination dated 5 March 2021 (Exhibit R1, annex D), liability for the claimed injury was denied under ss 14, 16 and 19 of the SRC Act. That determination included a notice of rights. e)The Applicant sought review of that determination in accordance with the notice of rights outlined in the determination. In a reviewable decision dated 30 March 2021, the determination of 5 March 2021 was affirmed (Exhibit R1, annex F). That reviewable decision included a notice of rights which clearly outlined the Applicant’s right to seek review of the reviewable decision dated 30 March 2021 in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.f)In October 2021 the Applicant underwent a 3-level cervical fusion which she said “took about 3 months to heal” (Exhibit A2, para 17).g)On 20 April 2021 the Applicant emailed the Respondent asking her to complete a HESTA income protection form and return it to her via email (Exhibit R1, annex G).h)The Applicant did not return to work with the Respondent in the period from 9 January 2021 to her termination date on 6 April 2023. i)On 13 June 2023 the Applicant filed an application for an extension of time to apply to the Tribunal for review of the reviewable decision dated 30 March 2021, and accepts that she is substantially out of time (Exhibit A1, para 7).ISSUE The Tribunal must decide whether the Applicant should be granted an extension of time pursuant to s 29(7) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act) to lodge an application for a review of the decision dated 30 March 2021. The Respondent opposes the application for an extension of time.MATERIAL BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL The Tribunal had the following material before it:a)Applicant’s submissions dated 1 August 2023 (Exhibit A1);b)Applicant’s Witness Statement dated 31 July 2023 (Exhibit A2);c)Applicant’s documents filed 1 August 2023 (Exhibit A3);d)Respondent’s Written Submissions dated 3 October 2023 (Exhibit R1);e)Enclosures to Respondent’s Written Submissions filed 3 October 2023 (Exhibit R2);f)Outline of Evidence of Karen Haran dated 2 October 2023 (Exhibit R3); andg)Annexures A-F of Exhibit R3.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The letter by Valerie Franks on behalf of the Respondent dated 30 March 2021 (Exhibit R3, Annex F) clearly and comprehensively details the Applicant’s appeal rights and states under a heading, ‘Notice to claimant - Review of decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’: If you believe this decision is wrong, you have the right to apply for a review of the decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT has no connection with QBE Self Insurance Services. If you wish the AAT to review the decision, you must apply to the AAT within 60 days of the date you receive this decision. If you have good reason for not meeting the time limit, you can write to the AAT and ask for an extension of time, giving details of your reason or reason (s). Ms Franks’ letter then goes on to provide further details including phone numbers, fax numbers and information to assist in seeking a review. In her oral evidence the Applicant confirmed that she had read and understood her rights and decided that she did not wish to pursue an appeal in the AAT. As already stated, the Applicant’s explanation for the delay in lodging an application for review is that she thought she had either to pursue her claim for workers compensation or a claim for income protection, and that she would recover from her conditions. Nowhere in the determination dated 5 March 2021, or the later reviewable decision dated 30 March 2021, is there any reference to a claim for income protection or any preclusion from seeking review of a reviewable decision in the AAT. The Applicant has demonstrated her understanding of these notices of rights, because she sought review of the determination dated 5 March 2021 in accordance with the notice included in that decision (Exhibit R1, annex D). Ms Haran has confirmed in her outline of evidence dated 2 October 2023 (Exhibit R3) and her oral evidence that she did not make any representations to the Applicant about her ability to pursue a claim for income protection when she spoke with the Applicant on 10 February 2021. Ms Haran provided a checklist of the matters she discussed with the Applicant on 10 February 2021 (Exhibit R4, annex A) and that checklist is signed by the Applicant and makes no reference to a claim for income protection. The Tribunal notes the evidence in relation to the assistance Ms Haran provided to the Applicant with respect to the paperwork associated with her income protection claim, but is satisfied that Ms Haran took no role in recommending or substantially progressing that claim and therefore delaying or precluding any appeal to the AAT. When the Respondent engaged with the Applicant about her fitness for work, there is no evidence indicating that the Applicant advised her employer that she intended to pursue her claim for workers compensation for the claimed injury, or that she asked her employer about it. In her oral evidence the Applicant agreed that she did not raise the issue of workers compensation in her medical assessment with Dr Lee on 5 December 2022 (Exhibit A2, para 19 refers), or in the subsequent discussion with the Respondent on 8 March 2023, and did not respond to the show cause letter dated 23 March 2023 (Exhibit A3/4-5).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The relevant principles are laid out in Exhibit A1 at [11] and also in Exhibit R1 at [21], and were not disputed during the hearing. The Tribunal now turns to its consideration of relevant principles.CONSIDERATIONThe length of delay The length of delay involved in a case will be a relevant consideration. In relation to the importance of statutory time limits, the Federal Court in Selvidge v Director of Professional Services Review [2010] FCA 965, repeated the long-established review and stated at [6]: Time limits for bringing applications or appeals are prescribed for good reasons. While the court has power to extend the period of 28 days provided, it should not do so without good reason. In the absence of such a reason, an extension should not be granted, even if to do so would not cause prejudice to the respondent. In this application the Tribunal notes that the provisions of the SRC Act are more generous than the provisions of the AAT Act, in that the timeframe for lodging an application for review is more than double the timeframe for lodging an application for review in other types of matters. In other words, 60 days rather than 28 days. The Respondent submits that the 60 day timeframe for lodging an application for a review of decision expired on 1 June 2021. The Respondent submits that the extension of time application was lodged on 13 June 2023, the date of the Tribunal’s notice of application such that it was, therefore, lodged 804 days from the date on which the Applicant alleges she received the reviewable decision (Exhibit R1, para 24). Based on the information that is available, the Tribunal finds that the extension of time application was lodged some 742 days out of time. This is clearly a very significant delay. The Tribunal and courts have previously found that such long delays would need an exceptional case for an extension of time to be granted. For example, in WZANW v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FMCA 1075 it was found at [28] that a delay of 54 days would likely be fatal to an application to extend time. In a case involving a delay of two and a half years, the Federal Court stated: “The length of delay here is of such extreme duration that the merits of the application for an extension of time would have to be particularly obvious to overcome the delay”. In the current matter the Respondent relevantly cites Coney and Comcare [2018] AAT 1859 where the Tribunal found that an extension of 80 days is significant and should be refused, and also Noonan and Comcare [2019] AATA 515, where it was suggested by the Tribunal that extensions over six months should be rare. The Tribunal notes that even in matters where the delay is not considered to be lengthy, the Tribunal has found that the “brevity of the extension sought does not, however lead automatically to an order extending the time” (Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services v Roberts [2003] AATA 269 at [16]). The Tribunal’s consideration of this factor weighs heavily against the granting of an extension of time.Explanation for the delay and the awareness of appeal rights