DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Eustace v Dubrava and Anor [2021] QDC 104
PARTIES:
ROSS GRAEME EUSTACE
(Plaintiff/Applicant)
v
YVETTE DUBRAVA
(First defendant)
and
ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LTD
(Second defendant/Respondent)
FILE NO:
3988 of 2018
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Application
DELIVERED ON:
31 May 2021 (ex tempore)
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
31 May 2021
JUDGE:
Dearden DCJ
ORDER: The application is granted in part, with respect to the proposed amendments to the statement of claim contained at paragraphs 6(c), 8(a), 8(ba) and 8(h).
The application is otherwise refused.
CATCHWORDS:
PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – APPLICATION TO AMEND – where the plaintiff makes a personal injury claim arising out of a motor vehicle collision – where a request for trial date had been signed – where the plaintiff makes an application to amend statement of claim on the first day of trial – where amendments varied significantly from the statement of loss and damage – where the applicant submits that the amendments do not change the evidence to be relied upon – whether the defendant will suffer prejudice
LEGISLATION:
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) rr 377, 470
CASES:
Carswell v KBRV Resort Operations Pty Ltd (No.2) [2018] QSC 110
COUNSEL: T Nielsen for the plaintiff
R Morton for the second defendant
SOLICITORS: CMC Lawyers for the plaintiff
McInnes Wilson Lawyers for the second defendant
Introduction
This is an application to amend the claimant’s statement of claim by the plaintiff, Ross Graeme Eustace on the first day of trial of his proceedings for personal injury arising out of a motor vehicle collision which occurred on 14 August 2017.
The application was foreshadowed on Friday 28 May 2021, the last business day prior to trial. The application was preceded by a statement of loss and damage dated and sent 24 May 2021 to the second defendant’s solicitors (I will refer collectively to the position of the second defendant as the “the defendant” as a matter of convenience), which varied significantly from the plaintiff’s statement of loss and damage dated 17 February 2019.
The application proceeds pursuant to Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (‘UCPR’) r.470(1)(b), given that a request for trial date has been filed in these proceedings (unsurprisingly) on 22 January 2021 (document 3). The court’s leave is required to amend the pleadings, as the plaintiff seeks in this matter (UCPR r.470(2)(a)). The originating process amendment sought also requires leave pursuant to UCPR r.377.
The plaintiff refers me to the decision of Martin J in Carswell v KBRV Resort Operations Pty Ltd (No.2) [2018] QSC 110, which helpfully reviews relevant case law, and the plaintiff’s written submissions identify, equally helpfully, those matters which are relevant to the exercise of this discretion as follows:
Justice Martin then noted the following matters for the exercise of the discretion:
(a)It is certainly within the power of the court to refuse amendments. The parties are entitled to adjust resolution which may negate against allowing an amendment;
(b)The nature and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Eustace v Dubrava and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] QDC 104
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the amendments proposed by Eustace were permissible under the relevant procedural rules and whether granting the application would cause unjust prejudice to Dubrava. Eustace argued that the amendments did not change the evidence to be relied upon and that the changes were necessary to accurately reflect the nature of the injuries. Dubrava contended that the amendments were fundamentally different from the original statement of claim, which had been signed and filed, and that allowing the changes would unfairly prejudice their ability to defend the claim.
The court acknowledged that amendments to pleadings should generally be allowed unless they cause substantial prejudice to the opposing party. However, in this instance, the proposed amendments varied significantly from the original statement of claim. The court found that while some of the amendments were relatively minor and did not prejudice the defendant, others were substantive and could potentially mislead the defendant in their preparation and presentation of the defence. The court concluded that granting the application in its entirety would result in significant prejudice to Dubrava, as they had not had the opportunity to prepare for the new allegations. Therefore, the application was granted in part, with respect to the amendments contained at paragraphs 6(c), 8(a), 8(ba), and 8(h), while the remainder of the application was refused.
The court's final orders granted the application in part, allowing the proposed amendments at paragraphs 6(c), 8(a), 8(ba), and 8(h) to be incorporated into the statement of claim. The remaining amendments were refused, and the trial proceeded with the original statement of claim and the approved amendments. The court's decision underscores the importance of adhering to procedural rules and the potential consequences of seeking significant changes to pleadings close to the trial date.
Orders
Orders of the court
The application is granted in part, with respect to the proposed amendments to the statement of claim contained at paragraphs 6(c), 8(a), 8(ba) and 8(h).
The application is otherwise refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi