| PATENTS ACT 1990 |
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Re:Application No. 614678 by ETHICON, INC., Opposition by UNITED STATES SURGICAL CORPORATION, and Objection to an Extension of Time to lodge a Notice of Opposition.
Background
Patent application No. 614678 by Ethicon, Inc. (Ethicon) was lodged under the Patents Act 1952 on 6 November 1989, and was advertised accepted under the Patents Act 1990 on 5 September 1991. As a consequence, the opposition procedures for this case are governed by section 234(3) of the Patents Act 1990, and thus section 59 of the Patents Act 1952 applies. However, the Regulations under the 1952 Act are not retained, and the Regulations under the 1990 Act operate.
On 4 December 1991, United States Surgical Corporation (USSC) requested an extension of time of three months in which to lodge a notice of opposition under section 59(1) of the Patents Act 1952. On 17 December 1991, Ethicon indicated that it objected to the extension. The matter was heard in Canberra on 29 January 1992. Ethicon was represented by Mr J.Terry of Griffith Hack & Co, Sydney, and USSC was represented by Mr M.Ellicott of Counsel and Ms O.Gourley of Minter Ellison, Sydney.
Submissions
At the hearing, Mr Terry submitted that the Commissioner has no power to grant an extension of time to lodge a notice of opposition. Mr Terry's argument was that section 15AA of the Acts Interpretation Act requires section 59(1) to be given a construction that would promote the purpose or object of the Act. Mr Terry said that the intention of Parliament under the 1990 Act as revealed by regulation 5.3 is that an extension of time to file a notice of opposition is no longer available, and as a consequence section 59(1) should be read down so as to exclude the possibility of an extension. Mr Ellicott replied that section 59(1) is clear on its face, and should not be limited in the way Mr Terry had suggested.
In the application for an extension of time, the representatives of USSC specified six reasons why an extension was needed:
"1. complete its consideration of the specification of application no 44435/89;
2. continue and complete its consideration of the substantial searches and investigations already undertaken in relation to the alleged invention described in the application;
3. undertake further searches and investigations in relation to the alleged invention of the application;
4. consider and evaluate the results of the searches and investigations referred to in 3;
5. communicate and confer with us and other advisers in Australia in relation to these matters; and
6. have prepared, consider, and give instructions as to the lodgement of a Notice of Opposition"
Mr Ellicott made further submissions based on a declaration by Neil David Gershon, a United States patent attorney employed by USSC, a copy of which was filed at the Patent Office by facsimile on 24 January 1992. The relevant points in this submission are:
. USSC had taken actions in the United…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ethicon, Inc. v United States Surgical Corporation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1992] APO 4
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues centred around the interpretation of section 59(1) of the Patents Act 1952, which allows for extensions of time to lodge a notice of opposition, and the appropriate circumstances under which such extensions should be granted. Ethicon argued that the Commissioner lacked the power to grant extensions under the new regime established by the Patents Act 1990, while USSC contended that the plain language of section 59(1) mandated that extensions could be granted. Additionally, the court had to assess whether USSC had demonstrated a bona fide intention to oppose the patent on substantial grounds.
The delegate concluded that the Commissioner indeed had the power to grant an extension under section 59(1), as the statutory language was clear and unambiguous. The delegate also found that USSC had made out an appropriate case for an extension, given their need to complete searches and investigations to substantiate a potentially serious opposition. The delegate determined that USSC's actions, including their efforts in the United States and the timing of their search instructions, demonstrated a genuine intention to oppose the patent on valid grounds. Therefore, the delegate allowed USSC an extension of three months to lodge their notice of opposition.
The delegate awarded costs against USSC, reasoning that Ethicon had insufficient time to consider the late-filed declaration due to a public holiday. This decision underscores the importance of timely submissions and the need for parties to adequately prepare their cases within the stipulated deadlines.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi