Espanol Holdings Pty Ltd v Banning

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   ESPANOL HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR -v- BANNING & ORS [2000] WASC 45

CORAM:   MASTER BREDMEYER

HEARD:   10 & 11 FEBRUARY 2000

DELIVERED          :   25 FEBRUARY 2000

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1172 of 1999

BETWEEN:   ESPANOL HOLDINGS PTY LTD

First Plaintiff

MARIA MICHELLE ORTIN
Second Plaintiff

AND

MARTIN PAUL BANNING
First Defendant

DOUGLAS FRANK BREWER
Second Defendant

ESCON LANE PTY LTD
Third Defendant

JOHN ANDREW MILLER
Fourth Defendant

COUNTRYWIDE HOME LOANS PTY LTD
Fifth Defendant

GEORGE JASPER
Sixth Defendant

DON CAMPBELL-SMITH
Seventh Defendant

Catchwords:

Discovery of particular documents

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Applications allowed in part

Representation:

Counsel:

First Plaintiff                :     Mr J C Giles

Second Plaintiff            :     Mr J C Giles

First Defendant             :     Mr K J O'Toole

Second Defendant         :     In person

Third Defendant           :     Mr C R Coulson

Fourth Defendant          :     Mr C R Coulson

Fifth Defendant            :     No appearance

Sixth Defendant            :     No appearance

Seventh Defendant        :     Mr G H Murphy & Ms D M Templeman

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff                :     Solomon Bros

Second Plaintiff            :     Solomon Bros

First Defendant             :     K J O'Toole & Associates

Second Defendant         :     In person

Third Defendant           :     Coulsons

Fourth Defendant          :     Coulsons

Fifth Defendant            :     No appearance

Sixth Defendant            :     No appearance

Seventh Defendant        :     Minter Ellison

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Nil

Case(s) also cited:

Alba Nominees Pty Ltd v Cecil Bros Pty Ltd, unreported; SCt of WA; Library No 970698; 12 December 1997

Astra-National Productions Ltd v Neo-art Productions Ltd [1928] WN 218

Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol-Myers Co [1979] VR 273

Biala v Mallina Holdings Pty Ltd [1990] WAR 174

British Association of Glass Bottle Manufacturers Ltd v Nettlefold [1912] AC 709

Commissioner of Taxation v Ryan [2000] HCA 4

Flower & Hart (A Firm) v White Industries (Qld) Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 773

Hoad v Nationwide News Pty Ltd (1998) 19 WAR 468

Jones v Monte Video Gas Co (1880) 5 QBD 556

Kent Coal Concessions Ltd v Duguid [1910] 1 KB 904

Mann v Carnell [1999] HCA 66

Molnycke A B v Proctor and Gamble Ltd (No 3) [1990] RPC 498

Moody v Cox and Hutt [1917] 2 Ch 71

Mulley v Manifold (1959) 103 CLR 341

Pulitano v Ginbey [1999] WASC 5

Schlam v WA Trustees [1964] WAR 178

Science Research Council v Nasse [1980] AC 1028

Spector v Ageda [1973] Ch 30

Temwood Holdings Pty Ltd v Oliver [1999] WASC 251

Tipperary Developments Pty Ltd v State of Western Australia [1999] WASC 62

York v Rowe & Ors, unreported; SCt of WA; Library No 8681; 18 January 1991

  1. MASTER BREDMEYER:  I have before me three applications for discovery of specific documents.  The first is by the plaintiff against the first, second and seventh defendants.  The second is by the first defendant against the plaintiff and the third is by the seventh defendant against the plaintiff.

  2. I will consider first the plaintiff's application against the first defendant.  The documents sought are set out in par…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Espanol Holdings Pty Ltd v Banning and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] WASC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Espanol Holdings Pty Ltd v Banning involved a dispute regarding the discovery of particular documents. Espanol Holdings Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, was a company associated with the defendants, Mr. and Mrs. Banning. The defendants sought the discovery of specific documents relating to the plaintiff's business transactions, real estate dealings, leasing activities, and negotiations with Blue Line Realty. The defendants argued that these documents were relevant to proving that Mrs. Ortin, a key figure in the plaintiff company, was under undue influence and subject to unconscionable conduct by Mr. Banning.

The court had to determine whether the documents sought by the defendants were relevant and necessary for the just determination of the litigation. The documents in question were related to the purchase, operation, and sale of various businesses and properties, as well as leasing activities and negotiations with a real estate agency. The court needed to assess whether these documents had direct, indirect, or remote relevance to the central issues of the case, which primarily concerned the business experience and competence of Mrs. Ortin and whether she was under undue influence and subject to unconscionable conduct by Mr. Banning.

In its decision, the court found that while some of the documents were relevant to the issues in the case, others were not. Specifically, the court allowed the request for documents related to real estate dealings, as they were pertinent to determining whether the plaintiffs had correctly understood the binding nature of certain offers and acceptances, especially regarding the conditions of finance. The court declined to grant the request for documents related to leasing activities and negotiations with Blue Line Realty, as these were not directly or indirectly relevant to the primary issues of the case. Additionally, the court refused to grant the request for documents relating to the purchase, operation, and sale of businesses, finding them not necessary for the just determination of the litigation.

The court ordered that the plaintiff company must provide the documents related to real estate dealings, while the other requests for discovery were denied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I turn now to the first defendant's application for discovery of particular documents against the plaintiff. The documents sought are listed in the Schedule to the first defendant's chamber summons of 21 December 1999. "1.All documents relating to the purchase, operation and sale of:(a)Lucky's Cake and Lunch BarShop 21 Coolbellup Shopping CentreCoolbellup AvenueCoolbellup(b)Newcastle Sandwich Supply466 Newcastle StreetPerth(c)Sunflower Take-away and CaféShop 20 Coolbellup Shopping CentreCoolbellup AvenueCoolbellup(d)Hilton Lunch Bar38 Stockdale RoadHilton Park(e)Richardson DrycleanersO'Connor(f)Melville Plaza Coffee LoungeMelville Plaza(g)Lunch BarOsborne Park" The first defendant says that these documents are relevant because they will show the level of business experience and competence of Mrs Ortin and hence whether she was in a relationship of disability to Mr Banning, so that she was under his undue influence and subject to his unconscionable conduct. I consider the documents are not directly relevant to this issue. They may be indirectly relevant or remotely relevant but I consider it reasonable to apply O 26 r 7(3)(b)(ii) and O 1 r 4B. I consider that these documents are not necessary for the just determination of the litigation and are not directly relevant to the issues in this case and I refuse this request."2.All documents relating to the purchases and offers to purchase and sale of real estate (the 'Real Estate Dealings') by the plaintiffs since 1989 including but not limited to:(a)12 Beaconsfield Avenue, Midvale(b)57 Piercy Way, Beaconsfield(c)lots 13, 16, 17 and 18 Coolbellup Shopping Centre, Coolbellup Avenue, Coolbellupincluding documents evidencing communication between the plaintiff and(i)their settlement agents(ii)their finance brokers(iii)their legal advisors(iv)their financial advisorsin respect to each of the real estate dealings." On (b), I consider the reference to 57 Piercy Way, Beaconsfield is a typing error and I have amended that to 57 Piercy Way, Kardinya. An issue in this case is whether the plaintiffs incorrectly believed that the second transaction offer and acceptance was binding on them. The contract was subject to finance to be obtained by 21 January 1998 and that finance was sought but not obtained by that date. These documents relate to real estate deals done by the plaintiffs in 1995 and 1997. Some of the contracts are made subject to finance and the discovery of the related documents sought may show whether any of these contracts fell over because of inability to obtain loan finance. That is relevant to that issue in this case. I will allow this request."3.Documents evidencing the leasing of the plaintiffs' properties, the appointment of managing agents, rent receipts and trust statements in respect to real estate owned by the plaintiffs since 1989." I consider Mrs Ortin's experience of leasing is not directly or indirectly relevant to the issues in the case which relate to buying properties, not leasing. I decline to grant this request."4.All documents evidencing dealings between the plaintiffs and Blue Line Realty in respect to negotiations by the plaintiffs to the purchase of(a)Karrinyup Newsagency(b)The Plantation Restaurant South Perth(c)Earlybird Seafood(d)Riverton Auto Lodge(e)Canning River Auto Lodge"