Ere18 v Minister for Home Affairs (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ERE18 v Minister for Home Affairs (No 2) [2021] FCA 1346  

Appeal from: Application for extension of time to appeal: ERE18 v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor [2019] FCCA 262
File number: NSD 1843 of 2019
Judgment of: STEWART J
Date of judgment: 2 November 2021
Catchwords: MIGRATION – application for an extension of time to file a notice of appeal – where applicant refused temporary protection visa by delegate of the Minister – where Immigration Assessment Authority confirmed the decision of the delegate – whether there was a failure to inquire by the delegate or Authority as to the applicant’s heart condition – where applicant sought to adduce further evidence – where prospects of appeal poor – application dismissed
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 11

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36(2A), 473CA, s 473DC, 473DD, s 476

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 36.03

Cases cited:

Abebe v The Commonwealth of Australia [1999] HCA 14; 197 CLR 510

AQF17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 966

DYK16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 222; 267 FCR 69

ERE18 v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor [2019] FCCA 262

ERE18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] FCA 997

FSG17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 29

Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; 264 CLR 123

Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen [1984] FCA 176; 3 FCR 344

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CRY16 [2017] FCAFC 210; 253 FCR 475

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA [2019] HCA 3; 264 CLR 421

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI [2009] HCA 39; 259 ALR 429

MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] HCA 17; 390 ALR 590

MZZLL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 1367

Re Commonwealth of Australia; Ex parte Marks [2000] HCA 67; 177 ALR 491

Vu v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCAFC 59; 101 ALD 211

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 56
Date of hearing: 29 October 2021
Counsel for the Applicant: S Blount and P Bodisco (pro bono)
Solicitor for the Applicant: ABU Legal
Counsel for the First Respondent: G Johnson
Solicitor for the First Respondent: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 1843 of 2019

BETWEEN:

ERE18

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

STEWART J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 NOVEMBER 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for an extension of time and the interlocutory application to lead further evidence on appeal be dismissed with costs.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

STEWART J:

Introduction

  1. The applicant seeks an extension of time…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ere18 v Minister for Home Affairs (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1346
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ere18 v Minister for Home Affairs (No 2) involved an applicant from Lebanon who had applied for a temporary protection visa, which was refused by a delegate of the Minister. The Immigration Assessment Authority upheld the delegate's decision, leading the applicant to seek judicial review in the Circuit Court. Ultimately, the applicant sought an extension of time to appeal the Circuit Court's decision to the Federal Court. The primary issues for the Federal Court were whether there was a failure by the delegate or the Authority to inquire into the applicant's heart condition and whether the applicant could rely on new evidence and grounds of review that had not been presented in the Circuit Court.

The Federal Court found that the delegate had adequately considered the applicant's heart condition and had reasonably concluded that the healthcare available in Lebanon would not amount to significant harm as defined in the Migration Act. The Court noted that the concept of "significant harm" did not include a right to access a certain standard of healthcare. The Circuit Court had already upheld the Authority's findings, and the Federal Court saw no reason to depart from those findings. Additionally, the Court was not persuaded that the applicant's prospects of appeal were sufficient to warrant an extension of time. The Court found that the applicant's reasons for delay were not compelling and that the late filing of the appeal notice was significant.

Accordingly, the Court dismissed the application for an extension of time and the interlocutory application to lead further evidence on appeal, with costs. This decision underscores the importance of timely legal action and the requirement for compelling reasons to extend the statutory deadlines for filing appeals in immigration matters.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for an extension of time and the interlocutory application to lead further evidence on appeal be dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

As will be seen, the applicant also seeks leave to rely on evidence that was not before the Circuit Court and he seeks leave to rely on a ground of review that was not advanced before the Circuit Court. On a previous occasion, I made orders to enable the simultaneous hearing of the application for an extension of time and the appeal, if an extension is granted: ERE18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] FCA 997.Background The applicant, a male citizen of Lebanon, arrived in Australia by boat from Indonesia with the assistance of people smugglers at Christmas Island in May 2013. Also, in May 2013, he gave an arrival interview at which he made claims to fear harm in his home country. The applicant said that as a result of the Syrian civil war, Lebanon had experienced an influx of Syrian refugees which had led to the rise of militias and also economic problems. The applicant’s sister also attempted to travel to Australia by boat, however she tragically died at sea on the attempt. Some 18 months after arriving in Australia, the applicant married an Australian permanent resident. He and his wife have two daughters, both of whom are Australian citizens. He has established his own business in Sydney, in which he works full-time. If he was to have to return to Lebanon, he has said that his wife and children would go with him. On 6 October 2016, following an invitation from the (then) Department of Immigration and Border Protection to apply for a visa, the applicant applied for a Temporary Protection (subclass 785) visa (TPV). The applicant enclosed with his application a statement in which he said he was unable to return to Lebanon because Syrians and extremist Muslims were recruiting young men to fight the Alawites in Syria. He also said that he feared being caught in crossfire between Syrian refugees and Hezbollah and that Lebanon was too dangerous for his family to return to. At an interview by a delegate of the Minister in June 2018, the applicant made some additional claims which were summarised in the delegate’s reasons as follows:•The applicant has a heart problem and takes Metoprolol to regulate his heart beat.•The security situation in Lebanon is very dangerous and the war in Syria has spilled over into Lebanon creating tensions between the different religious and political groups.•There are many non-state militia who possess arms. The applicant fears that given the proliferation of firearms, he and his family may be harmed in the context of a violent and unstable security situation in Lebanon. On 26 June 2018, the applicant was notified of the delegate’s decision made earlier that day to refuse his TPV application. The delegate accepted that the applicant’s claims regarding the general security situation in northern Lebanon were true. However, the delegate noted that the applicant did not claim to ever have been targeted by militia for recruitment or harassed because he was Sunni. The delegate also found that the applicant and his family did not face a risk of serious harm due to his family circumstances or on account of deportation to Lebanon. In relation to the complementary protection criterion, the delegate examined country information and found that Lebanese health authorities would be able to provide him with adequate care.The Authority’s decision

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Before addressing each particular, it is convenient to identify the relevant evidence.The evidence The Authority had before it, amongst other material, a recording of the applicant’s interview by the delegate and the delegate’s decision. In the interview, the applicant said that he has personal health issues and that he was attending specialists in Australia in relation to his heart. He also offered the delegate proof from a doctor or specialist if it was required. He said that he would not get the quality of healthcare in Lebanon that he enjoys in Australia. The delegate responded by asking the applicant to tell them about his heart condition. The applicant said that he has a weak or fast beating heart. He said that he was on “continuous medication” which he identified as Metoprolol. Later in the interview, in answer to the question what he thinks would happen to him if he went back to Lebanon, amongst other things he said: “My life is not there, there is no life. By life I mean there is no health, there is no education …”. Towards the end of the interview, the applicant asked the delegate whether the delegate had “enough”, whether the applicant had satisfied the delegate’s questions, and whether the delegate required anything more from him. The delegate responded by assuring the applicant that he should have every opportunity to say whatever he wanted or needed to say. As mentioned, in their decision the delegate recorded that the applicant had raised that he has a chronic heart problem and requires medical treatment. The delegate accepted that evidence including that he requires specialist consultations and ongoing medication, namely Metoprolol. The delegate went on to note that the applicant had not provided any evidence from his treatment providers as to what his diagnosis is and what his recommended treatment plan is. Further, the delegate noted that there was no evidence to indicate that the applicant will be denied medication or access to healthcare in Lebanon. The delegate went on to consider country information available at that time as to the provision and availability of health care in Lebanon on. Ultimately, the delegate accepted that there may be some difficulty accessing healthcare in Lebanon due to availability and cost, but did not consider that the applicant would be intentionally denied healthcare access in a way that would be regarded as cruel or inhuman or degrading in nature. The delegate stated that they were unable to find information regarding whether the applicant would be able to obtain Metoprolol specifically, but said that it appears that most chronic health medications including for cardiac related illnesses are available and can be provided free of charge. The Authority recorded the applicant’s claims with regard to his health and that “there is no healthcare in Lebanon.” The Authority then made findings on the applicant’s claims as follows: DFAT reports Lebanon’s health facilities have historically been considered adequate, but that they are under strain. DFAT also reports that healthcare in Akkar is under-serviced and in need of institutional support. There is nothing before me however to indicate, and nor was it claimed, that the applicant would be denied healthcare in an act that was intentionally inflicted. The definitions of torture, cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment, and degrading treatment or punishment all include an element of intention. I am not satisfied that a health system under strain is evidence of an intention to inflict any of the significant harms defined in s 5 on the applicant. Nor is there evidence that health care would be withheld from the applicant such as to amount to a real risk he will be arbitrarily deprived of life. The consequences of scarce medical resources do not fall within the concept of arbitrary deprivation of life. I acknowledge the applicant may currently be receiving better healthcare than he would in Lebanon, but ‘significant harm’ as defined in s 36(2A) does not include a right to access a certain standard of health care.(Reference omitted, and emphasis added.)

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to the complementary protection criterion, the Authority held that while the applicant may receive better healthcare in Australia than he would in Lebanon, the concept of “significant harm” in s 36(2A) of the Migration Act does not include a right to access a certain standard of healthcare.Decision in the Circuit Court By an application filed with the Circuit Court on 10 September 2018, the applicant sought judicial review of the Authority’s decision and raised the following two grounds:1. Contrary to the comment made by the Delegate there is substantial grounds that I will suffer significant harm with my family should I return to Lebanon;2. The Delegate misunderstood my well-founded fear of harm should I be compelled to return to Lebanon. While both grounds 1 and 2 asserted errors on the part of the “Delegate”, the judicial review application noted that the decision of which review was sought was that of the Authority on 17 August 2018. The delegate’s decision is a primary decision as defined by s 476(4) of the Migration Act and as such was not susceptible to judicial review by the Circuit Court: s 476(2). Accordingly, the matter was dealt with as though references to “the Delegate” in the applicant’s grounds were intended to be references to the Authority. The applicant appeared before the primary judge on 7 February 2019 for hearing, assisted by an Arabic interpreter. He was otherwise self-represented. In relation to ground 1, the Circuit Court found that the Authority’s findings pertaining to the complementary protection criterion were open to it for the reasons that it gave (at [26]). The Court noted that the Authority made dispositive findings in respect of the applicant’s claims under each of the refugee and complementary protection criteria which were logical and could not be said to lack an evident and intelligible justification. In relation to ground 2, the Circuit Court found that the Authority had taken into account the consequences of the applicant’s family travelling with him back to Lebanon, and that no misunderstanding by the Authority of the evidence had been identified (at [27]). The Court concluded that the Authority had correctly identified the relevant tests under the Migration Act and made adverse findings that were open to it, which findings were not illogical, irrational or unreasonable.Application for an extension of time By an application for an extension of time filed on 11 November 2019, the applicant seeks to extend time to appeal from the whole of the judgment of the Circuit Court. Pursuant to r 36.03 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), any notice of appeal from the decision of the primary judge was due to have been filed on or by 7 March 2019. Accordingly, the application was 249 days (or just over 8 months) out of time. On any view, that is a long time. The following explanations are advanced by the applicant for his delay in seeking review in this Court:(1)the applicant sought ministerial intervention, which was refused and that is when he decided to appeal his matter to the Federal Court; and(2)he was unaware he had to lodge an appeal within a certain timeframe.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The delegate’s decision was referred to the Authority for review under s 473CA in Pt 7AA of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) as a “fast track review process”. The applicant did not make a submission or provide any further information in support of his case on review. Neither was he invited to do so. On 17 August 2018, the applicant was notified of the Authority’s decision made earlier that day to affirm the decision on review. The Authority noted that the applicant had never claimed to have been targeted for recruitment or otherwise by militia such as Hezbollah or extremist Muslim groups (at [10]). It considered country information in finding that the applicant was not subject to a real risk of serious harm from parties involved in the Syrian conflict or Hezbollah (at [15]-[16]). In relation to the complementary protection criterion, the Authority held that while the applicant may receive better healthcare in Australia than he would in Lebanon, the concept of “significant harm” in s 36(2A) of the Migration Act does not include a right to access a certain standard of healthcare.Decision in the Circuit Court By an application filed with the Circuit Court on 10 September 2018, the applicant sought judicial review of the Authority’s decision and raised the following two grounds:1. Contrary to the comment made by the Delegate there is substantial grounds that I will suffer significant harm with my family should I return to Lebanon;2. The Delegate misunderstood my well-founded fear of harm should I be compelled to return to Lebanon. While both grounds 1 and 2 asserted errors on the part of the “Delegate”, the judicial review application noted that the decision of which review was sought was that of the Authority on 17 August 2018. The delegate’s decision is a primary decision as defined by s 476(4) of the Migration Act and as such was not susceptible to judicial review by the Circuit Court: s 476(2). Accordingly, the matter was dealt with as though references to “the Delegate” in the applicant’s grounds were intended to be references to the Authority. The applicant appeared before the primary judge on 7 February 2019 for hearing, assisted by an Arabic interpreter. He was otherwise self-represented. In relation to ground 1, the Circuit Court found that the Authority’s findings pertaining to the complementary protection criterion were open to it for the reasons that it gave (at [26]). The Court noted that the Authority made dispositive findings in respect of the applicant’s claims under each of the refugee and complementary protection criteria which were logical and could not be said to lack an evident and intelligible justification. In relation to ground 2, the Circuit Court found that the Authority had taken into account the consequences of the applicant’s family travelling with him back to Lebanon, and that no misunderstanding by the Authority of the evidence had been identified (at [27]). The Court concluded that the Authority had correctly identified the relevant tests under the Migration Act and made adverse findings that were open to it, which findings were not illogical, irrational or unreasonable.Application for an extension of time