FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Equity Financial Planners Pty Ltd v AMP Financial Planning Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 741
File number: VID 498 of 2020 Judgment of: MOSHINSKY J Date of judgment: 5 July 2023 Catchwords: CONTRACT – construction – where the applicant and group members were authorised representatives of the respondent (AMPFP) – where the contracts between the applicant/group members and AMPFP included a buyer of last resort (BOLR) policy that provided for AMPFP to buy back the register rights of the authorised representative at a multiple of 4.0x ongoing revenue – where AMPFP amended the BOLR policy to change the multiple from 4.0x to 2.5x (for ongoing revenue other than grandfathered commission revenue) and a lower multiple for grandfathered commission revenue – whether the changes to the BOLR policy were authorised by the amendment provision for legislation, economic or product changes – whether there was an “economic change” within the meaning of the policy – whether there was a “legislation change” within the meaning of the policy – whether any such changes rendered any part of the BOLR policy “inappropriate” – whether the changes to the policy were proportionate – whether AMPFP satisfied requirement of consultation with financial planners association – held: changes to the BOLR policy were ineffective
CONSUMER LAW – unconscionable conduct – where the applicant and group members were authorised representatives of AMPFP – where the contracts between the applicant/group members and AMPFP included a BOLR policy that provided for AMPFP to buy back the register rights of the authorised representative at a multiple of 4.0x ongoing revenue – where AMPFP amended the BOLR policy on 8 August 2019 to change the multiple from 4.0x to 2.5x (for ongoing revenue other than grandfathered commission revenue) and a lower multiple for grandfathered commission revenue – where a sample group member (WealthStone) had lodged a BOLR application before 8 August 2019 with an exercise date after 8 August 2019 – where AMPFP purported to apply the 8 August 2019 changes in calculating the BOLR benefit payable to WeathStone – where AMPFP included a release in draft buy-back agreement – where WealthStone requested removal of the release – where AMPFP refused to remove the release – whether AMPFP’s conduct in procuring the release was, in all the circumstances, unconscionable – held: AMPFP’s conduct in procuring the release was unconscionable
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2, Australian Consumer Law, ss 2, 18, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 237
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth)
Treasury Laws Amendment (Ending Grandfathered Conflicted Remuneration) Act 2019 (Cth)
Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Get Qualified Australia Pty Ltd (in liq)(No 2) [2017] FCA 709; [2017] ATPR ¶42‑548
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lux Distributors Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 90; [2013] ATPR ¶42‑447
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Quantum Housing Group Pty Ltd [2021]…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Equity Financial Planners Pty Ltd v AMP Financial Planning P... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FCA 741
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that arose in this case included the interpretation and application of the amendment clause in the BOLR policy, whether the changes constituted an economic or legislative change, the necessity of consultation with the financial planners association, and the proportionality of the changes. Additionally, the court had to determine whether AMPFP’s actions in obtaining a release from WealthStone were unconscionable under the Australian Consumer Law.
The court held that the amendments to the BOLR policy were not authorised by any of the stipulated changes in the policy and therefore were ineffective. The court found that neither an economic change nor a legislative change had occurred that would permit AMPFP to amend the policy. Furthermore, the court found that AMPFP had failed to consult with the relevant association as required by the policy. The court also determined that AMPFP’s conduct in procuring the release from WealthStone was unconscionable. The court concluded that the changes to the BOLR policy were not only unauthorised but also rendered the policy inappropriate due to the lack of consultation and the disproportionate nature of the changes.
In conclusion, the Federal Court ruled that the amendments to the BOLR policy were ineffective, and AMPFP’s conduct in procuring a release from WealthStone was unconscionable. The court ordered that the parties file proposed orders to give effect to the court’s reasons, along with supporting submissions, to address the quantification of damages payable to Equity and WealthStone. The court would deal with costs separately after the substantive orders were made.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Within 21 days, the applicant file a minute of proposed orders to give effect to the Court’s reasons, together with a short outline of submissions (of not more than five pages) in support of those orders.
2. Within a further 14 days, the respondent file a minute of proposed orders to give effect to the Court’s reasons, together with a short outline of submissions (of not more than five pages) in support of those orders.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
[1]
PLEADINGS
[23]
THE HEARING AND EVIDENCE
[27]
FACTUAL FINDINGS
[48]
AMPFP and the AMPFP network
[48]
ampfpa
[53]
Some key concepts – institutional ownership and register rights
[62]
The key contractual documents
[66]
Authorised representative agreements
[66]
Master Terms
[70]
BOLR Policy
[78]
The period before May 2017
[101]
The period May 2017 to August 2018
[102]
The period September 2018 to January 2019
[127]
The period 1 February to mid-March 2019
[135]
The period mid-March to 25 July 2019
[161]
The meeting on 25 July 2019 between AMPFP and RemCo
[206]
The period 25 July to 8 August 2019
[236]
25 and 26 July 2019
[236]
The “Formal Consultation materials” provided on 26 July 2019
[237]
27 July 2019 to 7 August 2019
[252]
AMPFP Board papers and meeting (7 August 2019)
[269]
Further communication on 7 August 2019
[292]
Announcement of the 8 August 2019 Changes
[293]
Evidence as to whether RemCo was appropriate body for consultation
[297]
Evidence as to whether reasonable notice was given of the proposed changes
[300]
The period after 8 August 2019
[309]
Facts relating to Equity
[315]
The period before May 2019
[315]
The period from May 2019 to August 2020
[327]
The period after August 2020
[364]
Counterfactual evidence
[378]
Facts relating to WealthStone
[386]
The period before December 2018
[386]
The period from December 2018 onwards
[401]
The WealthStone Buy-Back Agreement
[429]
The period after February 2020
[437]
EXPERT AND TRANSACTION DATA EVIDENCE
[440]
Mr Scott’s evidence
[441]
Multiples for P2P transactions in the AMPFP network
[450]
Average multiple for on-sell and lease transactions
[455]
Average multiple for P2P transactions and on-sell transactions
[460]
Mr Siolis’s evidence
[464]
Mr Neill’s evidence
[475]
Ms Wright’s evidence
[495]
Professor Brimble’s evidence
[496]
Professor Frino’s evidence
[519]
Part 1 of the report
[528]
Part 2 of the report
[537]
Mr Tappe’s evidence
[546]
WHETHER THE 8 AUGUST 2019 CHANGES WERE EFFECTIVE (WITH IMMEDIATE EFFECT)
[547]
Onus of proof
[549]
Construction issues
[553]
The economic change issue
[563]
AMPFP’s first alternative “economic change” contention
[567]
AMPFP’s second alternative “economic change” contention
[585]
The legislation change issue
[598]
The consultation issue
[603]
The effect of any failure to consult
[607]
Whether AMPFP breached the obligation to consult
[616]
The good faith issue
[643]
Conclusion
[644]
WHETHER THE 8 AUGUST 2019 CHANGES WERE EFFECTIVE 13 MONTHS LATER
[645]
UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT
[648]
MISLEADING OR DECEPTIVE CONDUCT
[649]
EQUITY’S CLAIM
[654]
Whether Equity failed to mitigate its loss
[664]
The amount of Equity’s loss or damage
[671]
WEALTHSTONE’S CLAIM
[676]
Whether the condition precedent to the operation of the release has been satisfied
[683]
Whether the release is void under s 23 of the Australian Consumer Law
[689]
Whether AMPFP’s conduct in procuring the release was unconscionable
[701]
Conclusion
[719]
OTHER MATTERS
[720]
CONCLUSION
[721]
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi