Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Permanent Custodians Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

EPWORTH GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR v PERMANENT CUSTODIANS LTD

[2011] SASCFC 32

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice Sulan and The Honourable Justice Vanstone)

29 April 2011

LANDLORD AND TENANT - RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL TENANCIES LEGISLATION - OBLIGATIONS, PROHIBITED TERMS AND PROTECTION FOR LESSEES - MINIMUM TERM OF LEASE AND RENEWAL OF TERM

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF LEGISLATION - GENERALLY

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INCONSISTENCY WITH OTHER LEGISLATION

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - LEASES - UNREGISTERED LEASE FOR TERM EXCEEDING STATUTORY LIMIT OF EXCEPTION TO INDEFEASIBILITY

Appeal from a decision to allow a registered mortgagee to take possession of premises the subject of an unregistered lease - whether an unregistered retail shop lease for a term of five years prevails over the interest of a registered mortgagee, for the purposes of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) - whether the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) creates an exception to the principle of indefeasibility under the Real Property Act.

Held: Appeal dismissed - the relevant provisions of the Retail and Commercial Leases Act do not confer on a lessee rights that would take priority over registered interests under the Real Property Act.

Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) s 3, s 16, s 20A, s 20B and s 20K; Real Property Act 1886 (SA) s 6, s 69(h), s 118 and s 119, referred to.
Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Permanent Custodians Limited (2010) 108 SASR 556; Breskvar v Wall (1971) 126 CLR 376; Gibbs v Messer [1891] AC 248; Bahr v Nicolay (No 2) (1988) 164 CLR 604; South-Eastern Drainage Board (SA) v Savings Bank of South Australia (1939) 62 CLR 603, considered.

EPWORTH GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR v PERMANENT CUSTODIANS LTD
[2011] SASCFC 32

Full Court        Gray, Sulan and Vanstone JJ

GRAY J:

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal from a decision to allow a registered mortgagee to take possession of premises the subject of an unregistered lease.

  2. The primary issue arising on the appeal is whether an unregistered retail shop lease for a term of five years prevails over the interest of a registered mortgagee.  To put the issue another way; do the provisions of the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) create an exception to the principle of indefeasibility of title under the Real Property Act 1886 (SA).

    Background

  3. Y H Epworth Pty Ltd is the registered proprietor of land in the city of Adelaide.  On this land is a building containing leased offices. 

  4. On 15 August 2008, Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd, the plaintiff and first appellant, entered into a memorandum of lease with Y H Epworth to lease office premises on the ground floor of 33 Pirie Street, Adelaide, known as Suite 8.  The lease was for a period of two years and one…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Permanent Custodians Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASCFC 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia regarding the priority of an unregistered retail shop lease over a registered mortgage. The appellants, Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd and Commercial & General Law (SA) Pty Ltd, held an unregistered lease and sublease respectively over office premises. The respondent, Permanent Custodians Ltd, was the registered mortgagee of the land on which the premises were located. The dispute arose when the mortgagor defaulted, and Permanent Custodians sought possession of the premises, asserting its registered mortgage took priority over the unregistered lease.

The central legal issue before the court was whether an unregistered retail shop lease, for a term exceeding one year, could prevail over the interest of a registered mortgagee under the Torrens system in South Australia. This required the court to determine whether the provisions of the *Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995* (SA) created an exception to the principle of indefeasibility of title enshrined in the *Real Property Act 1886* (SA), specifically in relation to unregistered leases. The court also had to consider the effect of sections 69(h), 118, and 119 of the *Real Property Act* on the rights of the parties.

The Full Court, affirming the decision of the primary judge, held that the unregistered lease did not prevail over the registered mortgagee's interest. The court reasoned that section 69(h) of the *Real Property Act* only provided an exception to indefeasibility for unregistered leases for a term not exceeding one year, which was not the case here. Furthermore, section 118 of the *Real Property Act* stipulated that no lease of mortgaged land is binding against a non-consenting mortgagee unless the mortgagee has consented in writing prior to registration, and no such consent had been given. Section 119 was also found inapplicable as the lease term exceeded one year and was not protected by a caveat. While the *Retail and Commercial Leases Act* applied to the lease and potentially extended its term, this statutory extension did not override the priority established by the registered mortgage under the *Real Property Act*.

Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the court affirmed that Permanent Custodians Ltd, as the registered mortgagee, was entitled to possession of the premises, subject to the rights of any tenant who might have had a registered interest or a protected unregistered interest under the *Real Property Act*. The unregistered lease, for a term exceeding one year and lacking a caveat, did not create an interest that prevailed against the registered mortgagee.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The primary issue arising on the appeal is whether an unregistered retail shop lease for a term of five years prevails over the interest of a registered mortgagee. To put the issue another way; do the provisions of the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) create an exception to the principle of indefeasibility of title under the Real Property Act 1886 (SA).Background Y H Epworth Pty Ltd is the registered proprietor of land in the city of Adelaide. On this land is a building containing leased offices. On 15 August 2008, Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd, the plaintiff and first appellant, entered into a memorandum of lease with Y H Epworth to lease office premises on the ground floor of 33 Pirie Street, Adelaide, known as Suite 8. The lease was for a period of two years and one day, commencing on 18 August 2008 and expiring on 19 August 2010. The lease included five rights of renewal, each for a one year period. The lease was unregistered. No caveat was lodged to protect the interest granted by the lease. On 18 August 2008, Y H Epworth consented to Epworth Group subleasing Suite 8 to Commercial & General Law (SA) Pty Ltd, the second defendant by counterclaim and the second appellant. On 3 March 2009, Y H Epworth granted a registered mortgage over the land at 33 Pirie Street to Permanent Custodians Ltd, the defendant and respondent. Y H Epworth defaulted under the mortgage. This default is not in dispute. On 1 October 2009, Permanent Custodians used its powers under a charge granted in its favour by Y H Epworth, to appoint receivers and managers of Y H Epworth’s undertaking, property and assets. Permanent Custodians used its powers conferred by the mortgage to appoint the same receivers and managers as receivers and managers of the mortgaged property. On 18 March 2010, Epworth Group gave Y H Epworth notice in writing of its intention to extend the lease for a further period of one year upon the expiry of the original term of two years and one day. The case at trial was conducted on the basis that a lease for a period of one year came into force on 20 August 2010. On 24 June 2010, following the exercise of the first right of renewal, but prior to the commencement of the extended term, Permanent Custodians served notice on Epworth Group to vacate and deliver up possession of Suite 8. On 16 September 2010, Permanent Custodians entered into possession of 33 Pirie Street, Adelaide, on the basis of the default by Y H Epworth under the mortgage. However, the sub-lessee, Commercial & General Law, remained in occupation of Suite 8. Permanent Custodians did not attempt at this time to enter into possession of Suite 8. About eight days later, on about 24 September 2010, Permanent Custodians served a notice to vacate and deliver up possession of Suite 8 on both Epworth Group and on Commercial & General Law. The notice further asserted that Commercial & General Law occupied Suite 8 by, through or under the Epworth Group. The notice contained the grounds upon which Permanent Custodians claimed that it was entitled to possession of Suite 8. It was asserted that the lease between Y H Epworth and Epworth Group over Suite 8 was unregistered and was for a term longer than one year. It was further asserted that Permanent Custodians had not consented to the lease or the occupation of Suite 8 and that it was not bound by the lease by virtue of its subsequent registered mortgage over 33 Pirie Street.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Permanent Custodians did not and has not sought payment of rent from Epworth Group or Commercial & General Law. The Decision of the Trial Judge Doyle CJ began by observing that Permanent Custodians’ title, as registered mortgagee, was “absolute and indefeasible” pursuant to section 69 of the Real Property Act. Doyle CJ then considered the exception to indefeasibility provided in section 69(h) of the Real Property Act. That section relevantly provides:[1]The title of every registered proprietor of land shall, subject to such encumbrances, liens, estates, or interests as may be notified on the original certificate of such land, be absolute and indefeasible, subject only to the following qualifications:…(h)A lease or letting for not more than a yearwhere at the time when the proprietor becomes registered a tenant shall be in actual possession of the land under an unregistered lease or an agreement for a lease or for letting for a term not exceeding one year: In which case the title of the tenant under such lease or agreement shall prevail;Doyle CJ concluded that section 69(h) did not apply because the unregistered lease was for a term which exceeded one year. [1] Real Property Act 1886 (SA), section 69(h). Doyle CJ then addressed sections 118 and 119 of the Real Property Act. Those sections provide:118—Leases not to bind non-consenting mortgagees or encumbranceesNo lease of mortgaged or encumbered land shall be valid and binding against any mortgagee or encumbrancee of the land unless such mortgagee or encumbrancee shall have consented in writing to such lease prior to the same being registered.119—Lease for one year need not be registeredEvery registered dealing with land shall be subject to any prior unregistered lease or any agreement for lease or for letting for a term not exceeding one year to a tenant in actual possession thereunder: Provided that no right or covenant to purchase the freehold contained in any such unregistered lease or agreement, nor any right or covenant for renewal of such lease or agreement shall be valid as against any subsequent purchaser of the reversion, lessee, mortgagee, or encumbrancee, unless such lease or agreement be registered or protected by caveat. Doyle CJ emphasised the unregistered nature of the lease in his reasons for rejecting the application of section 118 of the Act. In any event, Permanent Custodians had not provided prior, relevant written consent. Section 119 was not applicable because the term of the lease exceeded one year and the right of renewal provided in the lease had not been protected by caveat. Doyle CJ concluded that the interest of Permanent Custodians had priority over the interest of Epworth Group under the lease and over the interest of Commercial & General Law under the sublease, and that, subject to the Retail and Commercial Leases Act, Permanent Custodians was entitled to possession of Suite 8. Doyle CJ next considered whether the provisions of the Retail and Commercial Leases Act allowed Epworth Group and Commercial & General Law to remain in possession despite Permanent Custodians’ priority under the provisions of the Real Property Act. Doyle CJ considered that the Retail and Commercial Leases Act applied to the lease between Y H Epworth and Epworth Group because that lease fell within the meaning of a “retail shop lease”.[2] His Honour considered section 20B of the Retail and Commercial Leases Act, which provides for a minimum term for retail shop leases and further provides for the extension of the term of an existing lease in the event that it is less than the minimum term. His Honour concluded that in the present proceeding section 20B operated “to extend the term of the lease to four years with a statutory option for a further one year, with a contractual entitlement to two further one year renewals”.[3] [2] Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA), section 3(1).[3] Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Permanent Custodians Limited (2010) 108 SASR 556, [55].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established