Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Permanent Custodians Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

EPWORTH GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD v PERMANENT CUSTODIANS LIMITED

[2010] SASC 327

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle

30 November 2010

LANDLORD AND TENANT - RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL TENANCIES LEGISLATION - OBLIGATIONS, PROHIBITED TERMS AND PROTECTION FOR LESSEES - MINIMUM TERM OF LEASE AND RENEWAL OF TERM

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF LEGISLATION - GENERALLY

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INCONSISTENCY WITH OTHER LEGISLATION

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - LEASES - UNREGISTERED LEASE FOR TERM EXCEEDING STATUTORY LIMIT OF EXCEPTION TO INDEFEASIBILITY

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - MORTGAGES, CHARGES AND ENCUMBRANCES - POWERS AND REMEDIES OF MORTGAGEE - POSSESSION - RECOVERY UNDER CLAUSE ENTITLING MORTGAGEE TO POSSESSION UPON DEFAULT OF MORTGAGOR

Plaintiff lessee of office premises - written but unregistered lease - defendant mortgagee in possession of the property containing the leased premises - mortgage registered - whether mortgagee bound by the unregisterd lease - whether unregistered lease prevails over the registered mortgage by operation of s 69(h) of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) (RPA) - whether Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) creates an exception to the principle of indefeasibility under the RPA - whether retail shop lease for a term of five years prevails over the defendant mortgagee's registered interest - action dismissed.

Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) s 3(1), s 4(2), s 16, s 20A, s 20B, s 20B(2); Real Property Act 1886 (SA) s 6, s 69, s 69(a), s 69(h), s 118, s 119; Retirement Villages Act 1987 (SA) s 19, referred to.
R M Hosking Properties Pty Ltd v Barnes [1971] SASR 100, applied.
The South-Eastern Drainage Board (South Australia) v The Savings Bank of South Australia (1939) 62 CLR 603, discussed.
Mercantile Credits Limited v The Shell Company of Australia Limited (1976-1977) 136 CLR 326, considered.

EPWORTH GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD v PERMANENT CUSTODIANS LIMITED
[2010] SASC 327

Civil

  1. DOYLE CJ:          This case raises a point of some significance under the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) (the RCL Act).

  2. The plaintiff (Epworth Group) is the lessee of office premises in a city building.  It holds those premises under a written but unregistered lease from Y H Epworth Pty Ltd (the registered proprietor).

  3. Permanent Custodians Limited (Permanent) is a mortgagee in possession of the property on which stands the building containing the leased premises.  The mortgage is registered on the registered proprietor’s title pursuant to the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) (the RPA). Permanent asserts that it is not bound by the lease because it is unregistered.

  4. Epworth Group contends that its unregistered lease prevails over the registered mortgage by operation of s 69(h) of the RPA. If that argument fails, it relies on submissions based on the RCL Act.

  5. Epworth Group claims that the lease is a retail shop lease for the purposes of the RCL Act. Under the RCL Act, the term of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Permanent Custodians Limite... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 327
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Epworth Group Holdings Pty Ltd v Permanent Custodians Limited involved a dispute between the lessee of office premises and the mortgagee in possession of the property. The plaintiff, Epworth Group, leased the premises under a written but unregistered lease, while the defendant, Permanent Custodians Limited, held a registered mortgage over the property. The central issue before the court was whether the unregistered lease could prevail over the defendant's registered interest, particularly in light of the statutory provisions governing Torrens title and the principle of indefeasibility.

The primary legal question was whether the unregistered lease, which exceeded the statutory limit for exceptions to indefeasibility, could bind the defendant mortgagee. This involved interpreting the relevant statutory provisions, specifically sections 69(h) of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) and the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA). The court had to determine if these statutes created an exception to the principle of indefeasibility that would allow an unregistered retail shop lease for a term of five years to override the defendant's registered mortgage interest.

In delivering the judgment, the court thoroughly examined the statutory framework and the nature of the lease. It considered whether the unregistered lease could bind the mortgagee in possession under the principles of equity and the exceptions to indefeasibility. The court concluded that the statutory provisions did not create an exception that would allow an unregistered lease to override a registered mortgage. The court also held that the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) did not establish a new exception to the principle of indefeasibility. Consequently, the unregistered lease did not prevail over the defendant's interest. The court dismissed the action, ruling that the defendant mortgagee was not bound by the unregistered lease.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The main issue is whether the retail shop lease for a term of five years prevails, although unregistered, over the interest of Permanent. Facts The trial of the action proceeded before me on the basis of documents tendered by consent, and certain affidavits tendered by consent. No oral evidence was given. By the time the parties moved to their addresses there was really no factual dispute of any great significance. I make the following findings of fact on the basis of the exhibits before me. The registered proprietor owns land at 33 Pirie Street, Adelaide. A building known as Epworth Building is situated on the land. The building is a commercial office building. As I understand it, it contains a number of separate offices which are occupied by a number of different tenants. On 15 August 2008 the registered proprietor entered into a Memorandum of Lease with Epworth Group. The term of the lease was for two years and one day commencing on 18 August 2008 and expiring on 19 August 2010, with five rights of renewal, each of one year. The premises the subject of the lease are an office known as Suite 8 on the ground floor of Epworth Building. The lease is in registrable form but was never registered. Epworth Group did not lodge a caveat in respect of its interest under the lease. On 18 August 2008 the registered proprietor consented to Epworth Group subleasing the premises to Commercial & General Law (SA) Pty Ltd (C & G Law). The sublease was not tendered before me. I have no evidence of its terms. I find that C & G Law conducts a legal practice from the premises. The lease of the premises is for their use as legal offices. It is common ground that the lease is a retail shop lease as defined in s 3(1) of the RCL Act, even though the premises are sublet to C & G Law. I gather, therefore, that I am possibly concerned with two retail shop leases, that from the registered proprietor to Epworth Group and that from Epworth Group to C & G Law. On 3 March 2009 the registered proprietor granted a mortgage over the land to Permanent. The mortgage is registered under the RPA. On 1 October 2009 Permanent appointed Receivers and Managers of the registered proprietor’s undertaking, property and assets. The appointment was made in exercise of powers granted to Permanent by a charge granted by the registered proprietor. In exercise of the powers conferred by the mortgage, Permanent also appointed the same persons as receivers and managers of the mortgaged property. On 18 March 2010 Epworth Group gave to the registered proprietor notice in writing under the lease of its request to rent the premises for a further period of one year, after the expiry of the initial term of two years and one day. By Clause 4.9 of the lease Epworth Group had a right upon request by written notice to lease the property for a further period of one year, and the notice given complied with the requirements of Clause 4.9. The case was conducted on the basis that as from 20 August 2010 a lease for a period of one year came into force.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established