Environment Protection Authority v Sydney Water Corporation Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
Environment Protection Authority -V- Sydney Water Corporation Ltd [1999] NSWLEC 60
          PARTIES
Prosecutor:
Environment Protection Authority
Defendant:
Sydney Water Corporation Ltd
          NUMBER:
50019 of 1996
          CORAM:
Talbot J
          KEY ISSUES:
:- costs and penalty
          LEGISLATION CITED:
costs and penalty
          DATES OF HEARING:
03/15/1999
          DATE OF JUDGMENT DELIVERY:

03/19/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


Prosecutor:
Mr J Glissan QC
with:
Mr B Docking (Barrister)

Solicitors:
Environment Protection Authority

Defendant:
Mr L P Robberds QC
with:
Mr D Brogan (Barrister)

Solicitors:
Sydney Water Corporation



    JUDGMENT:

      IN THE LAND AND MATTER No. 50019 of 1996
      ENVIRONMENT COURT CORAM: Talbot J
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES DECISION DATE: 19 March 1999
      ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY
      Prosecutor

      v

      SYDNEY WATER CORP LTD
      Defendant
      REASONS FOR JUDGMENT ON PENALTY & COSTS


      1. Both parties have made submissions following a finding by the Court on 11 December 1998 that it was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the defendant committed an offence against the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989 (the EOP Act) when it contravened condition L4 of licence No. 000378 contrary to s 17D(9) of the Pollution Control Act 1970.

      2. The defendant failed to comply with its obligation to maintain penstock controls in an efficient manner. It did not detect that a tie line to emergency power had been connected to the main switchboard in the reverse order. The controls were inefficient and did not function as expected when the mains power was disrupted.

      3. Because the phase rotation within the emergency power circuit was not synchronised or matched, when the penstock controls were operated under emergency power they were driven down into the seat rather than opening to allow the flow of effluent as expected.

      4. The successful complaint had been particularised by the prosecutor as a failure to carry out necessary mechanical and electrical maintenance to ensure that the penstocks would operate in an efficient manner when required.

      5. Other particularised claims relative to the maintenance of the penstocks themselves, the 7-section siphons and stopboards and raw sewage pump (RSP) No. 1 as evidence of the failure to maintain the industrial plant in an efficient condition, were unsuccessful.

      6. The Court recognised that some proper maintenance was carried out from time to time according to a Works Information Management System (WIMS), but the program did not identify the problem associated with a switch to emergency power because no appropriate test had been undertaken to facilitate an understanding of whether the penstocks would operate under emergency power. When the controls were activated under emergency power, they operated in reverse and accordingly did not function efficiently.

      7. The defendant has made a number of submissions which depend upon a formal finding as to whether there was any environmental harm caused by the breach of the licence condition.

      8. This submission is relevant to a consideration of the application of s 556A of the Crimes Act 1900, s 9(a) of the EOP Act and penalty generally.

      Section 556A Crimes Act

      9. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Environment Protection Authority v Sydney Water Corporation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, the Environment Protection Authority (EPA) brought a case against Sydney Water Corporation Ltd (the defendant) for breaching its licence conditions under the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989. The defendant was found guilty of contravening condition L4 of its licence by failing to maintain penstock controls in an efficient manner, leading to a significant environmental incident. The Court was required to determine the appropriate penalty and costs in light of the defendant's breach. The legal issues involved assessing the seriousness of the environmental harm, the foreseeability of the incident, and the adequacy of the defendant's maintenance procedures. The Court found that the defendant's failure to maintain the penstocks in an efficient condition led to a prolonged discharge of untreated effluent, causing significant environmental harm. The Court rejected the defendant's argument that the environmental harm was not directly caused by the failure to maintain the penstocks. The Court held that the defendant could reasonably have foreseen the potential for significant environmental harm if the plant was not maintained in an efficient condition. The Court imposed a fine of $100,000, considering the seriousness of the environmental consequences and the defendant's responsibility as a public authority. The Court also ordered the defendant to pay the prosecutor's costs, finding no exceptional circumstances that would warrant a departure from the usual order as to costs. The Court emphasized that the imposition of costs was not a punishment but a compensation for the expenses incurred in conducting the proceedings.