Environment Protection Authority v CSR Ltd (trading as CSR Woodpanels)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
Environment Protection Authority v CSR Ltd (trading as CSR Woodpanels) [1999] NSWLEC 173
          PARTIES
PROSECUTOR
Environment Protection Authority
DEFENDANT
CSR Ltd (trading as CSR Woodpanels)
          NUMBER:
50080 of 1997
          CORAM:
Pearlman J
          KEY ISSUES:
Environmental Offences :- stated case - discretion
          LEGISLATION CITED:
Criminal Appeal Act 1912 s 5AE
Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989 s 6(1)
          DATES OF HEARING:
06/04/1999
          EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE:

06/04/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


PROSECUTOR
Mrs J C Kelly (Barrister)

SOLICITORS
Environment Protection Authority

DEFENDANT
Mr P D McClellan QC

SOLICITORS
Mallesons Stephen Jaques


    JUDGMENT:

IN THE LAND AND 50080 of 1997


ENVIRONMENT COURT Pearlman J


OF NEW SOUTH WALES 4 June 1999

ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY
                              Prosecutor
v
CSR LTD (trading as CSR WOODPANELS)
                              Defendant
JUDGMENT

1. Before me this morning is a notice of motion put on by the defendant seeking a case to be stated to the Court of Criminal Appeal under s 5AE of the Criminal Appeal Act 1912.

2. A draft stated case has been furnished which raises three questions for the Court of Criminal Appeal, namely:


          Did I err in:
          (a) permitting the prosecutor to amend the summons so as to add the words “or was likely to harm” after the word “harmed” in paragraph 1 of the summons;
          (b) holding that the prosecutor has furnished the further particulars which I ordered to be provided on 18 December 1997; and
          (c) dismissing the defendant’s/appellant’s motion of 1 April 1999?

3. I say at once that the third question is consequential upon the other two.

4. The application arises, as I have said, under s 5AE of the Criminal Appeal Act subsection (1) which relevantly provides as follows:


          At any time before the completion of proceedings before … the Land and Environment Court in its summary jurisdiction, …, the judge hearing the proceedings may, or if requested by the Crown must, submit any question of law arising at or in reference to the proceedings to the Court of Criminal Appeal for determination.

5. It is clear, of course, that the power which I now exercise, since the application is made by the defendant, is entirely discretionary.

6. The defendant claims that two fundamental questions arise for determination in the stated case and each involves a question of the proper construction of s 6(1) of the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989 (“the EOP Act”). Each of them raises, in the defendant's submission, a question of law.

7. Mr McClellan QC, appearing for the defendant, says that the questions are fundamental. The first question, he submits, raises a question of duplicity. If I erred in permitting the prosecutor to amend the summons and the case proceeds to trial without that error being corrected, then the defendant is faced with a question of duplicity at the trial. That is fundamental, in Mr McClellan’s submission. Secondly, he submits that the second question raises also a fundamental question, namely, whether a continuing offence may be the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Environment Protection Authority v CSR Ltd (trading as CSR W... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 173
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Environment Protection Authority v CSR Ltd (trading as CSR Woodpanels) before Pearlman J in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales involved a dispute concerning environmental offences under the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989. The Environment Protection Authority brought the case against CSR Ltd, alleging environmental harm caused by the company's operations. The defendant sought a case to be stated to the Court of Criminal Appeal under s 5AE of the Criminal Appeal Act 1912, raising questions regarding the amendment of the summons, the sufficiency of particulars provided by the prosecutor, and the dismissal of a prior motion. The court was required to decide whether to exercise its discretion to submit these questions to the Court of Criminal Appeal.

Pearlman J considered the application under s 5AE of the Criminal Appeal Act, which allows a judge to submit questions of law to the Court of Criminal Appeal during proceedings. The court examined whether the questions raised by the defendant were fundamental and required determination before the trial. The defendant argued that the questions involved the proper construction of s 6(1) of the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act, including whether the prosecutor could amend the summons and whether the particulars provided were adequate. The prosecutor countered that the questions were procedural rather than substantive, and that the case had already suffered significant delays, making further referral to the Court of Criminal Appeal undesirable from a case management perspective. The court acknowledged the importance of case management but found that the questions at hand were fundamental to the fairness and justice of the proceedings, particularly given the serious nature of the charges and potential penalties involved.

After weighing the arguments, Pearlman J decided to exercise the court's discretion in favour of the defendant and state a case to the Court of Criminal Appeal. The judge found the questions raised by the defendant to be threshold issues that needed resolution before the trial. The court directed the parties to collaborate on preparing a draft of the stated case and scheduled a meeting to finalize it.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established