Environment Protection Authority v CSR Ltd (trading as CSR Woodpanels)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
Environment Protection Authority v CSR Ltd (trading as CSR Woodpanels) [1999] NSWLEC 99
          PARTIES
PROSECUTOR
Environment Protection Authority
DEFENDANT
CSR Ltd (trading as CSR Woodpanels)
          NUMBER:
50080 of 1997
          CORAM:
Pearlman J
          KEY ISSUES:
:- application to strike out - adequate particulars - amendment - summons - duplicity
          LEGISLATION CITED:
application to strike out - adequate particulars - amendment - summons - duplicity
          DATES OF HEARING:
04/20/1999; 04/22/1999; 05/03/1999
          DATE OF JUDGMENT DELIVERY:

05/05/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


PROSECUTOR
Mr S J Rushton (Barrister)

SOLICITORS
Environment Protection Authority

DEFENDANT
Mr P D McClellan QC with Mr B J Preston (Barrister)

SOLICITORS
Mallesons Stephen Jacques


    JUDGMENT:


      IN THE LAND AND 50080 of 1997
      ENVIRONMENT COURT Pearlman J
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES 5 May 1999

      ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY
                              Prosecutor
      v
      CSR LTD (trading as CSR WOODPANELS)
                              Defendant
      JUDGMENT

      Introduction

      1. Two issues have currently arisen for determination in the course of these proceedings.

      2. First, the defendant has sought, by notice of motion, an order that the proceedings be struck out on the ground that the prosecutor has failed to provide the particulars which, on 18 December 1997, the Court ordered to be given.

      3. Secondly, the prosecutor has sought, by notice of motion, an order that the summons in these proceedings be amended by adding after the word “harmed” in par 1 the words “or was likely to harm” .

      4. It is appropriate that I deal with the defendant’s notice of motion first, because, of course, if the defendant is successful, the prosecutor’s notice of motion will not arise.

      The defendant’s motion to strike out

      Background

      5. A brief recapitulation of the proceedings thus far is necessary for an understanding of the basis for the defendant’s claim that the proceedings should be struck out.

      6. The defendant has been charged under s 6(1) of the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1979 (“the EOP Act”) alleging that it did, without lawful authority, negligently cause a substance to leak in a manner which harmed the environment. The summons particularised the substance as being liquid from an effluent pond called “the Blue Lagoon” , the negligence as being that the defendant knew or ought to have known that the Blue Lagoon would leak the substance, and that the environmental harm was constituted by a number of specified matters, including pollution of waters, destruction of biota, and change in the composition of waters.

      7. The defendant sought further and better particulars of the charge, and letters about this passed between the prosecutor and the defendant’s solicitors. Ultimately, the defendant claimed that the prosecutor had failed to furnish adequate particulars, and it put on a notice of motion seeking an order that the prosecutor provide the particulars sought. On 18 December 1997, I ordered that particulars relating to certain matters be furnished by the prosecutor to the defendant ( I shall return to the detail of that order in due course).

      8. In response to the prosecutor’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Environment Protection Authority v CSR Ltd (trading as CSR W... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 99
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Environment Protection Authority v CSR Ltd (trading as CSR Woodpanels) was heard in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. The matter involved two primary issues. Firstly, CSR Ltd sought an order to strike out the proceedings, claiming that the Environment Protection Authority (EPA) had failed to provide adequate particulars as ordered by the court on 18 December 1997. Secondly, the EPA sought to amend the summons by adding the phrase "or was likely to harm" after the word "harmed." The court needed to determine whether the EPA had provided sufficient particulars to meet the requirements of the law and whether the proposed amendment to the summons was permissible.

The court began by addressing the motion to strike out the proceedings. It was necessary to review whether the EPA had provided the particulars ordered on 18 December 1997. The court found that the EPA had indeed provided adequate particulars concerning the date and nature of the alleged offence. The EPA had detailed that the alleged negligent act of causing a substance to leak occurred continuously from 1992 until the decommissioning of the Blue Lagoon in 1997 or 1998. Furthermore, the EPA sufficiently explained that CSR Ltd knew or ought to have known that the Blue Lagoon was insufficiently impervious to receive effluent, as evidenced by internal documents noting the lagoon's leakage. Consequently, the court dismissed CSR Ltd's motion to strike out the proceedings.

Next, the court considered the EPA's motion to amend the summons. The EPA sought to add the phrase "or was likely to harm" to reflect the statutory language of the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1979. CSR Ltd argued that this amendment would create duplicity, allege an offence outside the statutory limitation period, and unfairly expand the charged offence. The court, however, held that the amendment did not create a new offence but rather clarified the existing charge. By penalising the act of negligently causing a substance to leak if it harmed or was likely to harm the environment, the court found that the amendment did not introduce uncertainty or duplicity. The court also rejected the argument that the amendment would allege an offence outside the statutory limitation period, as no new offence was being charged. Finally, the court dismissed CSR Ltd's claim that the amendment would unfairly expand the offence charged, noting that the proceedings were still in their early stages and no evidence had yet been filed. The court granted the EPA leave to amend the summons accordingly.

The court's formal orders were that CSR Ltd's motion to strike out the proceedings was dismissed, and leave was granted to the EPA to amend the summons by adding "or was likely to harm" after the word "harmed." The question of costs was reserved for further consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established