ENGWIRDA and THE OWNERS OF QUEENS RIVERSIDE STRATA PLAN 55728

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: STRATA TITLES ACT 1985 (WA)

CITATION:   ENGWIRDA and THE OWNERS OF QUEENS RIVERSIDE STRATA PLAN 55728 [2021] WASAT 17

MEMBER:   MR D AITKEN, SENIOR MEMBER

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   9 FEBRUARY 2021

FILE NO/S:   CC 732 of 2017

BETWEEN:   JENNIFER ENGWIRDA

Applicant

AND

THE OWNERS OF QUEENS RIVERSIDE STRATA PLAN 55728

Respondent


Catchwords:

Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) (pre 1 May 2020) - Section 90 orders for inspection of records and documents of strata company excluding documents subject to legal professional privilege - Contention that strata company improperly claimed legal professional privilege - Tribunal to determine whether documents are actually privileged - Preliminary issue - Should the Tribunal determine whether the strata company has improperly claimed legal professional privilege for documents which have now been provided to the applicant with the claim for legal professional privilege waived

Legislation:

State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 60, s 86, s 95, s 95(1), s 98, s 100, s 105
Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) (prior to 1 May 2020), s 43, s 90, Sch 5, cl 30(1)

Result:

Preliminary issued determined

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : In Person
Respondent : Mr W Robinson

Solicitors:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : Wotton + Kearney Lawyers (Perth)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Engwirda and The Owners of Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728 [2018] WASAT 15

Engwirda v The Owners of Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728 [2019] WASCA 190

Schreuder v Murray [No 2] [2009] WASCA 145

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. This proceeding was commenced by an application lodged with the Tribunal by the applicant, Ms Jennifer Engwirda (Ms Engwirda) against the respondent, The Owners of Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728 (Strata Company) under s 90 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) (ST Act) on 1 May 2017, seeking an order that she be allowed to inspect the records of the Strata Company.

  2. In the application Ms Engwirda also sought a number of other orders, which did not fall within s 90 of the ST Act and she withdrew the application in respect of those orders at an early stage of the proceeding.

  3. Major amendments to the ST Act commenced operation on 1 May 2020. Under cl 30(1) of Sch 5 to the ST Act, a proceeding in the Tribunal under the ST Act commenced before 1 May 2020, such as this proceeding, 'must be dealt with as if the [Strata Titles Amendment Act 2018 (WA)] had not been enacted', that is under the pre-amendment ST Act. All references to the ST Act in these reasons are to the pre­amendment ST Act.

Tribunal's decision

  1. On 6 November 2017 the Tribunal (constituted by then President, Curthoys J) made the following final orders (2017 orders):

    1. The Respondent is provide the Applicant with a USB containing electronic copies of the requested documentation (excluding those documents subject to legal professional privilege).

    2. Before the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ENGWIRDA and THE OWNERS OF QUEENS RIVERSIDE STRATA PLAN 5572... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASAT 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a dispute between Jennifer Engwirda, an owner of a lot in the Queens Riverside Strata Plan, and the Owners of Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728, the strata company for the strata titles scheme. The case revolves around Ms Engwirda's application for an inspection of the strata company's records and documents, specifically eight documents, which the strata company claimed were subject to legal professional privilege. The State Administrative Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the strata company had improperly claimed legal professional privilege for the eight documents.

The Tribunal examined the legal principles regarding legal professional privilege and the evidence provided by both parties. The Tribunal found that the Strata Company had not proved that the disputed documents were privileged. Consequently, Ms Engwirda is entitled to inspect the disputed documents. The Tribunal ordered the Strata Company to provide inspection of the eight documents to Ms Engwirda by giving her an electronic copy of those documents within a period of seven days.

This decision completes the remaining task of the Tribunal in this proceeding, and Ms Engwirda will now have access to the eight disputed documents.

Background

Background to the litigation

This proceeding, which has been before the State Administrative Tribunal since 1 May 2017, concerns the entitlement of the applicant, Ms Jennifer Engwirda, as an owner of a lot in the strata scheme known as Queens Riverside, to inspect the records of the strata company of the strata titles scheme, The Owners of Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728 (the Strata Company). Ms Engwirda applied to the Tribunal under s 90 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) seeking an order that she be allowed to inspect the records of the Strata Company. The only remaining task for the Tribunal in this proceeding is to determine whether the Strata Company has improperly claimed legal professional privilege for eight documents. Ms Engwirda contends that the Strata Company has improperly claimed legal professional privilege for those eight documents. The Strata Company contends that the task of the Tribunal in this matter is to determine whether or not the Strata Company has improperly claimed legal professional privilege for those eight documents. For the reasons which follow, I have decided that the Strata Company has not proved its claim for legal professional privilege in respect of those eight documents and Ms Engwirda is entitled to inspect those documents. The eight documents for which the Strata Company claims legal professional privilege, which Ms Engwirda disputes, are emails between Jackson McDonald Lawyers and Colliers (the Strata Company's strata manager/agent) dated between 30 March 2017 and 6 April 2017. The Strata Company claims that each of those emails contains legal advice provided by Jackson McDonald to Colliers in relation to the matters the subject of the disputes with Ms Engwirda and in anticipation of legal proceedings. The evidence shows that the Strata Company did not become a client of Jackson McDonald until 19 April 2017, when a retainer agreement with Jackson McDonald was signed by the council of the Strata Company. The evidence further shows that the legal advice sought and obtained by Colliers from Jackson McDonald between 30 March 2017 and 6 April 2017 was advice for Colliers in its own right and not for the Strata Company. I, therefore, find that the Strata Company has not proved, on the balance of probabilities, that any of the disputed documents fall within either legal advice privilege or litigation privilege which can be invoked by the Strata Company against Ms Engwirda. Accordingly, Ms Engwirda is entitled to inspect the disputed documents. I will make an order that the Strata Company provide inspection of those documents to Ms Engwirda by giving her an electronic copy of those documents within the period of seven days.

This proceeding commenced in the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia on 1 May 2017 when Jennifer Engwirda, a proprietor of a strata lot, filed an application under section 90 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) seeking an order that she be allowed to inspect records and documents of the respondent, The Owners of Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728. This application followed a series of disputes between Ms Engwirda and the Strata Company regarding the inspection of records and documents. The initial application by Ms Engwirda was amended, and the Tribunal ultimately ordered on 6 November 2017 that the Strata Company provide Ms Engwirda with electronic copies of the requested documentation, excluding those documents subject to legal professional privilege. This decision was appealed by Ms Engwirda to the Court of Appeal of Western Australia, which allowed the appeal and set aside certain orders, but left other orders in place, including the order that the Strata Company provide Ms Engwirda with documentation excluding privileged documents. Ms Engwirda subsequently sought further orders from the Tribunal, which led to the current proceeding focused on whether certain documents claimed by the Strata Company to be privileged are actually privileged. This matter has now come before the Tribunal to determine this specific issue on the documents, following written submissions and affidavits from both parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the task of the Tribunal to determine whether the Strata Company has improperly claimed legal professional privilege for all or any of documents 1-7, or only documents 8-15?
2. What is the appropriate procedure for determining whether the Strata Company's claim of legal professional privilege over documents 8-15 is justified?
3. Does the Strata Company have a valid claim of legal professional privilege for documents 8-15, and if so, on what basis?
4. If the Strata Company's claim of privilege is not upheld, what remedies or consequences should apply, if any?

Held
1. The task of the Tribunal in this matter is to determine whether the Strata Company has improperly claimed legal professional privilege for all or any of documents 8-15. Result: The task of the Tribunal is determined to be assessing the propriety of the Strata Company's claim of privilege for documents 8-15.

2. The appropriate procedure for determining whether the Strata Company's claim of legal professional privilege over documents 8-15 is justified is to review the written submissions and affidavits provided by both parties, and to make a determination on the documents pursuant to s 60 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). Result: The procedure is set out in the orders made by the Tribunal, requiring submissions and affidavits from both parties.

3. The Strata Company does not have a valid claim of legal professional privilege for documents 8-15. Result: The claim for privilege is not upheld.

4. If the Strata Company's claim of privilege is not upheld, the Strata Company should provide inspection of documents 8-15 to Ms Engwirda by giving her an electronic copy of those documents within seven days. Result: The Strata Company is ordered to provide inspection of the specified documents to Ms Engwirda.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning in this case revolves around several key issues. Firstly, the court had to determine whether its task was to assess the Strata Company's claim of legal professional privilege for all documents (1-15) or only for those documents (8-15) that had not been provided to the applicant. The court concluded that its task was to determine whether the Strata Company had improperly claimed legal professional privilege for documents 8-15 only, as documents 1-7 had already been provided to the applicant and the claim for legal professional privilege had been waived. The court relied on the Court of Appeal's decision which stated that the Tribunal should only concern itself with the documents for which privilege was still being claimed.

Secondly, the court had to decide the appropriate procedure for determining whether the Strata Company's claim of legal professional privilege over documents 8-15 was justified. The court determined that it should decide the issue entirely on the documents, pursuant to s 60 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), after giving both parties the opportunity to provide written submissions and any affidavits on which they wished to rely in support of their submissions.

Thirdly, the court had to assess whether the Strata Company had a valid claim of legal professional privilege for documents 8-15. The court found that the Strata Company had not proved its claim for legal professional privilege, as the legal advice sought and obtained by Colliers from Jackson McDonald during the period in which the disputed documents were created (from 30 March 2017 until 6 April 2017) was for Colliers in its own right and not for the Strata Company. The court based its decision on the evidence provided by the Strata Company and the applicant, as well as the relevant legal principles regarding legal professional privilege.

Lastly, the court had to determine the appropriate remedies or consequences if the Strata Company's claim of privilege was not upheld. The court ordered that the Strata Company provide inspection of the disputed documents to the applicant by giving her an electronic copy of those documents within seven days.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the task of the Tribunal in this matter is to determine whether the Strata Company has improperly claimed legal professional privilege for documents 8-15, and if the claim is not upheld, the Strata Company must provide inspection of those documents to the applicant. The court distinguished prior authority by focusing its determination on the specific documents for which privilege was still being claimed, rather than assessing the claim for all documents in question.