Energy Solutions (US) LLC v Earth Science Laboratories, Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Energy Solutions (US) LLC to registration of trade mark application number 2291713 (class 1) - KLEENBREAK - in the name of Earth Science Laboratories, Inc.

Delegate:

Anne Makrigiorgos

Representation:

Opponent: Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick

Applicant: Spruson & Ferguson

Decision:

2024 ATMO 112

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition under s 52 – ss 42(b), 44 and 60 pursued – no ground of opposition established – trade mark to proceed to registration

Background

  1. This decision concerns an opposition under s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)[1] by Energy Solutions (US) LLC (‘Opponent’) to registration of the following trade mark:

    Trade mark number    2291713 (‘Application’)

    Trade mark:                KLEENBREAK (‘Trade Mark’)

    Applicant:                   Earth Science Laboratories, Inc (‘Applicant’)

    Filing date                  5 August 2022

    Specification:              Class 1: Chemicals used for water treatment; scale removing preparations, other than for household purposes; chemical products for preventing scale (‘Applicant’s Goods’)

    [1] Unless otherwise stated, each reference to a regulation below is a reference to a regulation in the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) and each reference to a section is a reference to a section of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).

  2. The Trade Mark was examined and advertised as accepted for possible registration on 6 January 2023.

  3. On 23 February 2023, the Opponent filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose the Application. On 23 March 2023, the Opponent filed its Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’). The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend the opposition on 9 June 2023.

  4. The Opponent filed Evidence in Support (‘EIS’) on 13 September 2023. The Applicant did not file any Evidence in Answer.

  5. The parties were given the opportunity to request a hearing. Neither party requested a hearing, rather the Opponent requested a decision on the written record. Under reg 21.15(5)(d), as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I have decided this matter on the information available to the Registrar, in this case being the SGP and the EIS.

    Grounds and onus

  6. The SGP nominates grounds of opposition under ss 42(b), 44 and 60.

  7. The Opponent carries the burden of establishing one or more of the grounds of opposition[2] on the balance of probabilities.[3] The date at which the rights of the parties are assessed is 5 August 2022 (‘Relevant Date’), being the filing date of the Trade Mark and the priority date of the Trade Mark for the purposes of ss 44 and 60.

    Evidence and Summary

  8. As its EIS, the Opponent filed a Declaration of Kari Harper, marketing and communications manager of the Opponent made on 12 September 2023 with Exhibits 1 to 12 (‘Harper’).

  9. Much of Harper refers to the use and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Energy Solutions (US) LLC v Earth Science Laboratories, Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ATMO 112
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Energy Solutions (US) LLC, the opponent, opposed the registration of a trade mark by Earth Science Laboratories, Inc. The opposition was based on several grounds, including sections 42(b), 44, and 60 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). The opponent contended that its own trade mark, an International Registration Designating Australia (IRDA) for demulsifying agents and emulsion breakers used in crude oil production, had prior rights and was well-known. The relevant date for assessing the parties' rights was 5 August 2022, the filing date and priority date of the trade mark application.

The primary legal issues before the delegate were whether the opponent had established any of the grounds of opposition relied upon. Specifically, the delegate had to determine if the opponent's trade mark was identical or deceptively similar to the applied-for mark under section 44, or if the applied-for mark was well known or had acquired distinctiveness in Australia under section 60, in relation to the relevant goods. The opponent also pursued a ground under section 42(b), relating to the registration being contrary to law, though this was not elaborated upon in the provided text. The burden of proof rested with the opponent to establish these grounds on the balance of probabilities.

The delegate found that the opponent had not discharged its burden of proof. The evidence presented by the opponent, including a declaration from its marketing manager, primarily focused on the use and registration of its trade mark in the United States. While the opponent claimed use of its mark in Australia since 2015, the evidence of this use, such as a brochure and revenue figures, was considered insufficient and lacking in detail. The delegate noted the absence of evidence of product labelling or widespread advertising and promotion within Australia. Consequently, the delegate concluded that no ground of opposition had been established.

Accordingly, the delegate ordered that the opposed trade mark, number 2291713, may proceed to registration one month from the date of the decision, unless a notice of appeal was filed. The opponent was also ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Energy Solutions (US) LLC v Earth Science Laboratories, Inc revolves around an application for the registration of a trade mark by Energy Solutions (US) LLC, which Earth Science Laboratories, Inc opposed. The Opponent, Earth Science Laboratories, Inc, filed a declaration from its marketing and communications manager, Kari Harper, on 12 September 2023. This declaration, accompanied by exhibits, detailed the use and registration of the trade mark CLEARBREAK in the United States by the Opponent or its predecessors in title. The declaration also noted that the Opponent is a wholly owned subsidiary of Solvay SA. The Opponent's protected International Registration Designating Australia (IRDA) for the trade mark CLEARBREAK was outlined, indicating that it was designated for goods under Class 1, specifically chemical agents, demulsifying agents, and emulsion breakers used in crude oil production, with a priority date of 6 December 2019.

Harper claimed that the Opponent first used the trade mark CLEARBREAK in Australia in August 2015 and continues to use it primarily in Queensland for the aforementioned goods. Distribution of these goods is managed by the Opponent's Australian distributor, Brenntag Australia Pty Ltd, located in Victoria. Harper asserted that the trade mark was prominently used on product labelling and provided a Solvay brochure from February 2023 titled ‘Demulsifiers’ that listed goods under the trade mark. Although the brochure was not shown to include any product labelling and there was no evidence that it was available in Australia, it did provide Asia Pacific contact details. Harper further stated that the primary method of advertising and promotion of the goods under the trade mark was through direct discussions with customers, with no documentary evidence provided of any advertising or promotion in Australia. Revenue figures from the sale of these goods in Australia from 2015 to 2022 were also provided, although these figures were indicated as being in excess of whole numbers in the hundred thousands and not the actual revenue figures.

The Opponent also provided copies of overseas registration certificates for the trade mark CLEARBREAK. The burden of establishing a ground for opposition lay with the Opponent, which needed to demonstrate on the balance of probabilities that the trade mark should not be registered. The relevant date for assessing the rights of the parties was 5 August 2022, the filing date of the trade mark application. Despite the Opponent's efforts, it failed to establish any grounds for opposition, leading to the conclusion that the trade mark could proceed to registration. Costs were awarded against the Opponent as the Opponent did not succeed in establishing any grounds for opposition.

The matter of Energy Solutions (US) LLC v Earth Science Laboratories, Inc came before the Australian Trade Marks Hearing Office as an opposition to the registration of a trade mark under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The application for registration of the trade mark was filed by Energy Solutions (US) LLC. In opposition to this application, Earth Science Laboratories, Inc filed a declaration on 12 September 2023, asserting prior use and registration of the mark CLEARBREAK in the United States and claiming it had been used in Australia since August 2015. The opposition was based on several grounds, including those under sections 42(b), 44, and 60 of the Act. The matter was listed for a final hearing, with key procedural steps including the filing of evidence and witness statements, and the submission of written and oral arguments by both parties. The decision to refuse the registration was based on the failure of the opponent to establish any grounds of opposition on the balance of probabilities, with the assessment date for the rights of the parties being 5 August 2022. The decision was rendered by Anne Makrigiorgos, Hearing Officer and Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 21 June 2024. The Opponent sought an award of costs but was unsuccessful, with costs ordered against them in accordance with the amounts specified in Schedule 8 of the Regulations.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Opponent carries the burden of establishing one or more of the grounds of opposition[2] on the balance of probabilities.[3] The date at which the rights of the parties are assessed is 5 August 2022 (‘Relevant Date’), being the filing date of the Trade Mark and the priority date of the Trade Mark for the purposes of ss 44 and 60.[2] Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network GP [2010] FCAFC 58, [32] (Keane CJ, Stone and Jagot JJ).[3] Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 156, [133] (Besanko, Jagot and Edelman JJ).Evidence and Summary As its EIS, the Opponent filed a Declaration of Kari Harper, marketing and communications manager of the Opponent made on 12 September 2023 with Exhibits 1 to 12 (‘Harper’). Much of Harper refers to the use and registration of the trade mark CLEARBREAK in the United States of America by the Opponent and its predecessors in title. Harper also claims that the Opponent is a wholly owned subsidiary of Solvay SA. Harper provides details of the Opponent’s protected International Registration Designating Australia (‘IRDA’) (‘Opponent’s Mark’) which appear below: IRDA number: 2060897 Trade mark: Goods: Class 1: Chemical agents; demulsifying agents and emulsion breakers used in crude oil productionPriority date: 6 December 2019 Harper claims that the Opponent (or its predecessor in title) first used the Opponent’s Mark in Australia in August 2015 and continues to use the Opponent’s Mark, primarily in Queensland, in relation to demulsifying agents and emulsion breakers used in crude oil production (‘Used Goods’). Harper claims that the Used Goods are distributed to customers in Australia by the Opponent’s distributor, Brenntag Australia Pty Ltd, located in Victoria. Harper claims the Opponent’s Mark has been used on product labelling and exhibits a Solvay brochure dated February 2023 entitled ‘Demulsifiers’ listing a number of goods under the Opponent’s Mark. I note this brochure does not showing any product labelling. I also note there is no evidence that the brochure was available in Australia. Rather the brochure provides the following contact details under the heading Asia Pacific: Harper claims that advertising and promotion of the Used Goods under the Opponent’s Mark has essentially been through direct discussions with customers. No documentary evidence of any advertising or promotion in Australia is provided. Harper provides a table of revenue claimed to be generated from the sale of the Used Goods in Australia from 2015 to 2022. I note the figures are expressed in terms of whole numbers in the hundred thousands prefaced by the words ‘in excess of’, which I consider indicates they are not the actual revenue figures. I also note that there is no indication of the cost of the Used Goods, nor the number of Used Goods sold and nor the number of customers. Harper also provides copies of overseas registration certificates of the Opponent’s Mark.Discussion and ReasonsSection 44/Reg 4.15A[4][4] Reg 4.15A is identical to s 44 but applies when the basis for the ground of opposition is an IRDA.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 relevantly provides:Decision(1)Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a)to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b)to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note:For limitations see section 6. The Opponent has not established a ground of opposition. Accordingly, trade mark number 2291713 may proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued and that the disposition of the application should otherwise be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction.Costs The Opponent sought an award of costs. Costs usually follow the event. Accordingly, I award costs against the Opponent in accordance with the amounts in Schedule 8 of the Regulations.Anne MakrigiorgosHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks21 June 2024

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Energy Solutions (US) LLC v Earth Science Laboratories, Inc considered the grounds for opposing the registration of a trade mark under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Opponent sought to oppose the registration of the trade mark on several grounds, including under sections 42(b), 44, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act. The court meticulously evaluated each of these grounds, applying relevant legal principles and authorities to determine whether the Opponent had successfully established a ground for opposition. The court found that the Opponent did not meet the burden of proof required to establish any grounds of opposition on the balance of probabilities, leading to the conclusion that the trade mark could proceed to registration.

Under section 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act, the court examined whether the trade mark was deceptive or likely to deceive. The court considered the evidence presented by the Opponent, including the use of the trade mark in the United States and the claims regarding the use of the mark in Australia. However, the court found that the evidence was insufficient to establish that the trade mark was deceptive or likely to deceive. The court relied on previous authorities such as Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network GP, which emphasized the need for substantial evidence to prove deception or likelihood of deception. Given the lack of persuasive evidence, the court concluded that the ground under section 42(b) was not established.

The court also assessed the ground for opposition under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act, which pertains to prior rights. The Opponent argued that its International Registration Designating Australia (IRDA) provided grounds for opposition. However, the court determined that the Opponent had not provided sufficient evidence to substantiate its claims regarding the use and registration of the trade mark in Australia. The court referenced Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd, which underscored the necessity for clear and compelling evidence of prior rights. The Opponent's evidence, including the Solvay brochure and revenue figures, was deemed inadequate to establish the required grounds for opposition. Thus, the court found that the ground under section 44 was not established.

Furthermore, the court examined the ground for opposition under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act, which addresses the use of the trade mark in the course of trade by another person. The Opponent claimed extensive use of the trade mark in Australia, but the court found the evidence lacking. The court considered the relevance of the Relevant Date, 5 August 2022, and found that the evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate use of the trade mark in Australia by the Opponent. The court applied the principles from Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd to determine that the ground under section 60 was not established.

The court then addressed the overall burden of proof, which required the Opponent to establish the grounds of opposition on the balance of probabilities. The court concluded that the Opponent failed to meet this burden, as the evidence provided was not sufficient to substantiate any of the grounds for opposition. The court emphasized the need for clear and convincing evidence to establish grounds of opposition, a principle consistently applied in Australian trade mark law.

Lastly, the court considered whether there were any circumstances under which the Registrar should not proceed with the registration of the trade mark if an appeal was lodged by the Opponent. The court ruled that if the Registrar received a notice of appeal before the trade mark was registered, the registration should be withheld until the appeal was decided or discontinued. This decision aligned with the procedural fairness required in such cases, ensuring that the interests of both parties were protected.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that where the Opponent fails to establish a ground for opposition under sections 42(b), 44, or 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) on the balance of probabilities, the trade mark may proceed to registration. The court applied established legal principles and authorities to conclude that the Opponent did not meet the required burden of proof. The decision also clarifies the procedural steps to be taken if an appeal is lodged after the court’s decision but before the trade mark is registered.