Emmanuel Khoury v Telstra Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Emmanuel Khoury to registration of trade mark application 963492 (9, 16, 35, 38, 41, 42) - YELLOW - filed in the name of Telstra Corporation Limited

-and-

Opposition by Telstra Corporation Limited to registration of trade mark application 1138225 (35) yellowbook.com.au filed in the name of yellowbook.com.au Pty Ltd

Delegate:

Michael Kirov

Representation:

Yellowbook.com.au Pty Ltd/Mr Khoury: Mr Emmanuel Khoury

Telstra Corporation Limited: Georgina Schoff of Counsel, instructed by Melissa Marcus of Mallesons, Stevens, Jacques

2010 ATMO 36

Decision:

Opposition 1: s52 opposition – sections 41 and 44 – trade mark YELLOW shown by evidence to be capable of distinguishing Telstra’s goods and services; s44 ground not established. Opposition not established.

Opposition 2: s52 opposition – sections 44 and 60 – trade marks YELLOW PAGES and yellowbook.com.au deceptively similar. Opposition established.

Background

  1. This matter involves two “cross oppositions” under s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) concerning the trade marks YELLOW and yellowbook.com.au respectively.  The earlier of the opposed applications is owned by Telstra Corporation Limited (“Telstra”) and is detailed below:

Application No: 963492

Priority Date:  25 July 2003

Services:Class 9: Computer software including computer programs; publications in electronic form including publications supplied on-line from databases or from facilities provided on the Internet (including web sites)

Class 16: Telephone books; telephone directories; and business directories

Class 35: Retail and wholesale services including retail and wholesale services in relation to directories, publications, printed matter, telecommunications equipment, computer hardware and software, recording discs and CD ROMs; marketing, merchandising, retail and wholesale distribution services (excluding transport); directory services; business advisory services; business planning and analysis services; business management and business administration services; business surveys, appraisals and research; collection, preparation, compilation, storage, processing, retrieval and provision of business information; conduct of business studies and preparation of business reports; economic forecasting and analysis for business purposes; market analysis, research and monitoring services for business purposes; advertising services; advertising survey services, including telephonic and electronic surveys; electronic commerce services; business information services; agency services in respect of such directories and business supplements; advertising services promoting the services and goods of advertisers in such directories and business supplements in any medium; co-operative advertising with those who advertise in telephone and telephone directory business supplements; domain name registration services; research provided to business relating to the telecommunications industry; on-line business information services relating to e-commerce.

Class 38: Telecommunication and communication services including telecommunication of information (including web pages), computer programs and any other data; directory services including provision of on-line directories; electronic mail services; provision of telecommunication access and links to computer databases and the Internet; transmission of information on a wide range of topics, including on-line transmission; arranging and providing electronic, digital and computerised communications services and facilities between wholesalers, retailers, customers, transport service providers; computer aided transmission of messages, data and images; on-line telecommunications information services relating to e-commerce

Class 41: Electronic publication of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Emmanuel Khoury v Telstra Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ATMO 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by Emmanuel Khoury to Telstra Corporation Limited's application to register the trade mark YELLOW solus. The dispute arose in the context of an opposition proceeding before the Registrar of Trade Marks, with the decision being delivered by Kirov J.

The court was required to determine whether the trade mark YELLOW solus was capable of distinguishing Telstra's goods and services in Australia, considering its use in the country. This involved assessing the relevance of a prior World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) decision, the nature of the word "yellow" in relation to the goods and services, and whether Telstra was required to establish acquired distinctiveness for registration. The court also considered the significance of other traders using the word "yellow" or the colour yellow in their directories and trade marks.

Kirov J found that the WIPO decision was not determinative, as it was final and the panellist was limited to considering registered trade marks, not Telstra's broader application for YELLOW solus. His Honour disagreed with the WIPO panellist's apparent view that "yellow solus" was not an essential feature of Telstra's YELLOW PAGES trade mark, but noted this was not the issue before him. The court clarified that Telstra was not required to prove acquired distinctiveness, but rather that the mark was "capable of distinguishing" the relevant goods and services. His Honour also disagreed with the WIPO panellist's characterisation of "yellow" as a "highly generic" term for Telstra's goods and services. The court noted that while other traders might use the word "yellow" or the colour yellow, this did not directly impact the inherent adaptability of the word mark YELLOW to distinguish Telstra's offerings.

Ultimately, the Registrar decided that Telstra's application for YELLOW solus could proceed to registration, subject to a pending opposition by another party. However, the Registrar refused to register the trade mark yellowbook.com.au. Costs were awarded against yellowbook and Mr Khoury.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 of the Act relevantly provides:55 Decision(1) Unless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. Subject to the outcome of a still pending opposition to trade mark application 963492 YELLOW by another party, Phone Directories Company Australia Pty Ltd, I have decided that the application may otherwise proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. That said, if the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal by Emmanuel Khoury of my decision, I direct that registration shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued and that the disposition of the application be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. I refuse to register 1138225 (35) yellowbook.com.au. In the event Telstra was successful, Ms Schoff requested an award of costs in its favour. It is appropriate that costs follow the outcomes of these proceedings and I award costs against yellowbook and Mr Khoury in the respective proceedings at the official scale set out in the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Khoury also regards the WIPO decision and the lack of appeal against it by Telstra to the Federal Court as supporting his position. This approach is not well founded because:· There is no avenue of appeal from the WIPO decision to the Federal Court of Australia. Indeed, the panellist’s decision is final and there is no avenue of appeal at all.· The WIPO panellist was unable to consider Telstra’s application 963492 for YELLOW solus because he was bound to only consider trade mark registrations. Thus he was only able to consider Telstra’s registered YELLOW PAGES trade mark.· To the extent that the WIPO panellist relied on the decision in de Cordova v Vick Chemical Co (1951) 69 RPC 103 it was, submitted Mr Khoury, apparently because the panellist did not believe the element YELLOW solus was “an essential feature” of Telstra’s YELLOW PAGES trade mark. I do not agree with the panellist’s apparent view in that regard. However that is not a matter which bears upon the issue I am called upon to decide in this opposition in any event. Rather, the issue I must consider is whether I am satisfied that the trade mark YELLOW solus is now “capable of distinguishing” the Telstra Goods and Services in Australia given, inter alia, its use in this country.· To the extent that the panellist considered it significant that, as Mr Khoury put it in his written submissions, “Telstra did not provide evidence that the word YELLOW had acquired distinctiveness”, I point out that Telstra is not required to establish “acquired distinctiveness” in order for the YELLOW trade mark to be registrable in Australia. Rather, Telstra need only show the YELLOW trade mark is “capable of distinguishing” the Telstra Goods and Services, that is that it does, or will at some future time, distinguish those goods and services.· The WIPO panellist, in comparing the trade mark YELLOW PAGES with the “yellowbook” portion of the domain names <yellowbook.com.au> and <yellowbook.net.au>, placed much weight on his view that the word “yellow” was “highly generic”. The panellist does not explain or nominate the goods or services in relation to which the word “yellow” might be generic, nor indeed what he understands by his use of the word “generic”. I do not in fact agree that the word “yellow” (as distinct from the colour “yellow”) is a generic term for any of the Telstra Goods and Services for reasons I will explain below.· The WIPO decision was made in 2006 and the panellist was without the benefit of the 2007 decision in the NZ yellowbook case which could have considerably strengthened Telstra’s “bad faith” arguments[21].[21] To succeed before the WIPO tribunal in question a complainant needs to establish bad faith on the part of the domain name owner. Mr Khoury has pointed to other traders who have apparently printed their business directories on yellow paper, or featured the colour yellow on their websites, or who have the word “yellow” within their composite trade marks, to attempt to establish that the word “yellow” is common to the trade. In some of these cases, however, Telstra (or Sensis) has taken steps to stop these other uses; in others there is extra matter within the trade marks which is distinctive and which serves to distinguish the mark as a whole from Telstra’s YELLOW Trade Marks. In the circumstances of this opposition, the fact that other traders might print (or have printed) their directories on yellow paper (there are no such directories in evidence), or operate websites featuring the colour yellow, does not directly bear on the question of the inherent adaptation of the word trade mark YELLOW to distinguish the Telstra Goods and Services.