[2014] AATA 612
Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION File Number
2014/0279
Re
Emmanuel Ezekiel-Hart
APPLICANT
And
Child Support Registrar
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal RM Creyke, Senior Member
Date 28 August 2014 Place Canberra The decision under review is affirmed.
................................[sgd]........................................
RM Creyke, Senior Member
Catchwords
CHILD SUPPORT PAYMENT – Departure prohibition order – Whether applicant satisfies criteria for revocation of departure prohibition order – whether discretion to revoke departure prohibition order should be exercised.
Legislation
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) ss 3, 17, 17A, 72I, Part VII, VIIA, VIII
Cases
Re O’Neill and Child Support Registrar [2010] AATA 545
Secondary Materials
REASONS FOR DECISION
RM Creyke, Senior Member
Mr Emmanuel Ezekiel-Hart has sought review of a decision of the Child Support Registrar, dated 23 December 2013, to refuse to revoke a departure prohibition order made under section 72I of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (Act).
The Tribunal is satisfied that it has jurisdiction in this matter. The application was heard on 31 July 2014 by conference telephone.
Background
Mr Ezekiel-Hart, born 1964, was registered on 25 May 2007 to pay child support for two children in Australia, born respectively in 1999 and 2002. The child support assessment application was accepted on 19 June 2007. Mr Ezekiel-Hart, who normally resides in Australia, is a sole trader.
On 16 October 2013, the Child Support Registrar made a departure prohibition order under section 72D of the Act prohibiting Mr Ezekiel-Hart from departing Australia for a foreign country.
At that time, Mr Ezekiel-Hart had not made payments of child support amounting to $7,166.69, comprising $6,611.36 in outstanding child support payments, and penalties of $555.33. At the time, Mr Ezekiel-Hart’s monthly child support liability was $296.17. Collection of Mr Ezekiel-Hart’s child support payments has been undertaken by enforced collection by Centrelink deductions and 2 TRIPS (tax refund intercept process) in 2008.
Mr Ezekiel-Hart has made payments to his former partner outside the agency collection system. Mr Ezekiel-Hart’s former partner has declared receipt of non-agency payments from him as follows:
·17 January 2013 - $250;
·18 October 2012 - $250;
·3 August 2012 - $75:
·15 October 2008 - $50.
In the submission relating to his Departure Authorisation Certificate further figures for non-agency payments showed:
·2 July 2014 - $250;
·20 March 2014 - $250;
·4 March 2014 - $250.
On 15 November 2013, Mr Ezekiel-Hart sought revocation of the departure prohibition order. At that time Mr Ezekiel-Hart’s arrears were $7,515.75, comprising $6,907.53 in child support and $608.22 in penalties. On 21 November 2013, Mr Ezekiel-Hart was notified that his application had been refused.
On 13 December 2013 Mr Ezekiel-Hart made another application for the departure prohibition order to be revoked. At that time his arrears were $7,867.18 comprising $7,203.70 in child support payments, and $663.48 in penalties. His regular child support liability at that time was $47.50 a month commencing 1 December 2013. The rejection of that claim is before this Tribunal.
Again, in early July 2014, Mr Ezekiel-Hart applied…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Emmanuel Ezekiel-Hart and Child Support Registrar and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] AATA 612
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary issue was whether Mr Ezekiel-Hart met the criteria set out in section 72I(1) of the Act for revocation of the departure prohibition order. Additionally, if he did not meet these criteria, the tribunal had to consider whether it should exercise its discretion under section 72I(3) of the Act to revoke the order. The tribunal noted that Mr Ezekiel-Hart had been in arrears for a substantial amount and had a history of non-compliance with child support obligations. The tribunal also considered Mr Ezekiel-Hart's lack of good faith and reliability, particularly his breach of the conditions of the departure authorisation certificate he was granted in July 2014. The tribunal found that Mr Ezekiel-Hart had not provided evidence of his daughter's injury or his aunt's death, which were the reasons he cited for leaving Australia.
The tribunal concluded that Mr Ezekiel-Hart did not satisfy the criteria for revocation of the departure prohibition order. His failure to adhere to the terms of the departure authorisation certificate and his lack of good faith demonstrated a continued unreliability and lack of commitment to fulfilling his child support obligations. The tribunal found that revoking the departure prohibition order would be inappropriate and contrary to the intent of the legislation. Therefore, the tribunal did not exercise its discretion to revoke the order.
The tribunal upheld the Child Support Registrar’s decision to maintain the departure prohibition order against Mr Ezekiel-Hart. Mr Ezekiel-Hart was not granted permission to leave Australia, and the order remained in effect. The tribunal's decision emphasised the importance of ensuring that parents meet their child support obligations and that the Act's provisions are enforced to achieve this goal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The issues are:·Whether Mr Ezekiel-Hart satisfies the criteria in section 72I(1) of the Act for revocation of the departure prohibition order; and·If not, whether the Tribunal should revoke the departure prohibition order in the exercise of its discretion under section 72I(3) of the Act.Consideration Mr Ezekiel-Hart has been under a registrable child support maintenance liability since 2007.[1] At the time of the decision to make a departure prohibition order he was in arrears to the tune of $7,867.18, comprising $7,203.70 in child support payments, and $663.48 in penalties. At the hearing it was established that these amounts took into account the non-agency payments made by Mr Ezekiel-Hart. [1] Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) ss 17, 17A. In view of his liability and the arrears of his child support payments, a departure prohibition order was made in October 2013 in relation to Mr Ezekiel-Hart, a decision which was affirmed by the Child Support Registrar. That is consistent with the objects of the Act which are ‘to ensure (a) that children received from their parents the financial support that the parents are liable to provide’ and ‘to ensure (b) that periodic amounts payable by parents towards the maintenance of their children are paid on a regular and timely basis’.[2][2] Ibid s 3(1)(a), (b). In the meantime, in July 2014, Mr Ezekiel-Hart sought and obtained a departure authorisation certificate so he could leave Australia. The certificate was granted for Mr Ezekiel-Hart to depart in the period between 14 July and 21 July 2014, and to return no later than 30 July 2014. Mr Ezekiel-Hart had not returned by 30 July 2014 and advised that he does not intend to return until August 2015. The Child Support Registrar has submitted that in addition to the arrears of child support maintenance, Mr Ezekiel-Hart’s unreliability and lack of good faith is indicated by his breach of the departure certificate order. As a submission dated 30 July 2014 stated: [Mr Ezekiel-Hart’s] failure to advise the delegate of his intention to study overseas and to withhold information about his true travel arrangements raises concerns about [his] commitment to discharging the outstanding child support liability. It remains the Child Support Registrar’s position that it would be inappropriate and contrary to the intention of the legislation to revoke the departure prohibition order in these circumstances. As the representative submitted non-agency payments were only made after the departure prohibition order was made, the $500 ‘goodwill’ payment appeared to be made solely to ensure Mr Ezekiel-Hart obtained a departure authorisation certificate, there was no regularity in his non-agency payments, and Mr Ezekiel-Hart’s undertakings about payments of $250 a month, commencing in August 2014, are called into question in the light of his failure to adhere to the other undertaking made in relation to obtaining the departure authorisation certificate. In particular the representative referred to Mr Ezekiel-Hart’s breach of his undertaking that he would return no later than 30 July 2014.