Elton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

Elton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2018] AATA 1329 (21 May 2018)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s):      2015/2851

Re:Peter Robert Elton

APPLICANT

Repatriation CommissionAnd  

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Egon Fice, Senior Member

Date:21 May 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

....................[sgd]....................................................

Egon Fice, Senior Member

VETERANS’ APPEALS – Standard of proof – post-traumatic stress disorder – major anxiety disorder – lumbar spondylosis – whether injuries war-caused – reasonable hypothesis – whether factual foundation of hypothesis is disproved

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Veterans Entitlements’ Act 1986

Cases

Byrnes v Repatriation Commission (1993) 177 CLR 564

Keely v The Honourable Mr Justice Brooking (1979) 143 CLR 162

Morales v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1988) 82 FCR 374

Repatriation Commission v Bawden (2012) 206 FCR 296

Repatriation Commission v Gorton (2001) 110 FCR 321

Repatriation Commissioned v Keeley (2000) 98 FCR 108

Woodward v Repatriation Commission (2003) 131 FCR 473

Secondary Materials

American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, DSM-IV-TR, published on 31 July 1994

American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, DSM -5, published on 18 May 2013

Repatriation Medical Authority, Statement of Principles concerning POSTTRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER, No. 5 of 2008, for the purposes of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004, 9 January 2008

Repatriation Medical Authority, Statement of Principles concerning POSTTRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER, No. 82 of 2014, for the purposes of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004, 22 September 2014

Repatriation Medical Authority, Statement of Principles concerning anxiety disorder, No. 102 of 2014, made under subsection 196B(2) of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986, 28 November 2016

Repatriation Medical Authority, Amendment Statement of Principles concerning ANXIETY DISORDER, No. 99 of 2016, for the purposes of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004, 28 November 2016

Repatriation Medical Authority, Statement of Principles concerning LUMBAR SPONDYLOSIS, No. 62 of 2014, for the purposes of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004, 2 July 2014

Repatriation Medical Authority, Statement of Principles concerning LUMBAR SPONDYLOSIS, No. 37 of 2005, for the purposes of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004, 16 November 2005

Repatriation Medical Authority, Statement of Principles concerning SPONDYLOLISTHESIS AND SPONDYLOLYSIS (Reasonable Hypothesis) (No. 24 of 2017), 27 March 2017

REASONS FOR DECISION

Egon Fice, Senior Member
21 May 2018

  1. Mr Peter Elton enlisted in the Royal Australian Navy (RAN) on 7 July 1968 as a Junior Recruit. He underwent 12 months of naval and academic training at HMAS Leeuwin and was then posted to the Destroyer Escort, HMAS Parramatta on 14 July 1969 for Common Sea Training. He was promoted to Ordinary Seaman Electrical Mechanic on


    13 September 1969, on his 17th birthday. When HMAS Parramatta went to Melbourne for a refit at Williamstown Naval Dockyard,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 1329
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Elton against a decision of the Repatriation Commission regarding his entitlement to veterans' benefits. The dispute centred on whether Mr Elton had established the necessary factual basis and reasonableness of hypotheses connecting his claimed conditions, specifically lumbar spondylosis and psychological conditions such as PTSD and GAD, to his operational service. The decision was made by Senior Member Egon Fice of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Elton had discharged his onus of proof, on the balance of probabilities, to establish that he suffered from lumbar spondylosis and a psychological condition, and whether the hypotheses connecting these conditions to his operational service were reasonable in accordance with the *Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986* (Cth). Specifically, the Tribunal was required to assess the objective evidence supporting the claimed physical injury and the adequacy of the psychiatric reports in addressing diagnostic criteria and functional impairment for the psychological conditions.

Senior Member Fice reasoned that Mr Elton had not provided sufficient objective evidence to support his claim of lumbar spondylosis occurring at the time he alleged, noting the absence of medical attention sought at that time. Consequently, the factual foundation for this claim was disproved. However, the Senior Member found that Mr Elton did have lumbar spondylosis/spondylolisthesis, but the hypothesis connecting this condition to his operational service was not reasonable as a necessary factor was not met. Regarding the psychological conditions, the Senior Member found that the psychiatric reports were inadequate as they relied solely on Mr Elton's subjective statements and failed to address diagnostic criteria or evidence of clinically significant distress or impairment. Despite this, the Senior Member considered the reasonableness of the hypotheses connecting any psychological condition to operational service, finding a category 1A stressor was present, and also found the hypothesis connecting operational service to lumbar spondylosis reasonable.

Ultimately, the Senior Member found that the factual foundation for Mr Elton's claimed injury at the time of the alleged incident was disproved, and the hypothesis connecting his spondylolisthesis to operational service was not reasonable. However, the Senior Member found that the hypothesis connecting Mr Elton's psychological condition to his operational service was reasonable, and that Mr Elton did have lumbar spondylosis/spondylolisthesis. The Senior Member concluded that the evidence was insufficient to make a finding, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Elton had developed PTSD, GAD, or any psychological condition due to the inadequacy of the psychiatric reports.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my opinion, because Mr Elton did not appear to require medical attention and did not seek it at or about the time that he claimed his injury occurred, the only conclusion that can be drawn is that it was not sufficiently severe to warrant medical intervention. Therefore, there is no objective evidence of trauma, that is, the application of a significant physical force, to his spine. Without objective medical evidence, it is not possible to make a finding that Mr Elton satisfies the SOP dealing with lumbar spondylosis. Accordingly, I am satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the factual foundation of the hypothesis has been disproved. The facts relied on by Mr Elton to support his hypothesis have not been established and accordingly cannot be true. That is not to say Mr Elton is not telling the truth. Despite his evidence, the medical evidence does not accord with his subjective account of what happened. There is also significant doubt about the severity of the claimed fall or the striking of his back against the gangway.Conclusion I have found that the evidence before me on this hearing is insufficient for me to make a finding, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Elton has developed PTSD, GAD or any psychological condition. That is because all of the psychiatric reports which were before me in evidence do not properly address the diagnostic criteria set out in DSM-IV-TR or DSM-5. Not one of those reports refers to evidence from family or other third parties. There is no attention given to a finding of clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational or other important areas of functioning. Each of those reports relied solely on the subjective self-serving statements made by Mr Elton. To make a finding that Mr Elton has acquired a psychological condition on the basis of that evidence is the equivalent of simply ticking the box. That approach is, in my opinion, clearly incorrect. I have found that, on the balance of probabilities, Mr Elton does have lumbar spondylosis/spondylolisthesis. In the event that my analysis of the evidence dealing with the diagnosis of a psychological condition is incorrect, I have proceeded to determine whether that condition, by whatever name, could be described as war-caused in accordance with the VE Act. On examining the whole of the material before me, I have found that the hypothesis connecting Mr Elton’s psychological condition with his operational service is reasonable as it satisfies the minimum which must exist for making that connection. The whole of the material points to Mr Elton experiencing a category 1A stressor. I have also found that the hypothesis connecting Mr Elton’s operational service with his lumbar spondylosis is reasonable. The whole of the material points to Mr Elton having experienced trauma to the lumbar spine. However, I have found that Mr Elton’s hypothesis connecting his spondylolisthesis with his operational service is not reasonable. That is because Mr Elton does not satisfy one of the factors which must, as a minimum, be present for his hypothesis to be regarded as reasonable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.