Elsinora Global Ltd v Healthscope Ltd (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Elsinora Global Ltd v Healthscope Ltd (No. 2) [2006] FCA 18

TAXATION – income tax - collection and recovery of tax – Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), s 255 - collection from person having receipt control or disposal of money belonging to non-resident – where Commissioner communicated requirement by notice at particular time – whether relevant receipt control or disposal required at that time – whether tax must be due and payable by non-resident at that time – circumstances in which money belongs to another person – whether obligation to pay equivalent sum sufficient –– operation of deeming provision where liability arises on fulfilment of condition – Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), Sch 1, s 260-5 – collection from person owing money to taxpayer – circumstances in which third party owes or may later owe money to debtor – whether privity required – effect of deeming provisions in s 260-5(3)

WORDS & PHRASES – ‘money belonging to’

Commissioner of Taxation v Wong (2002) 121 FCR 60 applied
Conley & Anor v Commissioner of Taxation & Anor (1998) 81 FCR 24 referred to
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Conley (1998) 88 FCR 98 referred to
Ex parte Walton; re Levy (1881) 17 Ch D 746 applied
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Comber (1986) 10 FCR 88 applied
Melluish v BMW (No. 3) Ltd (1996) AC 454 referred to

Mann on the Legal Aspect of Money, Sixth Edition, by Charles Proctor, 2005, Oxford University Press
I V Gzell, ‘Treaty Protection from Capital Gains Tax’, (2000) 29 Australian Tax Review, 25 – 49
I V Gzell, ‘Treaty Application to a Capital Gains Tax introduced after Conclusion of the Treaty’, (2002) 76 Australian Law Journal 309 – 327

ELSINORA GLOBAL LIMITED, TIOGA WORLDWIDE LIMITED, PERLETTE OVERSEAS LIMITED, PETER ARMSTRONG, JONATHAN BERGER and EC MEDICAL INVESTMENTS NV v HEALTHSCOPE LIMITED, ANZ NOMINEES LIMITED and DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

NSD 96 OF 2005

EDMONDS J
3 FEBRUARY 2006
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 96 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

ELSINORA GLOBAL LIMITED
FIRST APPLICANT

TIOGA WORLDWIDE LIMITED
SECOND APPLICANT

PERLETTE OVERSEAS LIMITED
THIRD APPLICANT

PETER ARMSTRONG
FOURTH APPLICANT

JONATHAN BERGER
FIFTH APPLICANT

EC MEDICAL INVESTMENTS NV
SIXTH APPLICANT

AND:

HEALTHSCOPE LIMITED
FIRST RESPONDENT

ANZ NOMINEES LIMITED
SECOND RESPONDENT

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
THIRD RESPONDENT

AND BETWEEN:

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
CROSS-CLAIMANT

AND:

ELSINORA GLOBAL LIMITED
FIRST CROSS-RESPONDENT

TIOGA WORLDWIDE LIMITED
SECOND CROSS-RESPONDENT

PERLETTE OVERSEAS LIMITED
THIRD CROSS-RESPONDENT

PETER ARMSTRONG
FOURTH CROSS-RESPONDENT

JONATHAN BERGER
FIFTH CROSS-RESPONDENT

HEALTHSCOPE LIMITED
SIXTH CROSS-RESPONDENT

ANZ NOMINEES LIMITED
SEVENTH CROSS-RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE OF ORDER:

3 FEBRUARY 2006

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties have leave to make submissions as to the orders, if any, consistent with the reasons for judgment, to be made in respect of the application.

2.The cross-claim be dismissed.

3.The third respondent pay the costs of the applicants and the first and second respondents of the proceedings.

Note:    Settlement and entry…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elsinora Global Ltd v Healthscope Ltd (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Elsinora Global Ltd v Healthscope Ltd (No. 2), the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation filed a cross-claim seeking declaratory relief that various parties were required to withhold and pay certain taxes due by ECMI. The court was tasked with determining whether the Section 255 and Section 260-5 notices issued by the Deputy Commissioner imposed a statutory obligation on the respondents to withhold and remit the specified tax amount.

The key legal issue was the interpretation and application of Sections 255 and 260-5 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953. The court examined whether the notices correctly identified ANZ Nominees as an entity owing money to ECMI or holding money on its behalf, which would trigger the statutory obligation to remit the tax amount to the Deputy Commissioner. The court found that ANZ Nominees did not have a direct monetary obligation to ECMI, nor did it hold money for or on account of ECMI, or on account of another entity for payment to ECMI. Therefore, the notices did not impose a statutory obligation on ANZ Nominees or the other respondents unless and until they received, controlled, or disposed of the relevant money in Australia.

The court concluded that none of the Section 255 notices imposed a statutory obligation on Healthscope or ANZ Nominees, and none of the Section 260-5 notices imposed an obligation on Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong, or Mr Berger unless they had receipt, control, or disposal of the money in Australia. The cross-claim was dismissed, and the third respondent was ordered to pay the costs of the applicants and the first and second respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties have leave to make submissions as to the orders, if any, consistent with the reasons for judgment, to be made in respect of the application.

2. The cross-claim be dismissed.

3. The third respondent pay the costs of the applicants and the first and second respondents of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

In her cross-claim, the Deputy Commissioner seeks declaratory relief:(1)That each of Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger is, or is upon payment to ANZ Nominees by Healthscope of the amount of $9,953,426.10 –(a)authorised and required by s 255(1)(b) of the ITAA 1936 to retain out of the moneys which he or it is liable to pay to ECMI the amount of $9,953,426.10; and(b)obliged, in accordance with s 255(1)(a) of the ITAA 1936, to pay to the Deputy Commissioner on 1 December 2005 the amount of $9,953,426.10, being the tax due and payable by ECMI on that date.(2)Further, or in the alternative, that Healthscope –(a)is authorised and required by s 255(1)(b) of the ITAA 1936 to retain the sum of $9,953,426.10; and(b)is obliged, in accordance with s 255(1)(a) of the ITAA 1936, to pay to the Deputy Commissioner on 1 December 2005 the amount of $9,953,426.10, being the tax due and payable by ECMI on that date.(3)Further, or in the alternative, that ANZ Nominees is upon payment to it by Healthscope of the amount of $9,953,426.10 –(a)authorised and required by s 255(1)(b) of the ITAA 1936 to retain the sum of $9,953,426.10; and(c)obliged, in accordance with s 255(1)(a) of the ITAA 1936, to pay to the Deputy Commissioner on 1 December 2005 the amount of $9,953,426.10, being the tax due and payable by ECMI on that date.(4)Further, or in the alternative, that ANZ Nominees is, or is upon payment to it by Healthscope of the amount of $9,953,426.10, required by s 260-5 of Schedule 1 of the Administration Act and the notice issued to it in reliance on s 260-5, to pay the said sum of $9,953,426.10 to the Deputy Commissioner.(5)Further, or in the alternative, that each of Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger is, or is upon payment to ANZ Nominees by Healthscope of the amount of $9,953,426.10, required by s 260-5 of Schedule 1 of the Administration Act and the notice issued to it or him in reliance on s 260-5, to pay its or his proportionate share of the said sum of $9,953,426.10 to the Deputy Commissionerand orders that:(6)The said sum of $9,953,426.10 be paid to the Deputy Commissioner by Healthscope and/or ANZ Nominees and/or each of Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger in his or its proportionate share –(a)forthwith;(b)alternatively on 1 December 2005.(7)In the alternative, an order that the said sum of $9,953,426.10 currently held by Healthscope –(a)be retained by Healthscope; or(b)be remitted by Healthscope to ANZ Nominees to be retaineduntil 1 December 2005 at which time the party retaining that amount shall pay it to the Deputy Commissioner.By agreement among the parties, the date of 1 December 2005 was, subsequent to the hearing, extended until the date of judgment.BACKGROUND To a large extent, the factual background is not in dispute. Prior to 2 November 2004 ECMI beneficially owned 194,516,455 ordinary shares (‘the Shares’) in Gribbles, representing 43.05 per cent of the issued ordinary shares in Gribbles. At the time, the ordinary shares in Gribbles were listed on the Australian Stock Exchange (‘ASX’). ANZ Nominees was the registered holder of the Shares as trustee for ECMI and ANZ Bank was mortgagee of the Shares.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

EDMONDS J
In relation to the second ground of challenge, it is said that at neither time:(1)Is ANZ Nominees an entity by whom money is due or accruing to ECMI: Par (a). Again, that must be right. At neither time does, or will, ANZ Nominees have any monetary obligation to ECMI which is due or accruing due.(2)Does ANZ Nominees hold money for or on account of ECMI: Par (b). Again, that must be right. At neither time does, or will, ANZ Nominees hold money for or on account of ECMI. At both times it will only hold money for or on account of CSC, Investec Trustees or Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger.(3)Does ANZ Nominees hold money on account of some other entity for payment to ECMI: Par (c). Again, that must be right. For the Commissioner it was contended that on its receipt of the retained sum from Healthscope, ANZ Nominees will hold money on account of CSC or Investec Trustees, or on account of Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger, for payment to ECMI. In my view, that is not so. What par (c) of subs 260‑5(3) is concerned with is situations where the entity concerned (ANZ Nominees) holds money on account of some other entity (CSC or Investec Trustees, or Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger) for payment by ANZ Nominees to the tax debtor (ECMI); in other words, where the first mentioned entity (ANZ Nominees) itself has a dual or split obligation to hold the money on account of some other entity for payment to the tax debtor (ECMI). It is not concerned with a situation where the first mentioned entity holds money on account of some other entity where that other entity is under some obligation to pay it to the tax debtor. In the present case, ANZ Nominees will not hold money on account of CSC or Investec Trustees, or on account of Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger for payment to ECMI; on the contrary, it will hold money on account of CSC or Investec Trustees, or on account of Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger, for payment to them.(4)Does ANZ Nominees have authority from some other entity to pay the money to ECMI: Par (d). Again, that must be right.CONCLUSIONSThe Section 255 Notices For the foregoing reasons, I therefore conclude that:(1)None of the s 255 notices addressed to Healthscope, that is, the 8 November 2004 Notice, the 24 November 2004 Notice and the 15 February 2005 Notice, imposes a statutory obligation on Healthscope in accordance with its terms.(2)None of the s 255 notices addressed to ANZ Nominees, that is, the 7 January 2005 Notice and the 28 June 2005 Notice, will impose a statutory obligation on ANZ Nominees in accordance with its terms if and when ANZ Nominees receives from Healthscope the retained sum of $9,953,426.10.(3)None of the 2 June 2005 Notices will impose a statutory obligation on each of Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong and Mr Berger in accordance with its terms unless and until the addressee has, in Australia, the receipt, control or disposal of the money representing the retained sum of $9,953,426.10.The Section 260-5 Notices

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EDMONDS J

The s 260-5 Notices to Elsinora, Tioga, Perlette, Mr Armstrong, Mr Berger, Investec Trustees, ANZ Nominees and CSC were in common form and it suffices to set out the letter to ANZ Nominees:‘NOTICE TO PAY MONEY TO THE COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION UNDER SECTION 260-5 OF SCHEDULE 1 OF THE TAXATION ADMINISTRATION ACT 1953.E.C. MEDICAL INVESTMENTS NVThis document is a notice under section 260-5 of Schedule 1 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (TAA 1953) requiring you to pay money to the Commissioner of Taxation. A copy of the relevant Legislation is enclosed. Below are the procedures you must follow to ensure that you comply with this notice.PaymentsPayments in compliance with this notice should be forwarded to the attention of the contact officer at the address shown at the top of this notice.IndemnityIn complying with this notice, you are legally protected by section 260-15 of Schedule 1 of the TAA 1953 which provides that any payment made under subdivision 260-A is taken to have been authorised byE.C. MEDICAL INVESTMENTS NV.Expiration of this noticeThis notice will remain in force until the full amount due is paid to the Commissioner or until you are notified in writing that it is withdrawn.…NoticeANZ NOMINEES LIMITED, YOU are a third party who owes, or may later owe, money (“the available money”) to E.C. MEDICAL INVESTMENTS NV (“the debtor”), of (or previously of) C/- T M F TERVUKENLAAN 13A 1040 BRUSSELS, BELGIUM, who, in terms of section 260-5 of Schedule 1 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 has a debt payable to the Commonwealth of $9,953,426.10. In exercise of powers conferred on me as Deputy Commissioner of Taxation by delegation from the Commissioner of Taxation under section 8 of the Taxation Administration Act, YOU, ANZ NOMINEES LIMITED, ARE REQUIRED TO PAY TO THE COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION the sum of $9,953,426.10 or, if the available money is less than $9,953,426.10, the whole of the available money.If you now owe the available money to the debtor, the payment to the Commissioner of Taxation is to be made IMMEDIATELY. If you do not owe the available money to the debtor but you will later owe it to the debtor, the payment to the Commissioner of Taxation is to be made immediately the money becomes owing to the debtor.For the purpose of section 260-5 of Schedule 1 of the Taxation Administration Act, a third party is taken to owe money (the available money) to the debtor if the third party:(a)is an entity by whom the money is due or accruing to the debtor; or(b)holds the money for or on account of the debtor; or(c)holds the money on account of some other entity for payment to the debtor; or(d)has authority from some other entity to pay the money to the debtor.The third party is so taken to owe the money to the debtor even if:(e)the money is not due, or is not so held, or payable under the authority, unless a condition is fulfilled; and(f)the condition has not been fulfilled.If the debt (or any part of the debt) is paid by the debtor or another entity before a payment is made by you under this notice, I will notify you of that fact and any amount that you are required to pay under this notice will be reduced by the amount so paid.’SECTION 255 OF THE ITAA 1936 AND ITS CONSTRUCTION