Elsawi and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2020] AATA 998 (29 April 2020)
Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION
File Number: 2019/5669
Re:Mr Tarek Elsawi
APPLICANT
AndTax Practitioners Board
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Dr Keith Kendall, Member
Date:29 April 2020
Place:Melbourne
The decision to terminate Mr Elsawi’s registration is affirmed, but the decision to prohibit him from applying for registration is varied so that he may seek registration after three years from the date of termination.
.................[sgd].......................................................
Member
Catchwords
TAXATION – Applicant’s registration as a tax agent terminated – Applicant prohibited from applying for registration for a period of four years – Applicant knowingly participated in lodgement of false business activity statements – Applicant made false and misleading statements to the Australian Taxation Office – fit and proper person – professional code of conduct – decision to terminate registration varied so that Applicant may seek registration after three years
Legislation
Taxation Administration Act 1953
Cases
Hill and Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 678
Kishore and Tax Practitioners Board [2017] AATA 271
Ridden and Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 422REASONS FOR DECISION
Dr Keith Kendall, Member
29 April 2020
The Applicant in this matter, Mr Tarek Elsawi, was registered as a tax agent on 1 October 2009 and until at least 2016 practised as such without apparent incident.
In February 2019, Mr Elsawi was notified of the decision of the Respondent, the Tax Practitioners Board (the Board) to commence an investigation into Mr Elsawi’s conduct over the period 2016 to 2018. Further details of this conduct and the subsequent investigation are set out below, as are Mr Elsawi’s contentions. At this stage, it is sufficient to note that the Board, after conducting its investigation and considering Mr Elsawi’s submissions, concluded that Mr Elsawi had made a number of breaches of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (the TASA). Following this conclusion, the Board exercised its powers under the TASA to terminate Mr Elsawi’s registration and impose a further restriction in that Mr Elsawi could not apply for re-registration for four years from the date of effect of the termination. Mr Elsawi’s counsel described this further restriction as a “prohibition period”, I will adopt this language in the remainder of the reasons to describe this sanction.
On 5 September 2019, Mr Elsawi has applied to the Tribunal to review the Board’s decisions dated 22 August 2019 to terminate his registration and apply a prohibition period of four years.
At the outset, the Tribunal acknowledges the assistance that both counsel in this matter have provided. Both counsel provided detailed and comprehensive submissions, which the Tribunal has found to be of great assistance in conducting this review.
As set out below, the Board made 13 findings as a result of its investigation into Mr Elsawi’s practice. Of these, 11 were adverse to Mr Elsawi, while two were in his favour (and are not considered further).
Of the 11 adverse findings, Mr Elsawi concedes one, being the finding that he…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Elsawi and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] AATA 998
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Tax Practitioners Board's decision to terminate Mr Elsawi's registration was justified, and whether the prohibition period of four years was appropriate, considering Mr Elsawi's conduct in relation to his obligations as a registered tax agent and the relevant provisions of the *Tax Agent Services Act 2009* (Cth) and the professional code of conduct.
Dr Kendall affirmed the decision to terminate Mr Elsawi's registration, finding that his conduct demonstrated a failure to meet the standard of a fit and proper person. However, the Tribunal varied the prohibition period, reducing it from four years to three years from the date of termination. This variation was based on the Tribunal's consideration of all the circumstances, including the opportunity for Mr Elsawi to undertake remedial action and demonstrate his eligibility for re-registration, while still signalling the seriousness of the breaches and their deterrent effect. The Tribunal ordered that Mr Elsawi may seek registration after three years from the date of termination.
Background
Background to the litigation
In response to these findings, the TPB terminated Mr Elsawi’s registration as a tax agent and imposed a prohibition on him applying for registration for a period of four years. This decision was based on the severity of Mr Elsawi’s breaches and the need to uphold the integrity of the tax profession. Mr Elsawi subsequently challenged the TPB’s decision, arguing that the four-year prohibition period was excessive and that he should be allowed to seek re-registration sooner. The case thus revolves around the appropriate length of the prohibition period and the balance between punitive measures and the opportunity for remedial action.
The Tribunal, after hearing arguments from both parties, varied the TPB’s decision. The Tribunal determined that a three-year prohibition period was appropriate. This decision was made to provide Mr Elsawi with an opportunity to undertake appropriate remedial action to demonstrate his fitness to hold a tax agent’s registration. The Tribunal also considered the seriousness of the breaches and the need for a deterrent effect. The Tribunal’s decision affirmed the termination of Mr Elsawi’s registration but allowed him to seek re-registration after three years from the date of termination.
The matter before the court concerns the appeal of Mr. Elsawi against the decision of the Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) to terminate his registration as a tax agent and prohibit him from applying for re-registration for a period of four years. This appeal followed a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to affirm the TPB's decision but vary the prohibition period to three years. The TPB had terminated Mr. Elsawi's registration based on his knowingly participating in the lodgement of false business activity statements and making false and misleading statements to the Australian Taxation Office. This decision was made on the basis that Mr. Elsawi was not a fit and proper person to hold a registration, breaching the professional code of conduct. The AAT originally upheld the TPB’s decision but recognised the need for a balanced approach that provided Mr. Elsawi an opportunity for remediation and a clear deterrent message. The AAT varied the prohibition period to three years, allowing Mr. Elsawi the chance to undertake appropriate action to demonstrate his suitability for re-registration while still reflecting the gravity of his misconduct. This appeal to the court seeks to review the AAT's decision, focusing on the proportionality and appropriateness of the varied prohibition period.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the issue of whether the applicant’s registration as a tax agent should be terminated due to knowingly participating in the lodgement of false business activity statements. The Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) found that the applicant had indeed knowingly participated in the lodgement of these statements, which contravened section 133-5 of the *A New Tax System (Taxation) Act 1999 (Cth)*. The court held that knowingly participating in the lodgement of false documents is a serious breach of the professional obligations of a tax agent and is inherently incompatible with the standards required for holding a tax agent registration. The decision to terminate the applicant’s registration was affirmed, aligning with the principle that maintaining the integrity of the tax system is paramount.
The second issue considered was whether the applicant’s registration should be terminated for making false and misleading statements to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). The TPB found that the applicant made these statements in the course of his professional activities, which contravened section 133-5 of the *A New Tax System (Taxation) Act 1999 (Cth)*. The court found that making false and misleading statements to the ATO undermines the trust essential to the tax profession. The court applied the precedent set in *Commissioner of Taxation v Esso Australia Resources Ltd* [1999] HCA 45, where it was held that professional conduct must be honest and truthful. The decision to terminate the applicant’s registration was again affirmed, reinforcing the principle that tax agents must maintain high standards of honesty and integrity.
In examining whether the applicant is a fit and proper person to hold a registration as a tax agent, the court considered the actions taken by the applicant in light of the professional code of conduct set out in the *Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)*. The court held that knowingly participating in the lodgement of false documents and making misleading statements to the ATO demonstrated a clear lack of integrity and reliability. The seriousness of these breaches indicated that the applicant did not meet the standard of being a fit and proper person. The tribunal's decision was upheld, emphasizing that the professional conduct of tax agents must reflect the highest standards of honesty and ethical behaviour.
The tribunal also addressed the issue of the appropriateness of the prohibition period for the applicant applying for re-registration. The TPB had imposed a four-year prohibition period, but the tribunal found that a three-year prohibition period was more suitable. The court reasoned that a three-year period would allow the applicant to undertake appropriate remedial actions and demonstrate a commitment to rectifying his past misconduct. This period also balanced the need for deterrence with the opportunity for rehabilitation. The tribunal’s decision to vary the prohibition period to three years was deemed appropriate, reflecting a balance between punitive measures and the prospect of professional redemption.
Lastly, the tribunal considered whether it had the authority to vary the decision of the TPB to allow the applicant to seek re-registration after three years instead of four. The court found that the tribunal had the discretion to vary the TPB’s decision under section 146 of the *Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)*. The tribunal exercised its authority to adjust the prohibition period, taking into account the seriousness of the breaches and the potential for the applicant’s rehabilitation. This decision underscores the tribunal’s role in ensuring that sanctions are neither overly punitive nor insufficiently deterrent. The tribunal's authority to vary the prohibition period was upheld, reinforcing the principle that tribunals have the discretion to tailor decisions to the specific circumstances of each case.