FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| ELLIS v LEFT BANK HOLDINGS PTY LTD | [2017] FCCA 90 |
| Catchwords: HUMAN RIGHTS – Disability discrimination – access to premises – provision of goods, services and facilities – refusal of access with assistance animal. |
| Legislation: Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth), ss.46PH, 46PO |
| Applicant: | TROY ELLIS |
| Respondent: | LEFT BANK HOLDINGS PTY LTD TRADING AS LEFT BANK BAR & CAFÉ |
| File Number: | PEG 487 of 2015 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Antoni Lucev |
| Hearing date: | 11 March 2016 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 11 March 2016 |
| Delivered at: | Perth |
| Delivered on: | 24 January 2017 |
REPRESENTATION
| For the Applicant: | No appearance |
| For the Respondent: | Ms C Sluiter |
| Solicitors for the Respondent: | Allion Legal |
ORDERS
By 28 February 2017, the Applicant do file and serve:
(a)a statement of claim setting out the basis of his claim against the Respondent; and
(b)any affidavits in support of his statement of claim.
The matter be adjourned to 3.15pm on 3 March 2017 for further directions.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT PERTH |
PEG 487 of 2015
| TROY ELLIS |
Applicant
And
| LEFT BANK HOLDINGS PTY LTD TRADING AS LEFT BANK BAR & CAFÉ |
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction
By an application in a case filed on 26 November 2015 (“Application in a Case”) the respondent, Left Bank Holdings Pty Ltd trading as Left Bank Bar & Café (“Left Bank Holdings”) seeks certain procedural orders in relation to these proceedings.
The originating application filed by the applicant, Mr Troy Ellis (“Mr Ellis”) on 25 October 2015 (“Originating Application”) alleges that Left Bank Holdings Pty Ltd discriminated against Mr Ellis…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ellis v Left Bank Holdings Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCCA 90
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the scope and application of specific Federal Circuit Court Rules concerning discovery and the production of documents. The key rules in question were Rule 14.02, which allows for a declaration to permit discovery, and Rule 14.10, which governs the process for requesting and providing copies or inspection of documents referred to in filed documents or affidavits. The court also considered Rule 15.28, which mandates that documents used in conjunction with an affidavit must be annexed to it.
Judge Lucev's reasoning focused on the interpretation of Rule 14.10. He adopted the observation from *Faulkner v Tidewater Marine Australia Pty Ltd (No.3)* that for a document to be considered "referred to" under Rule 14.10(1), it must at least be mentioned in the relevant affidavit; an implied existence is insufficient. Furthermore, the court held that the use of the word "must" in Rule 14.10(2) indicates a mandatory obligation to provide a copy of a requested document or to appoint a time and place for its inspection, unless a privilege is claimed or the document is not in the party's possession. The court found no basis to dispense with compliance with these rules in the present case.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Rule 14.02 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) (“FCC Rules”) provides:Declaration to allow discovery(1) A declaration may be made under subsection 45(1) of the Act to allow discovery on the application of a party or on the Court’s own motion.(2) If a declaration is made, the Court or a Registrar may make an order for disclosure:(a) generally; or(b) in relation to particular classes of documents; or(c) in relation to particular issues; or(d) by a specified date. Rule 14.10(1) of the FCC Rules provides that:If a document or affidavit filed by a party refers to another document, another party may request the party in writing for a copy of the document or to produce it for inspection. Rule.14.10(2) of the FCC Rules provides that:(2) The party requested to provide a copy of, or produce, a document must, within 4 days of the request, in writing to the party making the request:(a) provide a copy of the document or appoint a time within 7 days, and a place where, it may be inspected; or(b) claim that the document is privileged from production and state the grounds; or(c) state that the document is not in his or her possession, custody or power and state his or knowledge, information or belief about its whereabouts. Rule 15.28(1) of the FCC Rules provides that:A document to be used in conjunction with an affidavit must be annexed to the affidavit. In relation to r.14.10 of the FCC Rules the Court made the following observations in Faulkner v Tidewater Marine Australia Pty Ltd (No.3) [2016] FCCA 2918 (“Faulkner (No.3)”) at [30]-[34] per Judge Lucev:30. It is convenient to begin with a discussion of r.14.10(1) of the FCC Rules. Like the former Federal Court rule, O.15 r.10(1) of the Federal Court Rules 1976 (Cth) it refers to an affidavit which “refers” to another document.31. For relevant purposes “refer” means:To send or direct (a person) to a person, a book or its author for informationThe Shorter Oxford English Dictionary on Historical Principles (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1973) page 1776.32. In Flick, Federal Court Practice (accessed online at at FCR 20.31.60 the learned author observes as follows:There is little authority on the question as to when a pleading or affidavit “refers to” a document. In King v GIO Australia Holdings Ltd (2001) FCA 1487 Moore J cited Smith v Harris (1883) 48 LT 869. The pleadings there spoke of “invoices, letters, bill heads, and brands on casks”. A notice was served seeking the production of those documents. The application was resisted by the plaintiff on the basis that the rule operated only on documents which were identified in the pleadings or particularly described. Chitty J rejected this submission and concluded:It is said, that that is only a general reference to documents, but, in my opinion, that is both a general reference and also a special reference to each and every bill head and each and every letter; because the plaintiff, instead of setting out each document separately, refers to them compendiously, but that is no reason why inspection should not be allowed.In Betfair Ptv Ltd v Racing New South Wales (No 2) [20091 FCA 195 at [11] it was said that Federal Court Rules O 15 r 10 was intended to give the opposite party the same advantage, with respect to documents referred to in pleadings or an affidavit, as if the documents were set out in the pleading or affidavit. It was there not necessary to decide whether a notice to produce issued under Federal Court Rules O 15 r 10(1) could be set aside on the ground that the applicant already had the documents requested in its possession, custody or power and that production would thereby be futile or oppressive : at [16]. Perram J there observed that there is “a forensic benefit in being able to review a document relied upon by another party even [though] that party may believe it is the same as a document that is already held by the first party”.33. The Court agrees with the thrust of submissions made by Tidewater that the requirement in r.14.10(1) of the FCC Rules for a document to be referred to requires that document to be, at the very least, mentioned in the relevant affidavit. A document the existence of which it is necessary to imply from a consideration of the text of an affidavit is not a document referred to in the affidavit.34. Because of the use of the word “must” in r.14.10(2) of the FCC Rules where, as here, the request has been made to provide a copy of or produce the document referred to in one of the categories of document referred to in an affidavit referred to in the application in a case, as set out above, then it is mandatory for a copy of that document to be provided to the party requesting it, or for it to be produced for inspection as requested. This is because the use of “must” ordinarily imports a mandatory requirement: Pitrau v Barrick Mining Services Pty Ltd [2012] FMCA 186; (2012) 259 FLR 447; (2012) 219 IR 208; (2012) 64 AILR 101-563 at [23]-28] per Lucev FM (“Pitrau”), and the High Court, Full Court of the Federal Court, South Australian Supreme Court and Federal Magistrates Court of Australia cases there referred to, save where, in respect of Court Rules, compliance may be dispensed with: Burrell v Reavill Farm Pty Ltd & Ors [2014] FCCA 1449; (2014) 286 FLR 310. In this case there is no basis for dispensing with compliance with the provisions of r.14.10 of the FCC Rules, and indeed, such dispensation is not sought.