Ellahi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ellahi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2025] FCA 549

File number(s): NSD 551 of 2022
Judgment of: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 27 May 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – where applicant’s third student visa application refused on the ground he had given, or caused to be given, a bogus document – where applicant seeks a declaration that his student visa application was invalid by reason of his agent fraudulently giving the bogus document to the Department without his authority – where three-year limitation imposed by PIC 4020(2) of Schedule 4 of the Migration Regulations on applicant’s capacity to apply for the same visa by reason of the bogus document had expired – where applicant more than happy to return to Pakistan – where no finding by the delegate that the applicant was aware that the document was bogus – where the declaration would serve no useful purpose and should be refused in the exercise of discretion – where applicant in any event failed to establish that he was not recklessly indifferent to whether his agent used unlawful or dishonest means to apply for his third student visa – application dismissed
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 21(1)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5(1), 46, 47(3), 48(1)(b)(i)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), clause 500.217 of Schedule 2, PIC 4020 of Schedule 4

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564

Australian Society of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery Limited v Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency [2024] FCA 995

Bass v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd [1999] HCA 9; (1999) 198 CLR 334

Blatch v Archer (1774) 1 Cowp 63; (1774) 98 ER 969

Forster v Jododex Australia Pty Ltd (1972) 127 CLR 421

Gill v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 142; (2016) 248 FCR 398

Katragadda v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 143

Kaur v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCA 212

Kaur v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] HCATrans 229

Kaur v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] FCA 1026

Maharjan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 258 FCR 1; [2017] FCAFC 213

Mohammed v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 767

National Australia Bank Ltd v Nautilus Insurance Pte Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCA 1543; (2019) 377 ALR 627

S & V Nominees Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Rabobank Australia (Formerly known as Primary Industry Bank of Australia Limited) (No 2) [2011] FCA 1039

Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 261 FCR 556; [2018] FCAFC 52

Trivedi v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 220 FCR 169

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 118
Date of last submission/s: 5 November 2024
Date of hearing: 11 March 2024
12 March 2024
30 April 2024
9 October 2024
30 October 2024  
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ellahi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 549
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ellahi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship involves the applicant, Mr. Ellahi, who had his third student visa application refused by the Department. The primary issue before the court was whether the applicant's third student visa application was invalid due to his agent fraudulently providing a bogus document. The court was also required to determine if the applicant could be granted a declaration that his visa application was invalid by reason of his agent's fraudulent conduct, despite the three-year limitation period imposed by PIC 4020(2) of Schedule 4 of the Migration Regulations having expired. Additionally, the court had to decide whether the applicant had established that he was not recklessly indifferent to whether his agent used unlawful or dishonest means to apply for his third student visa.

The court found that the applicant had indeed provided a bogus document, which was an account maintenance certificate fraudulently issued by ICIBL. However, the court also noted that there was no finding by the delegate that the applicant was aware that the document was bogus. The court further found that the applicant had not established that he was not recklessly indifferent to whether his agent used unlawful or dishonest means to apply for his third student visa. The court considered the declaration sought by the applicant to serve no useful purpose and declined to exercise its discretion in favour of the applicant. Therefore, the application was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs. The court also noted that the evidence given by the applicant on 9 October 2024 at transcript page 32 lines 10 to 20 is prohibited from publication and may not be used in any other proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The name of the respondent be changed to ‘Minister for Immigration and Citizenship’.

2. The application is dismissed.

3. The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs as agreed or assessed.

4. Subject to further order, pursuant to section 37AF(1)(b)(i) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), on the ground set out in section 37AG(1)(a) of that Act, the evidence given by the applicant on 9 October 2024 at transcript page 32 lines 10 to 20 is prohibited from publication and may not be used in any other proceeding.

5. Unless the parties are agreed and provide an agreed submission on the issue:

(a) on or before 4pm on 9 June 2025, the applicant is to file and serve submissions (limited to 5 pages) and any evidence on whether order 4 of these orders should be extended and if so, on what basis;

(b) on or before 4pm on 23 June 2025, the respondent is to file and serve submissions (limited to 5 pages) and any evidence in response; and

(c) on or before 4pm on 30 June 2025, the applicant is to file and serve any submission (limited to 3 pages) and evidence in reply.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

6. Order 4 of these orders extends the protection that had been afforded to the applicant until the delivery of final judgment by order 1 of the orders made on 30 October 2024.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I note that these matters may have a bearing on the quantum of costs properly recoverable on a taxation, should that ultimately be necessary. 2. BACKGROUND Save where I otherwise identify, the facts below are drawn from the statement of agreed facts. 2.1 Mr Ellahi’s first student visa in 2015 Mr Ellahi completed High School in Pakistan in 2012/2013. In January 2013, Mr Ellahi completed three of fourteen modules of a “Certificate of Accounting” in Pakistan and was awarded a “Diploma in Accounting and Business” at the Pakistan Association of Chartered Certified Accountants. On 20 September 2014, Mr Ellahi obtained satisfactory results in the International English Language Testing System (IELTS). Mr Ellahi’s first application for a student visa was arranged by an agent in Pakistan and was received by the Department on 31 December 2014 (the first visa application). On 22 February 2015, Mr Ellahi arrived in Australia on his first student visa, being a student visa Subclass 500. He was enrolled in accounting and commerce at Raffles College of Design and Commerce in Parramatta. On 15 May 2015, Mr Ellahi completed two subjects at Raffles in the first semester of the Bachelor of Commerce, achieving a Pass and Distinction.2.2 Mr Ellahi’s first contact with Mr Khan of Roots in 2015 It is agreed that later in 2015, Mr Ellahi met Muhammad Arif Khan of Roots Education Consultants at Group College Australia (GCA). It is also agreed that: (1)at no time has Mr Khan been registered as a Migration Agent by the Authority;(2)at no time has Roots been registered as a Migration Agent by the Authority; and(3)Mr Ellahi did not enter into any written agreements with Mr Khan or Roots. However, the circumstances of Mr Ellahi’s first meeting with Mr Khan in 2015 were put in issue by the respondent. I accept that there is doubt about whether Mr Ellahi in fact received a $300 discount from Mr Khan (which was one reason identified by Mr Ellahi for engaging Mr Khan). Notwithstanding that and my concerns generally about Mr Ellahi’s credibility (as explained later), I otherwise accept as plausible and credible Mr Ellahi’s evidence as to why he engaged Mr Khan, as opposed to the hundreds of other advertised agents. First, Mr Ellahi gave evidence that some of his classmates from Raffles had already engaged Mr Khan. Secondly, Mr Ellahi could speak with Mr Khan in his native language, Urdu, which is a particularly compelling reason in my view. Thirdly, I accept that Mr Ellahi conducted his own research into Mr Khan on the internet before engaging him and that his online inquiries gave him some comfort about engaging Mr Khan, including because Roots was identified as being on the list of GCA Representative Agents. In this regard, I note that there was some confusion as to the order in which Mr Ellahi undertook this research, that is, whether it preceded his first meeting with Mr Khan or alternatively whether it came later as was suggested in cross-examination. However, overall Mr Ellahi’s evidence was sufficiently clear and persuasive that Mr Khan gave him a business card with his website and Facebook page at their initial meeting and that Mr Ellahi then undertook his own research into Mr Khan on the internet.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 13 August 2021, the Department sent a letter to the 284 Gmail address, refusing the third visa application, and enclosing the delegate’s Decision Record (refusal decision). It is agreed that Ms Khalil sent the refusal decision to Mr Ellahi on 26 September 2021. As earlier explained, the delegate refused the granting of a third student visa on the ground that the criterion in clause 500.217(1) of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations – that an applicant satisfy PIC 4020 – was not met. PIC 4020(1)(a) of Schedule 4 to the Migration Regulations, in turn, relevantly provides that: (1)There is no evidence before the Minister that the applicant has given, or caused to be given, to the Minister … a bogus document … in relation to:(a) the application for the visa; The delegate found that there was evidence before the Minister that Mr Ellahi had given, or caused to be given, a “bogus document” for the purposes of PIC 4020(1) of Schedule 4 to the Migration Regulations. The Department, in the June 2021 letter and the refusal decision, identified the bogus document as an account maintenance certificate purportedly issued by ICIBL on 14 February 2020. A bogus document is defined in s 5(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) as follows:bogus document, in relation to a person, means a document that the Minister reasonably suspects is a document that:(a)purports to have been, but was not, issued in respect of the person; or(b)is counterfeit or has been altered by a person who does not have authority to do so; or(c)was obtained because of a false or misleading statement, whether or not made knowingly. Mr Ellahi accepts that the account maintenance certificate identified in the June 2021 letter and the refusal decision is fraudulent and thus a “bogus document” as defined in the Migration Act. Mr Ellahi contends that, after hearing “nothing further about his student visa” following the receipt of the bridging visa on 15 February 2020, he subsequently conducted his own research through the Visa Entitlement Verification Online (VEVO) system and discovered that he no longer had a visa. On 24 September 2021, Mr Ellahi sent a WhatsApp message to Ms Khalil with a screenshot of the relevant VEVO page that showed that he did not have a visa. Subsequently, on 26 September 2021, Ms Khalil provided Mr Ellahi with the June 2021 letter, the refusal decision, and the login details for the second ImmiAccount. I note here that Mr Ellahi made a complaint to police about Ms Khalil’s fraudulent conduct sometime in 2022: see T-32.45.2.8 Mr Ellahi’s studies in 2020 and 2021 Mr Ellahi was enrolled in a Graduate Certificate of Business Management & Graduate Diploma in Strategic Leadership at Lennox College between 24 February 2020 and 20 February 2022. On 25 April 2021, Mr Ellahi qualified for a Graduate Certificate in Business Management (Learning) at Lennox. On 10 July 2021, Mr Ellahi commenced studying for a Diploma in Strategic Leadership at Lennox. Mr Ellahi completed the first module in the Diploma on 20 September 2021, and the second module in the Diploma on 5 December 2021. 2.9 Proceedings in the former Administrative Appeals Tribunal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A bogus document is defined in s 5(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) as follows:bogus document, in relation to a person, means a document that the Minister reasonably suspects is a document that:(a)purports to have been, but was not, issued in respect of the person; or(b)is counterfeit or has been altered by a person who does not have authority to do so; or(c)was obtained because of a false or misleading statement, whether or not made knowingly. Mr Ellahi accepts that the account maintenance certificate identified in the June 2021 letter and the refusal decision is fraudulent and thus a “bogus document” as defined in the Migration Act. Mr Ellahi contends that, after hearing “nothing further about his student visa” following the receipt of the bridging visa on 15 February 2020, he subsequently conducted his own research through the Visa Entitlement Verification Online (VEVO) system and discovered that he no longer had a visa. On 24 September 2021, Mr Ellahi sent a WhatsApp message to Ms Khalil with a screenshot of the relevant VEVO page that showed that he did not have a visa. Subsequently, on 26 September 2021, Ms Khalil provided Mr Ellahi with the June 2021 letter, the refusal decision, and the login details for the second ImmiAccount. I note here that Mr Ellahi made a complaint to police about Ms Khalil’s fraudulent conduct sometime in 2022: see T-32.45.2.8 Mr Ellahi’s studies in 2020 and 2021 Mr Ellahi was enrolled in a Graduate Certificate of Business Management & Graduate Diploma in Strategic Leadership at Lennox College between 24 February 2020 and 20 February 2022. On 25 April 2021, Mr Ellahi qualified for a Graduate Certificate in Business Management (Learning) at Lennox. On 10 July 2021, Mr Ellahi commenced studying for a Diploma in Strategic Leadership at Lennox. Mr Ellahi completed the first module in the Diploma on 20 September 2021, and the second module in the Diploma on 5 December 2021. 2.9 Proceedings in the former Administrative Appeals Tribunal On 29 September 2021, Mr Ellahi lodged an application for merits review in the former Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to review the delegate’s decision (the AAT application). However, on 11 January 2022, the AAT dismissed the AAT application on the ground that it lacked jurisdiction because the time limit for commencing proceedings in the AAT had expired on 3 September 2021. 2.10 Proceedings in the High Court and remittal to this Court On 11 March 2022, Mr Ellahi filed an application in the High Court, seeking (1) an extension of time for making a judicial review application, (2) a writ of certiorari to quash the delegate’s decision of 13 August 2021, and (3) a writ of mandamus requiring the respondent to determine the third student visa application according to law. It was common ground in this regard that the delegate’s decision could only be challenged in the High Court. In the alternative to the constitutional writs directed to the delegate’s decision of 13 August 2021, Mr Ellahi sought a declaration that the third visa application was invalid on the basis of the fraud of Ms Khalil. On 23 May 2022, the High Court remitted the claim for declaratory relief to this Court.3. DISCRETION TO GRANT DECLARATORY RELIEF 3.1 The issue before this Court