Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Elizabeth Joyce O'Connor v John Estens & Anor [2014] NSWSC 95 Hearing dates: 14 February 2014 Decision date: 14 February 2014 Before: Kunc J Decision: Notice of motion and Summons dismissed
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Settlement agreement substantially performed but no provision for disposition of proceedings - No further utility in proceedings - Proceedings dismissed with no order as to costs Legislation Cited: Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 (NSW) Category: Principal judgment Parties: Elizabeth Joyce O'Connor (Plaintiff)
John and Annette Estens (Defendants)Representation: Ms Kim O'Donnell (Solicitor) (Plaintiff)
Mr M Estens (by telephone) (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2009/287961 Publication restriction: No
EX TEMPORE Judgment
HIS HONOUR: The plaintiff, Ms O'Connor, and the defendants, Mr and Mrs Estens, were neighbours in Namoi Street, Coonabarabran. In 2009 a boundary dispute erupted between them which led to the commencement of these proceedings by a Summons filed 11 March 2009. The Summons sought the following relief:
1. An order that:
(a) The Defendants transfer to the Plaintiff that part of the land comprised in Lot 1 of Section 4 in Deposited Plan 758281 on which the encroachment is erected (the "Subject Land"); or
(b) In the alternative, an easement for continuance of the encroachment on the Subject Land; and
(c) A declaration of compensation in favour of the Defendants for the Subject Land.
2. An injunction to stop the Defendants from erecting a dividing fence in a position that would detrimentally affect the Plaintiff's ability to access her property.
3. An order that the Defendants reinstate the dividing fence removed by them pending the outcome of proceedings.
4. That the Summons be referred to the Supreme Court Equity Duty Judge and dealt with on an ex parte basis.
5. Costs.
The proceedings ultimately were the subject of a mediation. An agreement was entered into between the parties on 16 December 2009 (the "agreement").
1. The Parties agree that a copy of this agreement may be provided to their legal advisers otherwise these Heads/Terms of Agreement are not to be disclosed.
2. Estens are to sign all documents to apply to purchase a strip of Crown land 7m x 71.41m adjacent to 21 Namoi Street, Coonabarabran ("the Application").
3. O'Connor to pay all costs associated with the Application including but not limited to application fee, surveyor, purchase price of Crown land, stamp duty on Crown land, registration fees, production fees on certificates of title and legal costs.
4. Ptolemy Legal to have carriage of the Application.
5. Pending determination of the Application by the Department of Lands:
(a) the Colourbond fence erected between 19 and 21 Namoi Streets to be removed and O'Connor permitted to access existing driveway and garage
(b) Supreme Court Proceedings No. 1880 of 2009 to be stood out of the Equity List
6. Should the Application be successful:
(a) Estens to transfer strip of land 2.26m x 86.58m to O'Connor for consideration of $1.00
(b) O'Connor to pay stamp duty based on land…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Elizabeth Joyce O'Connor v John Estens and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NSWSC 95
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether, given the substantial performance of the settlement agreement, the proceedings had any further utility. It assessed whether dismissing the proceedings would be appropriate under the circumstances and whether an order for costs should be made. The court determined that since the settlement agreement had been substantially performed and no further utility could be derived from the proceedings, the case could be dismissed without any costs order.
The court found that dismissing the proceedings was the appropriate course of action, as the primary purpose of the litigation had been fulfilled through the substantial performance of the settlement agreement. The court concluded that there was no need for a further order regarding costs, given the circumstances of the case.
The final order was for the proceedings to be dismissed with no order as to costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following a settlement agreement being reached between the parties. Both parties filed an application to have the proceedings dismissed, arguing that there was no further need to continue with the litigation since the settlement agreement had been substantially performed. The court considered the submissions and agreed that there was no further utility in maintaining the proceedings. Consequently, the court dismissed the proceedings without making any order as to costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proceedings should be dismissed due to the substantial performance of the settlement agreement and the lack of utility in continuing the litigation.
2. Whether there should be any order as to costs in light of the dismissal of the proceedings.
Held
1. The court concluded that the proceedings should be dismissed due to the substantial performance of the settlement agreement and the lack of utility in continuing the litigation. As a result, the proceedings were dismissed.
2. In light of the dismissal of the proceedings, the court decided there should be no order as to costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing whether the proceedings should be dismissed. It was established that the settlement agreement had been substantially performed, meaning that both parties had fulfilled their primary obligations under the agreement. However, the agreement did not contain any provisions regarding the disposition of the proceedings themselves. Given this, the court considered whether there was any further utility in continuing the litigation. The court determined that there was no further purpose to be served by the proceedings, as both parties had fulfilled their obligations under the agreement, and the only remaining issues were procedural in nature. Consequently, the court found that there was no further utility in continuing the litigation and dismissed the proceedings.
Next, the court examined whether there should be any order as to costs. The court noted that the dismissal of the proceedings was due to the substantial performance of the settlement agreement and the lack of utility in continuing the litigation. Since both parties had substantially performed the agreement, and there was no clear provision in the agreement addressing the costs, the court decided that it would be inappropriate to make any order as to costs. Therefore, the court dismissed the proceedings with no order as to costs. This decision aligns with the principle that costs should not be awarded when there is no clear basis for doing so, particularly where both parties have substantially performed their obligations under an agreement.