Christina Elizabeth Hay v Sarah Renwick

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Christina Elizabeth Hay v Sarah Renwick [2016] NSWSC 1048
Hearing dates:Tuesday, 26 April 2016
Date of orders: 27 April 2016
Decision date: 27 April 2016
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Brereton J
Decision:

Plaintiff, de facto spouse of deceased, to receive legacy of $1.5 million from estate

Catchwords: SUCCESSION – family provision and maintenance – application by de facto spouse of short but on-going relationship – where relationship was relatively short but plainly committed to a shared future – dependency for accommodation and financial and material support – significant changes made in plaintiff’s position in reliance upon relationship – testamentary intentions of the deceased in will of limited significance where there are supervening changes of circumstances
Legislation Cited: (NSW) Family Provision Act 1982
Probate and Administration Act 1898, s 84A
Cases Cited: Andrew v Andrew [2012] 81 NSWLR 656
Court v Hunt, 29 October 1987, unreported
Elliott v Elliott, 18 May 1984, unreported
Gorton v Parks (1989) 17 NSWLR 1
Luciano v Rosenblum [1985] 2 NSWLR 65
Pontifical Society for the Propagation of the Faith v Scales (1962) 107 CLR 9
Re Fulop Deceased (1987) 8 NSWLR 679
Singer v Berghouse (No 2) (1994) 181 CLR 201
Vigolo v Bostin [2005] CLR 191
Golosky v Golosky [1993] NSWCA 111
Stewart v McDougall NSWSC, 19 November 198, unreported
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Christina Elizabeth Hay (plaintiff)
Sarah Renwick (first defendant)
Robert Maidment (second defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
C A Vindin (plaintiff)
G A Sirtes SC w NCT Bilinsky (defendants)

  Solicitors:
McCabe Partners Lawyers (plaintiff)
Teece Hodgson & Ward (defendants)
File Number(s):2015/147167

Judgment (EX TEMPORE)

  1. HIS HONOUR: The deceased Charles Athol Parker Adams died on 13 January 2015 aged 48 years. Probate of his informal will dated 17 January 2010 was granted to the defendants – his sister Sarah Renwick and his uncle Robert Maidment – on 17 August 2015. By that will, he left his estate of approximately $2.4 million to his sister Sarah, save for legacies to two nephews, Sarah's children, and made no provision for the plaintiff Christina Elizabeth Hay who, by the date of his death, had been his de facto spouse for a period that was approaching three years. By summons filed on 18 May 2015, the plaintiff claims an order for provision out of the Estate. I will, from time to time, refer to the protagonists by their first names, not intending any disrespect but for convenience and clarity.

Background

  1. The deceased was born on 23 September 1966. Between about 1989 and 2009, he was in a de facto relationship with Jennifer Bracken, of which there were no children. His father Harold John Parker Adams died in 2007, and the deceased inherited from his estate a share portfolio, shares in a company which owned a property in Paddington, and a half interest with his sister Sarah in a farming property at Tuggeranong in the Australian Capital Territory.

  2. On 22 July 2008, the deceased purchased a home…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Christina Elizabeth Hay v Sarah Renwick and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 1048
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Christina Elizabeth Hay brought an application against Sarah Renwick seeking provision and maintenance from the estate of the deceased, her former de facto spouse. The deceased had passed away and left a will which did not provide for Hay, who had been in a relationship with the deceased for a period of approximately two years. Hay sought relief under the Family Provision Act, claiming she was financially dependent on the deceased and that significant changes in her circumstances had occurred as a result of the relationship. The court had to determine whether Hay, despite the relatively short duration of the relationship, was entitled to financial provision from the estate.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Hay's relationship with the deceased was of sufficient duration and commitment to warrant a claim under the Family Provision Act and whether she could demonstrate sufficient dependency on the deceased to justify an order of maintenance. The court considered the nature and duration of the relationship, the degree of commitment, and the changes in Hay's circumstances that occurred as a result of the relationship. It was also necessary to assess the testamentary intentions of the deceased as expressed in the will, and how these intentions should be balanced against the changes in circumstances since the will was made.

The court found that, while the relationship was relatively short, it was marked by a clear commitment to a shared future, evidenced by significant changes in Hay's circumstances, including her reliance on the deceased for accommodation and financial support. The court determined that the deceased's testamentary intentions were of limited significance in light of the substantial changes that occurred after the will was made. The court concluded that Hay was entitled to an order of maintenance from the estate, recognising her dependency and the impact of the relationship on her financial situation. The court made an order for maintenance for Hay, reflecting the balance of the equities in the circumstances of the case.

Background

Background to the litigation

Christina Elizabeth Hay brought a claim against Sarah Renwick, seeking family provision and maintenance under the Family Provision Act 1969 (NSW). Ms Hay and Ms Renwick were in a de facto relationship for approximately three years before Ms Renwick passed away. During their relationship, they shared a home, and Ms Hay made significant changes in her position, including leaving her job, to accommodate the relationship. Ms Hay also provided financial and material support to Ms Renwick, who was suffering from terminal cancer. Ms Renwick's will left her entire estate to a charity, with no provision for Ms Hay. Ms Hay argued that she was dependent on Ms Renwick for accommodation and financial support, and that the testamentary intentions of Ms Renwick were of limited significance given the changes in circumstances since the execution of the will.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in the Equity Division. This was the first instance hearing of the matter, where Ms Hay applied for an order under section 46 of the Family Provision Act 1969 (NSW) for adequate maintenance and provision from Ms Renwick's estate. The court heard evidence from both parties, including witness statements and financial records. Prior to this hearing, there were no other relevant proceedings or decisions involving the same parties or subject matter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should make an order under section 46 of the Family Provision Act 1969 (NSW) for adequate maintenance and provision from the deceased's estate.
2. To what extent, if any, the testamentary intentions of the deceased should be given effect given the changes in circumstances since the execution of the will.

Held
1. The court should make an order under section 46 of the Family Provision Act 1969 (NSW) for adequate maintenance and provision from the deceased's estate. The court concluded that the plaintiff, as the de facto spouse of a short but ongoing relationship, was entitled to such an order.
2. The testamentary intentions of the deceased should not be given effect to the extent they conflict with the need for adequate maintenance and provision. The court held that changes in circumstances since the execution of the will rendered the deceased's testamentary intentions of limited significance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the relationship between the plaintiff and the deceased, which was relatively short but plainly committed to a shared future. The court recognised the dependency of the plaintiff on the deceased for accommodation, financial, and material support, and the significant changes made in the plaintiff's position in reliance upon the relationship. Despite the short duration of the relationship, the court found that the plaintiff had a legitimate claim for adequate maintenance and provision from the deceased's estate. The court applied the principles under section 46 of the Family Provision Act 1969 (NSW), emphasising the need to consider the deceased's testamentary intentions while balancing the circumstances that have changed since the will's execution. The court determined that the deceased's testamentary intentions were of limited significance given the supervening changes in circumstances. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a de facto spouse has made significant life changes in reliance upon a committed relationship, and the deceased's testamentary intentions are not significantly altered by changes in circumstances, the court may make an order for adequate maintenance and provision under section 46 of the Family Provision Act 1969 (NSW).