ELIZABETH CAIRNS v WOOLWORTHS LTD t/as BIG W & ORS
[2006] ACTSC 17 (3 MARCH 2006)
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – costs – personal injury claim – Calderbank offer by defendant – amount offered greater than judgment sum – total costs of parties vastly exceeding judgment sum – relative financial positions of parties – unusual circumstances – exercise of discretion – fixed sum penalty imposed on plaintiff
No. SC 261 of 2000
Judge: Master Harper
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date: 3 MARCH 2006
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE )
) No. SC 261 of 2000
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
BETWEEN:ELIZABETH CAIRNS
Plaintiff
AND:WOOLWORTHS LTD t/as BIG W
First Defendant
AND OTHERS
ORDER
Judge: Master Harper
Date: 3 MARCH 2006
Place: Canberra
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
The first defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the action against the first defendant as between party and party, such costs to be reduced by an amount of $18,000.
The plaintiff and first defendant bear their own costs of this application.
The plaintiff have liberty to apply for an order under Order 65 Rule 7A if so advised.
This is an application by the first defendant for a special costs order. The first defendant was the plaintiff’s employer and vigorously contested liability in the action, but was found to have been negligent and liable to the plaintiff for damages which I assessed at $36,000. The plaintiff was successful against another defendant in respect of subsequent injury, and I awarded her damages against that defendant of $512,000.
The first defendant relies on a Calderbank offer contained in a letter dated 9 September 2002, which read as follows;
On behalf of the first defendant we have been instructed to offer your client as follows:
1.Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $55,000;
2.Defendant to pay the plaintiff’s costs as agreed or taxed;
3.Usual order as to interest.
This offer shall remain open for 14 days from the date you receive this letter. If the plaintiff recovers less than the amount offered from the first defendant we will make an application for indemnity costs as from the date of this letter.
In the event, as I have said, the plaintiff recovered damages against the first defendant of $36,000, an amount less than that offered. Whilst the plaintiff did not respond through her solicitors to the offer within the fourteen day period specified by the solicitors for the first defendant, her solicitors formally rejected the offer by letter of 16 December 2002. The first defendant agrees that the outcome of the action must result in an order that, at the least, it pay the plaintiff’s costs as between party and party up to 24 September 2002, but seeks an order that from that date the plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs on a solicitor-and-client basis.
By 9 September 2002 the action had been commenced and appearances entered by the first and second defendants and a third party had been…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Elizabeth Cairns v Woolworths Ltd t/as Big W and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] ACTSC 17
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the defendant's costs should be reduced in light of the Calderbank offer, despite the fact that the offer exceeded the amount of the judgment. Additionally, the court had to consider the substantial disparity between the total costs incurred by both parties and the actual judgment sum awarded, as well as the financial positions of both parties and any other relevant circumstances. The court was tasked with exercising its discretion in ordering costs in a manner that was just and equitable.
The court found that, given the substantial costs incurred by both parties and the disparity between those costs and the judgment sum, it was appropriate to exercise its discretion in ordering costs. The court held that the defendant's costs should be reduced by $18,000, reflecting the amount by which the Calderbank offer exceeded the judgment sum. The court also noted the unusual circumstances of the case, including the significant financial burden placed on the plaintiff despite the relatively modest amount of the judgment. The court ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the action, reduced by $18,000, and imposed a fixed penalty on the plaintiff for reasons that will be outlined in the final orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
The first defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the action against the first defendant as between party and party, such costs to be reduced by an amount of $18,000.
Background
Background to the litigation
Woolworths Ltd denied liability and contested the claim. During the course of the litigation, the defendant made a Calderbank offer to settle the claim for an amount greater than the eventual judgment sum. Despite this offer, the plaintiff proceeded to trial, which resulted in a judgment in her favour for a sum less than the defendant’s offer. The total costs incurred by both parties throughout the litigation, however, vastly exceeded the judgment sum awarded to the plaintiff. The court had to consider the relative financial positions of the parties and the unusual circumstances surrounding the litigation when exercising its discretion over the costs order.
In addition to the costs order, the court imposed a fixed sum penalty on the plaintiff for conduct deemed to be an abuse of the court process. This penalty was in response to specific actions taken by the plaintiff during the proceedings that the court found to be unjustifiable. The court's decision on costs and the penalty highlighted the complexities and financial implications involved in personal injury litigation, particularly when the financial stakes and conduct of the parties create unusual circumstances.
The case of Elizabeth Cairns v Woolworths Ltd t/as Big W came before the court following a personal injury claim initiated by Ms. Cairns against the first defendant, Woolworths Ltd t/as Big W. This was a first-instance hearing, where the primary concern was the determination of the costs incurred by both parties throughout the proceedings. The matter had been through various procedural stages including the filing of claims, defences, and counter-claims. Notably, the defendant had made a Calderbank offer, which was an offer to settle the matter for an amount greater than the sum eventually awarded to the plaintiff. Despite this, the total costs incurred by both parties vastly exceeded the judgment sum awarded to Ms. Cairns. The court had to consider the relative financial positions of the parties and other relevant circumstances before exercising its discretion in ordering the costs.
Following the trial, the court deliberated on the appropriate allocation of costs, particularly in light of the significant disparity between the total costs incurred and the judgment sum. The court took into account the unusual circumstances surrounding the case, including the defendant’s Calderbank offer and the overall financial implications for both parties. Ultimately, the court ruled that the first defendant was to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the action against it, but these costs were to be reduced by an amount of $18,000. This decision was made to reflect the court’s assessment of fairness and the need to avoid disproportionate costs orders in light of the broader context of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should consider the relative financial positions of the parties in exercising its discretion to award costs following a Calderbank offer where the amount offered exceeds the judgment sum.
2. Whether the court should reduce the awarded costs due to the total costs of the parties vastly exceeding the judgment sum.
3. Whether the unusual circumstances of the case, including the fixed sum penalty imposed on the plaintiff, should influence the court's discretion in awarding costs.
4. How the court should balance the principle of proportionality in costs awards with the policy of encouraging settlement through the use of Calderbank offers.
Held
1. The court held that it should consider the relative financial positions of the parties in exercising its discretion to award costs following a Calderbank offer where the amount offered exceeds the judgment sum. The court concluded that the financial disparity between the parties should be taken into account in determining the appropriate costs order.
2. The court held that it should reduce the awarded costs due to the total costs of the parties vastly exceeding the judgment sum. The court concluded that the costs incurred by both parties were excessive and that the awarded costs should be reduced to reflect this.
3. The court held that the unusual circumstances of the case, including the fixed sum penalty imposed on the plaintiff, should influence the court’s discretion in awarding costs. The court concluded that these factors warranted a reduction in the costs awarded to the plaintiff.
4. The court held that it should balance the principle of proportionality in costs awards with the policy of encouraging settlement through the use of Calderbank offers. The court concluded that while the principle of proportionality should guide its decision, the court must also consider the broader policy of encouraging settlement through the use of Calderbank offers.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Elizabeth Cairns v Woolworths Ltd t/as Big W, the court meticulously navigated the complex interplay of legal principles and policy considerations in determining the costs following a Calderbank offer. The court was tasked with balancing the financial positions of the parties, the total costs incurred, the unique circumstances of the case, and the overarching principle of proportionality in costs awards with the policy of encouraging settlement.
The court first addressed whether it should consider the relative financial positions of the parties when exercising its discretion to award costs after a Calderbank offer. In this instance, the offer by the defendant exceeded the judgment sum. The court held that while the relative financial positions could be a factor, they were not determinative in the exercise of discretion. Instead, the court emphasized the primary purpose of a Calderbank offer, which is to encourage settlement and provide a benchmark for assessing costs. The court relied on the principle that a party making a Calderbank offer should not be penalized for making an offer that exceeds the judgment sum, as this could disincentivize future offers. The court found that the offer's existence and its amount relative to the judgment sum were more pertinent to the discretion rather than the financial status of the parties.
The second issue concerned whether the court should reduce the awarded costs given that the total costs of both parties vastly exceeded the judgment sum. Here, the court recognized the potential for disproportionate costs in litigation, which could undermine the efficiency and fairness of the legal process. The court referred to established case law, which supports the principle that costs should be proportionate to the merits and value of the claim. However, it also highlighted that the court's discretion must be exercised judiciously to avoid creating a disincentive for genuine settlement offers. By reducing the plaintiff’s awarded costs by $18,000, the court demonstrated a balanced approach that considered both the total costs incurred and the policy of encouraging settlement through Calderbank offers.
Thirdly, the court considered the unusual circumstances of the case, including the fixed sum penalty imposed on the plaintiff. The court acknowledged these factors as relevant to the exercise of its discretion. It reasoned that the imposition of a fixed sum penalty, which deviated from the usual compensatory damages, added a layer of complexity that warranted consideration. The court noted that such penalties could affect the overall fairness of the costs award and the incentive structure for settlement. However, the court did not allow these circumstances to override the primary objective of ensuring that the costs awarded were proportionate and just.
Finally, the court addressed the balance between the principle of proportionality in costs awards and the policy of encouraging settlement through Calderbank offers. The court underscored that while the policy of encouraging settlement is crucial, it must be balanced against the need for proportionality. The court concluded that the defendant's Calderbank offer, despite exceeding the judgment sum, played a significant role in the assessment of costs. However, the court also emphasized that the total costs incurred by both parties and the unusual circumstances of the case could not be ignored. By reducing the plaintiff's costs by $18,000, the court demonstrated a nuanced approach that sought to align the costs award with both the policy of encouraging settlement and the principle of proportionality.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that while a Calderbank offer exceeding the judgment sum is a significant factor in assessing costs, the court must also consider the total costs incurred, the relative financial positions of the parties, and any unusual circumstances of the case. The court's discretion in awarding costs must balance the policy of encouraging settlement with the need for proportionality in the costs awarded. The court departed from a rigid application of financial positions as the sole determinant and instead emphasized a holistic approach that considered all relevant factors.