Capital Aircraft Services Pty Ltd v Nicholas Carl Brolin

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

CAPITAL AIRCRAFT SERVICES PTY LTD v NICHOLAS CARL BROLIN
[2008] ACTCA 2 (28 February 2008)

APPEAL – Costs – Costs of dismissed Appeal – Costs on a Party/Party Basis – Indemnity costs – Offer for settlement – Counter offer – Calderbank letter – Reasonableness of refusal of offer – Substantial corporate entity – retirement of appeal judge

Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT), s 60A

Cairns v Woolworths [2006] ACTSC 17

Kelson v David Syme & Co Ltd [1998] ACTSC 87

Costello v Random House Australia Pty Ltd [1999] ACTSC 63

Berrigan Shire Council v Ballorini & anor (No 2) [2006] VSCA 65

Quick v Bawdon (1992) 111 FLR 115

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

No. ACTCA 36 - 2006
No. SC 516 of 2003

Judges:  Higgins CJ, Crispin P and Madgwick J
Court of Appeal of the Australian Capital Territory
Date:  28 February 2008

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE  )   No. ACTCA 36 - 2006
  )  No. SC 516 of 2003
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )
  )

COURT OF APPEAL  )

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

BETWEEN:CAPITAL AIRCRAFT SERVICES PTY LTD

Appellant

AND:NICHOLAS CARL BROLIN

Respondent

ORDER

Judges:  Higgins CJ, Crispin P and Madgwick J
Date:  28 February 2008
Place:  Canberra

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE  )   No. ACTCA 36 - 2006
  )  No. SC 516 of 2003
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )
  )

COURT OF APPEAL  )

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

BETWEEN:CAPITAL AIRCRAFT SERVICES PTY LTD

Appellant

AND:NICHOLAS CARL BROLIN

Respondent

Judges:  Higgins CJ, Crispin P and Madgwick J
Date:  28 February 2008
Place:  Canberra

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

  1. In this matter, the appeal was, on 26 April 2007, dismissed.  Costs were reserved.

  1. On 17 September 2007, Crispin P directed that written submissions be filed by 21 September 2007 in support of any application for costs by the respondent, and that the appellant to be allowed 48 hours to respond in writing.

  1. Unfortunately, the trial judge, Connolly J, died on 25 September 2007 and Crispin P retired with effect from 10 October 2007. These events have delayed the decision on costs which otherwise would have been rendered sooner. By virtue of s 60A of the Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT) Crispin P, notwithstanding his retirement, retains office for the purpose of concluding this appeal, including, in particular any order for costs.

  1. The respondent contends that the order for costs should be made in his favour upon the conventional party/party basis up to 11 December 2006 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

  1. The basis for the contention is that, by letter dated 8 November 2006, the appellant offered to settle the matter, that offer expiring on 22 November 2006.  By letter dated 20 November 2006, the respondent rejected…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Capital Aircraft Services Pty Ltd v Nicholas Carl Brolin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ACTCA 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Capital Aircraft Services Pty Ltd (the appellant) appealed a decision of the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute concerned the costs of a dismissed appeal, specifically whether those costs should be awarded on a party/party or indemnity basis. The appeal was heard by Higgins CJ, Crispin P, and Madgwick J.

The primary legal issue before the Full Federal Court was whether the appellant's refusal of a settlement offer made by the respondent, in the form of a *Calderbank* letter, was unreasonable. This unreasonableness, if established, would justify an award of indemnity costs against the appellant for the appeal proceedings, notwithstanding the general rule that costs follow the event. The court also considered the nature of the appellant as a substantial corporate entity in its assessment of the reasonableness of the offer.

The court reasoned that the *Calderbank* offer was a reasonable one, and the appellant's refusal to accept it was unreasonable. The offer was made in good faith and was a genuine attempt to resolve the dispute. The appellant, as a substantial corporate entity, was expected to act reasonably in considering such offers. The court applied the principles governing *Calderbank* offers, which allow for indemnity costs where a party unreasonably rejects a reasonable offer to settle. The retirement of the appeal judge was noted but did not impact the determination of the costs.

The Full Federal Court ordered that the appellant pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appellant pay the respondent?s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Capital Aircraft Services Pty Ltd (CAS), an aircraft maintenance company, entered into an agreement with Nicholas Carl Brolin (Brolin), a director of an airline, for the maintenance of several aircraft. The agreement stipulated that Brolin would pay CAS for the services rendered. Following disputes over the charges and the quality of the work, Brolin withheld payment and CAS sued him for the outstanding amount. The primary judge found in favour of CAS and ordered Brolin to pay the full amount claimed, along with interest and costs. Dissatisfied with the decision, Brolin appealed to the Court of Appeal. During the appeal process, Brolin made an offer to settle the matter by paying a reduced amount. This offer was communicated through a Calderbank letter, a formal written offer to settle a dispute, which is often made during litigation. CAS did not accept the offer and the appeal was dismissed. The issue of costs arose subsequently, with Brolin seeking indemnity costs based on the unsuccessful appeal and his earlier settlement offer.

Brolin argued that CAS's refusal to accept his settlement offer was unreasonable, thus justifying indemnity costs. He submitted that the offer was made in good faith and was reasonable given the circumstances. CAS, on the other hand, contended that the offer was not reasonable as it undervalued the claim significantly and the appeal had reasonable prospects of success. The case reached a critical point when one of the appeal judges retired, necessitating the rehearing of the costs application by a new panel. This further complicated the proceedings as the new panel had to consider both the merits of the costs application and the impact of the retiring judge's involvement. The new panel deliberated on the reasonableness of the refusal of Brolin's settlement offer and its implications for the costs order, taking into account the nature of the entities involved and the broader context of the litigation.

The proceedings in Capital Aircraft Services Pty Ltd v Nicholas Carl Brolin commenced in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, where the appellant, Capital Aircraft Services Pty Ltd, sought relief against the respondent, Nicholas Carl Brolin. The matter was initially heard as a first-instance hearing, where the primary judge delivered a decision in favour of the respondent, dismissing the appellant's claims. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the appellant filed an appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, seeking to overturn the primary decision. During the appeal, several interlocutory applications were made, including an application for leave to appeal and subsequent applications for costs.

Following the dismissal of the appeal, the respondent applied for costs on an indemnity basis under the Court's inherent jurisdiction and pursuant to section 83 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021. The respondent also provided a Calderbank letter, making an offer of settlement to the appellant, which was refused. The appellant, in turn, made a counter offer, which the respondent also declined. The Full Court was tasked with determining the appropriateness of the costs orders, including whether the refusal of the settlement offers was reasonable, and the allocation of costs on a party/party basis. The case was further complicated by the retirement of one of the appeal judges, necessitating the involvement of a replacement judge in the final determination of the costs order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should award indemnity costs against the appellant for the costs of the dismissed appeal.
2. Whether the respondent’s offer to settle the appeal was reasonable and whether the appellant’s refusal to accept the offer was justified.
3. Whether the appellant is considered a substantial corporate entity for the purposes of determining costs orders.
4. Whether the retirement of the appeal judge affects the costs order to be made in this case.

Held
1. Whether the court should award indemnity costs against the appellant for the costs of the dismissed appeal.
The court held that indemnity costs should not be awarded against the appellant for the costs of the dismissed appeal.

2. Whether the respondent’s offer to settle the appeal was reasonable and whether the appellant’s refusal to accept the offer was justified.
The court held that the respondent’s offer to settle the appeal was reasonable, but the appellant’s refusal to accept the offer was justified.

3. Whether the appellant is considered a substantial corporate entity for the purposes of determining costs orders.
The court held that the appellant is considered a substantial corporate entity for the purposes of determining costs orders.

4. Whether the retirement of the appeal judge affects the costs order to be made in this case.
The court held that the retirement of the appeal judge does not affect the costs order to be made in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Capital Aircraft Services Pty Ltd v Nicholas Carl Brolin, the court addressed several issues concerning costs orders, including whether indemnity costs should be awarded to the respondent for the costs of the dismissed appeal, the reasonableness of the respondent's offer to settle the appeal, and the classification of the appellant as a substantial corporate entity. The court also considered the implications of the retirement of the appeal judge on the costs order.

The court began by examining whether it should award indemnity costs to the respondent for the costs of the dismissed appeal. The court held that indemnity costs are typically awarded in cases where the losing party has acted unreasonably or where the offer to settle the proceedings was reasonable and the refusal to accept it unjustified. Here, the court found that the respondent had made a reasonable offer to settle the appeal, and the appellant's refusal to accept this offer was not justified. Consequently, the court ruled that the appellant should pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal on a party/party basis, including indemnity costs.

The court then evaluated the reasonableness of the respondent’s offer to settle the appeal. The offer was made pursuant to a Calderbank letter, which is a tool used to encourage settlement by providing protection against costs penalties if the offer is not accepted. The court considered the merits of the case, the strength of the respondent's position, and the potential outcomes of proceeding with the appeal. It found that the respondent's offer was reasonable given the circumstances, and the appellant's refusal to accept it was unjustified because it had little chance of success. This conclusion was pivotal in determining that indemnity costs were appropriate.

Next, the court addressed whether the appellant was considered a substantial corporate entity for the purposes of determining costs orders. The court noted that the appellant, Capital Aircraft Services Pty Ltd, was a corporation that could be classified as a substantial entity due to its financial resources and the nature of its business. The court held that the appellant’s status as a substantial corporate entity meant it had the means to bear the costs of the appeal, reinforcing the decision to award indemnity costs.

Finally, the court considered the impact of the retirement of the appeal judge on the costs order. The court noted that the retirement of a judge generally does not affect the costs order unless there are exceptional circumstances. Here, the court found no exceptional circumstances that would warrant a different costs order and proceeded to apply the principles of indemnity costs as discussed above.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a respondent makes a reasonable offer to settle an appeal, and the appellant’s refusal to accept the offer is unjustified, the court may award indemnity costs to the respondent. Additionally, the court's decision is influenced by the classification of the appellant as a substantial corporate entity and is not affected by the retirement of the appeal judge in the absence of exceptional circumstances.