Elborough and Comcare (Compensation) [2016] AATA 29 (28 January 2016)
Division
GENERAL DIVISION
File Number
2014/0325
Re
Reginald Elborough
APPLICANT
And
Comcare
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal Deputy President K Bean
Date 28 January 2016 Place Adelaide The decision under review is affirmed.
......... [Sgd] ..........................................
Deputy President K Bean
CATCHWORDS
COMPENSATION – Commonwealth employees – Whether applicant’s claimed conditions caused by exposure to ionising radiation at Maralinga – Whether conditions contributed to by applicant’s employment with Postmaster-General’s Department – Low-level radiation exposure did not make any contribution to conditions – Decision under review affirmed.
LEGISLATION
Commonwealth Employees' Compensation Act 1930
Compensation (Commonwealth Employees) Act 1971
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 5B, 7(1), 7(4), 124Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation (Specified Diseases) Notice 2007(1)
CASES
Jovanovski v Telstra Corporation Limited (2008) 101 ALD 526
Re Hannaford and Telstra Corporation Limited [2008] AATA 879
Comcare v PVYW (2013) 250 CLR 246
Hatzimanolis v A.N.I. Corporation Limited (1992) 173 CLR 473
Coward v Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Service (2006) 153 FCR 535Abrahams v Comcare (2006) 93 ALD 147
SECONDARY MATERIALS
Walker F, Maralinga: The Chilling Exposé of Our Secret Nuclear Shame and Betrayal of Our Troops and Country (Hachette Australia, 2014)
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President K Bean
28 January 2016
The applicant, Mr Elborough, is 83 years old. On 22 June 2010, he lodged a claim for compensation in respect of a number of conditions which he contends resulted from exposure to ionising radiation while he was stationed at Maralinga in 1957, during his employment with the Postmaster-General’s Department (PMG) as a postal clerk.
The conditions Mr Elborough attributes to his time at Maralinga were specified before the Tribunal as follows:
1)Tinnitus;
2)Dry ears, eyes, nose and mouth;
3)Ear pain;
4)Migraine;
5)Hepatitis;
6)Calcification of costal cartilage;
7)Osteoarthritis;
8)Rheumatoid arthritis;
9)Honey bee sting allergy;
10)Sinuses;
11)Disseminated Idiopathic Skeletal Hyperostosis (DISH);
12)High cholesterol;
13)Overactive immune system;
14)Bridging of thoracic vertebrae;
15)Skin cancers;
16)Prostate cancer and removal;
17)Irritable bladder/infection;
18)Hypertension;
19)Bowel and urinary tract;
20)Impotence;
21)Irritable bowel and gastrointestinal tract;
22)Scarring of both lungs;
23)Osteoporosis;
24)Cataracts;
25)Mouth ulcers;
26)Muscle cramps;
27)Hay fever;
28)Viral infection;
29)Alcohol allergy; and
30)Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD).[1]
[1] Exhibit 8.
On 2 December 2010, the respondent (Comcare) denied liability for Mr Elborough’s claimed conditions (which did not include all of those listed above[2]), and that decision was affirmed upon reconsideration by a Comcare Review Officer on 5 December 2013.
[2] Ear pain, hepatitis, bee sting allergy, high cholesterol, impotence, mouth ulcers, muscle cramps, hay fever, viral infection, alcohol allergy and COPD were not referred to in Mr Elborough’s claim for compensation: PT3/41.
On 22 January 2014, Mr Elborough applied for review of that decision by this Tribunal, giving rise to these proceedings.
ISSUES
It follows that in broad terms the issue for my determination is whether any of the claimed conditions are attributable to Mr Elborough’s employment with the PMG, such that compensation is payable with respect to them. I understand Comcare’s position to be that it does not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Elborough and Comcare (Compensation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] AATA 29
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the evidence provided by expert witnesses Dr Crouch and Dr Stevenson, who both opined that Mr Elborough’s exposure to ionising radiation was relatively low and that there was no likely causal relationship between this exposure and his subsequent medical conditions. Dr Stevenson was particularly emphatic in ruling out any connection, noting that there was no evidence to support Mr Elborough’s claim that his sensitivities may have amplified his reaction to low-dose radiation. The court found that the evidence of Mr Stephen Walters, a naturopath, was not sufficient to establish a causal link between Mr Elborough’s conditions and his employment, as he acknowledged his lack of expertise in ionising radiation and only considered the possibility of a stress-related causal connection. Additionally, the book referenced by Mr Elborough did not provide specific details on his exposure or its effects, hence it was deemed unhelpful in resolving the case.
The court concluded that Mr Elborough’s exposure to ionising radiation did not contribute to any of his claimed conditions. Consequently, the court affirmed the decision under review, denying compensation liability on the grounds that there was no causal link established between the claimed conditions and the exposure to radiation.
ORDER:
The decision under review is affirmed.
Orders
Orders of the court
The decision under review is affirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Dr Stevenson was “very confident” that there was no connection between Mr Elborough’s conditions and his exposure to relatively low levels of ionising radiation. In response to Mr Elborough’s contention that his particular sensitivities may have caused him to have a greater reaction to low-dose radiation exposure, Dr Stevenson indicated that he could see no reason why that would be the case. Consideration Noting that there is no contrary expert evidence, I accept the opinions of Dr Crouch and Dr Stevenson respectively, as to the likely extent of Mr Elborough’s exposure to ionising radiation whilst at Maralinga, and the likelihood of a causal relationship between this and his subsequent medical conditions. I note that their evidence is to the effect that Mr Elborough’s exposure to ionising radiation was relatively low, and there is unlikely to be any causal relationship between that exposure and any of the medical conditions he has subsequently developed, including skin cancers, hypertension and cataracts. In these circumstances, I have concluded that it is unnecessary for me to determine the issue of whether Mr Elborough’s exposure to radiation was sufficiently connected with his employment so as to potentially give rise to compensation liability. That is because I am not satisfied in any event that Mr Elborough’s exposure to ionising radiation made any contribution to any of his claimed conditions. That being the case, and regardless of which Act applies to which condition, I am not satisfied that Comcare is liable to pay compensation with respect to any of those conditions.OTHER MATTERS For completeness, I should acknowledge that Mr Elborough also relied on the evidence of Mr Stephen Walters, Naturopath, who provided a report dated 6 January 2015[22] and also gave brief oral evidence. During his evidence Mr Walters acknowledged that he had no expertise in ionising radiation. He confirmed that he considered a number of Mr Elborough’s comorbidities may be related to his employment with the PMG, with the causal relationship being based on stress caused to Mr Elborough by his perception of being exposed to something toxic during his employment. However, he indicated this was something he regarded as possible rather than probable. Accordingly, Mr Walter’s evidence did not support the existence of any causal connection between Mr Elborough’s claimed conditions and his employment by the PMG, on the balance of probabilities.[22] Exhibit 13. Mr Elborough also provided me with a copy of a book written by Mr Frank Walker entitled “Maralinga: The Chilling Exposé of Our Secret Nuclear Shame and Betrayal of Our Troops and Country”[23], and directed me to particular parts and passages of the book. However, so far as I have been able to ascertain, there is nothing in this book which is specifically directed to quantifying Mr Elborough’s precise exposure to ionising radiation, or the effects of this upon him. As such, I have found it of little assistance in resolving the issues arising for my determination in this matter.[23] Walker F, Maralinga: The Chilling Exposé of Our Secret Nuclear Shame and Betrayal of Our Troops and Country (Hachette Australia, 2014).CONCLUSION