Arbon and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Arbon and Comcare (Compensation) [2019] AATA 663 (25 March 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/6643

Re:Stuart Arbon

APPLICANT

AndComcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President P Britten-Jones

Member D Ben-Tovim

Date:25 March 2019

Place:Adelaide

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review

...............................[sgnd]........................................

Deputy President P Britten-Jones

Member D Ben-Tovim

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – thyroid cancer – applicant worked at Maralinga –applicant was exposed to a low level of ionising radiation – whether the statutory presumption in s 7(1) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 applies – employment involving exposure to ionising radiation – consideration of what kind of employment the applicant was engaged in for the purposes of s 7(1)(c) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – applicant was an electrician and his work duties did not require him to attend in contaminated areas – presumption does not apply – was thyroid cancer contributed to by his employment to a significant degree – causation and epidemiological studies – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), ss 5B, 7(1) and 14(1)

CASES

Bird v Commonwealth of Australia (1988) 165 CLR 1
Comcare v PVYW (2013) 250 CLR 246
Connair Pty Ltd v Fredericksen (1979) 142 CLR 485
Coward v Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Service (2006) 153 FCR 535
Elborough and Comcare (Compensation) [2016] AATA 29
Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626
Hatzimanolis v ANI Corportation Ltd (1992) 173 CLR 473
Seltsam Pty Ltd v McGuinness (2000) 49 NSWLR 262

Sydney South WestArea Health Service v Stamoulis [2009] NSWCA 153

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation (Specified Diseases) Notice 2007 (1)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President P Britten-Jones
Member D Ben-Tovim

  1. The applicant spent some time working for the Department of Defence at Maralinga in 1978 and 1979. He now suffers from thyroid cancer and claims liability from the respondent under section 14(1) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act).

  2. The applicant seeks to rely upon a presumption created by section 7(1) of the Act to assist in establishing a causal link between his cancer and his employment. The key issue in this case is whether the statutory presumption operates. For the reasons that follow, we find that it does not and that the applicant has failed to establish liability under the Act.

    Background Facts

  3. In 1971, the applicant commenced employment as an electrician with the Weapons Research Establishment branch of the Department of Defence.  At some stage he did some work at Woomera and obtained the necessary security clearances which later enabled him to be chosen for some work at Maralinga.

  4. In April 1978, the applicant spent 3 weeks working at Maralinga. He was required to carry out electrical maintenance and repair work within the Maralinga village including the installation and maintenance of generators. He attended at Maralinga and carried out similar tasks a further three times for approximately 6 weeks from October 1978, 3 weeks in July 1979 and 3…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Arbon and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 663
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal to the Federal Court of Australia regarding a claim for compensation under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) by the applicant, Mr Arbon, against Comcare. Mr Arbon sought compensation for papillary thyroid cancer, alleging it was caused by his employment as an electrician with the Weapons Research Establishment, which involved periods working at Maralinga where he was exposed to ionising radiation. The central dispute revolved around whether the statutory presumption in section 7(1) of the Act applied to his condition and, if not, whether his employment had contributed to his cancer to a significant degree.

The court was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the applicant's employment involved exposure to ionising radiation in a manner that engaged the statutory presumption under section 7(1)(c) of the Act. Secondly, if the presumption did not apply, whether the applicant's thyroid cancer was contributed to by his employment to a significant degree, considering the causation and the available epidemiological studies.

The court found that the statutory presumption did not apply because, although Mr Arbon had been exposed to ionising radiation during patrols into the prohibited areas at Maralinga, his duties as an electrician were confined to the Maralinga village, which was not disputed to be a contaminated area. The court accepted the expert evidence of Dr Tinker, who concluded that the applicant's radiation exposure was very low, in the vicinity of 0.26 mSv to 1.56 mSv, and that this level fell well short of the high doses associated with adverse health outcomes, posing no credible risk for the onset of his thyroid cancer. While Professor Ruff suggested a possible causal link, his evidence lacked quantification of the increased risk. The court applied the principle that causation requires actual persuasion and that a causal relationship between low levels of radiation and thyroid cancer had not been established as a matter of probability, deeming the estimated increase in risk to be negligible.

Consequently, the court affirmed the decision that the statutory presumption did not apply and that the applicant had failed to establish that his thyroid cancer was contributed to by his employment to a significant degree. The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant seeks to rely upon a presumption created by section 7(1) of the Act to assist in establishing a causal link between his cancer and his employment. The key issue in this case is whether the statutory presumption operates. For the reasons that follow, we find that it does not and that the applicant has failed to establish liability under the Act.Background Facts In 1971, the applicant commenced employment as an electrician with the Weapons Research Establishment branch of the Department of Defence. At some stage he did some work at Woomera and obtained the necessary security clearances which later enabled him to be chosen for some work at Maralinga. In April 1978, the applicant spent 3 weeks working at Maralinga. He was required to carry out electrical maintenance and repair work within the Maralinga village including the installation and maintenance of generators. He attended at Maralinga and carried out similar tasks a further three times for approximately 6 weeks from October 1978, 3 weeks in July 1979 and 3 months from August 1979. All up he spent about 24 weeks at Maralinga. He travelled to and from Maralinga by train. On each trip he stayed in the old hospital which also accommodated at least four Commonwealth police officers. It was the role of those police officers to go on patrols to various sites previously used for nuclear testing situated about 30 to 40 km from the Maralinga village. These testing sites were in a prohibited area for which a pass was required to allow access. The applicant had such a pass as a result of his previous work at Woomera. None of his duties as an electrician required him to work in the prohibited area. The applicant’s work as an electrician was confined to the Maralinga village which was situated well away from the prohibited area. The applicant was not overly busy so in order to alleviate the “severe boredom” he decided to join the police officers on their daily patrols. He did so at least once a day. They would leave the Maralinga village and travel out to the various bomb testing sites in order to make sure there were no trespassers. The applicant would sometimes drive. He enjoyed the patrols because getting in the car created some wind and some relief from the hot weather. It is not in dispute that the prohibited area was contaminated as a result of the nuclear testing and that the applicant was exposed to ionised radiation during the patrols. The extent of that exposure is in dispute. The applicant gave oral evidence that upon his return from each of the four trips to Maralinga, he would be de-briefed by an ASIO officer. He also spoke to the radiation protection branch and answered generic questions about the sites that he had visited in the prohibited areas. This evidence was not included in his written statement but the applicant was not challenged about it in cross-examination. I accept the evidence but I note the limited extent of the evidence on this topic. It is not in dispute that the applicant has papillary thyroid cancer which was diagnosed in 2012 when lumps in his neck were found. He was under the care of Mr Kollias, senior consulting surgeon at the Royal Adelaide Hospital (RAH), who carried out a total thyroidectomy and a modified right neck dissection which removed some lymph nodes on 17 December 2012. He was reviewed in the RAH Thyroid Clinic in April 2014 at which time there was no evidence of disease progression. In a report from Mr Kollias, dated 8 August 2014, he said:Papillary thyroid cancer is usually sporadic (i.e. no obvious cause), although there are some rare forms of familial papillary thyroid cancer due to germ line mutations in causative genes. Previous exposure to ionising radiation (i.e. nuclear fall-out) is also a well-recognised cause.…There are no other contributing factors that may have caused Mr Arbon’s thyroid cancer, apart from previous exposure to ionising radiation.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Professor Ruff concluded in his second report by referring to the applicant’s radiation exposure as “being a likely contributing factor to his development of thyroid cancer” and says that his “radiation exposures at Maralinga cannot be discounted as a contributing factor for both his thyroid cancer and his heart disease.”Expert evidence from the respondent Dr Tinker is a scientist employed as a director of the Australian Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety Agency (ARPANSA). He is also a director of the World Health Organisation Collaborative Centre for Radiation Protection in Australia. He prepared a report dated 10 August 2018 and a Dose Reconstruction Update dated 18 December 2018. He said that in Australia very low radiation doses have been defined as below 10 mSv and correspond to the range of exposure any member of the public may experience under normal circumstances on a yearly basis from average background levels of radiation found in our environment. The annual equivalent dose to the thyroid from natural background is approximately 1.5 mSv. Dr Tinker concluded that at levels that are typical of background levels, health effects in a population or individual cannot be attributed. Dr Tinker’s opinion expressed in the Dose Reconstruction Update was that the applicant’s radiation exposure while at Maralinga was a very low radiation exposure in the vicinity of 0.26 mSv and 1.56 mSv. This level fell well short of the high levels of radiation associated with adverse health outcomes: The effects of high doses of radiation are extensively researched and well known. There is established evidence of harm at exposures of populations at ionising radiation doses above approximately 100 mSv. The cumulative equivalent dose to the thyroid of Mr Arbon was estimated to be significantly less than 100 mSv. Dr Tinker concluded that there is no credible risk for the onset of his thyroid cancer from this exposure. The applicant’s degree of exposure to any residual radioactive materials can only be assessed retrospectively. The established method for assessing the degree of exposure under those circumstances is that developed by ARPANSA. Dr Tinker documented the outcome of modelling in his Dose Reconstruction Update dated 18 December 2018 based upon a variety of exposure risks related to a range of scenarios covering frequency of participation in patrols and exposure to dust under various driving conditions. We accept the opinion of Dr Tinker that the applicant was likely to have been exposed to a relatively low level of radiation, in the vicinity 0.26 mSv and 1.56 mSv. Using the exposure values that Dr Tinker generated from his models, Dr Tinker estimated the lifetime risks for the onset of thyroid cancer attributable to exposure to the identified radiation was in a range from 0.055 to 0.32 extra cases per 100,000 people. Dr Tinker did not calculate a specific value for a change in relative risk based on rate-ratios.[1] However, he noted that the population risk of development of thyroid cancer due to exposure to background radiation was 14 per 100,000 people. [1] Seltsam Pty Ltd v McGuinness (‘Seltsam’) (2000) 49 NSWLR 262, 272.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Spigelman CJ said further:The predominant position in Australian case law is that a balance of probabilities test requires a court to reach a level of actual persuasion. This process does not involve a mechanical application of probabilities (footnotes removed).In Australian law, the test of actual persuasion does not require epidemiological studies to reach the level of a relative risk of 2.0, even where that is the only evidence available to a court. Nevertheless, the closer the ratio approaches 2.0, the greater the significance that can be attached to the studies for the purposes of drawing an inference of causation in an individual case. The “strands in the cable” must be capable of bearing the weight of the ultimate inference.[3] [3] Seltsam at 284-285.Conclusion as to causation The experts disagree as to whether the epidemiological studies show that exposure to low levels of radiation increases the risk of thyroid cancer. However, Professor Ruff, whilst asserting a causal relationship, does not provide any real quantification of the extent of the increased risk that he considers is apparent from the epidemiological studies. He fails to establish the strength of the asserted association between low levels of radiation and thyroid cancer. He talks in his reports of an “incremental health risk” and “measurable increases in cancer risk evident with exposures of very few mSv” and “ionising radiation as a risk factor for thyroid cancer.” In Sydney South West Area Health Service v Stamoulis [2009] NSWCA 153, a 10% increase in risk was found to have materially contributed to and therefore caused a tumour. In this case the applicant has not established the extent of any increased risk that the applicant’s exposure to a low level of radiation contributed to his thyroid cancer. On the other hand, Dr Tinker said that there was no credible risk that his exposure caused the thyroid cancer; in other words, there was no material increased risk. Dr Tinker said in oral evidence that where the level of exposure was below 100 mSv it was extremely challenging to find any clearly established health outcomes. In our opinion, the current state of the epidemiological evidence is that a causal relationship between low levels of radiation and thyroid cancer has not been established. The link between low levels of radiation and thyroid cancer remains a possibility, which has not been established as a matter of probability. Professor Ruff himself gave evidence that it cannot be determined with any precision how significant a role his exposure may have played in the genesis of his thyroid cancer but that his exposure cannot be disregarded as a possible contributing factor. In this circumstance, we would not accept the concluding evidence of Professor Ruff that the applicant’s exposure to radiation is a likely contributing factor to his development of thyroid cancer. Dr Tinker’s Dose Reconstruction Update estimates a risk of at most an extra 0.32 cases per 100,000 people. An increase of 0.32 cases per 100,000 people due to exposure can be compared to the underlying background case rate of 14 per 100,000 people. It follows that an increase in exposure of 1.56 mSv is likely to increase the risk of developing thyroid cancer by 2.286% (calculated by dividing 0.32 by 14 as a percentage). Such an increase would appear to be a negligible increase in risk attributable to the likely exposure to radiation during the applicant’s time at Maralinga.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.