Elaura Enterprises v Harnas & Harnas No. DCCIV-01-197

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

ELAURA ENTERPRISES V HARNAS & HARNAS

[2002] SADC 178

Judge Kitchen
Civil

  1. By a contract in writing dated 19th July 1995 Baleswood Pty Ltd (“Baleswood”) agreed to sell to Mark Andrew Paech (Mr Paech) “and/or nominee”, for the price of $80,000, plus stock at valuation, the business of a motel and restaurant known as Tony’s Tuscan Inn and Restaurant being conducted by Baleswood in premises at 74 Main Road, Hahndorf which were owned by the defendants and leased by the defendants to Baleswood pursuant to a lease entered into on 2nd February 1994 for a term of ten years (Exhibit P4).

  2. Tony Sanso (Mr Sanso) was a director of Baleswood.  Baleswood’s agent for the sale was Henry Dalton (Mr Dalton).

  3. The defendants had purchased the freehold land comprising the Tuscan Inn from Baleswood in early 1994.

  4. Mr Paech and his colleague in the venture to purchase the business, Timothy James Francis (Mr Francis), bought a “shelf” company and were appointed directors of that company, the name of which was changed to Elaura Enterprises Pty Ltd., the plaintiff.   Mr Paech nominated the plaintiff as the purchaser pursuant to the contract.

  5. At settlement for the sale and purchase of the business on 14 September 1995  the lease was transferred by Baleswood to the plaintiff.  As a condition of their agreement to that transfer the defendants required Mr Paech and Mr Francis, who agreed, to guarantee the plaintiff’s obligations and liabilities pursuant to the lease.  The guarantee is Exhibit D45.

  6. In this action the plaintiff alleges by its amended statement of claim, in summary,

    ·that before the contract was executed the defendants represented (the first representation) to Mr Paech they intended to build a new restaurant and four new motel rooms (the new works) on the land, Council approval for the erection of which was in the process of being obtained, the construction would be completed by Christmas 1995 and the new restaurant would attract more customers

    ·that Mr Paech and Mr Francis entered into the contract relying upon and induced by the representations

    ·that between November 1995 and November 1999 the defendants failed to, or refused the plaintiff’s request that, the defendants commence the construction of the new works

    ·that in November 1999 the defendants informed the plaintiff that Council approval for the new works had been obtained, they wished to begin construction and represented (the second representation) to the plaintiff:

    (a)the new works would be commenced in February or March 2000

    (b)construction would take ten to twelve weeks

    (c)the kitchen in the new restaurant would be built to accommodate the plaintiff’s existing equipment, fixtures and fittings the moving of which, and the bar and toilets, to the new restaurant would take only four days, the cost to be borne by the defendants

    (d)the defendants would supply any necessary fit-out items for the new restaurant.

  7. The plaintiff alleges that Council approval for the new works had not been obtained before the defendants commenced the new works in February 2000, that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elaura Enterprises v Harnas & Harnas No. DCCIV-01-197 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SADC 178
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Elaura Enterprises Pty Ltd, brought an action against the defendants, Harnas and Harnas, for breach of contract, misleading or deceptive conduct, and orders under the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995. The plaintiff alleged that before the contract was executed, the defendants represented that they intended to build a new restaurant and four new motel rooms on the land, Council approval for the erection of which was in the process of being obtained, the construction would be completed by Christmas 1995 and the new restaurant would attract more customers. The plaintiff further alleged that between November 1995 and November 1999 the defendants failed to, or refused the plaintiff’s request that, the defendants commence the construction of the new works. In November 1999 the defendants informed the plaintiff that Council approval for the new works had been obtained, they wished to begin construction and represented that the new works would be commenced in February or March 2000, construction would take ten to twelve weeks, the kitchen in the new restaurant would be built to accommodate the plaintiff’s existing equipment, fixtures and fittings the moving of which, and the bar and toilets, to the new restaurant would take only four days, the cost to be borne by the defendants, and the defendants would supply any necessary fit-out items for the new restaurant. The plaintiff alleged it thereby suffered loss of profits and trading losses, loss of quiet enjoyment in the period from February 2000 to September 2000, claims damages for breach of contract and for misleading or deceptive conduct both pursuant to Section 56 and Section 84 of the Fair Trading Act and Section 7 of the Misrepresentation Act and orders under Section 68(2)(d)(e) and (j)of the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995. The defendants denied they are in breach of contract or that they made any representation as alleged by the plaintiff. The court found that the plaintiff has failed to prove the representations it alleges were made by the defendants in July 1995 and November 1999, except there was an indication by the defendants that construction would take approximately three months and that the defendants would assist the plaintiff to move some of its kitchen equipment to the new restaurant. The court found that the plaintiff has failed to prove that it suffered any loss or damage by relying upon Mrs Harnas’ statement and, for similar reasons, the claim pursuant to Section 7 of the Misrepresentation Act cannot succeed. The court found that the plaintiff has failed to prove the defendants are in breach of the Act, the Lease or any collateral agreement. The court found that there are no grounds upon which the plaintiff should be relieved from its obligation to comply with the lease. The court dismissed the plaintiff’s claims and dismissed the plaintiff’s application to be re-instated into the leased premises. The court found that the defendants have taken reasonable steps to mitigate their loss and assessed their damages as the sum of the rent which would have been payable if the plaintiff had remained in possession up to and including 2nd March 2002. The court found that the plaintiff, in breach of Clause 2.1.1 of the Lease, has failed to pay rates to the District Council of Mount Barker in respect of the leased premises, the total of which is $10,409.24. The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendants the sum of $81,898.12.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established