Elammar v AAI Limited t/as AAMI

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Elammar v AAI Limited t/as AAMI [2024] NSWPICMP 280
CLAIMANT: Hassan Elammar
INSURER: AAMI
REVIEW PANEL
MEMBER: Gary Victor Patterson
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: John Baker
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Michael Hong
DATE OF DECISION: 8 May 2024
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; the claimant was driving home on 10 July 2020 on the M5 after work; he was travelling in the middle lane of three at approximately 100 kilometres per hour; the insured vehicle was travelling in the same direction; the two vehicles swerved into each other; there was an altercation between the two drivers; the claimant was struck by the insured vehicle as the claimant attempted to prevent it departing the scene; the insurer denied liability for the claim on the bases that the claimant was wholly at fault and that he suffered minor (now threshold) psychological injuries in the accident, namely adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood; Medical Assessor Wayne Mason so certified; certificate confirmed; Held – Review Panel finds PTSD not caused by the motor accident; motor accident caused the claimant to suffer an opioid use disorder in sustained remission, which is a non-threshold injury; Review Panel did not so certify as that condition/disorder outside terms of referral; Mandoukos v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd applied.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE
REVIEW PANEL ASSESSMENT OF THRESHOLD INJURY
Certificate issued under s 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

1.     The Review Panel confirms the certificate of Medical Assessor Wayne Mason dated
5 December 2022.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. Hassan Elammar (the claimant) was involved in a motor vehicle accident on 10 July 2020 when he was travelling home on the M5 after work. He was travelling in the middle lane of three at approximately 100kmph . The insured driver was travelling in the same direction in lane three closer to the median strip. The vehicles swerved into each other in circumstances that are contested. Both drivers pulled into the emergency lane at the side of the road and exchanged details. Another driver took dashcam footage of the incident. There was then an altercation between the claimant and the insured driver resulting in the claimant’s being on the bonnet of the insured vehicle as it moved forward. The insured driver then braked heavily causing the claimant to be propelled forward to the left on the side of the carriage way. The insured driver departed the scene. Police attended and subsequently interviewed both drivers and obtained footage from the M5 cameras at the scene. The claimant was issued with a Traffic Infringement Notice for causing the initial collision by not merging from one lane into the other safely. The insured driver was issued with a Traffic Infringement Notice for negligent driving.

  2. Member Boyd-Boland certified on 22 September 2021, after conducting a fully-contested hearing, that the motor accident was caused by the insured driver and that the claimant’s statutory benefits should be reduced by 10% for his contributory negligence.

  3. The claimant says that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elammar v AAI Limited t/as AAMI and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMP 280
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Elammar v AAI Limited t/as AAMI, the central dispute involves whether the injuries sustained by Hassan Abd Elammar in a motor accident are threshold injuries under the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017. The accident occurred on 10 July 2020 on the M5, where Elammar's vehicle collided with an insured vehicle. Following the collision, Elammar was struck by the insured vehicle while attempting to prevent it from leaving the scene. The insurer, AAI Limited, denied liability for the claim on the grounds that Elammar was wholly at fault and that he suffered minor psychological injuries, specifically an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood, as diagnosed by Medical Assessor Wayne Mason.

The legal issues before the court were whether the injuries Elammar claimed were threshold injuries under the Act, and whether the insurer's denial of liability was justified. The Review Panel was tasked with determining whether the psychological injuries Elammar sustained—post-traumatic stress disorder, severe shock, and severe anxiety and depression—were indeed threshold injuries. The Review Panel examined the joint assessment report from Medical Assessors Baker and Hong, who noted that Elammar submitted that it would be premature to conclude he had suffered a minor psychological injury without a formal diagnosis from his psychologist. Conversely, the insurer argued that Elammar's injuries were correctly assessed as minor by Medical Assessor Mason.

The Review Panel found that post-traumatic stress disorder was not caused by the motor accident. Instead, the accident caused Elammar to suffer an opioid use disorder in sustained remission, which the Panel determined to be a non-threshold injury. The Review Panel did not certify this condition as it fell outside the terms of referral. The court applied the principles from Mandoukos v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd, emphasising that the Review Panel is not required to choose between competing medical opinions but rather to form its own opinion based on the evidence presented. The Panel adopted the findings of Medical Assessors Baker and Hong, concluding that Elammar's injuries were not threshold injuries as defined by the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The joint assessment report from Medical Assessor Baker and Medical Assessor Hong is as follows:“BACKGROUND1. There is a dispute between Hassan Abd Elammar (the applicant) and the insurer about: · whether the injury is a threshold injury under Schedule 2, s 2(e) of the Act, Threshold injury dispute to be assessed.2. The following injuries were referred by the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) for further assessment: · Post-traumatic stress disorder · severe shock; and · severe anxiety and depression SUBMISSIONS3. The submission from the applicant for this review was considered. The Panel noted that the part of the submissions relevant to this review were Psychological Injuries.The claimant states he suffers from: · Severe shock;· Post-traumatic Stress Disorder;· Severe anxiety and depression;The applicant submits that without a formal diagnosis from the claimant’s psychologist, it would be unreasonably premature to conclude that the claimant has suffered a minor (threshold) psychological injury.The applicant seeks to have the Certificate of Assessor Mason dated 5 December 2022 overturned.4. The submission from the insurer for this review was considered. By certificate dated 5 December 2022, PIC Medical Assessor Mason diagnosed the applicant with an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood, which is considered a threshold (minor) injury for the purposes of the Motor Accidents Injuries Act.The insurer disputes that the applicant has demonstrated any material error in Assessor Mason’s assessment.5. The issue presently in dispute is whether the psychological injuries caused by the accident relevantly are threshold injuries for the purposes of the MAI Act. SUMMARY OF DOCUMENTS CONSIDERED6. DocumentsThe Panel has considered the documents provided in the application. The Panel has considered the document provided in the application and the documents and certificates relating to the previous application. The Panel has considered the documents provided in the previous reply and the documents and certificates relating to the previous reply. The Panel has watched and listened to the CCTV Footage, NSW Police Force Audios (i.e. two audio recordings) and the Witness Dashcam footage, forwarded with the review documents. 7. Additional late documents The Review Panel conducts a new assessment of all the matters with which the medical assessment is concerned.[4] The Review Panel adopts the examination findings of Medical Assessor Baker and Medical Assessor Hong as well as their reasons.[4] Section 7.26(6) of the MAI Act. The Review Panel is not required to choose between competing medical opinions and is required to form its own opinion.[5] The Medical Assessors have explained the basis of their assessment which is not dissimilar to the assessment made by Medical Assessor Shen. The Medical Assessors have considered, but do not accept, the findings of Dr Synnott for the reasons stated.[5] Insurance Australia Group Limited v Keen [2021] NSWCA 287.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.