Ho v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL

CITATION:

Ho v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2025] NSWPICMP 596

CLAIMANT:

Yi Swen Ho

INSURER:

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

REVIEW PANEL

MEMBER:

Gary Victor Patterson

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Shane Moloney

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Christopher Oates

DATE OF DECISION:

12 August 2025

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; review of Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC); assessment of degree of permanent impairment; insured vehicle collided with the claimant’s motorcycle; claimant was transported to hospital where he underwent surgical treatment for a deep laceration of his left leg and a fracture of his left lower leg; Medical Assessor (MA) found 5% whole person impairment (WPI) for injuries to the left leg, right knee, and scarring; MA found a number of other injuries not caused; claimant’s review application based upon causation; Held – Review Panel found all referred injuries caused but no change to assessment of WPI; MAC revoked.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE

REVIEW PANEL ASSESSMENT OF DEGREE OF PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT

Certificate issued under s 7.26(7) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017 (the Act)

1.     The Review Panel revokes the certificate dated 5 February 2025 and issues a new certificate determining that:

(a)     The following injuries caused by the motor accident give rise to a permanent impairment of 5% AND IS NOT GREATER THAN 10%:

·         left ankle;

·         right knee; and

·         skin-scarring-left leg, right knee.

(b)    The following injuries caused by the motor accident have resolved with no assessable permanent impairment:

·         cervical spine;

·         thoracic spine;

·         lumbar spine;

·         left and right shoulders; and

·         left knee

.

(a)     

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 30 September 2021, at about 12.00pm, the claimant was riding his motorcycle in a westerly direction along Juno Parade at Greenacre. As the claimant’s motorcycle entered the intersection of Juno Parade and Hebe Street, the insured vehicle suddenly turned onto Juno Parade from Hebe Street, directly into the claimant’s path of travel, colliding with the claimant’s motorcycle.

  2. The claimant was thrown from his motorcycle. The left side of his body struck the road surface. He was knocked unconscious. His first memory following the collision was waking up on the road surface surrounded by people. Ambulance and Police Officers attended the scene. The claimant was transported to Liverpool Hospital where he underwent surgical treatment for a deep laceration of his left leg and a fracture of his left lower leg. He was discharged from Liverpool Hospital, after about three days, wearing a CAM boot and utilising crutches. The claimant’s motorcycle was written off by his insurer.

  3. Allianz (the insurer) indemnifies the owner and/or the driver of the at-fault vehicle for liability to pay the claimant any damages and/or statutory benefits under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (Act). The insurer wholly admitted liability for the claimant’s common law damages claim. The insurer would not concede that the claimant’s permanent impairment, arising from his accident-related injuries, exceeded the 10% statutory threshold. That decision was based upon the opinion of Dr Mitchell, occupational…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ho v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMP 596
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Ho v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the claimant sought a review of a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) issued by the insurer following a motor accident in which his motorcycle collided with an insured vehicle. The claimant argued that the MAC incorrectly assessed the degree of permanent impairment resulting from the injuries sustained in the accident. The dispute was heard and determined by a Review Panel under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The legal issues before the Review Panel involved the accuracy of the MAC, particularly whether the Medical Assessor had correctly assessed the degree of permanent impairment and whether the claimant's injuries were correctly attributed to the accident.

The Review Panel considered the evidence submitted by the insurer, which argued that the Medical Assessor had conducted a thorough examination and had properly considered all relevant evidence in forming his assessment. The insurer contested the claimant's review application, asserting that the Medical Assessor had adequately addressed the issue of causation, had provided sufficient reasons for his findings, and had not failed to afford procedural fairness to the claimant. The Panel examined the submissions and the evidence, focusing on whether the Medical Assessor had correctly determined the causation of the injuries and the degree of permanent impairment.

Upon review, the Panel found that while all the referred injuries were indeed caused by the accident, there was no alteration to the assessment of whole person impairment. Consequently, the Review Panel revoked the MAC, effectively allowing the claimant's review application but without changing the impairment assessment. This decision reflects a careful balance between the claimant's right to challenge the assessment and the insurer's reliance on the Medical Assessor's professional judgment.

The final orders of the Review Panel included the revocation of the MAC, thus permitting the claimant's review application. However, no change was made to the degree of permanent impairment as assessed by the Medical Assessor. The claimant's right to seek a further medical assessment was preserved, allowing for potential future challenges if new evidence or arguments are presented.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Briefly, the insurer submitted as follows:Error 1 – Alleged failure to engage with evidence·The insurer submits that the Medical Assessor provided a comprehensive certificate, having regard to both the treating and Medico-legal evidence, and the findings of a thorough physical examination. The insurer notes that the Medical Assessor listed all of the medical documents, to which he had regard, in coming to his causation findings.Error 2 – Alleged failure to disclose pathway of reasons·The insurer cites relevant authority to the effect that the obligations of Medical Assessors to provide reasons for their determination are to be construed very narrowly[3]. The insurer submits that the reasoning provided by the Medical Assessor satisfies the common law authorities governing the standard of reasoning required to be given.Error 3 – Alleged failure to address the issue of causation·The insurer notes the claimant’s original permanent impairment application was not accompanied by any submissions. The insurer cites relevant authority to the effect that the scope of a medical dispute is defined, not by the Act or bundles of evidence, but by the parties’ submissions[4]. The insurer says the claimant did not make an argument regarding causation in his submissions and seeks to agitate that issue only after the medical assessment was finalised.·The insurer submitted that it was not incumbent on the Medical Assessor to simply agree with or adopt Dr Giblin’s findings, but rather, he was required to use the entire gamut of clinical skill and judgment to form his own opinion.[5] The insurer then gives particulars of how, in its submission, the Medical Assessor properly came to his view that injuries to the cervical spine, thoracic spine and both shoulders were not caused by the motor accident, contrary to Dr Giblin’s opinion.Error 4 – Alleged failure to afford the claimant procedural fairness·The insurer proceeded on the basis that the claimant’s submission was made in relation to the variance between the shoulder range of motion findings recorded by the Medical Assessor and Dr Giblin. The insurer refutes any suggestion that the Medical Assessor was required to bring to the claimant’s attention a slight variance between the range of motion observed during his examination and that recorded by Dr Giblin. The insurer notes the time that elapsed between the assessments made by Dr Giblin (11 July 2023), Dr Mitchell on 30 May 2024 and the Medical Assessor on 16 January last. The insurer also submitted that clauses 6.40 and 6.41 of the Motor Accident Guidelines pertain to circumstances where there are gross or significant inconsistencies.[3] Wingfoot v Kocak [2013] HCA 43, Ali v AAI [2016] NSWCA 110 and Insurance Australia v Milton [2016] NSWCA 156[4] Mandoukos v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2024] NSWCA 71 and Elammar v AAI t/as AAMI [2024] NSWPICMP 280[5] Insurance Australia Group Limited v Keen [2021] NSWCA 287 and Insurance Australia Limited v Marsh [2022] NSWCA 31