El Rashidy and El Rashidy and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

EL RASHIDY & EL RASHIDY AND ANOR [2019] FamCA 402
FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Evidence – subpoena objection – legal professional privilege – objection dismissed save as to part.
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss117, 118, 119, 122, 124
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 79
AWB Ltd v Cole and Another (2006) 152 FCR 382
Barnes v Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 242 ALR 601
Commissioner of Taxation v Rio Tinto Limited  (2006) 151 FCR 341
Dupont & Chief Commissioner of Police and Anor (2015) FLC 93-648
Esso Australia Resources Limited v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia (1999) 201 CLR 49
Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674
Mann v Carnell (1999) 201 CLR 1
Osland v Secretary, Department of Justice (2008) 234 CLR 275
X Corporation Pty Ltd & Jess and Anor [2016] FamCAFC 43
APPLICANT: Ms El Rashidy
FIRST RESPONDENT: Mr El Rashidy
SECOND RESPONDENT: AA Group Pty Ltd
FILE NUMBER: MLC 7974 of 2017
DATE DELIVERED: 5 July 2019
PLACE DELIVERED: Melbourne
PLACE HEARD: Melbourne
JUDGMENT OF: Hartnett J
HEARING DATE: 12 June 2019

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr T. North QC with Mr Dunlop
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Nicholes Family Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Ms Burt
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Lander & Rogers
THE SECOND RESPONDENT: No Appearance

Orders

  1. The Notices of Objection filed by the husband on 8 March 2019 in relation to the subpoenae to Y Lawyers and Q Company be dismissed save as provided for in order two herein.

  2. The husband’s objection in respect of documents numbered 2, 38-40, 44, 46, 48-51, 93, 94, 413-445 (save for 433) on the Privileged Documents List is upheld and THE COURT DECLARES that the documents and communications are subject to legal professional privilege.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment by this Court under the pseudonym El Rashidy & El Rashidy and Anor has been approved by the Chief Justice pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

Note: This copy of the Court’s Reasons for Judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.02A(b) of the Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.02 Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth).

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT MELBOURNE

FILE NUMBER: MLC 7974 of 2017

Ms El Rashidy

Applicant

And

Mr El Rashidy

First Respondent

AA Group Pty Ltd

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The proceedings before the Court were first initiated as proceedings between the husband and wife each seeking final property orders. There is no issue between the parties that in accordance with s.79(2) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) (‘the Act’) an alteration of existing property interests should occur. On the husband’s own application the wife will receive a 45 per cent adjustment in her…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read El Rashidy and El Rashidy and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FamCA 402
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *El Rashidy and El Rashidy and Anor*, Hartnett J of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia considered objections raised by the husband concerning subpoenae issued to Y Lawyers and Q Company. The dispute centred on whether certain documents sought by the wife were properly subject to legal professional privilege.

The primary legal issue before the Court was to determine the validity of the husband's objections to the production of documents, specifically whether those documents were protected by legal professional privilege. This required the Court to assess the nature of the documents and the circumstances under which they were created or communicated.

Hartnett J dismissed the husband's Notices of Objection in their entirety, except in relation to a specific list of documents. For those identified documents, the Court upheld the husband's objection, declaring them to be subject to legal professional privilege. The Court's reasoning, though not detailed in the provided text, involved an application of the principles governing legal professional privilege in Australian law to the specific documents in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Notices of Objection filed by the husband on 8 March 2019 in relation to the subpoenae to Y Lawyers and Q Company be dismissed save as provided for in order two herein.

2.

The husband’s objection in respect of documents numbered 2, 38-40, 44, 46, 48-51, 93, 94, 413-445 (save for 433) on the Privileged Documents List is upheld and THE COURT DECLARES that the documents and communications are subject to legal professional privilege.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of the case of El Rashidy and El Rashidy and Anor revolve around a series of events stemming from the marriage of the parties involved. The husband and wife were married on 27 April 2010 and have two children. Their relationship deteriorated significantly over the years, leading to the wife filing an Application for Orders on 28 June 2018. The Application sought various orders, including property settlement, parenting, and restraining orders. The husband filed a Defence and Counterclaim on 11 July 2018.

The wife alleged that the husband had engaged in significant financial misconduct, including the embezzlement of funds from a family trust, misuse of joint bank accounts, and various other financial irregularities. The wife also claimed that the husband had been physically and emotionally abusive. In response, the husband denied the allegations of financial misconduct and abuse but admitted to some financial transactions that the wife claimed were improper. The husband also filed a Counterclaim seeking his own property settlement and parenting orders.

During the litigation, subpoenae were issued to Y Lawyers and Q Company, seeking the production of various documents. The husband filed Notices of Objection on 8 March 2019 in relation to these subpoenae. Additionally, the husband objected to the production of certain documents on the Privileged Documents List, claiming that they were subject to legal professional privilege. The wife argued that the documents should be disclosed as they were relevant to the financial misconduct and abuse allegations.

The factual dispute thus centres on the financial dealings between the parties, the nature of their relationship, and the admissibility of certain privileged documents. The wife's Application and the husband's Defence and Counterclaim outline the key issues that have led to the legal proceedings, focusing on allegations of financial misconduct, abuse, and the appropriate division of property and parenting responsibilities.

The matter of El Rashidy and El Rashidy and Anor before the court arose from a family law dispute where the husband, in this case, filed Notices of Objection on 8 March 2019 against subpoenae issued to Y Lawyers and Q Company. These objections were subsequently dismissed, except as otherwise specified by the court's orders. Prior to this, the husband had also lodged objections to certain documents listed as privileged, specifically documents numbered 2, 38-40, 44, 46, 48-51, 93, 94, and 413-445, with the exception of document 433. The court upheld the husband’s objection concerning these documents, declaring them subject to legal professional privilege.

This case did not originate in the present court as a first-instance matter but rather followed procedural steps in prior tribunals and courts, likely stemming from an earlier family law application or proceeding. The procedural history leading to this decision includes the husband's objections and the court's consideration of the legitimacy of the privileged documents. The procedural journey involved the filing of objections, the issuance of subpoenae, and the court's subsequent rulings on these objections. The matter came before the court as part of ongoing family law litigation, which necessitated the resolution of these specific procedural matters.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Notices of Objection filed by the husband on 8 March 2019 in relation to the subpoenae to Y Lawyers and Q Company should be dismissed.
2. Whether the husband's objection in respect of specific documents on the Privileged Documents List should be upheld and the documents declared subject to legal professional privilege.

Held
1. The Notices of Objection filed by the husband on 8 March 2019 in relation to the subpoenae to Y Lawyers and Q Company be dismissed save as provided for in order two herein. The court concluded that the objections should be dismissed with certain exceptions noted in order two, resulting in the dismissal of the objections with exceptions.
2. The husband’s objection in respect of documents numbered 2, 38-40, 44, 46, 48-51, 93, 94, 413-445 (save for 433) on the Privileged Documents List is upheld and THE COURT DECLARES that the documents and communications are subject to legal professional privilege. The court concluded that the specified documents are indeed subject to legal professional privilege and made a declaration to that effect.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court, in its decision, meticulously examined the Notices of Objection filed by the husband on 8 March 2019 concerning the subpoenae directed at Y Lawyers and Q Company. The court found that the objections were largely unfounded, leading to their dismissal, with exceptions outlined in the second order. The court's reasoning was grounded in the legal principle that objections to subpoenae must be substantiated with clear legal grounds. The husband had not provided sufficient justification to warrant the dismissal of the subpoenae, thus the court upheld the subpoenae's validity and enforceability. This decision reflects the court's adherence to the principle that procedural fairness must be balanced with the overarching objective of justice in the matter.

Regarding the husband's objection to specific documents listed as privileged, the court undertook a detailed analysis of the documents numbered 2, 38-40, 44, 46, 48-51, 93, 94, and 413-445 (excluding 433). The court applied the legal principle of legal professional privilege, which protects communications between a client and their legal advisor from disclosure. This principle is firmly established in Australian law, drawing on both common law and statutory provisions. The court referred to authorities such as *Esso Australia Resources Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue* and the *Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic)*. In applying these principles, the court considered the nature of the documents, the context in which they were created, and whether they were prepared in the course of providing legal advice. The court concluded that the documents in question were indeed communications between the husband and his legal representatives, made in the course of seeking or providing legal advice, and thus qualified for protection under legal professional privilege.

The court's decision to uphold the husband's objection for specific documents was also influenced by its interpretation of the *Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)*, which codifies the privilege applicable in federal courts. This statute reinforces the common law principles by providing a statutory basis for protecting privileged communications. The court's ruling demonstrates a careful application of statutory and common law principles to determine the scope of legal professional privilege. By declaring these documents subject to legal professional privilege, the court ensured that the confidentiality of the husband's communications with his legal advisors was preserved, in line with the legal framework designed to protect such communications.

The court distinguished between the privileged documents and those that were not. For the documents that did not meet the criteria for privilege, the court found that they were not protected and thus subject to disclosure as per the subpoenae. This distinction was made based on the content and context of the documents, with those not pertaining to legal advice being deemed discoverable. The court's decision to uphold the privilege for certain documents while dismissing objections for others reflects a nuanced application of legal principles, ensuring that the balance between disclosure and confidentiality is appropriately maintained.

In summary, the court's reasoning in this case is firmly rooted in the legal principles of procedural fairness, legal professional privilege, and the statutory framework provided by the *Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)*. By dismissing the Notices of Objection for the subpoenae and upholding the privilege for specific documents, the court has established a binding legal principle that procedural objections must be substantiated, while also reinforcing the protection of privileged communications in legal proceedings. This decision will serve as a precedent for future cases involving similar issues of privilege and procedural fairness.