El Bkassini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
30 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
El Bkassini v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCA 612
SABAH ASSAD EL BKASSINI v THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
V 987 of 2000
RYAN J
13 MAY 2002 MELBOURNE
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
V 987 of 2000
BETWEEN:
SABAH ASSAD EL BKASSINI Applicant
AND:
THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS Respondent
JUDGE:
RYAN J
DATE OF ORDER:
13 MAY 2002
WHERE MADE:
MELBOURNE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The decision of the Migration Review Tribunal made on 5 December 2000 be set aside.
2.The matter to which the decision relates be referred to the Migration Review Tribunal to be heard and determined according to law.
3.The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application to this Court, such costs to be taxed in default of agreement.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
V 987 of 2000
BETWEEN:
SABAH ASSAD EL BKASSINI Applicant
AND:
THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS Respondent
JUDGE:
RYAN J
DATE:
13 MAY 2002
PLACE:
MELBOURNE
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction
The applicant, Sabah Assad El Bkassini, seeks a review of a decision by the Migration Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) constituted by Senior Member Graham Friedman affirming the decision of a delegate of the Minister to refuse to grant the applicant a Family and Other Close Ties (After Entry) Visa under Subclass 806 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“the Regulations”). The applicant has relied on the following general ground of review;
“The Tribunal committed an error of law (either identifying the wrong issue or ignoring a relevant consideration) under s 476(1)(e) of the Act by incorrectly interpreting the applicable law or incorrectly applying the law to the facts.”
More specifically, the applicant contends that the Tribunal failed properly to interpret and apply the appropriate definition of “special need relative” particularly in light of its construction of the phrase “serious circumstances” giving rise to a special need.
Initially, the applicant had contended that the Tribunal had failed to make findings of fact as required by s 368 of the Act and that consequently the Tribunal had committed a procedural error under s 476(1)(a). However, the effect of the judgment of the High Court in Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 75 ALJR 1105 has been to exclude that as a permissible ground of review. Although the High Court had directed its observations to the relationship between s 430 and s 476(1)(a) of the Act, they are equally applicable to s 368 which subjects the Tribunal to the same obligations as s 430 imposes on the Refugee Review Tribunal.
Background
Ms El Bkassini is a citizen of Lebanon and was born on 2 January 1961. She entered Australia as a visitor on 12 July 1993 and was granted a temporary entry permit to enable her to remain in Australia until 13…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read El Bkassini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Aff... and more:
The case of El Bkassini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved Ms El Bkassini, a Lebanese citizen who had applied for a Subclass 806 entry permit to remain in Australia on the basis of her status as a remaining relative. Her application was refused by the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and subsequently by the Migration Review Tribunal (IRT), leading to a judicial review by Ms El Bkassini. The key issue before the court was whether the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the evidence of the substantial and continuing assistance provided by Ms El Bkassini to her sister, Dunia Boulos, who was an Australian citizen and had nominated her as a remaining relative. This assistance included care for the children, household tasks, and support for the nominator's mother-in-law. The court was required to determine if the Tribunal's failure to consider this evidence constituted a procedural error.
The court examined the evidence presented to the Tribunal, including testimonies and letters from various individuals, such as the nominator, a medical practitioner, and a special education teacher. The evidence highlighted the critical role Ms El Bkassini played in the family unit, particularly in the care of children with special needs and the support of the nominator's mother-in-law. The court found that the Tribunal had not adequately considered the importance of this assistance and its impact on the nominator's ability to care for her children and manage the household, especially given the impending birth of twins. The court concluded that the Tribunal's decision to affirm the delegate's refusal of the visa application was flawed due to this procedural error. Consequently, the court set aside the Tribunal's decision, referred the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration, and ordered the respondent to pay the applicant's costs of the application.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The decision of the Migration Review Tribunal made on 5 December 2000 be set aside.
2. The matter to which the decision relates be referred to the Migration Review Tribunal to be heard and determined according to law.
3. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application to this Court, such costs to be taxed in default of agreement.
Background
Background to the litigation
Initially, the applicant had contended that the Tribunal had failed to make findings of fact as required by s 368 of the Act and that consequently the Tribunal had committed a procedural error under s 476(1)(a). However, the effect of the judgment of the High Court in Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 75 ALJR 1105 has been to exclude that as a permissible ground of review. Although the High Court had directed its observations to the relationship between s 430 and s 476(1)(a) of the Act, they are equally applicable to s 368 which subjects the Tribunal to the same obligations as s 430 imposes on the Refugee Review Tribunal.Background Ms El Bkassini is a citizen of Lebanon and was born on 2 January 1961. She entered Australia as a visitor on 12 July 1993 and was granted a temporary entry permit to enable her to remain in Australia until 13 October 1993. This permit was extended until 12 January 1994. On 6 January 1994, she lodged an application for a Subclass 806 entry permit. The history of relevant events from that point as outlined by the Tribunal was as follows;“11.In her application the visa applicant stated that she was self-employed and that her parents were deceased. One sibling resided in the United States of America, 4 in Lebanon and 2 in Australia. Her sister Dunia BOULOS (the nominator), an Australian citizen, nominated her as a remaining relative. 12.At her interview held on 1 August 1994, the visa applicant stated that she lived in Lebanon with her mother until her mother's death in 1998. She said that she now had no place to live and had lost contact with her siblings. She stated that she and her family were Christians, and were subject to persecution in Lebanon. She stated that she has been caring for her sister's 3 children whilst in Australia. 13.On 14 May 1996 the delegate refused the application as the visa applicant did not meet the definition of remaining relative. On 18 June 1996 the visa applicant sought review by MIRO which affirmed the original decision 28 May 1997 as the visa applicant was not considered to be a remaining relative or a special need relative according to the Regulations. On 30 June 1997 the visa applicant applied to the IRT, which held a hearing on 21 January 1998. The visa applicant and a number of witnesses gave evidence about the assistance that the visa applicant provides to her sister by way of caring for the children and with household tasks. This enables the nominator to assist her husband in the operation of a restaurant, which requires long hours. 14.On 1 April 1998 the IRT affirmed the decision under review. On 5 May 1998 the visa applicant sought judicial review on the grounds that the IRT had failed to consider the evidence of the substantial and continuing assistance the visa applicant provided to the nominator in relation to the disability, prolonged illness and other serious circumstances of the nominator's mother-in-law who was a member of the nominator's family unit and therefore relevant to the determination. 15.On 1 March 1999 consent orders were entered in the Federal Court of Australia remitting the matter to the IRT for reconsideration according to law. As the IRT had not completed its reconsideration by 31 May 1999 the matter was transferred to the Tribunal on 1 June 1999. 16.A hearing was held on 10 November 2000 at which the visa applicant gave evidence. She told the Tribunal that she plays an important role in the care of the children. She said that the nominator and her husband have four children of their own and a further four who are the children of the husband's late brother. The visa applicant stated that the nominator's children currently living in the household are Jean-Claude aged 9 years, Natalie aged 7 years and Nina aged 2 years. The oldest child, Judy, aged 28 years, is married and lives with her husband in Mount Waverley. The adopted children in the home are Eli aged 25 years, Patricia aged 19 years and Najla aged 11 years. Joseph, aged 26 years, has been living in Lebanon with family members for 3 years. The nominator's mother-in-law, aged in her late 80's, is in Lebanon and has been on an extended holiday in the United States and Lebanon since 1997. 17.The visa applicant said that she looks after the children, takes them to school and performs household tasks such as cooking, cleaning and washing of clothes. She explained that the family lives above the restaurant in Belgrave, and the commitment to the running of the restaurant requires the nominator to spend long hours helping her husband. The visa applicant stated that Jean-Claude has special needs, as he suffered head injuries in 1992 as the result of an accident and he had an operation on his brain. She said that although he made a good recovery he exhibits behavioural problems and requires constant supervision, which she provides to a large extent. She said that Nina is an asthmatic and requires particular care from her. 18.In relation to other members of the household, the visa applicant stated that she assisted with the care of the nominator's mother-in-law before she departed in 1997. Although the mother-in-law had been in reasonable health, her age and reduced ability to assist in the home had placed further responsibility on the visa applicant. The visa applicant said that Eli is a 4th year medical student who spends some time out of the home, and Patricia is a full-time student who is able to look after herself. She stated that the nominator has come to rely on her assistance, as there is little in the way of community or other help available. She said that the situation would become more difficult from January 2001, when the nominator is due to give birth to twins. This will place further strain on the nominator and her ability to cope with the household and to assist in the restaurant.”
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Tribunal summarised as follows the remaining evidence taken at the hearing;21.Ms Boulos stated that she and the visa applicant have no contact with their three sisters who live in Lebanon, but she maintains irregular contact with her brother. She said that her mother-in-law used to help with the care of the children and other household tasks, but recently she developed health problems that have delayed her return to Australia. Ms Boulos stated that her mother-in-law is expected to return to Australia soon, and will need someone to help care for her.22.The migration agent representing the visa applicant submitted a letter dated 11 October 2000 from Dr Diane Phillips, the family's medical practitioner, who stated that the visa applicant has been central to the children's lives for seven years. Dr Phillips added that:“Her assistance will be invaluable with the expected twins and her presence allows a supervised childhood for all these children whilst their mother works long hours at the restaurant.”23.The migration agent also submitted a letter dated 7 November 2000 from Dr Michael Groner, special education teacher for Jean-Claude and Najla, who stated that both children are in need of special extended learning assistance and that an at-home program in terms of educational support is extremely important for both children's continued development. He said that the presence of the visa applicant within the household as an additional source of support:“could be of much benefit to their development in terms of assisting with their schoolwork or in taking on other domestic responsibilities which might then allow Mr or Mrs Boulos to spend more time in supporting the children's related education within the home.”24.A psychosocial assessment dated 9 June 2000 by Marie Spinosa, Social Worker, was produced to the Tribunal. In the assessment Ms Spinosa reviewed the family dynamics and stated that:“I have no doubt that there is a `special need relationship' between the children, Sabah and her sister Dunia from January 1994 and is still today. In fact with the benefit of hindsight I can see that without her help the family was at great risk of disintegration or other manifestations concomitant with coping with day to day life with 8 children and little support.”Ms Spinosa concluded that the visa applicant and the nominator are very close and that this type of closeness cannot be replicated by community services nor can community services provide this quality of assistance.25.The Tribunal's attention was drawn to documents previously submitted in support of the application. These include letters from Members of Parliament, customers of the restaurant and the Minister of Our Lady of Lebanon Maronite Parish. In relation to Jean-Claude, the Tribunal has before it a letter dated 18 July 1997 from Jean-Claude's Grade 1 teacher, and a letter dated 21 January 1998 from Dr Phillips stating that the child made a good recovery from the injury and that the visa applicant could provide supervision if this was needed in the event that epilepsy develops. Letters dated 27 June 1997 and 22 July 1997 from a neurosurgeon described the injuries suffered by Jean-Claude and the operation to remove a metal fragment from the child's brain. The neurosurgeon stated that the child made a satisfactory recovery.26.The migration agent submitted that the nominator's need for assistance arises because, without such assistance, there is a threat to the nominator's mental health and the growth and development of those within her family unit.”The Tribunal’s decision