Edith Bocaz and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

[2012] AATA 847 

Division TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION

File Number

 2010/4160

Re

Edith Bocaz

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms G Lazanas, Senior Member

Date 30 November 2012  
Place Sydney

The Tribunal:

1.Sets aside the objection decision for Ms Bocaz in relation to the income year ended 30 June 2008.

2.Remits the objection decision to the Commissioner of Taxation for reconsideration in accordance with these Reasons.

.................................[sgd].......................................

Ms G Lazanas, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

TAXATION - INCOME TAX - Deduction claimed by Applicant in respect of share of interest expenses and other expenses relating to residential properties tenanted to ex-husband and son – whether non-commercial arrangements - decision set aside and remitted for reconsideration.

LEGISLATION

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 - ss 6-5, 8-1

CASES

Fletcher v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 173 CLR 1

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Groser (1982) 65 FLR 121
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Kowal (1983) 79 FLR 75
Madigan v Commissioner of Taxation (1996) 68 FCR 12

Ure v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1981) 50 FLR 219

SECONDARY MATERIALS

New South Wales Department of Family & Community Services, Assessing Trends - Centre for Affordable Housing - Housing NSW, FOR DECISION

Ms G Lazanas, Senior Member

30 November 2012

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Edith Bocaz is a retired school teacher who is in dispute with the Commissioner of Taxation (Commissioner) with respect to deductions that she claimed in her tax return for the income year ended 30 June 2008.  The deductions claimed by Ms Bocaz were in respect of her share of interest expenses and other expenses relating to two residential properties in Eastlakes, New South Wales. 

  2. The Commissioner takes the view that rent was not derived from either of the residential properties and, therefore, Ms Bocaz is not entitled to claim any deductions.  In the alternative, the Commissioner states that if rent was derived from the residential properties, any expenses that were incurred would only be deductible to the extent of the assessable income.  There is the additional issue of Ms Bocaz not having substantiated all of the deductions which were claimed to have been incurred in the relevant year and to have claimed expenses for the entire year, when in fact she owned the properties, as a co-owner, for only part of the relevant year.

  3. The Commissioner’s primary position is premised on the fact that both residential properties were occupied in the relevant income year by relatives. Ms Bocaz’s ex-husband occupied one residential unit, while the other unit was occupied by one of her sons.  The Commissioner states that these tenancy arrangements were private and domestic arrangements such that any payments to Ms Bocaz for occupation did not possess the requisite characteristics of assessable income.  The Commissioner states that they were non-commercial arrangements evidenced by the non-arm’s length rate of rent, if any, charged.  Accordingly, the Commissioner has denied the claims made by Ms Bocaz for deductions.

  4. I am satisfied, based on the evidence, that Ms Bocaz earned rent from the tenancy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Edith Bocaz and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 847
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Edith Bocaz and the Commissioner of Taxation were before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to determine the validity of tax deductions claimed by Ms Bocaz in respect of interest expenses and other expenses related to residential properties that she had rented to her ex-husband and son. The Tribunal was required to decide whether the arrangements were non-commercial in nature, thereby precluding the deductions, or whether they were legitimate business transactions that justified the claimed deductions. The Commissioner argued that the payments made to Ms Bocaz were not assessable income because they did not have the characteristics of income and were instead reflective of private or domestic arrangements. Conversely, Ms Bocaz maintained that she was entitled to the deductions as the arrangements were legitimate rental agreements.

The Tribunal found that Ms Bocaz was indeed earning rent from the tenancy arrangements and that these were not non-commercial. Therefore, she should not be denied all her claims for deductions nor should her claims be limited to the extent of the rent earned. However, the Tribunal also noted that Ms Bocaz could not claim all the expenses as allowable deductions, as she held her interest in the properties for only part of the year, and some of these expenses needed to be pro-rated for the relevant period. The Tribunal set aside the Commissioner’s objection decision and remitted it to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with the Tribunal's reasons. The Tribunal concluded that Ms Bocaz should be allowed to claim deductions for her proportionate share of the expenses incurred during the period she held an interest in the properties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I am satisfied, based on the evidence, that Ms Bocaz earned rent from the tenancy arrangements. I am also persuaded by the explanations provided by Ms Bocaz with respect to the tenancy arrangements and find that they were not non-commercial arrangements. Therefore, Ms Bocaz should not be generally denied all her claims for the deductions nor should her claims be limited to the extent of the rent earned from the residential properties. However, Ms Bocaz cannot claim all of the expenses as allowable deductions, as she held her interest in the properties for only part of the year and some of these expenses need to be pro-rated for the relevant period. Accordingly, I have decided to set aside the Commissioner’s objection decision and to remit it to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with these Reasons. FACTUAL BACKGROUND Ms Bocaz is 63 years of age and retired. In the relevant income year ended 30 June 2008, she was a school teacher. She had been married to Hector Gutierrez Cuitino but had been divorced from about 1997. Mr Cuitino passed away in January 2010. Ms Bocaz has two sons, Hector Gutierrez Bocaz (Mr Bocaz) and Dr Christian Gutierrez. Mr Bocaz was the co-owner of both residential properties with his mother in the relevant income year, and purchased the interest of Ms Bocaz in one of the residential units part way through the year. Her other son, Dr Christian Gutierrez, purchased the interest of Ms Bocaz in the other residential unit part way through the relevant year of income. As explained below, Ms Bocaz’s claims for deductions are referable to her 50 per cent interest of each of the properties and, in most cases, for that part of the year for which she was a co-owner. Although the calculations in Ms Bocaz’s tax return did not reflect this latter factor, she accepted during the hearing that that was the proper analysis for certain expenses and the issue of apportionment based on period of ownership of the properties was, therefore, no longer in dispute. In February 1999, Ms Bocaz and her son, Mr Bocaz, purchased a residential unit at Barber Avenue, Eastlakes (the Barber Avenue Property), as joint tenants, for $170,000. During the 2008 income year, the Barber Avenue Property was occupied by Ms Bocaz’s ex-husband. Her ex-husband had moved into the property in or about 2000, after he returned from living overseas. Ms Bocaz sold her interest in the Barber Avenue Property to her other son, Dr Gutierrez, in mid-January 2008. In February 2003, Ms Bocaz and her son, Mr Bocaz, purchased another residential unit at Dalby Place, Eastlakes (the Dalby Place Property), as joint tenants, for $281,000. During the 2008 income year, the Dalby Place Property was occupied by Ms Bocaz’s son, Mr Bocaz with his girlfriend. Ms Bocaz sold her interest in the Dalby Place Property to Mr Bocaz in mid-November 2007. On 4 September 2008, Ms Bocaz filed her income tax return for the year ended 30 June 2008 through her tax agent. She declared, besides her salary from teaching, gross rental income of $6,128 and she claimed interest expenses of $11,769 and other expenses of $11,345 with respect to the two residential properties. She did not prepare any part of her tax return but handed over folders containing the receipts for her tax agent to attend to the calculations, including as to the depreciation of items.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Commissioner contends that the Applicant did not receive rental payments that amounted to assessable income because the payments, if any, received by her do not have the characteristics of income and instead are reflective of a private or domestic arrangement between the Applicant and her ex-husband and son in respect of the properties. The Commissioner also argues that any expenses incurred by the Applicant are not deductible in accordance with paragraph 8-1(2)(b) of the 1997 Tax Act as they are of a private or domestic nature. Not surprisingly, these issues arise because the deductions claimed by Ms Bocaz exceed the rental payments in respect of the two residential properties.THE EVIDENCE OF MS BOCAZ Ms Bocaz stated that she and her son, as co-owners of the Barber Avenue Property, together received $200 rent per week in cash from Mr Cuitino, her ex-husband, who occupied this property since about 2000 until January 2010 when he passed away. Ms Bocaz stated that she received rent of $165 rent per week in cash for her 50 per cent interest in the Dalby Place Property from her son, Mr Bocaz, who occupied that property. Mr Bocaz owned the other 50 per cent interest in each of the properties. Ms Bocaz told the Tribunal that there was no written tenancy agreement with respect to either of the properties nor was there any real estate agent involved in these arrangements and, therefore, she did not pay any commission to an agent. Ms Bocaz gave evidence that she trusted her ex-husband to pay the rent and to look after the Barber Avenue Property and did not arrange for any rental bond or landlord insurance. Ms Bocaz also trusted her son to pay the rent in respect of the Dalby Place Property and, further, it was in his interest to do so, as he was the co-owner of both properties. Ms Bocaz stated that both units were in very poor condition when they were purchased and that considerable work was required, including renovations to the respective kitchens, bathrooms and flooring. It was Ms Bocaz’s position that the rent that she received, in particular from her ex-husband for the Barber Avenue Property over a period of some 10 years, reflected the condition of the property and the arrangements that she had made for the renovations and repairs.Barber Avenue Property Ms Bocaz told the Tribunal that she and her son had opted to lease the Barber Avenue Property to her ex-husband for $200 per week in 2000 when he moved in, on the basis that he would live in the property in the condition it was in at that time, and undertake the necessary renovations and repairs to the unit over a period of time. The Barber Avenue Property was described as a ground floor, small two bedroom unit with a bathroom and balcony in a building that is more than 50 years old and located in a noisy area. Being a ground floor unit, Ms Bocaz considered that there were also security concerns. Ms Bocaz stated that prior to her ex-husband moving in, the Barber Avenue Property was rented by a local real estate agent to tenants for $175 per week for approximately a year after she purchased the property with her son in 1999. She said that it was the cheapest flat for sale at that time because the condition of the property was “really bad”. She said that there was no functioning stove and no floor coverings, only a concrete slab. The tenants living there beforehand used the property as sleeping quarters only on the basis, as she observed, that there were some 12 bunk beds throughout the residential unit but no functioning kitchen.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The deductions claimed for depreciation and borrowing expenses were also not pro-rated and I find that these should also be adjusted to reflect her period of ownership in the relevant income year. Certain other expenses that were incurred by Ms Bocaz in the relevant period of her ownership, such as for rubbish removal, do not require any apportionment, except as to her 50 per cent interest in the properties.CONCLUSION The objection decision under review in relation to the income tax assessment for Ms Bocaz for the year ended 30 June 2008 is set aside. The Tribunal remits the objection decision to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with these Reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established