FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Eat Media Pty Ltd v Mulready Media Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 392
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Eat Media Pty Ltd v Mulready Media Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2010] FCA 392
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of Eat Media Pty Ltd v Mulready Media Pty Ltd (No 2) arose from a dispute between two small businesses regarding the resolution of costs incurred in litigation. The parties had previously engaged in proceedings where a costs order was made in favour of the applicant, Eat Media Pty Ltd, amounting to $67,832.14. The matter then proceeded to the resolution of these costs, which led to a Deed being signed on 30 March 2010, setting out an agreed costs award of $45,000 to be paid in instalments. The case before the court involved the enforcement of this Deed through an order under Order 62 Rule 4(2)(c) of the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (Qld).
The central legal issue before the court was whether to grant an order enforcing the payment of costs as agreed upon in the Deed. This required consideration of the principles underpinning the enforcement of such agreements and whether the delay in seeking the court's order was justified under the circumstances. The court had to assess the appropriateness of the costs claimed, the fairness of the agreed payment plan, and the procedural steps taken by the parties in reaching the agreement.
The court found that the parties had diligently negotiated the terms of the Deed, which provided a clear and fair basis for resolving the costs dispute. The delay in approaching the court was attributed to the need to first determine the existence and basis of any costs order before addressing the quantum. The court acknowledged that the costs claimed were logical, fair, and reasonable given the extent of the proceedings. The court concluded that the enforcement of the Deed through an order under Order 62 Rule 4(2)(c) was appropriate, as it provided a means to achieve finality and avoid the uncertainty and expense of a formal taxation process. The court also dispensed with the requirement of Practice Notice CM 4 due to the unique circumstances of the case.
The court ordered that the Deed be enforced, and the respondent, Mulready Media Pty Ltd, was directed to pay the agreed instalments as per the terms of the Deed. The order aimed to provide certainty and finality to the parties, facilitating the resolution of the costs dispute in a manner that was practical and efficient.
The central legal issue before the court was whether to grant an order enforcing the payment of costs as agreed upon in the Deed. This required consideration of the principles underpinning the enforcement of such agreements and whether the delay in seeking the court's order was justified under the circumstances. The court had to assess the appropriateness of the costs claimed, the fairness of the agreed payment plan, and the procedural steps taken by the parties in reaching the agreement.
The court found that the parties had diligently negotiated the terms of the Deed, which provided a clear and fair basis for resolving the costs dispute. The delay in approaching the court was attributed to the need to first determine the existence and basis of any costs order before addressing the quantum. The court acknowledged that the costs claimed were logical, fair, and reasonable given the extent of the proceedings. The court concluded that the enforcement of the Deed through an order under Order 62 Rule 4(2)(c) was appropriate, as it provided a means to achieve finality and avoid the uncertainty and expense of a formal taxation process. The court also dispensed with the requirement of Practice Notice CM 4 due to the unique circumstances of the case.
The court ordered that the Deed be enforced, and the respondent, Mulready Media Pty Ltd, was directed to pay the agreed instalments as per the terms of the Deed. The order aimed to provide certainty and finality to the parties, facilitating the resolution of the costs dispute in a manner that was practical and efficient.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
After a short adjournment, the parties handed up a statement of “Agreed Facts” which provided as follows (without alteration):Agreed Facts1.On 14 September 2009 the parties appeared before the Court on an argument as to costs of the proceedings.2.On 14 September 2009 the parties argued for competing costs orders and consequently were unable to seek a specific gross sum until the extent of any costs order was known.3.A costs order was made in the Applicant’s favour on 21 September 2009.4.On 13 October 2009 the Applicant wrote to the Respondent seeking to resolve the costs order by consent.5.The total amount of costs incurred by the Applicant was $67,832.14 (including counsel’s fees and disbursements)6.Between 13 October 2009 and 22 February 2010, the parties engaged in correspondence in an attempt to resolve the costs order.7.A final agreement for costs to be resolved was made on 30 March 2010.8.A Deed was signed between the parties setting out the agreed costs award at $45,000 payable in instalments of:(a) $15,000 on or before 20 April 2010.(b) $10,000 to be paid on or before 20 May 2010.(c) $10,000 to be paid on or before 20 June 2010.(d) $10,000 to be paid on or before 20 July 2010.9.The purpose of entering into the Deed, which sought an order be made under Order 62 Rule (4)(2)(c), was so that the parties could achieve finality as to the amount and payment regime for costs without the time, expense and uncertainty of a taxation process.10.In exchange for the Applicant agreeing a payment by instalments plan, the Respondent’s agreed to an order being made under Order 62 Rule (4)(2)(c) so that fresh proceedings pursuant to the Deed would not have to be commenced by the Applicant if there was default in payment by the Respondents.11.Both parties in these proceedings are small businesses with limited resources.12.The Respondents have paid the first instalment as agreed. That statement of “Agreed Facts”, it is considered, provides a basis upon which the discretion may now be exercised to give effect to the agreement of the parties. The statement of “Agreed Facts” sufficiently explains the reasons for the apparent delay in approaching the Court for an order pursuant to O 62 r 4(2)(c). Time was necessarily expended in negotiating the agreement now reached. Indeed, the time taken may well be less than the time otherwise involved in a formal process of taxation of costs. And, although some reservation is expressed as to why an order pursuant to O 62 r 4(2)(c) was not previously sought in September 2009, there is some merit in the parties first resolving whether any costs order at all should be made and, if so, on what basis before turning attention to the quantum of any costs that may be payable. Although initial reservation was expressed as to the quantum of costs set forth in the “Agreed Facts”, oral submissions focussed attention upon the fact that the proceeding had as at September 2009 reached the point where there had been an earlier interlocutory hearing and where pleadings had been amended, discovery completed and affidavits filed. Most of the costs to be involved in a contested hearing, it was submitted, had by then already been incurred. Given the steps that had been taken, the fees claimed may well fall within the range of what would otherwise be expected and what would otherwise be regarded as “logical, fair and reasonable”. Compliance with Practice Notice CM 4 is, in the present proceeding, dispensed with.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi