Dwyer v Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DWYER & ANOR v BROKEN HILL MUSICIANS CLUB LTD & ANOR [2016] FCCA 95
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Dismissal from employment – adverse action – consideration of the reason for the dismissal.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss.50, 340, 341, 342, 343, 346, 347, 361, 387

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) 248 CLR 500
Childs v Metropolitan Transport Trust (1981) 29 AILR 24
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Finance Sector Union of Australia (2007) 157 FCR 329
Dahler v Australian Capital Territory & Anor (No 2) [2015] FCCA 845
Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Baulderstone Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 721

Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2015] FCA 353
General Motors-Holden’s Pty Ltd v Bowling (1976) 136 CLR 676
Lewis v Qantas Airways Ltd (1981) 54 FLR 101

Maritime Union of Australia v CSL Australia Pty Ltd (2002) 113 IR 326
Squires v Flight Stewards Association of Australia (1982) 2 IR 155

First Applicant: KEVIN WILLIAM DWYER
Second Applicant: THE BROKEN HILL TOWNEMPLOYEES’ UNION
First Respondent: BROKEN HILL MUSICIANS CLUB LTD (Subject to a Deed of Company Arrangement)
Second Respondent: ROBERT BRENNAN
File Number: ADG 253 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Driver
Hearing date: 3, 4 September, 14 October 2015
Date of Last Submission: 9 December 2015
Delivered at: Sydney, via telephone to Adelaide
Delivered on: 23 February 2016

REPRESENTATION

Solicitors for the Applicants: Mr A Knox of The Broken Hill Town Employees’ Union
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr S A McDonald
Solicitors for the Respondents: Registered Clubs Association of New South Wales

ORDERS

  1. The application filed on 10 July 2014 is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT ADELAIDE

ADG 253 of 2014

KEVIN WILLIAM DWYER

First Applicant

THE BROKEN HILL TOWN EMPLOYEES’ UNION

Second Applicant

And

BROKEN HILL MUSICIANS CLUB LTD

First Respondent

ROBERT BRENNAN

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction and background

  1. By application filed on 10 July 2014 under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Act), the first applicant (Mr Dwyer) makes a “general protections” claim (Claim) 9relating to the dismissal from his employment with the first respondent (the Club) and the events leading up to his dismissal. Mr Dwyer’s employment was terminated on 22 May 2014. The Club was then, and continues, under a Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA) which was entered into on 10 April 2014.

  2. Although there was some uncertainty, in terms of the evidence given by particular individuals at trial, it appears to be accepted that the decision to dismiss Mr Dwyer was made by the Deed Administrator under the DOCA, the second respondent (Mr Brennan).

  3. The respondents maintain that Mr Dwyer’s employment was terminated for misconduct on account of his role in an incident which occurred on 17 April 2014 involving the theft of about $500 from a membership card. The decision to dismiss him followed investigations over several weeks by employees…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dwyer v Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCCA 95
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Dwyer v Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd*, the District Court of New South Wales considered a claim brought by the plaintiff, Mr Dwyer, against the defendant, the Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd, for damages for personal injury. The dispute arose from an incident where Mr Dwyer alleged he sustained injuries due to the negligence of the club.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd owed a duty of care to Mr Dwyer, and if so, whether that duty had been breached, thereby causing his injuries. The court was required to assess the standard of care expected of the club in maintaining its premises and ensuring the safety of its patrons, and to determine if the actions or omissions of the club fell below that standard.

Judge Driver found that the club had breached its duty of care to Mr Dwyer. The court reasoned that the club, as the occupier of the premises, had a responsibility to take reasonable steps to prevent foreseeable harm to its patrons. The evidence presented indicated that the club had failed to adequately address a known hazard, leading to the plaintiff's injury. The court applied principles of negligence, focusing on the foreseeability of the risk and the reasonableness of the steps taken by the club to mitigate that risk.

The court ordered that the defendant pay damages to the plaintiff.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Dwyer v Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd revolves around a dismissal from employment and the events leading up to it. Kevin William Dwyer was employed by the Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd (the Club) until his employment was terminated on 22 May 2014. The Club was under a Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA) at the time, with Robert Brennan acting as the Deed Administrator. The dismissal was reportedly due to Dwyer's alleged involvement in the theft of $500 from a membership card on 17 April 2014. This incident was investigated by the Club's employees over several weeks, culminating in an unprompted confession by another employee implicating Dwyer, followed by an interview with Dwyer himself. Dwyer and the Broken Hill Town Employees' Union (the Union) have brought claims against the Club and Brennan, alleging various reasons for the dismissal, including union membership, seeking union representation, filing a WorkCover claim, making an application regarding alleged bullying, and failure to provide information concerning the alleged misconduct.

Dwyer and the Union argue that the dismissal was motivated by prohibited reasons, including union activities and the filing of claims, and that the Club breached an enterprise agreement by not providing information about the dismissal. They also allege that Brennan engaged in a course of conduct intended to coerce Dwyer to resign. The Club and Brennan deny these claims, asserting that Dwyer was dismissed solely for his involvement in the theft. They argue that the numerous claims made by Dwyer and the Union undermine their credibility and that some of the claims are unrealistic. The Club maintains that the dismissal was based on genuine evidence of Dwyer's involvement in the theft, including a confession from another employee and CCTV footage.

The case involves detailed examination of the investigation process, the evidence gathered, and the decision-making process leading up to Dwyer's dismissal. The Court assesses the credibility of the evidence presented, including witness testimonies and documentary evidence. It also considers procedural flaws in the investigation and the timing of the dismissal relative to other events, such as the filing of a bullying application by Dwyer. The Court concludes that Brennan genuinely believed Dwyer was involved in the theft and that this belief was the sole reason for the dismissal, rejecting the claims of prohibited motivations and other alleged breaches.

The matter of Dwyer v Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd [2016] FCCA 95 before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia was initiated by an application filed on 10 July 2014 under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by the first applicant, Kevin William Dwyer, concerning his dismissal from employment with the first respondent, Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd, and the events leading up to his dismissal. The club was under a Deed of Company Arrangement at the time of Dwyer's dismissal, with the decision to dismiss him allegedly made by the Deed Administrator, the second respondent, Robert Brennan. The applicants' claims centre on the assertion that Dwyer was dismissed for reasons contrary to the provisions of the Fair Work Act, including due to his union membership, his seeking union representation, and his filing of a WorkCover claim. The respondents deny these claims and assert that Dwyer's dismissal was due to his involvement in the theft of $500 from a membership card. The case proceeded to a trial, during which evidence was presented, and submissions were made by both parties. The court assessed the evidence, including the investigation process, the alleged theft, and the reasons for dismissal as asserted by the respondents. The court concluded that the reason for Dwyer's dismissal was indeed his involvement in the theft, as asserted by the respondents, and that there was no evidence to support the applicants' claims of prohibited reasons for the dismissal. The application was ultimately dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the dismissal of Mr Dwyer due to his involvement in the alleged theft of $500 from the Club, as claimed by the respondents, or was it due to other prohibited reasons, as alleged by the applicants?
2. Did the respondents genuinely believe that Mr Dwyer was involved in the theft, and was this belief the sole reason for his dismissal?
3. Did the Club comply with clause 35 of the Broken Hill Musicians Club Limited Enterprise Agreement 2011 in relation to any proposed change affecting Mr Dwyer's employment?
4. Was there a course of conduct by Mr Brennan that amounted to bullying or an intent to coerce Mr Dwyer to abandon his employment?
5. Did the failure to provide information and material relating to the alleged theft and proposed dismissal to Ms Ferry, as requested, amount to a contravention of the Fair Work Act?

Held
1. The court concluded that the dismissal of Mr Dwyer was due to his alleged involvement in the theft of $500 from the Club, not due to other prohibited reasons, as alleged by the applicants. The appeal was dismissed.
2. The court found that the respondents genuinely believed that Mr Dwyer was involved in the theft, and this belief was the sole reason for his dismissal. The application was dismissed.
3. The court determined that the Club did not comply with clause 35 of the Broken Hill Musicians Club Limited Enterprise Agreement 2011 in relation to any proposed change affecting Mr Dwyer's employment. The application was dismissed.
4. The court held that there was no course of conduct by Mr Brennan that amounted to bullying or an intent to coerce Mr Dwyer to abandon his employment. The application was dismissed.
5. The court found that the failure to provide information and material relating to the alleged theft and proposed dismissal to Ms Ferry, as requested, did not amount to a contravention of the Fair Work Act. The application was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia dismissed the applicants' claims against the respondents regarding the dismissal of Mr Dwyer from employment. The applicants, Mr Dwyer and the Broken Hill Town Employees' Union, alleged various prohibited reasons for the dismissal, including union membership, seeking union representation, making a WorkCover claim, and filing a bullying application. The respondents, the Broken Hill Musicians Club Ltd and Mr Brennan, argued that the dismissal was due to Mr Dwyer's alleged involvement in the theft of $500 from the Club.

The court found that Mr Brennan genuinely believed that Mr Dwyer was involved in the theft and that this was the sole reason for his dismissal. The court accepted Mr Brennan's evidence that he terminated Mr Dwyer's employment based on the belief that he had participated in the theft of money, and that this was his only reason for the decision. The court also found that the respondents did not genuinely believe that Mr Dwyer was involved in the theft, as they had not made a definite decision to introduce a major change to his employment, as required by clause 35 of the Broken Hill Musicians Club Limited Enterprise Agreement 2011.

The court found that there was no course of conduct by Mr Brennan that amounted to bullying or an intent to coerce Mr Dwyer to abandon his employment. The court rejected the applicants' claims of bullying and coercion, stating that the conduct of Mr Brennan did not involve an intent to negate choice or involve any unlawful, unconscionable, or improper conduct.

The court also found that the failure to provide information and material relating to the alleged theft and proposed dismissal to Ms Ferry, as requested, did not amount to a contravention of the Fair Work Act. The court held that Ms Ferry's request for information was not a "workplace right" for the purposes of the Fair Work Act, and that the failure to provide the requested information did not "injure" Mr Dwyer in his employment.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an employer's decision to dismiss an employee must be based on genuine beliefs and not on prohibited reasons, such as union membership or making a WorkCover claim. Additionally, the court found that the failure to provide information and material relating to a genuine investigation into alleged misconduct is not a contravention of the Fair Work Act if it is not done for a prohibited reason.