DWD Project Pty Ltd v Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

CITATION:DWD Project Pty Ltd & Anor v Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority [2023] NTCA 3

PARTIES:DWD PROJECT PTY LTD (ACN 601 275 108)

and

ANTHONY, Michael Adrian

v

NORTHERN TERRITORY ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY

TITLE OF COURT:  COURT OF APPEAL OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  CIVIL APPEAL from the SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:AP 7 of 2022 (22037655)

DELIVERED:  4 April 2023

HEARING DATE:  11 November 2022

JUDGMENT OF:  Grant CJ, Kelly & Blokland JJ

CATCHWORDS:

CRIME – Appeals – Appeal against conviction – Wrong decision on a question of law

Whether pollution abatement notices not issued in the approved form and therefore invalid – As a matter of statutory construction, the issue of notices in other than approved form did not invalidate them – Notices substantially complied with the approved form – Whether complaints issued outside limitation period – Purpose of amending pollution abatement notice not to extend limitation period – Issue of amended notice establishes fresh obligation on recipient – Failure to comply by extended date for compliance gives rise to fresh offence which is subject to fresh limitation period – Appeal dismissed.

Interpretation Act 1978 (NT) s 68
Supreme Court Act1979 (NT) s 51
Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1989 (NT) s 12, s 77, s 79, s 80, s 80, s 83, s 94

Banjima People v Western Australia (No 2) (2013) 305 ALR 1, Bianamu v Rigby [2021] NTCA 4; John Mann International Limited v Vehicle Inspectorate [2004] EWHC 1236, NB & Ors v SB & Ors [2020] NTCA 2, Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355, R v Haynes and Haynes [1916] NZLR 407, R v Turner (2001) 10 Tas R 233, Saraswati v The Queen [1990] 172 CLR 1, SPNZT Ltd v Trecap Pty Ltd [2016] WASC 75, Swann v R [1999] WASCA 106, referred to.

COSTS – Party/Party – Bases of quantification – Factors relevant to the court’s discretion when quantifying costs

Costs of appeal from Local Court to Supreme Court a discretionary matter – Exercise of that discretion informed by length and complexity of case – Relevant consideration that offences committed in commercial context – Appeals more complex than the standard appeal from Local Court – Appeals raised important questions of statutory interpretation within a reasonably complex statutory context – No error demonstrated – Appeal dismissed.

Thyer v Whittington (No 2) [2018] NTSC 31, referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellants:D Robinson SC

Respondent:  T Moses

Solicitors:

Appellants:Clayton Utz

Respondent:  Hutton McCarthy

Judgment category classification:    B

Number of pages:  35

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

DWD Project Pty Ltd & Anor v Northern Territory

Environment Protection Authority [2023] NTCA 3

No. AP 7 of 2022 (22037655)

BETWEEN:

DWD PROJECT PTY LTD

(ACN 601 276 108)

First Appellant

AND:

MICHAEL ADRIAN ANTHONY

Second Appellant

AND:

NORTHERN TERRITORY ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY

Respondent

CORAM:    GRANT CJ, KELLY and BLOKLAND…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DWD Project Pty Ltd v Northern Territory Environment Protect... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NTCA 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

DWD Project Pty Ltd and Michael Anthony appeal against the Supreme Court's decision to dismiss their appeal against convictions and penalties imposed by the Local Court. The convictions and penalties arose from alleged offences under the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1989 (NT) involving the dumping of pollutants on land and in adjacent water. The respondents issued pollution abatement notices (PANs) to the appellants, which were not strictly in the approved form. The appellants argued the notices were invalid because they did not adhere to the approved form. They also claimed the amended notices were issued outside the statutory limitation period.

The court was required to determine whether the pollution abatement notices, not issued in the approved form, were valid. The court also had to decide if the amended notices were issued outside the limitation period, and whether the issuance of amended notices extended the limitation period or created a new obligation. The court examined the statutory requirements for the form of the notices, the consequences of issuing notices not in the approved form, and the effect of amending the notices on the limitation period. Additionally, the court considered whether the amended notices established a new obligation, and if non-compliance with the extended compliance date resulted in a fresh offence subject to a new limitation period.

The court found that the notices, though not in the approved form, substantially complied with it. Therefore, they were valid. The court held that amending the notices did not extend the limitation period; rather, it created a fresh obligation on the recipient. Consequently, non-compliance by the extended compliance date gave rise to a fresh offence subject to a fresh limitation period. The court concluded that the Supreme Court did not err in its reasoning and dismissed the appeal. The convictions and penalties imposed by the Local Court were affirmed.

The appeal is dismissed. The convictions and penalties imposed by the Local Court remain in place.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal against a decision of the Supreme Court dismissing an appeal against convictions and penalties imposed by a Judge of the Local Court for offences under s 80(1) of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1989 (NT) (“the WMPC Act”) of intentionally contravening or intentionally failing to comply with the requirements of an amended pollution abatement notice issued by the respondent on 1 June 2020.Background The first appellant, DWD Project Pty Ltd (“DWD”), is the owner of land on Stokes Hill Road, Darwin which adjoins vacant Crown Land. The second appellant, Michael Anthony (“Mr Anthony”), is the sole director and shareholder of DWD. It was alleged that DWD dumped a large volume of uncontrolled fill material containing a range of pollutants on its own land, on the adjacent Crown land, and in the water immediately adjacent to that land. On 12 October 2018, the respondent issued pollution abatement notices (“PANs”) to DWD and Mr Anthony pursuant to s 77 of the WMPC Act. These notices set out the bases on which the respondent “believe[d] on reasonable grounds” that the appellants had committed an offence against s 83 or had contravened s 12 of the WMPC Act, and required the appellants to:(a)provide a Waste Removal Management Plan to the respondent by 31 October 2018;(b)provide a Waste Sampling, Classification, Quality Assurance and Disposal Plan to the respondent by no later than 31 October 2018;(c)remove all wastes and contaminants that had been used to fill and/or reclaim land at the premises since 20 October 2015 by 15 December 2018;(d)return the land/sea boundary of the premises to the boundary identified in aerial imagery of the premises from 30 June 2016 by 15 December 2018; and(e)provide specified reports to the respondent evidencing compliance with the requirements of the PANs by 30 March 2019. Revised PANs were issued to DWD and Mr Anthony on 10 January 2019 and 1 June 2020 extending the time for compliance. The revised PANs were not in identical terms but did require substantially the same remedial action. As is discussed further below, the revised PANs issued on 10 January 2019 also included the formulation that the respondent “believe[d] on reasonable grounds” that the appellants had committed an offence against s 83 or had contravened s 12 of the WMPC Act. The revised PANs issued on 1 June 2020 did not contain that precise formulation, but were structured to include a Part detailing the reasons for the belief that the appellants had committed an offence against s 83 or had contravened s 12 of the WMPC Act. It was not contested that the appellants did not comply with the PANs. Separate prosecutions were commenced against the appellants alleging:(a)a contravention of s 83(1) of the WMPC Act by intentionally polluting the environment where serious environmental harm results (“the s 83 charges”); (b)summary offences under s 75 of the Planning Act 1999 (NT) (“the planning charges”); and(c)a contravention of s 80(1) of the WMPC Act by intentionally failing to comply with the PANs (“the PAN charges”).

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Bianamu v Rigby,[3] Kelly and Hiley JJ said:The role of the Court of Appeal when hearing an appeal against a decision of the Supreme Court when the Supreme Court was sitting as an intermediate court of appeal, has been considered in a number of decisions of this Court. Tiver Constructions Pty Ltd v Clair was an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court as the intermediate appellate court hearing an appeal from the Workers Compensation Court. Under the relevant legislation, the appeal to the Supreme Court was confined to questions of law. In examining the nature of the appeal to the Court of Appeal, Gallop J referred to the provisions of the Supreme Court Act set out above and expressed the view that the extensive powers granted to the Court of Appeal by s 55 point to the right of appeal to the Court of Appeal being in the nature of a rehearing, and not confined to questions of law. Nevertheless, Gallop J emphasised the undoubtedly correct fact that the appeal to the Court of Appeal involved a review of the decision of the Supreme Court as intermediate court of appeal, and not a rehearing of the case before the Workers Compensation Court. Hence, as the appeal to the Supreme Court was on a question of law only, the appeal from the Supreme Court to the Court of Appeal ought to be similarly confined.Similarly, in Wilson v Lowery, for the same reason, it was held that the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal reviewing a decision of the Supreme Court as an intermediate court of appeal hearing an appeal against a decision of the Workers Compensation Tribunal on a question of law, was limited to questions of law, notwithstanding the breadth of the jurisdiction otherwise given to the Court.However, the focus of each of those decisions, and also of the decision in Lee v McMahon Contractors Pty Ltd, was the ability of the Court of Appeal to become involved in questions of fact that were in the domain of the primary court. Those decisions were not concerned with other kinds of miscarriages of justice that might fall within the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal.As a matter of logic, it must be true that in the general run of appeals to the Court of Appeal from the Supreme Court, where the role of the Supreme Court as an intermediate court of appeal is limited by statute (eg to a question of law), the role of the Court of Appeal on appeal from the Supreme Court will be similarly limited. This is because, as pointed out in Tiver Constructions Pty Ltd v Clair and Wilson v Lowery, the role of the Court of Appeal will generally be to determine whether the Supreme Court was in error in its decision.[Citations omitted and emphasis by underlining added] Although the subject appeal is not limited to questions of law, the role of this court is to determine whether the Supreme Court committed error. The appellants’ written submissions essentially re-argue the case put before the Supreme Court (and, before that, the Local Court). They do not identify any error in the reasoning process of the intermediate appeal judge. However, the Court was taken to various portions of the immediate appeal judge’s reasons in oral argument. We have carefully examined the reasons for decision of the intermediate appeal judge and, for the reasons which follow, we discern no error in that reasoning process or in the orders ultimately made. Ground 1: the approved form

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court reviewed the statutory provisions of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1989 (NT) and determined that the pollution abatement notices substantially complied with the approved form. The court emphasised that the notices required the appellants to take specific actions to address the environmental harm caused by the dumping of uncontrolled fill material. The court found that the notices were valid despite not being in the exact approved form, as the core requirements and the purpose of the notices were met.

The court examined the limitation periods for the complaints and determined that the purpose of amending the pollution abatement notice was not to extend the limitation period. The court held that the limitation period for issuing the complaints remained unaffected by the amendment of the notice. The court relied on the statutory language and the intent behind the legislation to conclude that the limitation period was not extended by the issuance of the amended notice.

Regarding the issuance of the amended pollution abatement notice, the court found that it established a fresh obligation on the recipient. The court held that the amended notice created a new requirement for the appellants to comply with, which resulted in a fresh offence. The court reasoned that the fresh obligation and the corresponding fresh offence were subject to a fresh limitation period.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of whether the failure to comply by the extended date for compliance gave rise to a fresh offence subject to a fresh limitation period. The court held that the failure to comply with the extended date for compliance indeed resulted in a fresh offence, which was subject to a fresh limitation period. The court relied on the statutory language and the intent behind the legislation to conclude that the failure to comply by the extended date resulted in a new offence.