DWD Project Pty Ltd v Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

CITATION:DWD Project Pty Ltd & Anor v Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority [2022] NTSC 37

PARTIES:DWD PROJECT PTY LTD
(ACN 601 276 108)

AND

ANTHONY, Michael Adrian

v

NORTHERN TERRITORY ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  Appeal from LOCAL COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:LCA 35 of 2021 (22037655)
LCA 36 of 2021 (22037649)

DELIVERED ON:  23 May 2022

HEARING DATE:  3 May 2022

JUDGMENT OF:  Burns J

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellants:D Robinson

Respondent:  T Moses

Solicitors:

Appellants:Clayton Utz

Respondent:  Hutton McCarthy

Judgment category classification:  C

Judgment ID Number:  Bur2207

Number of pages:  54

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

DWD Project Pty Ltd & Anor v Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority [2022] NTSC 37

No. LCA 35 of 2021 (22037655)
No. LCA 36 of 2021 (22037649)

IN THE MATTERS of appeal under the Local Court (Criminal Procedure) Act 1928 (NT)

BETWEEN:

DWD PROJECT PTY LTD
(ACN 601 276 108)

First Appellant


AND:


MICHAEL ADRIAN ANTHONY

Second Appellant

AND:

NORTHERN TERRITORY ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY

Respondent

CORAM:    Burns J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 23 May 2022)

  1. These proceedings are appeals from convictions and penalties imposed by a Judge of the Local Court of the Northern Territory (the primary Judge). Each of the appellants were charged with an offence under s 80(1) of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1989 (NT) (the WMPC Act) of intentionally contravening or intentionally failing to comply with the requirements of an amended pollution abatement notice issued by the respondent on 1 June 2020.

  2. A contested hearing took place in which virtually all of the prosecution material was tendered without objection. Only one prosecution witness was required for cross-examination. The appellants led no evidence.

  3. After the hearing, on 1 October 2021 the primary Judge convicted each of the appellants of the offences charged and, after the parties made submissions on sentence, the first appellant, DWD Project Pty Ltd (DWD) was fined $250,000.00 and the second appellant, Michael Anthony, the sole director and shareholder of DWD, was fined $50,000.00. Each appellant was also ordered to pay a victim assistance levy, and costs and disbursements incurred by the respondent.

  4. The respondent, the Northern Territory Environment Protection Agency (the NT EPA, or the respondent) is a body corporate established by the Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority Act 2012 (NT).

Background

  1. On 20 October 2015, DWD became the owner of Lot 5280, Town of Darwin, also known as 4 Mavie Street, Darwin. Adjoining Lot 5280 are Lots 10881 and 10882, known as 2 Stokes Hill Road, Darwin and 41 Stokes Hill Road, Darwin respectively. Both Lots 10881 and 10882 are vacant Crown Land. Each of these three parcels of land have a frontage to Darwin Harbour. For convenience, I will refer to these parcels of land collectively as “the premises”.

  2. It was alleged that since October 2015, DWD had dumped a large volume of uncontrolled fill material on, and in the water immediately adjacent to, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DWD Project Pty Ltd v Northern Territory Environment Protect... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NTSC 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

DWD Project Pty Ltd and Michael Anthony (the appellants) appeal against convictions and penalties imposed upon them by a Judge of the Local Court of the Northern Territory (the primary Judge). The appellants were convicted of offences under s 80 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1989 (NT) (the WMPC Act) for contravening or failing to comply with the requirements of pollution abatement notices (PANs) issued by the respondent, the Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority (the NT EPA). The appellants led no evidence at the hearing of the charges in the Local Court. The appeal against conviction and penalty was dismissed. The primary Judge did not err in finding that the appellants would suffer no unfairness if the hearing of the PAN charges preceded the hearing of the more serious charges in the Supreme Court. The PANs issued by the NT EPA were not invalid by reason of not being in the approved form. The appellants were not precluded from being prosecuted for the alleged failure to comply with the further amended PANs by the limitation period found in s 94 of the WMPC Act. The further amended PANs did not require the appellants to trespass on land belonging to another. The primary Judge was not in error in taking into account the appellants’ conduct during the proceedings in the Local Court in sentencing them. The penalties imposed by the primary Judge were not manifestly unreasonable.

Background

Background to the litigation

DWD Project Pty Ltd (DWD) was the owner of Lot 5280 in Darwin and had dumped a large volume of waste material on the premises. The Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority (the NT EPA) issued pollution abatement notices (PANs) to DWD and Michael Anthony, the sole director and shareholder of DWD, requiring them to remove the dumped waste. DWD and Mr Anthony failed to comply with the PANs, leading to criminal proceedings against them. The appellants were convicted of the offences and fined. The appellants appealed the convictions and sentences, raising several grounds of appeal. The first ground of appeal related to the refusal of the primary Judge to adjourn the hearing of the charges under the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1989 (NT) pending the hearing of other charges. The appellants argued that they would be prejudiced by having to defend the charges before the more serious charges were heard. However, the court found that the primary Judge did not err in finding that no relevant prejudice would arise if the charges were heard in the order they were heard. The second ground of appeal related to the validity of the PANs issued by the NT EPA. The appellants argued that the PANs were invalid because they were not in the approved form. The court found that the PANs were not invalid as they were substantially in the approved form and any deviation from the form was not misleading. The third ground of appeal related to the limitation period for commencing proceedings under the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act. The appellants argued that the charges were commenced outside the 12-month period after the NT EPA became aware of the commission of the offence. The court found that the limitation period began when the appellants failed to comply with the further amended PANs, which occurred after the 12-month period had commenced. The fourth ground of appeal related to the validity of the requirements imposed by the further amended PANs. The appellants argued that the PANs required them to trespass on land belonging to another and that the NT EPA did not have the power to require them to do so. The court found that the PANs did not require the appellants to trespass and that the NT EPA had the power to issue the PANs. The fifth ground of appeal related to the primary Judge's failure to take into account that Mr Anthony was the sole director and shareholder of DWD. The court found that the primary Judge had taken this into account in imposing sentence. The sixth and seventh grounds of appeal related to the primary Judge's application of s 5(2)(ha) of the Sentencing Act 1995 (NT) and his comment about "nil utility." The court found that the primary Judge did not err in his application of the sentencing legislation. The eighth ground of appeal related to the penalties imposed on the appellants. The appellants argued that the penalties were manifestly unreasonable. The court found that the penalties were moderate and took into account the appellants' good character and the cost of the remediation works. The appeals were ultimately dismissed.

This appeal arises out of convictions and penalties imposed by a Judge of the Local Court of the Northern Territory (the primary Judge). The appellants, DWD Project Pty Ltd and Michael Anthony, were charged with offences under s 80(1) of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1989 (NT) of intentionally contravening or intentionally failing to comply with the requirements of amended pollution abatement notices issued by the Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority (the respondent) on 1 June 2020. A contested hearing took place in which virtually all of the prosecution material was tendered without objection. Only one prosecution witness was required for cross-examination. The appellants led no evidence. After the hearing, on 1 October 2021, the primary Judge convicted each of the appellants of the offences charged and, after the parties made submissions on sentence, the first appellant, DWD, was fined $250,000.00 and the second appellant, Michael Anthony, the sole director and shareholder of DWD, was fined $50,000.00. Each appellant was also ordered to pay a victim assistance levy, and costs and disbursements incurred by the respondent. The appeals were heard before Burns J. The appeal was dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the primary Judge correct in refusing to adjourn the hearing of the charges under appeal before the hearing of the s 83 charges?
2. Were the further amended pollution abatement notices (PANs) issued in the approved form and, if not, were they invalid?
3. Were the charges laid against the appellants outside the limitation period prescribed by s 94 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1998 (NT)?
4. Did the further amended PANs exceed the power granted by s 79 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1998 (NT) by requiring the appellants to undertake remedial action on land they did not own?
5. Did the primary Judge fail to take into account that Mr Anthony was the sole director and shareholder of DWD when imposing sentence?
6. Did the primary Judge err in applying s 5(2)(ha) of the Sentencing Act 1995 (NT) and comment about "nil utility" when imposing sentence?
7. Were the penalties imposed upon the appellants manifestly unreasonable?
8. Did the primary Judge fail to consider relevant mitigating factors when imposing sentence?

Held
1. The court found that the primary Judge did not err in refusing to adjourn the hearing of the charges under appeal before the hearing of the s 83 charges.
2. The court concluded that the further amended pollution abatement notices (PANs) were issued in the approved form and were valid.
3. The court found that the charges laid against the appellants were not outside the limitation period prescribed by s 94 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1998 (NT).
4. The court determined that the further amended PANs did not exceed the power granted by s 79 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1998 (NT) by requiring the appellants to undertake remedial action on land they did not own.
5. The court concluded that the primary Judge did take into account that Mr Anthony was the sole director and shareholder of DWD when imposing sentence.
6. The court found that the primary Judge did not err in applying s 5(2)(ha) of the Sentencing Act 1995 (NT) and commenting about "nil utility" when imposing sentence.
7. The court determined that the penalties imposed upon the appellants were not manifestly unreasonable.
8. The court found that the primary Judge did consider relevant mitigating factors when imposing sentence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary judge was correct in refusing to adjourn the hearing of the charges under appeal before the hearing of the s 83 charges. The court held that the appellants had not established that they would suffer prejudice if the PAN charges were heard before the s 83 charges, and that the primary judge's error in suggesting that any prejudice could be cured in the s 83 proceedings was not material. The court also rejected the appellants' argument that the primary judge had failed to take into account relevant mitigating factors, such as the fact that Mr Anthony was the sole director and shareholder of DWD and that the penalty imposed on DWD would be borne by Mr Anthony. The court held that the primary judge had taken into account this factor in imposing sentence, and that the primary judge was entitled to form the conclusion that the appellants had not disputed the factual basis of the prosecution case against them. The court further held that the primary judge did not err in applying s 5(2)(ha) of the Sentencing Act 1995 (NT) and comment about "nil utility" when imposing sentence. The court held that the primary judge was entitled to conclude that the way in which the appellants had conducted the proceedings in the Local Court disentitled them to the discount that they might otherwise have received. The court also rejected the appellants' argument that the penalties imposed upon them were manifestly unreasonable. The court held that the primary judge was entitled to conclude that the appellants had shown no willingness to undertake the required works, and that the potential cost of those works was not a matter to which the primary judge was required to give great weight. The court further held that the maximum penalty to which the appellants were exposed in the Local Court proceedings was moderate, and that the penalties imposed by the primary judge were also moderate.

The further amended pollution abatement notices (PANs) issued in the approved form and were not invalid. The court held that the PANs issued on 1 June 2020 were not invalid, even though they deviated from the approved form, because the deviation was not misleading and did not affect the substance of the notices. The court held that the objectives of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act 1998 (NT) were preventative and protective, and that matters of substance should be prioritised over matters of form. The court also held that the further amended PANs were not invalid because they did not require the appellants to trespass on the vacant Crown land or to perform an action that was not permitted under the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act.

The charges laid against the appellants were not outside the limitation period prescribed by s 94 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act. The court held that the limitation period for commencing a prosecution for a breach of the further amended PANs issued on 1 June 2020 commenced on 18 July 2020, and that the present proceedings were commenced within the time allowed by s 94 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act. The court held that the legislature did not intend for s 94 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act to operate as a bar to the respondent pursuing further remedial action under the Act against an alleged polluter simply because the respondent chooses not to commence a criminal prosecution within 12 months of becoming aware of a breach of the requirements of a PAN.

The further amended PANs did not exceed the power granted by s 79 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act by requiring the appellants to undertake remedial action on land they did not own. The court held that the further amended PANs did not require the appellants to trespass on the vacant Crown land, and that the appellants could undertake the required works on the Crown land at the request of the appellants and at their expense, or seek the approval of the Crown to enter onto the land to undertake the works. The court also held that the further amended PANs did not require the appellants to perform an action that was not permitted under the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act, such as carrying out works without required planning permission.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the primary judge was correct in refusing to adjourn the hearing of the charges under appeal before the hearing of the s 83 charges, the further amended PANs were issued in the approved form and were not invalid, the charges laid against the appellants were not outside the limitation period prescribed by s 94 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act, the further amended PANs did not exceed the power granted by s 79 of the Waste Management and Pollution Control Act by requiring the appellants to undertake remedial action on land they did not own, the primary judge did not err in applying s 5(2)(ha) of the Sentencing Act 1995 (NT) and comment about "nil utility" when imposing sentence, the penalties imposed upon the appellants were not manifestly unreasonable, and the primary judge did not fail to take into account relevant mitigating factors when imposing sentence. The court distinguished the present case from the decision of the High Court in Zhao v Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police, where the Court held that the risk of prejudice to the respondent if a stay of proceedings was not granted was plain. The court held that the risk of prejudice to the appellants if the PAN charges were heard before the s 83 charges was not plain, and that the appellants had not established that they would suffer prejudice if the PAN charges were heard before the s 83 charges. The court also distinguished the present case from the decision of the High Court in Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority, where the Court held that an act done in breach of a condition regulating the exercise of a statutory power is not necessarily invalid and of no effect. The court held that the PANs issued on 1 June 2020 were not invalid because the deviation from the approved form was not misleading and did not affect the substance of the notices.