Durnford v Allen Taylor and Company

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Re: RUSSELL FRANCIS DURNFORD
And: ALLEN TAYLOR AND COMPANY LIMITED
No. I18 of 1989
FED No. 474
Industrial Law
34 IR 423

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Wilcox J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Industrial Law - Alleged breaches of industrial award - Proceeding brought after commencement of Industrial Relations Act but in respect of breaches prior to that commencement - Applicability of the Industrial Relations Act - Two persons employed to tend a boiler used to manufacture steam for seasoning of timber - Proper classification of employees under award - Employers able to eat meal whilst at work but with no structured meal break - Whether breach of requirement to allow a meal break - Short payment of annual holiday pay and loading.

Industrial Relations Act 1988, ss.147, 148, 178

Industrial Relations (Consequential Provisions) Act 1988, ss.4, 83(2)

Acts Interpretation Act 1901, s.8

Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904, ss.58, 59, 119

Timber Industry Consolidated Award, cll.4, 17, 18, 21

HEARING

SYDNEY

#DATE 5:9:1990

Counsel for the applicant: C. Simpson, QC and G.T. Johnson

Solicitors for the applicant: Australian Government Solicitor

Counsel for the respondent: J.N. Gallagher

Solicitors for the respondent: Murphy and Moloney

ORDER

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub.cl.(d) of cl.4 of the Timber Industry Consolidated Award 1974 ("the Award") in that it failed to pay its employee Kevin John Warren the rate prescribed for a person performing the duties of a boiler attendant (fireman) in New South Wales, for duties performed in the pay periods ending 4 November 1985, 18 December 1985 and 15 January 1986.

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub.cl.(d) of cl.4 of the Award in that it did fail to pay to its employee John Henry Maynes the prescribed rate for a person performing the duties of a boiler attendant (fireman) in New South Wales, for duties performed in the pay periods ending 24 July 1985 and 15 January 1986.

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub-cl.(d)(ii) of cl.18 of the Award in that it did require its employee Kevin John Warren to work in excess of five hours of the afternoon shift on 19 September 1985 and 20 September 1985 without allowing the employee a meal break of not less than 20 minutes as prescribed.

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub.cl.(d)(ii) of cl.18 of the Award in that it did require its employee John Henry Maynes to work in excess of five hours of the afternoon shift on each of 22 July 1985, 23 July 1985 and 24 July 1985 without allowing the employee a meal break of not less than 20 minutes as prescribed.

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub.cl.(kk)(1)(b) of cl.21 of the Award in that it did fail to pay its employee Kevin John Warren the correct amount by way of loading as calculated at the rate prescribed for annual leave entitlement payable to the employee during the close down of the respondent's premises during Christmas…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Durnford v Allen Taylor and Company and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1990] FCA 474
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Durnford v Allen Taylor and Company, the applicant, Russell Francis Durnford, sought to enforce compliance with the Timber Industry Consolidated Award 1974 against the respondent, Allen Taylor and Company, for alleged breaches of the award provisions by the respondents’ employees, Kevin John Warren and John Henry Maynes. The proceedings were brought under the Industrial Relations Act 1988, but concerned breaches occurring prior to the commencement of the Act. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the Act applied to the proceedings and, if so, the nature and extent of the breaches of the award provisions.

The court was required to decide whether the Industrial Relations Act applied to the proceedings despite the alleged breaches occurring before the Act came into force. Furthermore, the court needed to determine whether the respondents had breached the award by failing to classify the employees correctly, by not allowing meal breaks, and by underpaying annual holiday pay and loading.

The court held that the Industrial Relations Act did apply to the proceedings, as it was enacted to give effect to international obligations and to provide a national framework for industrial relations. The court found that the respondents had indeed breached the award by misclassifying the employees, thereby underpaying them, and by not allowing the employees the mandated meal breaks. Additionally, the court found that the respondents had failed to pay the employees the correct amount of annual leave pay and loading. Consequently, the court declared the breaches and imposed penalties on the respondents, ordering them to pay the employees the outstanding amounts and the penalties to the applicant.

The court's final orders included declarations of the specific breaches of the award, imposition of penalties for those breaches, and orders for the respondents to pay the employees the amounts owed plus the penalties to the applicant within one month.

Orders

Orders of the court

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub.cl.(d) of cl.4 of the Timber Industry Consolidated Award 1974 ("the Award") in that it failed to pay its employee Kevin John Warren the rate prescribed for a person performing the duties of a boiler attendant (fireman) in New South Wales, for duties performed in the pay periods ending 4 November 1985, 18 December 1985 and 15 January 1986.

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub.cl.(d) of cl.4 of the Award in that it did fail to pay to its employee John Henry Maynes the prescribed rate for a person performing the duties of a boiler attendant (fireman) in New South Wales, for duties performed in the pay periods ending 24 July 1985 and 15 January 1986.

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub-cl.(d)(ii) of cl.18 of the Award in that it did require its employee Kevin John Warren to work in excess of five hours of the afternoon shift on 19 September 1985 and 20 September 1985 without allowing the employee a meal break of not less than 20 minutes as prescribed.

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub.cl.(d)(ii) of cl.18 of the Award in that it did require its employee John Henry Maynes to work in excess of five hours of the afternoon shift on each of 22 July 1985, 23 July 1985 and 24 July 1985 without allowing the employee a meal break of not less than 20 minutes as prescribed.

Declares that the respondent committed breaches of sub.cl.(kk)(1)(b) of cl.21 of the Award in that it did fail to pay its employee Kevin John Warren the correct amount by way of loading as calculated at the rate prescribed for annual leave entitlement payable to the employee during the close down of the respondent's premises during Christmas 1985.

Declares that the respondent committed a breach of sub.cl.(kk)(1)(b) of cl.21 of the Award in that it did fail to pay its employee John Henry Maynes the correct amount by way of loading as calculated at the rate prescribed for annual leave entitlement payable to the employee during the close down of the respondent's premises during Christmas 1985.

Declares that the respondent committed a breach of sub.cl.(m)(2) of cl.21 of the Award in that it did fail to pay, prior to the close down of the respondent's premises for Christmas 1985, to its employee Kevin John Warren the amount for annual leave prescribed for each week of service completed by the employee from 15 April 1985 to 31 December 1985 for which leave had not already been given during that period.

Declares that the respondent committed a breach of sub.cl.(m)(2) of cl.21 of the Award in that it did fail to pay, prior to the close down of the respondent's premises for Christmas 1985, to its employee John Henry Maynes the amount for annual leave prescribed for each week of service completed by the employee from 30 April 1985 to 31 December 1985 for which leave had not already been given during that period.

Declares that the respondent committed a breach of sub.cl.(m)(2) of cl.21 of the Award in that it did fail to pay its employee Kevin John Warren the correct amount, calculated at the rate as provided by sub.cl.(k) of cl.21 of the Award, prior to his going on leave during the close down of the respondent's premises for Christmas 1985.

Declares that the respondent committed a breach of sub.cl.(m)(2) of cl.21 of the Award in that it did fail to pay its employee John Henry Maynes the correct amount, calculated at the rate as is provided by sub.cl.(k) of cl.21 of the Award, prior to his going on leave during the close down of the respondent's premises for Christmas 1985.

Imposes a penalty in the total sum of seven hundred and fifty dollars ($750) in respect of the breaches referred to in paras.1 and 2 hereof.

Imposes a penalty in the total sum of five hundred dollars ($500) in respect of the breaches referred to in paras.3 and 4 hereof.

Imposes a penalty in the total sum of two hundred and fifty dollars ($250) in respect of the breaches referred to in paras.5 to 10 hereof.

Orders that each of the said penalties be paid to the applicant Russell Francis Durnford within one month.

Orders that, within one month, the respondent pay to Kevin John Warren the sum of five hundred and thirty three dollars and seventy three cents ($533.73).

Orders that, within one month, the respondent pay to John Henry Maynes the sum of four hundred and eighty one dollars and seventy eight cents ($481.78).

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules. (See also Order 37 rule 2(3)).

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two employees, Kevin John Warren and John Henry Maynes, who were employed by Allen Taylor and Company to tend a boiler used in the manufacture of steam for the seasoning of timber. The dispute arises out of alleged breaches of the Timber Industry Consolidated Award 1974 (the Award) by the respondent company. The employees were classified as boiler attendants (firemen) under the Award, and they were not provided with a structured meal break during their shifts. Additionally, the employees were underpaid in relation to their annual holiday pay and loading. The employees, represented by Russell Francis Durnford, brought the proceedings after the commencement of the Industrial Relations Act but in respect of breaches that occurred prior to the commencement of the Act.

The case came before the court after being initiated by Russell Francis Durnford on behalf of the employees. The matter was heard and determined by the court, which made findings in favour of the employees and issued declarations of breaches of the Award. The court also imposed penalties on the respondent company and ordered them to pay the employees the amounts due to them, including the penalties, within one month of the judgment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent company committed breaches of sub.cl.(d) of cl.4 of the Award by failing to pay the prescribed rates to the employees for their duties as boiler attendants.
2. Whether the respondent company committed breaches of sub-cl.(d)(ii) of cl.18 of the Award by requiring the employees to work without allowing the prescribed meal breaks.
3. Whether the respondent company committed breaches of sub-cl.(kk)(1)(b) and sub-cl.(m)(2) of cl.21 of the Award by failing to pay the correct amount of loading and annual leave to the employees.

Held
1. The court held that the respondent company committed breaches of sub.cl.(d) of cl.4 of the Award by failing to pay the prescribed rates to the employees for their duties as boiler attendants.
2. The court held that the respondent company committed breaches of sub-cl.(d)(ii) of cl.18 of the Award by requiring the employees to work without allowing the prescribed meal breaks.
3. The court held that the respondent company committed breaches of sub-cl.(kk)(1)(b) and sub-cl.(m)(2) of cl.21 of the Award by failing to pay the correct amount of loading and annual leave to the employees.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the specific clauses of the Timber Industry Consolidated Award 1974 to determine the obligations of the respondent company towards its employees. The court found that the employees, Kevin John Warren and John Henry Maynes, were correctly classified as boiler attendants under the Award, entitling them to the prescribed rates of pay. The court identified that the respondents had not paid these prescribed rates for several pay periods, resulting in the first set of breaches. Regarding the meal breaks, the court noted that while the employees were allowed to eat during work, they were not provided with a structured meal break as mandated by the Award, leading to the second set of breaches. The court further held that the respondents failed to pay the correct amount of loading and annual leave as stipulated by the relevant clauses of the Award, thereby committing the final set of breaches. The court applied the principles of the Award and the specific provisions to the facts of the case to arrive at its decisions. The binding legal principle established by this decision is the importance of adhering to the prescribed terms and conditions of employment as outlined in the relevant industrial awards.