Administrative
Appeals
Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2003] AATA 1284
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No Q2002/60
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION
)
Re JOHN ERNEST DUNWOODY Applicant
And
INSPECTOR-GENERAL IN BANKRUPTCY
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Ms J Cowdroy, Member Date17 December 2003
PlaceBrisbane
Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decision review and substitutes for it a decision that the following amounts should be regarded as income for the purposes of calculating the applicant’s contribution during the period 9 October 1988 to 8 October 1999:
Gross Income $30,000.00
Legal Expenses $50, 576.05
Accountancy Expenses $53,340.90
...................(Sgd).........................
J Cowdroy
Member
4. The matter was decided on the basis of the oral evidence of the applicant and the witnesses, the exhibit material and the written and oral submissions of the parties.
Background to the Application
5. It is not disputed that the applicant became bankrupt following the filing of his debtor’s petition on 9 October 1998. On that date Messrs Philip Jefferson and Jay Stevenson consented to, and were appointed as, Trustees of the bankrupt’s estate. On 9 August 1999, a meeting of the creditors passed a resolution for the removal of the Trustees and upon this occurring, the Official Trustee (“the Trustee”) became Trustee of the bankrupt’s estate.
6. The Trustee issued compulsory contribution assessments dated 23 June 2000, 12 July 2000 and 22 March 2001 to the applicant for the period 9 October 1988 to 8 October 1999 (“CAP1”). By letter dated 9 November 2001, the applicant asked the respondent to review the income assessments made by the Trustee, and, by letter dated 19 December 2001, the Trustee advised the applicant that it had set aside the previous assessments and had made a fresh assessment.
7. On 18 January 2002 the applicant lodged an application to the respondent to review the decision made by the Trustee on 19 December 2001.
The Issues
(1)Whether the original assessment made by the Trustee, after the expiration of the contribution assessment period, was authorised by the relevant legislation.
(2)What amount of income did the applicant derive from employment for the period 9 October 1998 to 8 October 1999 or might reasonably be expected to have been received by a person who engaged in similar employment?
(3)What was the value of the benefits provided by third parties to the applicant during the period 9 October 1998 to 8 October 1999 in respect of the payment of legal expenses?
(4)What was the value of the benefits provided by Hickman and Associates during the period 9 October 1998 to 8 October 1999 in respect of services performed for the applicant at no charge?
The Legislation
Issue 1
8. The authority under which the Trustee issues compulsory contribution assessments (CAP) is contained in subsection 139W(1) and (2) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (“the Act”).
9. Immediately prior to the enactment of the Bankruptcy Legislation Amendment Act 1966 (“the December 1996 amendments”), subsections 139W(1) and (2) of the Act provided:
“(1)As soon as practicable after the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dunwoody and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] AATA 1284
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were the proper methods for assessing the value of income for contribution assessment purposes and the applicability of the Fringe Benefits Tax Assessment Act 1986 in determining the value of benefits provided by third parties. The Tribunal had to consider statutory provisions, including sections 139L, 139W(1), 139W(2), and 139Y of the Bankruptcy Act, and section 139W(1) and s 139W(2) of the Bankruptcy Legislation Amendment Act 1966.
The Tribunal found that the assessment of income for contribution purposes should reflect the actual income derived by the bankrupt. It applied the principles set out in Challen v Bendeich, which held that income derived from employment and benefits provided by third parties should be included in the calculation. The Tribunal concluded that the bankrupt's actual income, including legal and accountancy expenses, should be used for the contribution assessment. It set aside the original decision and substituted its own, determining specific amounts that should be regarded as income.
The Tribunal ordered that the gross income, legal expenses, and accountancy expenses be included in the calculation of the contribution assessment for the specified period. The amounts were set at $30,000.00 for gross income, $50,576.05 for legal expenses, and $53,340.90 for accountancy expenses.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal sets aside the decision review and substitutes for it a decision that the following amounts should be regarded as income for the purposes of calculating the applicant’s contribution during the period 9 October 1988 to 8 October 1999:
Gross Income $30,000.00
Legal Expenses $50, 576.05
Accountancy Expenses $53,340.90
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi