Dunstan v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dunstan v Human Rights & Equal Opportunity Commission [1999] FCA 1608

COLIN GEORGE DUNSTAN v HUMAN RIGHTS AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION, COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA, SUSAN LESLEY LANGFORD and LINDA JANE HIGGINSON

A 77 OF 1999

MANSFIELD J

19 NOVEMBER 1999

ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

DISTRICT REGISTRY

A 77 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

COLIN GEORGE DUNSTAN
Applicant

AND:

HUMAN RIGHTS AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION
First Respondent

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Second Respondent

SUSAN LESLEY LANGFORD
Third Respondent

LINDA JANE HIGGINSON
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 NOVEMBER 1999

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed.

2.The time from which any application for leave to appeal from the order in par 1 hereof, or from which any appeal from the order in par 1 hereof, commence to run from 22 November 1999.

3.The applicant pay to the first respondent and to the second respondent their costs of the application, including their costs of their notices of motion of 9 and 8 November 1999 respectively, to be taxed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

A 77 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

COLIN GEORGE DUNSTAN
Applicant

AND:

HUMAN RIGHTS AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION
First Respondent

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Second Respondent

SUSAN LESLEY LANGFORD
Third Respondent

LINDA JANE HIGGINSON
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE:

19 NOVEMBER 1999

PLACE:

ADELAIDE

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. There is before the Court two notices of motion of the first respondent (“HREOC”) and of the second respondent (“the Commonwealth”) under O 20 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules (“the Rules”) to dismiss this application on the grounds that no reasonable cause of action is disclosed, the proceeding is frivolous or vexatious, or that the proceeding is an abuse of the process of the Court.

  2. Neither motion was supported by affidavit (see O 19 r 1(2) of the Rules).  Each of those respondents made submissions based upon the terms of the application itself and upon the affidavit of the applicant (“Mr Dunstan”) filed in support of the application (see O 4 r 6).  They did not seek to rely upon any extraneous material.  In those circumstances, in my view, it is appropriate to dispense with compliance with O 19 r 1(2) of the Rules in respect of each motion.  I do so, pursuant to the power in O 1 r 8 of the Rules.

  3. As the parties did in the course of submissions, I have however also had regard to the nature of the allegations in matters AG 30 of 1997 and AG 77 of 1997.  In each of those proceedings Mr Dunstan is the applicant.  In matter AG 30 of 1997, HREOC and the Commonwealth are also respondents, and in matter AG 77 of 1997, the respondents are named officers of the Commonwealth.  Upon the same basis, I have also had regard to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dunstan v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1608
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Dunstan v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission involved the applicant, Mr. Dunstan, who sought to challenge various proceedings against him brought by HREOC and the Commonwealth. Mr. Dunstan, who was employed with the Australian Taxation Office, had made several complaints to HREOC about sexual harassment and discrimination. Following these complaints, criminal proceedings were initiated against him. The core of the dispute was Mr. Dunstan's application for judicial review and damages against HREOC, the Commonwealth, and several officers, alleging maladministration, defamation, and negligence in the handling of his complaints. Additionally, he sought to challenge decisions made by his superiors regarding his suspension and charges of misconduct.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Federal Court had jurisdiction to hear the application and whether the application constituted an abuse of process. HREOC and the Commonwealth argued that the court lacked jurisdiction and that the application was an improper attempt to influence the criminal proceedings. The court had to determine if the application was solely aimed at the conduct of the criminal proceedings, which would fall outside the court's jurisdiction, or if it also included claims that could be addressed by the court.

The court found that the application was largely focused on the conduct of the criminal proceedings, which the court did not have jurisdiction to review. The claims regarding the handling of Mr. Dunstan's complaints and the decisions made by his superiors were not sufficient to confer jurisdiction on the court. Furthermore, the application was deemed to be an abuse of process as it was primarily directed at influencing the ongoing criminal proceedings. The court concluded that Mr. Dunstan's proper recourse was to appeal the decisions of the trial judge regarding the conduct of the criminal trial. Therefore, the application was dismissed, and costs were awarded to the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The time from which any application for leave to appeal from the order in par 1 hereof, or from which any appeal from the order in par 1 hereof, commence to run from 22 November 1999.

3. The applicant pay to the first respondent and to the second respondent their costs of the application, including their costs of their notices of motion of 9 and 8 November 1999 respectively, to be taxed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Without opposition, the Director of Public Prosecutions for the Australian Capital Territory (“the DPP”) was given leave also to make submissions on the motions. His concern was more with the claim for interlocutory relief to stay the criminal proceedings, which was included in the application. That claim in the event was not pursued.The background to the claim The application is somewhat difficult to comprehend fully. That is understandable, given the long history of Mr Dunstan’s disputes with HREOC and the Commonwealth, partly identified in the earlier proceedings, and given the fact that he is not legally represented. It is helpful to understand the nature of those allegations in those earlier proceedings. At material times Mr Dunstan was employed in the Commonwealth Public Service in the Australian Taxation Office (“ATO”). In matter AG 30 of 1997, against HREOC, the Commonwealth, and certain officers of those entities, his claim concerns four matters:(1)Following complaints made by him to HREOC on 17 September 1993 of sexual harassment and racial and sexual discrimination, and later in January 1995 of disability discrimination, HREOC on 2 April 1997 determined not to continue to inquire into the complaints of sexual harassment and sexual discrimination. He seeks judicial review of that decision.(2)In the period September 1993 to June 1997, in relation to the investigation and consideration of those complaints, three officers of the Commonwealth (who are also respondents to that application) maliciously published false and misleading information about him to HREOC and to the Commonwealth, so as to cause damage to him. He seeks damages from them for that conduct, and from the Commonwealth on the basis that it is responsible for that conduct.(3)During 1995 and 1996, on a number of occasions, an officer of EASACT Australia Pty Ltd (an organisation providing staff services to the ATO) published to an officer of the Commonwealth, and then officers of the Commonwealth in turn republished, material which was defamatory of Mr Dunstan, so as to cause him damage. Again he seeks damages for that conduct.(4)In the period November 1992 to January 1996, the Commonwealth by its officers and agents (who are alleged to include HREOC, COMCARE Australia, EASACT Australia Pty Ltd and others) was negligent in failing properly to investigate Mr Dunstan’s complaints, in failing to protect him from harassment, and in the manner it responded to his complaints, so that he has suffered substantial loss and damage. He has been charged with misconduct and has been suspended from duty. He again claims damages as a result. Mr Dunstan’s claim in matter AG 77 of 1997 is against three officers of the Commonwealth who were apparently his superiors in the ATO and charged with supervising the performance of his work. He complains in that proceeding of the following:(1)the decision of 4 June 1997 to notify him that he may have failed to fulfil his duty as an officer, under s 56 of the Public Service Act 1922 (Cth)(2)the decision of 4 June 1997 to suspend him from duty, and(3)the decision of 13 or 20 October 1997 to charge him with misconduct under the Public Service Act 1922.He seeks to have each of those decisions declared void, and to have his entitlement to pay and to continued employment recognised.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The submissions put on behalf of HREOC and the Commonwealth were:(1)The Court has no jurisdiction to hear and determine the application(2)The application was “foredoomed to fail” so that it constituted an abuse of the process of the Court; Walton v Gardiner (1993) 177 CLR 378 at 393 per Mason CJ, Deane and Dawson JJ(3)The application was brought for an improper purpose, namely either an attempt to intimidate or discourage witnesses from giving evidence in the criminal proceedings or to obtain information relevant to the prosecution of the criminal proceedings which is not otherwise available to Mr Dunstan, or to delay the criminal proceedings. If those purposes were made out, clearly they would constitute an abuse of the process of the Court: Williams v Spautz (1992) 174 CLR 509.Consideration of contentions In my judgment I can resolve the motions by ruling on submission (2) above. I have referred to the detailed claims in the application. In large measure they are directed at the conduct of the criminal proceedings. To the extent that they do so, Mr Dunstan now accepts that he cannot maintain the proceedings. Higgins J has addressed the issues which Mr Dunstan sought to raise in these proceedings regarding access to material, the withholding of relevant material, and the significance and consequences of the change in the nature of the charges after the committal hearing. Mr Dunstan acknowledges that the proper avenue, if he is dissatisfied with that ruling, is to appeal from that decision. He also acknowledges that matters such as access to material going to the conduct of a fair trial is a matter for the trial judge. Mr Dunstan nevertheless submits that the application is not directed exclusively to the course of the criminal proceedings. I accept that pars 1, 6 and 7 of the application are not expressly so confined. I have referred above to pars 2 and 3 of the application. They expressly relate to the criminal proceedings. Paragraphs 4 and 5 do not identify possible claims, but recite historical or factual matters, and pars 8 and 9 deal with jurisdiction only. Paragraph 1 of the application refers to judicial proceedings instituted against Mr Dunstan, or to the tribunals in which proceedings have been instituted against him. Those proceedings are nowhere identified. The affidavit in support of the application does not refer to any such proceedings, other than the criminal proceedings. Paragraph 1 of the affidavit is introductory. Paragraph 2 recites a series of general “grounds” for the application. To the extent to which there is any specific focus on those allegations, it is directed to the criminal proceedings (pars 2.4-2.7). Paragraph 3 does not refer to any such proceedings. The affidavit then deals with the “evolution” of charges and the alleged fabrication of evidence in relation to the criminal proceedings (par 4), with the significance of the change in the proposed charges after the committal hearing (pars 5-10 and 35), and with the quality of the proposed evidence concerning intent and other matters in relation to the criminal charges (pars 11-34).